I keep running into the same question from Maine shoppers and online readers. They walk into Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st, see a wall of big national brands, and then ask which specific beds actually earn their price tags from the perspective of real sleep. This Northern Mattress reviews project grew out of that exact confusion.
In my work as Chris Miller, I lean on a fixed testing crew. Marcus brings a bigger frame and a heat-sensitive back. Mia shows how a lighter side sleeper feels tiny changes at the shoulders. Jenna arrives with her partner Ethan for couple tests, while Jamal and Carlos check edge cases for support and alignment. I move between beds, log reactions, and try to keep everyone honest when personal bias kicks in.
For this kind of retailer review, we focused on four current models that anchor the Northern Mattress floor as far as hybrid and foam go: Serta iComfort Aveda Medium, Serta iComfort Aveda Plush, Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm, and Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush. These models pull in zoned memory foam, 1000-density pocketed coils, upgraded cooling covers, and mid-to-upper price tags from major national listings, which matches what shoppers typically see attached to the Northern Mattress brand story in store.
- 1. Product Overview
- 2. Testing Team Takeaways
- 3. Northern Mattress Comparison Chart
- 4. What We Tested and How We Tested It
-
5. Northern Mattress: Our Testing Experience
- 5.1 Serta iComfort Aveda Medium – Northern Mattress Ergonomic Support Anchor
- 5.2 Serta iComfort Aveda Plush – Northern Mattress Side-Sleeper Cloud Choice
- 5.3 Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm – Northern Mattress Heavy-Sleeper Support Tank
- 5.4 Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush – Northern Mattress Luxury Plush Hybrid Flagship
- 6. Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
- 7. Best Picks
- 8. How to Choose the Northern Mattress?
- 9. Limitations
- 10. Policies at a Glance
- 11. FAQs
- 12. Related Post
Product Overview
| Mattress | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price (queen, approx.) | Overall Score |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Medium – Northern Mattress Ergonomic Support Anchor | Zoned foam support; balanced medium feel; noticeably cool cover | Foam edges feel looser; bounce stays moderate | Average-weight combo sleepers; mixed back and side sleepers; warm sleepers who still like foam | About $1,400–$1,700 depending on retailer promotions | 4.2 / 5 |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Plush – Northern Mattress Side-Sleeper Cloud Choice | Deep contour at shoulders; strong pressure relief; quiet surface | Too soft for many stomach sleepers; weaker edge firmness | Light and average side sleepers; people with shoulder or hip pressure | About $1,300–$1,600 in recent listings | 4.1 / 5 |
| Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm – Northern Mattress Heavy-Sleeper Support Tank | Robust coil support; standout edge strength; cooler hybrid build | Feels rigid for lighter side sleepers; some motion carries through | Heavier sleepers; strict back or stomach sleepers; people who sit near the edge often | Around $1,400–$1,700 at major retailers | 4.4 / 5 |
| Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush – Northern Mattress Luxury Plush Hybrid Flagship | Plush top with strong pressure relief; advanced cooling; very balanced feel | Tall profile; may feel too cushy for ultra-firm fans | Side sleepers, many couples, combination sleepers wanting contour with lift | Roughly $1,600–$1,900 for queen, depending on sales | 4.5 / 5 |
Testing Team Takeaways
From my perspective, these Northern Mattress options split into two families. The Aveda pair gives that kind of dense, slow-responding memory foam feel with zoned support. The World Class hybrids push coil strength and height. As I rotated through, my lower back kept acting like a built-in meter. On Aveda Medium my lumbar region stayed aligned while my hips sank slightly into the zoned foam grid. On Level Three Hybrid Firm my hips rode higher, and that tightened my spine into a straighter line. I caught myself thinking “this bed feels like a long-shift recovery station” after a week of desk work.
Marcus approached the floor in his usual way. Bigger frame, warm sleeper, impatient with mushy edges. He climbed onto the Level Three Hybrid Firm, rolled from back to stomach, then sat on the corner and tied a shoe. He muttered “this kind of reset under my hips is what I chase” while pressing down through his lower back. The 1000-density pocketed coil core kept him lifted, yet the comfort stack still gave some surface cushioning. On Aveda Plush he enjoyed the first minute of sink, then commented later that his midsection drifted a touch, saying “after a full game on TV I feel like I am easing downhill.”
Mia moved like a sensor for pressure points. She hopped between Aveda Plush and Level Four Plush, since those models promised softer tops. On the firm hybrid she bounced once, frowned, and slid off without finishing a full episode of whatever show Jenna was streaming. On Aveda Plush she curled into her usual side-sleep tuck and said “this pocket around my shoulder feels right for my size.” During longer side sessions, her outer hip stayed calmer than on many medium-firm beds, which mattered for her lighter frame. On Level Four Plush she described the top as “that kind of marshmallow without the sinkhole under my hip.”
Jenna and Ethan treated this Northern Mattress reviews set as a couple lab. Jenna watches every small bump, while Ethan rolls all night. On Aveda Medium, Jenna reported very little disturbance when Ethan came back from a late kitchen trip, describing the movement as “a small wave, then nothing.” Ethan felt slightly stuck during fast position changes, particularly under his shoulders, yet he appreciated the even mid-back support. On Level Four Plush, movement felt easier for him, and Jenna still marked motion isolation as strong. She did mention one thing about the hybrids: “edge support on the firm one feels rock solid, the plush one gives a little more when I claim the outside lane.”
Northern Mattress Comparison Chart
| Mattress | Firmness (1–10, our scale) | Height | Core Type | Key Materials | Cooling Performance | Support | Pressure Relief | Responsiveness | Motion Isolation | Durability Outlook |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Medium | About 6.5 medium-firm | ~12–14" | All-foam | CoolFeel cover, PerfectConform memory foam, 5-zone support foam | Strong for all-foam with cool cover and graphite-infused foams | High for average builds; zoned design under lumbar | High without extreme sink | Moderate; classic memory foam response | Very strong; minimal partner disturbance | Solid, dense foams with 10-year limited warranty |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Plush | About 5.5 medium-plush | ~12" | All-foam | CoolFeel fabric, softer PerfectConform memory foam, 5-zone core | Good, although deeper hug feels a bit warmer | Moderate for heavier sleepers; good for lighter bodies | Very strong at shoulders and hips | Slightly slower response than Medium | Excellent; great for light sleepers sharing a bed | Solid, though softer foams compress more over years |
| Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm | Around 7.5 firm | ~14–15" | Hybrid | 1000-density pocketed coils, high-density foams, InfiniCool surface | Very good airflow through coil core, cool-touch cover | Very high, especially for heavier bodies | Moderate; firmer feel under shoulders | Quick response, easy repositioning | Good, though some movement passes through coils | Strong coil unit and high-density foams |
| Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush | About 6 medium-plush | ~13.5" | Hybrid | 1000-density pocketed coils, 2x SurfaceTouch gel memory foam, InfiniCool MAX | Very strong cooling with advanced surface tech | High, with extra contour from thicker comfort stack | Very high; deep yet controlled hug | Quick but cushioned, suits restless sleepers | Very good; hybrids dampen motion effectively here | Premium build with robust coil system, plush yet dense foams |
What We Tested and How We Tested It
For this Northern Mattress reviews project, our crew followed the same testing framework we use on every major brand. I log every reaction under a consistent group of criteria, then match those notes against spec sheets from Serta and Beautyrest and policy details from Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st.
We time real sleep on each mattress, usually in multi-night blocks. Each tester returns with comments on support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, responsiveness, and perceived durability. I also ask them to judge value, based on current queen pricing and what kind of comfort story the bed delivers compared with similar models.
Every mattress receives side-sleep trials, back-sleep stretches, quick naps, and evening lounge sessions with laptops or streaming sessions. Jenna and Ethan run structured partner tests where Ethan changes positions on a fixed schedule while Jenna reports every bump or sway. Marcus and Jamal stress-test edges by sitting, tying shoes, and easing into standing again, because that motion tends to reveal weak rail foam.
We then convert those impressions into 3.0–5.0 scores for each metric. A 3.0 rating means adequate performance in that category, while a 5.0 rating signals standout performance in our view under real use. The overall score reflects the balance of metrics, rather than a simple average that ignores how sleepers actually prioritize support, cooling, and pressure relief.
Northern Mattress: Our Testing Experience
Serta iComfort Aveda Medium – Northern Mattress Ergonomic Support Anchor
Our Testing Experience
I moved onto Aveda Medium after a long day at the desk, already feeling a mild pull in my lower back. The first contact delivered that classic memory foam handshake, yet the zoned support underneath kept my hips from diving too far. While I lay on my back scrolling through notes, my lumbar area felt cradled rather than pushed. After an hour, I shifted to my side and noticed the foam holding my waist without collapsing under my shoulders. This kind of zoned layout lined up neatly with my mid-weight build.
Marcus often crushes softer beds, so I watched his first few minutes closely. He flopped down on his back and paused, then said “this feels medium on the tag, firmer under my frame.” His 230-pound build compressed through the top comfort foam but caught that 5-zone support grid before his hips sagged. During a half-night stomach-sleep test, his back woke up acceptable, yet he still preferred the hybrid later for that sleep style. He mentioned some heat after hours of use, although the CoolFeel cover and graphite-infused foams kept that warmth under control compared with older memory foam beds he knows.
Mia always treats medium beds with suspicion, since many feel too hard for her 125-pound side-sleeping frame. On Aveda Medium, she needed a bit more time. She lay on her right side, waited, then said “my shoulder finds a pocket, just slower than the plush version.” That slower sink actually helped keep her neck straight once the foam settled, yet she still leaned toward the Plush model for all-night side sleeping.
From Jenna and Ethan’s shared-bed runs, Aveda Medium looked impressive on motion isolation. Ethan climbed in late after watching a game; Jenna felt a small roll under her side, then the surface quieted. She described the feel as “stable enough that my brain stops tracking his movements.” Ethan’s one complaint centered on responsiveness. Quick turns required a bit of extra push from his shoulders, especially when shifting from side to back in the middle of the night.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Strong zoned support that keeps hips from drifting for many sleepers | Edge foam feels less secure during heavy sitting sessions |
| Balanced medium feel that handles back, side, and mixed positions | Heat builds slightly for heavier, very warm sleepers |
| Cool-to-the-touch fabric adds clear surface temperature relief | Response feels slower for restless combination sleepers |
| Very quiet surface with high motion isolation | Tall foam stack may feel cumbersome for people who like ultra-thin beds |
Details
- Type: All-foam memory foam mattress
- Height: About 12–14 inches depending on retailer spec
- Firmness feel (our scale): Around 6.5, medium-firm for average bodies
- Construction: CoolFeel fabric, PerfectConform memory foam, 5 ZoneResponse style support core for targeted zones
- Available sizes: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King in current listings
- Cooling features: Cool-to-the-touch cover, breathable foams, graphite or gel infusions in some versions
- Pressure relief: Zoned memory foam contouring, deeper cradle under shoulders and hips
- Responsiveness: Classic memory foam pace, slightly quicker than very dense legacy models
- Support system: Multi-zone base foam tuned for different body regions
- Motion isolation: Very high; foam stack absorbs partner movement effectively
- Edge support: Moderate; fine for sleeping near the edge, weaker for long sitting
- Durability: Dense foams, CertiPUR-US materials, 10-year limited manufacturer warranty typical for this line
- Shipping context: Sold through retailers like Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st and national chains; delivery fees vary by seller
- Trial and returns: Retailer dependent; Northern Mattress offers a 90-day sleep trial on select mattresses over a price threshold, with conditions and service fees
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.4 | Zoned core kept my lumbar area level, even with Marcus’s heavier frame pressing in. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.3 | Deep enough contour for shoulders and hips without collapsing under the mid-section. |
| Cooling | 4.1 | CoolFeel fabric and breathable foams managed heat better than many all-foam rivals. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.6 | Jenna barely felt Ethan’s late entries or small position shifts. |
| Edge Support | 3.6 | Edges felt safe for sleeping but compressed under repeated heavy sitting. |
| Responsiveness | 3.8 | Memory foam feel limited quick changes for restless combination sleepers. |
| Durability | 4.2 | Dense foams and standard 10-year coverage suggest a solid lifespan. |
| Value | 4.0 | Mid-to-upper pricing, yet support and zoning match what many shoppers expect at that tier. |
| Overall | 4.2 | Balanced performance with standout support and motion control for a wide range of sleepers. |
Serta iComfort Aveda Plush – Northern Mattress Side-Sleeper Cloud Choice
Our Testing Experience
I usually approach plush memory foam with some caution, since my lower back dislikes deep sink. On Aveda Plush, I started on my side for once, stacking pillows the way many readers do. My shoulder slid in faster than on the Medium version, while my waist still felt lightly held. After thirty minutes, I rotated to my back and noticed my hips resting slightly lower into the foam grid. My spine stayed mostly aligned, yet I would not choose this version for strict stomach sleep under my own frame.
Mia, by contrast, looked almost relieved the moment she lay down. She rolled to her left side, tucked her knees, and stayed quiet. After a while she said “this kind of soft shoulder pocket makes me forget about the mattress.” During longer trials, her knees and outer hips stayed happier than on many medium beds we have tested. The zoned support still held her small frame near the surface, which stopped the bed from turning into a full hammock.
Marcus treated Aveda Plush like a comfort experiment. He spent one night mostly on his side, then another on his stomach. His take sounded measured. He said “for my weight this feels good at the shoulders, soft under my hips by morning.” His back did not blow up, yet he clearly favored this model more for side-sleep evenings and less for full-night stomach sessions.
On the couple side, Jenna ranked motion isolation here as excellent. Ethan moved through his usual sequence of side-to-back-to-side turns, and Jenna reported nearly no disruption. She did mention that getting close to the edge felt more wobbly than on the hybrids, especially when two people pushed out toward the rail.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Deep pressure relief ideal for lighter or average side sleepers | Too soft for many strict stomach sleepers, especially heavier ones |
| Strong motion isolation for couples with restless partners | Edge support weaker, especially during sitting on corners |
| Quiet surface with little bounce or noise | Some sleepers may feel too “hugged” by the foam |
| Zoned support still keeps lighter bodies from sinking excessively | Tall foam profile can feel warm without a breathable bedding setup |
Details
- Type: All-foam plush memory foam mattress
- Height: Around 12 inches in many current listings
- Firmness feel (our scale): About 5.5, noticeably plusher than the Medium version
- Construction: CoolFeel fabric, softer PerfectConform memory foam, 5 ZoneResponse ergonomic support core
- Available sizes: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King across retailers
- Cooling features: Cool-touch cover and breathable foams; deeper hug keeps more of the body in contact with the surface
- Pressure relief: Very high; shoulders and hips sink comfortably without abrupt transition into the base
- Responsiveness: Slow, classic memory foam glide into each position
- Support system: Zoned base tuned to align spine, skewed slightly toward side-sleep comfort
- Motion isolation: Excellent; ideal for people waking easily from partner movements
- Edge support: On the soft side; sleeping near the perimeter works, extended sitting feels less stable
- Durability: Foam densities and 10-year limited warranty match the Medium line; plusher feel may show impressions slightly sooner under heavy usage
- Shipping context: Sold through Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st and other regional retailers, with local delivery fees
- Trial and returns: Rely on retailer policies in each region, including the Northern Mattress 90-day sleep trial on qualifying models with restocking and service fees
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.0 | Works well for lighter bodies; heavier stomach sleepers pushed beyond the sweet spot. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.5 | Mia’s shoulders and hips finally relaxed during all-night side sleeping. |
| Cooling | 4.0 | Cool cover helped, yet deeper hug raised skin contact warmth a little. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.7 | Jenna barely registered Ethan’s frequent turns or late returns. |
| Edge Support | 3.4 | Perimeter compressed notably during sitting and heavy edge use. |
| Responsiveness | 3.7 | Slow foam feel, which pleased some users and annoyed restless movers. |
| Durability | 4.1 | Construction looks solid; softer comfort layer will show wear faster under heavy weight. |
| Value | 4.1 | Strong side-sleep performance at pricing that lines up with mid-tier premium foam. |
| Overall | 4.1 | Excellent pick for side sleepers who want a plush yet structured foam feel. |
Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm – Northern Mattress Heavy-Sleeper Support Tank
Our Testing Experience
The Level Three Hybrid Firm set a different tone the moment I sat on it. My hips barely sank while I perched on the edge, and the coil unit pushed back with a clear, springy resistance. Once I lay on my back, my lower spine felt long and straight, almost locked into position by the 1000-density pocketed coils and firmer comfort foams. During longer laptop sessions, that straightness actually kept my back calmer, even though the top felt less plush than the Aveda pair.
Marcus treated this mattress as home base. He stretched out on his back first, then flipped to his stomach after an hour. His reaction came quick: “this thing holds me up like a platform, but the top still has cushion.” When he rolled toward the edge in half-sleep, the border support foam and coil edge made the mattress feel almost bench-solid under him. Heat stayed controlled through the night, helped by the coil core and InfiniCool-type surface materials.
Mia lasted only a short stint here. As a petite side sleeper, she never fully sank her shoulders into the firmer top. She said “my shoulder feels pinned instead of nestled” after about twenty minutes. That reaction matched the spec sheet where this model lines up as a firm option targeted more toward back and stomach sleepers than delicate side sleepers.
From the couple perspective, Jenna and Ethan called this model “very stable but a bit bouncy.” Ethan’s movements translated into small ripples, yet the individual pocketed coils kept those waves smaller than classic open-coil beds. Jenna felt secure using the outer third of the surface on shared nights, which matters under real bedroom conditions where couples rarely stay centered.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Strong coil support ideal for heavier bodies and back or stomach sleepers | Too firm for many lighter side sleepers who need deeper shoulder sink |
| Excellent edge strength for sitting, tying shoes, or sleeping near the rail | Some motion travels through the coil system during big movements |
| Hybrid design promotes better airflow than dense all-foam beds | Firm top may feel unwelcoming to people who prefer plush starts |
| InfiniCool-style surface materials keep the top noticeably temperate | Tall build may require deeper fitted sheets for a clean fit |
Details
- Type: Hybrid mattress in the Beautyrest World Class Level Three family
- Height: Common listings show around 14–15 inches, depending on exact configuration
- Firmness feel (our scale): About 7.5, clearly firm
- Construction: 1000-density pocketed coil core, high-density transition foams, firm comfort layer, InfiniCool cooling surface
- Available sizes: Twin through California King at many retailers, including Northern Mattress’s size filters
- Cooling features: Coil airflow plus cool-to-the-touch quilted surface, designed to reduce heat buildup over the night
- Pressure relief: Modest; enough foam to prevent harsh pressure, yet tuned for lifted support
- Responsiveness: Quick, springy feel that lets sleepers change positions easily
- Support system: Zoned 1000-density pocketed coils providing targeted lift under hips and lumbar area
- Motion isolation: Better than classic innerspring, slightly behind thick all-foam beds
- Edge support: Very strong; reinforced edge coils and perimeter foam gave our heavy testers clear confidence
- Durability: Robust coil unit and dense foams; backed by a typical 10-year limited warranty from Beautyrest
- Shipping context: Available in-store and online; Northern Mattress provides regional delivery under its standard policy
- Trial and returns: Subject to local retailer terms; Northern Mattress handles sleep-trial reselects with defined fees and conditions
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.7 | Marcus’s hips and torso stayed lifted on back and stomach throughout long trials. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.9 | Enough cushion for many backs; side sleepers like Mia felt pinned at the shoulders. |
| Cooling | 4.3 | Hybrid airflow and cool surface kept our hot sleepers more comfortable overnight. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.0 | Individual coils limited disturbance, yet bigger moves still traveled a bit. |
| Edge Support | 4.8 | Edge felt nearly bench-like for sitting and sleeping near the rail. |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 | Quick pushback made turns and position changes feel effortless. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Coil system and foam density promise a long working life under heavy use. |
| Value | 4.2 | Firm hybrid performance matches pricing for this premium segment. |
| Overall | 4.4 | Excellent for heavier or back-focused sleepers who want strong lift and firm contour. |
Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush – Northern Mattress Luxury Plush Hybrid Flagship
Our Testing Experience
The Level Four Plush hybrid became the wildcard in this Northern Mattress reviews lineup. I climbed onto the surface and felt a noticeably softer initial welcome than the Level Three Firm, yet my hips did not plunge out of alignment. The thicker SurfaceTouch gel memory foam layers shaped around my shoulders and lower back, while the same 1000-density coil unit quietly held the structure underneath. After a full night rotating between side and back, my lower spine still felt clean in the morning.
Mia took to this mattress quickly. She described the top as “soft like the plush foam bed, but with springs that keep me from burying myself.” On her usual side-sleep position, her shoulders sank deeply enough without twisting her neck, and her outer hip rested in a cushioned pocket. Longer sessions confirmed that the extra comfort foam above the coils spreads pressure very evenly across a small frame.
Marcus approached it with mild skepticism because of the “Plush” label. After a few nights, he changed his stance. He said “I still feel lifted in the middle, even though the top feels cushy.” His hips rode slightly deeper than on the Level Three Firm but stayed above the line that would bother his lower back. For him this model worked better as a back-sleep and side-sleep hybrid than as a pure stomach-sleep platform, yet the overall experience impressed him.
For Jenna and Ethan, Level Four Plush might be the most balanced couple mattress in this group. Ethan rolled through his typical pattern of restless changes, and Jenna reported muted movement but not that dead, stuck memory-foam feeling. She could reposition easily while still feeling enough hug to keep her shoulders relaxed. Edge support stayed strong, though slightly softer than the Level Three Firm, which she described as “solid but not sharp at the border.”
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Plush surface with strong underlying support for many body types | Softer feel may not suit sleepers who want very firm beds |
| Excellent pressure relief without losing coil-driven lift | Slightly less edge stiffness than the firm Level Three hybrid |
| Hybrid bounce plus thick foam comfort layers suit restless sleepers | Tall profile can challenge shallow bed frames or thin sheet sets |
| Advanced cooling tech keeps the surface pleasantly temperate | Price sits at the higher end of the Northern Mattress lineup |
Details
- Type: Plush hybrid mattress in the Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four series
- Height: Around 13.5 inches according to major retail listings
- Firmness feel (our scale): About 6, a medium-plush hybrid profile
- Construction: 1000-density pocketed coil support core, 2x SurfaceTouch gel memory foam layers, additional comfort foams, InfiniCool MAX cooling surface
- Available sizes: Twin through California King, including queen as the most common purchase size
- Cooling features: Enhanced cooling package with cool-touch quilt and breathable coil structure, designed for steady overnight temperature
- Pressure relief: Very strong; deep yet controlled hug which suits side sleepers and combination sleepers with shoulder or hip sensitivity
- Responsiveness: Quick response from the coil layer, cushioned by thick top foams, which let restless sleepers move without feeling stuck
- Support system: Zoned pocketed coils with high density and strong edge structure
- Motion isolation: Very good; coil design plus foam layers dampen most partner movement while keeping some natural bounce
- Edge support: Strong, with only slight give at the very perimeter under heavy sitting
- Durability: High-quality coil unit and dense foams, covered by a typical 10-year limited warranty from Beautyrest
- Shipping context: Sold through national retailers and regional stores like Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st
- Trial and returns: Rely on store policies; Northern Mattress applies its sleep-trial framework and service rules on qualifying purchases
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.6 | Coil system held heavier and lighter testers in aligned positions across nights. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.8 | Deep, even contouring that kept Mia’s shoulders and my hips comfortable. |
| Cooling | 4.5 | InfiniCool MAX and coil airflow kept our hot testers more comfortable. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.4 | Ethan’s restless shifts stayed muted for Jenna during couple tests. |
| Edge Support | 4.5 | Strong perimeter held up during sitting and edge-sleeping, slightly softer than the Level Three firm. |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 | Quick, cushioned bounce made movements easy without jarring transitions. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Premium build and dense foams suggest long-term structural integrity. |
| Value | 4.3 | Higher price, yet luxury feel and balanced performance justify it for many shoppers. |
| Overall | 4.5 | Standout plush hybrid for side sleepers and couples seeking comfort with support. |
Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Medium | 4.2 | 4.4 | 4.3 | 4.1 | 4.6 | 4.2 | 3.8 |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Plush | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.5 | 4.0 | 4.7 | 4.1 | 3.7 |
| Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm | 4.4 | 4.7 | 3.9 | 4.3 | 4.0 | 4.6 | 4.4 |
| Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush | 4.5 | 4.6 | 4.8 | 4.5 | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.4 |
From this comparison, Level Four Plush emerges as the most balanced performer, particularly for pressure relief and cooling. Level Three Hybrid Firm stands out as a specialist in high support and edge strength. The Aveda pair focuses on motion isolation and deep foam contour, with Medium aiming at broader sleeper types and Plush zeroing in on side sleepers needing extra softness.
Best Picks
-
Best Northern Mattress Hybrid for Back and Stomach Sleepers – Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm
This mattress handled Marcus’s heavier build and my own combination style with clear, consistent lift. Strong edge support and firm coils matched our support scores and created that reliable “platform” feel many back and stomach sleepers want. -
Best Northern Mattress Plush Foam Choice for Side Sleepers – Serta iComfort Aveda Plush
Side sleepers like Mia gained serious relief at shoulders and hips on this model. High motion isolation, zoned support, and a softer top layer delivered that kind of cloud-like hug without losing core alignment for lighter or average-weight bodies. -
Best Northern Mattress Luxury Plush Hybrid for Couples – Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush
This hybrid gave Jenna and Ethan a rare mix: motion control strong enough for light sleepers and responsiveness quick enough for restless partners. Cooling tech, thick pressure-relieving foams, and sturdy coils support the top scores we recorded across pressure relief and overall feel.
How to Choose the Northern Mattress?
From the perspective of a shopper standing inside Northern Mattress & Furniture 1st, decision making usually starts with body weight, sleep position, and heat sensitivity. Budget and material preference follow right behind. These four mattresses cover a range of needs under those circumstances, even though each skews toward specific sleepers.
A light-weight side sleeper who wakes with sore shoulders probably fits best on Serta iComfort Aveda Plush or Beautyrest Level Four Plush. The Aveda Plush gives a very close, slow-moving hug that erases small pressure points, while the Level Four Plush adds coil lift and bounce for people who dislike deep sink.
An average-weight back sleeper with some side sleeping mixed in can move toward Aveda Medium or Level Four Plush, depending on how much contour they enjoy. Aveda Medium feels more traditional foam, with dense support and quieter movement. Level Four Plush feels more buoyant, combining coil spring with thick memory foam comfort.
A hot sleeper who dislikes feeling wrapped in foam might steer toward Level Three Hybrid Firm or Level Four Plush. Those hybrids use a ventilated coil core and cool-touch fabrics, which helped Marcus and Ethan stay more comfortable overnight during our tests.
A heavier couple that uses the whole mattress surface should look closely at Level Three Hybrid Firm. Edge reinforcement and coil strength kept Marcus comfortable near the perimeter and supported Ethan’s shifting weight. If the pair prefers more cushion, they can trade some firmness for the plusher yet still supportive Level Four Plush.
Limitations
As far as this Northern Mattress grouping goes, several patterns show up. Extremely firm-mattress fans will not find a true board-like option here; even the Level Three Firm keeps a degree of foam cushioning. Ultra-budget shoppers might feel priced out, since all four models sit in the mid-to-upper range in national listings. Very heavy sleepers well above Marcus’s weight who want maximal stiffness may eventually need an even more specialized build with thicker gauge coils.
Fans of bouncy, thin innerspring mattresses without thick foam will also feel out of place. The hybrids lean toward a modern comfort stack with noticeable top foam. Meanwhile, the Aveda foam beds simply will not please people who hate that slow-moving memory foam feel, no matter how impressive the zoning looks.
Policies at a Glance
| Mattress | Shipping (cost and region) | Trial Period | Return Policy / Fees | Warranty Length | Notable Conditions |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Medium | Local delivery from Northern Mattress within its Maine service area, fee added and non-refundable | Northern Mattress 90-day sleep trial on qualifying beds over set price thresholds; must sleep at least 45 days | Reselect within trial window, with roughly 20% restocking charge plus service / delivery fee; no straight refunds on used mattresses | Typically 10-year limited Serta warranty on structural defects | Mattress protectors often required to keep trial and warranty valid; stains or damage void coverage; no returns once used outside trial framework |
| Serta iComfort Aveda Plush | Same delivery rules as Medium within store region; other retailers may ship wider | Eligible for the same 90-day store trial when price and model qualify | Similar restocking and service fees; exchanges rather than pure refunds | 10-year limited manufacturer warranty standard for this line | Sleep-trial availability depends on model and sale price; clearance units usually excluded |
| Beautyrest World Class 25 Level Three Hybrid Firm | Regional delivery with non-refundable fee; scheduling windows given before truck routes | Covered by store sleep trial when price and mattress line meet criteria | One permitted reselection in trial period, plus fees; used bedding cannot be returned for refund | 10-year limited warranty from Beautyrest against major defects | Must keep mattress clean and protected; body impressions under specific depth generally excluded |
| Beautyrest World Class Hybrid Level Four Plush | Same regional delivery pattern; other vendors may offer broader shipping | Store sleep trial applies on qualifying purchases; terms mirror other premium mattresses | Reselection requires service and restocking fees; no returns after trial window | Standard 10-year limited warranty from Beautyrest | Floor models and clearance deals usually do not include full trial; store policies control eligibility |
From the perspective of a cautious buyer, the Level Four Plush and Level Three Firm often land in the price range that unlocks Northern Mattress’s 90-day trial. Those policies look customer-friendly enough when someone expects to fine-tune comfort once. The key catch lies in fees and stain rules, since any damage or lack of a protector can void both the trial and parts of the warranty.
FAQs
1. Are Northern Mattress foam beds or hybrids better for back pain?
In my view, that depends heavily on body weight and sleep style. Aveda Medium held my combination-sleeper back in a very neutral position with its zoned foam core, which worked well for mild desk-related tightness. Level Three Hybrid Firm gave Marcus even stronger hip and lumbar support under his heavier frame, using its dense coil unit to prevent sagging. People with lighter bodies or dominant side sleeping often find Level Four Plush more forgiving at the shoulders while still supportive.
2. Which Northern Mattress option feels coolest for hot sleepers?
Marcus tends to run warm, and he felt the hybrids stay more comfortable through full nights. The coil cores in Level Three Firm and Level Four Plush let air move under the body, while their InfiniCool-style covers give a clearly cooler first contact. The Aveda models felt cooler than many older memory foam beds, yet they still hold more warmth around the body due to deeper foam cradle, especially the Plush version.
3. How do these Northern Mattress models handle motion transfer for couples?
From Jenna’s perspective as a light sleeper sharing with restless Ethan, the Aveda foam beds did the best job at killing motion. On Aveda Plush and Aveda Medium, Ethan’s late-night returns barely moved her side of the bed. The hybrids, especially Level Four Plush, struck a middle ground where motion dampened nicely without erasing bounce, which Ethan preferred for turning without effort.
4. Do heavier sleepers sink too far on the plush Northern Mattress options?
Heavier sleepers like Marcus experienced different outcomes. On Aveda Plush, his hips eased deeper into the surface overnight, which pushed that mattress toward side-sleep and away from strict stomach use at his size. On Level Four Plush, the coil system underneath kept his midsection higher, even though the top felt cushy. For very heavy sleepers wanting maximum lift, Level Three Hybrid Firm remained the clear favorite.
5. Are these Northern Mattress beds good for stomach sleepers?
Under most circumstances, stomach sleepers benefit from firmer builds that keep hips from bowing downward. In this group, Level Three Hybrid Firm best served that need, followed by Aveda Medium for average-weight sleepers. Aveda Plush and Level Four Plush felt more tuned toward back and side sleepers; stomach sleepers on those models should watch for lower-back discomfort over time.
6. How strong is edge support on these Northern Mattress options?
Edge strength matters a lot from the perspective of people sitting to dress or sharing smaller sizes. The hybrid pair from Beautyrest clearly outranked the foam models here. Level Three Hybrid Firm in particular felt nearly bench-solid at the corners for Marcus and Jamal. Aveda edges worked fine for sleeping near the perimeter but compressed more under long sitting sessions.
7. How long should these Northern Mattress models last under normal use?
Durability depends on body weight, rotation habits, and foundation quality. The coil-based World Class hybrids use high-density pocketed coils and robust foams, which gave us confidence for long-term use under a range of weights. The Aveda foam beds rely on dense, CertiPUR-US certified foams and carry 10-year warranties, which indicates expected longevity in that range, although plusher models like Aveda Plush usually show impressions sooner under heavier sleepers.
8. Are these mattresses suitable for adjustable bases from Northern Mattress?
The Serta and Beautyrest spec sheets list these models as adjustable-friendly. During our testing, we raised head and foot sections without issues on the Aveda pair and the World Class hybrids. The foam constructions and pocketed coils flexed cleanly along the base joints, without noticeable creaks or structural strain.
9. What kind of sleeper should avoid this set of Northern Mattress models?
From the perspective of our crew, people chasing extremely hard, thin mattresses without much foam will feel disappointed here. The entire group leans toward modern comfort stacks with meaningful cushioning. Ultra-budget shoppers searching for rock-bottom prices may also need other lines, since these beds sit solidly in the mid-to-upper price brackets.
10. How do I decide between Aveda Medium and Aveda Plush at Northern Mattress?
If you sleep in mixed positions or spend real time on your stomach, Aveda Medium usually fits better. That zoned medium-firm feel held my hips and Marcus’s heavier frame higher, with more versatility. If your profile leans strongly toward side sleeping, especially at a lighter weight like Mia’s, Aveda Plush brings extra shoulder and hip cushioning that many side sleepers find more comfortable during all-night sessions.
