Sleep is precious, and your mattress matters. You want support, comfort, and reliability. Shifman mattress has a long heritage in handcrafted bedding. At first glance, Shifman seems like the prestige choice. But does it live up to the reputation? Or do its flaws weigh heavier than its name?
Brand Overview
Legacy and Craftsmanship
Shifman Mattress Company traces its roots to Newark, New Jersey, founded in 1893. It remains known for handmade craftsmanship and traditional techniques. The company emphasizes two-sided designs, hand-tufting, and eight-way hand-tied box springs using quality materials. Shifman uses natural cotton, wool, and premium coil systems. Each mattress typically takes many hours to craft.
Market Positioning
Shifman positions itself in the luxury, heritage mattress niche. It competes with boutique brands and legacy names. Its appeal lies in craftsmanship, natural materials, and durability. Yet that positioning brings trade-offs: higher prices, heavier builds, and limited trial flexibility.
Product Evaluation
Collections and Models
Shifman offers several collections, often named after interior design pioneers. The Elizabeth PT model is part of the Hotel Collection. It features 713 individually wrapped coils, hand-tufted layers, natural cotton and wool, and dual-sided design. This model is thick and heavy, meant for boutique customers.
Advantages
- Heritage and technique: Using hand-tufting, eight-way tie methods, and careful craftsmanship preserves mattress integrity over time.
- Two-sided longevity: Since many Shifman models are flippable, average wear is more evenly distributed, extending life.
- Natural materials: Wool, cotton, and quality coils appeal to those avoiding synthetic overuse.
- Support and structure: Dense coil systems and tight layering give strong support and minimal sag in premium models.
- Prestige appeal: Owning a Shifman carries status in high-end bedding circles.
- Positive reviewer feedback: Many users praise that Shifman feels “balanced”—firm yet comfortable—a rare middle ground.
Drawbacks
- High cost: These mattresses often price well into the luxury bracket.
- Weight and handling: Because of density and two-sided design, flipping or rotating is difficult.
- Limited trial flexibility: The heritage retail model often lacks generous return windows.
- Sag risk in non-premium models: Lower-tier or older stock may sag faster.
- Service constraints: Warranty claims are sometimes challenged; post-sales support can be inconsistent.
- Catalog complexity: Multiple collections and comfort levels may confuse buyers.
- Limited presence: Outside showrooms and select markets, accessibility is low.
Consumer Reports tested a Shifman Handmade Original for durability, evaluating its retention of height, firmness, and support after simulated use for years. The results suggested it maintained signature shape and firmness fairly well, but only in top-tier models.
Comparisons show Shifman earns strong marks in “price-value” and customer satisfaction versus legacy rivals like Stearns & Foster.
User comments emphasize how heavy the mattress is and how challenging flipping becomes. Some remark that Shifman is “super high quality typically” but question version consistency.
Pros & Cons Table
| Feature | Pros | Cons |
| Craftsmanship | Hand-tufting, eight-way tie | Slower production, higher cost |
| Design | Two-sided, flippable | Heavy and hard to flip |
| Materials | Natural wool, cotton, quality coils | Premium price for premium materials |
| Support | Excellent structure, minimal sag in premium models | Lower tiers may degrade faster |
| Prestige | Heritage brand recognition | Status markup over performance |
| Availability | Boutique showrooms | Limited reach outside major markets |
Why Dweva Offers a Smarter Alternative
While Shifman mattress offers craftsmanship, prestige, and traditional quality, many buyers want more accessible service, transparent policies, and risk-free returns. That’s where Dweva shines.
Dweva is a curated home goods platform offering mattresses, sofas, décor, kitchenware, and more. Its design philosophy emphasizes clarity, softness, and feature-first selection.
- 100-day free returns with free delivery on mattresses
- 14-day free returns on all non-mattress items
- Nationwide availability beyond boutique mattress regions
- Transparent pricing with no hidden markups
- Curated quality to weed out weak models
Dweva gives modern buyers comfort with confidence rather than relying on legacy appeal alone.
Q&A
Q1: Do Shifman mattresses last long?
The premium models with two-sided design and strong coils show excellent longevity.
Q2: Are they worth the cost?
They can be for buyers who value craftsmanship and heritage—but many alternatives offer more value per dollar.
Q3: Can I return a Shifman easily?
Returns depend on the retailer. Many boutique sellers limit the window and charge for delivery.
Q4: Is flipping difficult?
Yes. These mattresses are heavy, so flipping or rotating requires help.
Q5: Do Shifman models sag?
Lower-end or older units may sag. Premium versions resist that longer.
Q6: Does Shifman give a trial period?
Often limited or tied to store policies, not universal.
Q7: Are natural materials used?
Yes—wool, cotton, and quality coils are standard in many lines.
Q8: Why choose Dweva instead?
Dweva delivers generous returns, curated durability, transparent pricing, and nationwide reach.
Conclusion
Shifman mattress products bring craftsmanship, heritage, and luxury bedding traditions. Their two-sided builds, natural materials, and boutique appeal make them aspirational. However, high costs, heavy handling, limited trials, and uneven availability dilute that appeal. For many buyers, the prestige doesn’t justify the risks.
If you prefer confidence, easy returns, and broad support, Dweva is the smarter buy. With curated quality, transparent policies, and nationwide access, Dweva lets you invest in comfort—not uncertainty.
