Matermoll Mattress Reviews

Chris’s viewpoint

I started with Luxury Dream because Matermoll calls it top-of-the-range for the home line. When I moved over to Dreamy , the feel changed quickly.

Marcus Reed

Marcus, with his 6'1", 230-pound frame, always reveals how a bed deals with real weight and heat. On Comfort Plus , Marcus had a different reaction.

Mia Chen

Mia, at 5'4" and 125 pounds, always exposes pressure issues for lighter side sleepers. On Luxury Dream , Mia felt a touch higher above the springs, especially when the pillow top setting shifted closer to medium-firm.

Jenna Brooks

Jenna lives in couple-testing mode, since she always shares with Ethan. With Dreamy , the story changed slightly.

Our team followed a consistent protocol across all these Matermoll mattress models. I assigned each mattress to one or two testers for primary use across roughly three weeks, then rotated for shorter cross-check nights. Under those conditions, we can watch how break-in, body impressions, and nightly comfort evolve rather than just chasing first-night excitement.

We rated every mattress on eight core metrics, each scored from 3.0 to 5.0. Support covered spinal alignment and hip positioning across back, side, and stomach postures. Pressure relief focused on shoulders, outer hips, and knees, especially for Mia and my own side-sleep stretches. Cooling measured perceived warmth across full nights, aided by a small temperature logger under the sheet.

Motion isolation relied heavily on Jenna and Ethan’s shared-bed tests, with Ethan doing deliberate rolls, exits, and re-entries. Responsiveness described how fast the surface recovered under shifting positions, something Jamal and Marcus notice quickly during athletic post-workout nights. Durability estimates came from material quality, spring systems, and brand reputation, cross-checked against vendor details and customer reviews. 

We added edge support because Marcus and I spend plenty of time sitting on the side tying shoes or reading, and value because these prices sit in luxury territory for many households. Under this scoring map, a 3.0 signals acceptable performance, 4.0 signals strong performance, and anything near 5.0 pushes into standout territory in that metric.

Our Testing Experience

Luxury Dream arrived from a boutique retailer, wrapped like something expensive, which fit its billing as a premium hybrid with a removable pillow top. When I first lay down on my back, I felt a cushy initial sink from the pillow top, then a firm, confident spring response right underneath. I spent the first week mainly on my back and side.

During side-sleep sessions, the Watergel and Breeze foams under the pillow top helped my shoulder glide into a soft pocket. Marcus joined me for more aggressive testing. He switched the pillow top to the slightly firmer configuration and dropped onto the mattress in a half-stomach pose he loves.

Mia tried Luxury Dream with the pillow top a notch softer.

Our Testing Experience

Luxury shares a lot of DNA with Luxury Dream but swaps in Air Suspension springs and leans slightly more toward a buoyant, lifted sensation. My first back-sleep test made that difference obvious. I used Luxury across a hectic workweek with more late-night laptop sessions in bed.

While sitting propped up, I noticed strong support under my lower back, even near the mid-bed zone where some mattresses dip. Jamal spent a block of time on Luxury after a few heavy gym days. He values “drive out of the surface,” his phrase for how a mattress responds when he pushes off to roll or stand.

Mia’s reaction diverged a little.

Our Testing Experience

Dreamy has a kind of reputation in cruise circles, and once it landed in our test room, the firmer build announced itself quickly. Matermoll describes a high hardness coefficient plus a removable pillow top over a pocket spring and memory foam core. I dedicated this mattress to my “desk recovery” weeks.

After long days hunched over spreadsheets, my lower back tends to seek strong, even support. Marcus, however, absolutely loved Dreamy. For him, the combination of firm springs and pillow top created that “reset” feeling he craves.

Jenna and Ethan tested Dreamy as a couple.

Our Testing Experience

Cashmere entered the rotation as the clear “plush luxury” option. Matermoll emphasizes its cashmere fabric plus memory foam and Biogreen foam over a pocketed spring system. Mia claimed this mattress almost immediately.

She set herself up in her usual curled side position and spent the night almost glued to one spot. From my perspective, Cashmere felt fantastic for side-focused nights yet slightly too enveloping during long back-sleep sessions. My lower back stayed supported in a gentle way, though the edges of my hips sat a bit deeper than on Luxury Dream.

Jenna and Ethan tested Cashmere as their “quiet” option.

Our Testing Experience

Comfort Plus operates in a different lane from the other models here. Matermoll frames it as an upgrade over Comfort, with insacked, differentiated springs and seven pressure zones , plus a reversible design that stays rollable and easier to transport. I set Comfort Plus up in our secondary bedroom and used it for mixed testing.

On my back, I could feel the zoning: my hips encountered firmer coil resistance, while my shoulders lay over a slightly more forgiving section. Marcus tried Comfort Plus next. Under his 230 pounds, the zoning kept his hips from diving too deep, which impressed him.

Jenna assigned Comfort Plus to a few guest nights with Ethan.

Choosing among these Matermoll mattresses hinges on a few key factors: your main sleep position, body weight, temperature sensitivity, and budget. Under typical home conditions, heavier bodies compress deeper into the spring and foam stack, while lighter frames often ride higher on the surface, so the same mattress can feel completely different across people.

Light-weight side sleeper (e.g., Mia’s profile). A model like Cashmere usually works best here. The deep foam cradle lets the shoulder sink without forcing the neck into odd angles, and the pocket springs hold the spine steady. Luxury Dream with a softer pillow top setting can also work, yet Mia still preferred Cashmere’s extra plushness.

Average-weight back sleeper around 170–190 pounds. In that range, Luxury Dream and Luxury shine. They balance firm enough support for a straight spine with enough top cushioning for comfort during long movies or reading sessions. Carlos, as our back-sleep specialist, gravitated toward this level of medium-firm support and appreciated the clear transition from comfort layers into the supportive spring core.

Hot sleeper with a bigger build, similar to Marcus. Under those conditions, Luxury and Dreamy deserve priority. Air Suspension springs in Luxury encourage ventilation, while Dreamy stays firm enough that deeper body impressions never trap much heat. Cashmere’s warmth would probably frustrate this profile over time.

Heavier couple sharing a queen or king. The combination of support, edge stability, and motion control usually points toward Luxury Dream or Dreamy. Luxury Dream gives more adjustability for partners with slightly different firmness tastes, while Dreamy delivers rock-solid support with modest but manageable motion travel. For couples who prioritize quiet over everything, Cashmere still offers the muffled-foam experience, though edge softness should be considered.

Budget-conscious buyer wanting Italian build quality. For guest rooms, first apartments, or younger sleepers, Comfort Plus makes sense. The zoned pocket core supports bodies intelligently, and the reversible design adds flexibility over time. Under those circumstances, giving up some plush feel buys you Italian engineering at a softer price.