Metro Mattress Reviews

I am Chris Miller, and I went into Metro Mattress mattress reviews with a specific curiosity in mind. Metro Mattress works mainly as a retailer, yet it also pushes several exclusive house collections that real shoppers encounter constantly on its floor and site. I wanted to see how these in-house lines behave across real bodies instead of stock marketing copy.

For this project, I focused on four current mainstream models that shoppers find through Metro Mattress: Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam, Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam, Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top, and American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top. These models cover foam, hybrid, and more traditional innerspring builds under the Metro Mattress umbrella, with Chill and Comfort Concepts described as exclusive collections and American Splendor positioned as a made-in-USA value line. 

Our standing six-person team stayed in place. I handled coordination as usual, with Marcus Reed, Mia Chen, and Jenna Brooks as the primary supporting testers for this brand. Marcus brought a bigger, heat-sensitive frame. Mia represented lighter side sleepers. Jenna checked couple-friendliness and motion transfer. Those three perspectives, combined with my combination-sleeping back, shaped every score you will see in this Metro Mattress deep dive.

Product Overview

Mattress	Pros	Cons	Ideal For	Price	Overall Score
Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam – “Metro Cooling Foam Workhorse”	Strong cooling cover and gel foams, good contouring for average sleepers	All-foam feel might feel too slow for very restless movers	Average-weight back and side sleepers who want a cool foam bed-in-a-box option	Queen prices usually sit in the mid-range among Chill models; size and promos change tags	4.3 / 5
Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam – “Metro Hybrid Chill Specialist”	Hybrid design with wrapped coils, cooler surface feel for hot sleepers	Slight bounce may bother ultra-light sleepers who want a perfectly still bed	Hot sleepers who like some bounce, combination sleepers, heavier teens and adults	From about $849 for twin sizes online, higher for larger sizes	4.4 / 5
Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top – “Metro Value Euro-Top Innerspring”	Pocket coil support with foam-encased edge, approachable feel for many	Less contouring than thick foam beds, motion isolation only moderate	Budget-conscious shoppers who prefer classic innerspring bounce and a cushioned top	Comfort Concepts pricing often keeps queens near the lower mid-range of the Metro Mattress lineup	4.1 / 5
American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top – “Metro Traditional Pillow-Top Favorite”	Deep pillow-top with gel foam and perimeter pocket coils, strong edge feel	Thicker top can feel warm for extremely hot sleepers without breathable bedding	Traditional-feel fans, side sleepers who like a plush top, guest rooms needing impact	American Splendor models typically run roughly $1,099–$1,699 across sizes	4.2 / 5

Testing Team Takeaways

From my perspective, the Metro Mattress house collections land in a middle zone between entry-level online foam beds and high-end boutique hybrids. I felt that during the first rotation on Chill CoolHaven. My lower back met a firm foam core under a fairly plush top, which produced a slow yet controlled sink. On Polar Dream I noticed a different rhythm. Wrapped coils pushed back faster under my hips, while the gel foam layers kept my shoulders from digging in. Sea Island Euro Top gave me a lighter, more buoyant ride, and Nobility Box Pillow Top gave classic pillow-top plushness that never quite swallowed my hips.

Marcus reacted quickly on the Chill models. During his first night on Chill CoolHaven, he rolled from back to stomach and muttered, “I like the support, but I want more snap under my hips.” After two more nights, his notes mentioned that the foam core held alignment decently, yet the pure-foam feel never became his favorite. On Chill Polar Dream, his tone shifted. After a long evening of streaming, he looked up and said, “Hybrid reset feeling here; my hips feel parked, and I am not overheating.” Sea Island’s firmer coil unit kept him decently leveled, while Nobility’s pillow-top comfort gave him a softer landing that he still treated as “weekend bed” rather than daily driver. 

Mia focused hard on pressure relief. On CoolHaven she described the first impression as “soft pocket around my shoulders with enough lift under my ribs.” During side sleep marathons, she liked the gel-infused layers yet occasionally missed a bit of bounce when switching sides quickly. Polar Dream gave her more spring under the foam; she liked that combination because it let her slide across the surface without getting stuck. On Sea Island Euro Top she sensed a firmer surface under lighter joints. Her notebooks included a line that read, “Euro top feels friendly for short naps, yet for long side sessions I prefer the Chill beds.” Nobility Box Pillow Top, with its thicker soft foam stack over coils, made her shoulders happiest, though she noted mild warmth on heavy blanket nights. 

Jenna cared most about how these Metro Mattress choices worked for couples. On CoolHaven she placed her phone with a motion app near her pillow while Marcus got in and out. The data spikes stayed small, and her comment afterward captured the feel: “I see him move; I hardly ride the wave though.” Polar Dream behaved a bit differently. Coils added bounce, which she noticed late at night. Her note read, “Still fine for me, yet the movement feels sharper when he rolls hard onto his side.” Sea Island landed closer to a classic innerspring for her, with more transfer when someone hopped into bed. Nobility softened that same bounce under its pillow-top, giving her a sense of buffered movement that still reminded her of traditional hotel mattresses. 

Metro Mattress Comparison Chart

Mattress	Firmness Profile	Type	Thickness	Key Materials	Cooling Performance	Support Character	Pressure Relief Character	Responsiveness	Motion Isolation	Durability Outlook
Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam	Medium-firm overall feel with plush upper memory-foam layers	All-foam bed-in-a-box style mattress	Around 14" profile, depending on size	Premium cooling cover, hybrid comfort foam, gel-infused visco layers, firm foam core	Strong surface-temperature control from cooling fabric and gel foams	Even support for average-weight backs and sides; heavier bodies sit deeper	Deep yet controlled cradle around shoulders and hips	Slower response than a coil bed, yet faster than dense memory-foam bricks	Good isolation; most partner motion shows as muted shifts	Foam core with higher-density layers and 10-year warranty gives respectable lifespan
Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam	Medium profile that leans slightly firm under heavier bodies	Hybrid combining foam comfort with wrapped coil support	Around 12–13" depending on exact model	Premium cooling cover, gel bead visco, transition foam, 8" 790 wrapped coils	Cooler feel than many standard hybrids, suitable for hot sleepers	Stronger mid-section lift from pocket coils, helpful for heavier testers	Balanced contour; less sink than CoolHaven but still relieves pressure	Livelier bounce from coils under foam; easy repositioning	More motion transfer than CoolHaven, yet still reasonable for many couples	Hybrid build with pocket coils and 10-year warranty indicates good long-term potential
Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top	Medium to medium-firm, depending on perceived softness of Euro top	Traditional pocket-coil innerspring with Euro-top foam comfort layer	Mentioned height around 11.5"	Comfort fiber, quilting foam layers, comfort foam, support pad, 660 pocket coil unit with foam-encased edge	Adequate cooling from air flow through pocket coils and fabric quilting	Buoyant coil support under the lumbar region; suits broad range of weights	Modest contour; Euro-top layer softens contact without deep sink	Quick response, classic spring feel that helps frequent movers	Noticeable partner movement, especially with big weight differences	Foam-encased pocket coils plus 10-year warranty should handle many years of nightly use
American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top	Medium-plush feel with a thicker pillow-top surface	Pillow-top hybrid using gel foams over pocket coils	Height around the low-to-mid teens, depending on size	Comfort fiber, soft foams, 3" gel foam, comfort foam, 9" 824 perimeter pocket coils, solid foundation	Pillow-top loft can feel warm without breathable bedding, yet gel layer moderates heat somewhat	Strong perimeter coils give solid hip support and edge stability	Plush top eases pressure at shoulders and hips for a wide range	Moderate bounce from coil core, softened by thick foam stack	Motion transfer sits between Sea Island and the Chill hybrids	10-year non-prorated warranty and robust coil design give solid durability prospects

What We Tested and How We Tested It

Our Metro Mattress mattress reviews used a shared testing house as usual. Each mattress went on an appropriate foundation or adjustable base, with foam models set on solid platform-style support and coil beds on sturdy foundations matching Metro Mattress recommendations. 

We rotated the four mattresses through the master bedroom and a secondary room for six weeks. Every tester logged at least a week on each model. I tracked my lower-back tension every morning. Marcus recorded hip alignment and overnight heat. Mia focused on side-sleeping pressure points. Jenna logged every noticeable partner disturbance with a simple motion-tracking app beside her pillow.

Our scoring rested on these core criteria. Support and spinal alignment were checked in back, side, and stomach positions for different weights. Pressure relief was evaluated through longer holds on shoulders and hips, combined with subjective pain and numbness reports. Cooling behavior was recorded with small temperature sensors at the surface and under the sheet. Motion isolation was tested by controlled roll-ins and exits with another person watching the motion traces. Responsiveness and ease of movement came from side-to-side flips, sitting up, and low-intensity stretching on the mattress. Edge support, materials quality, durability outlook, and value relative to pricing inside the Metro Mattress ecosystem filled out the final rating grid. 

Metro Mattress: Our Testing Experience

Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam – “Metro Cooling Foam Workhorse”

Our Testing Experience

Chill CoolHaven arrived rolled and boxed, then expanded on a solid platform in our main test room. From the first touch, the cover felt cool under my hand. That cooling fabric paired with the gel-infused foam stack gave a different vibe than older, warmer memory-foam beds in our long-term rotation. 

My first night on CoolHaven started in my usual back-sleep position. I felt my hips settle through the hybrid and gel layers and meet the firm transition and support core. That stack created a gentle cradle under my pelvis without leaving my lumbar spine sagging. After fifteen minutes, I noticed my mid-back muscles relax. In my notebook I wrote, “Foam feel is present, yet I don’t feel trapped or stuck.”

When I rolled to my side, my 185-pound frame compressed the top layers enough that my shoulder found a defined pocket. Under that pocket, the transition and support layers stopped the sink before my ribs twisted. I ran one of our simple pressure maps for twenty minutes on each side. The hottest zones stayed around my shoulder and hip, yet the map displayed smoother gradients than we usually see on cheaper basic foam mattresses.

Marcus took over CoolHaven a few nights later. His heavier frame changed the story. On his back, he felt deeper sink at the hips. After three nights he told me in the kitchen, “Support feels okay, but I want more pushback near my belt line.” He slept mostly on his back and stomach for that rotation. In stomach position, his hips rode lower than his chest. That alignment still landed within acceptable ranges for shorter naps, yet his morning notes mentioned mild lower-back tightness after long nights.

Mia’s time on CoolHaven played very differently. At 125 pounds, she sat higher in the comfort layers. On her dominant side, she described the feel as “a padded pocket that lets my shoulder fall enough without jabbing my neck.” She also liked that the cooling cover reduced that sticky feel she often gets on warm foam beds. Her only complaint came during faster side-to-side flips. The deep foam stack delayed her motion slightly, which made her feel a fraction slower compared with polar Dream’s hybrid design.

Jenna focused on motion. She placed her phone near her pillow and had Marcus get in and out three times while she lay still with eyes closed. The motion app registered small peaks, yet she described the sensation as “barely there compared with old-school spring beds.” During real nights she woke up mostly from her usual alarms rather than from his early-morning exits.

CoolHaven ended up fitting best for average-weight and lighter sleepers who like a cool, slow-response all-foam bed, and for couples where motion control ranks higher than bounce.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Strong cooling cover combined with gel-infused foams	Pure foam feel may frustrate people who want strong bounce
Good contouring for average-weight backs and sides	Heavier stomach sleepers may notice extra hip sink
All-foam design handles partner motion well	Thicker profile can feel tall on some low frames
Bed-in-a-box style suits easy delivery and setup	Edge sitting support less robust than on coil models

Details

• Price: mid-range within Chill lineup, with online promotions shifting tags across seasons 
• Firmness: lands near medium-firm for average-weight testers
• Construction: all-foam mattress shipped compressed in a box
• Comfort system: premium cooling cover, top hybrid foam layer, 1.5" higher-density gel-infused visco, 1.5" gel bead visco 
• Support core: 2" firm transition foam above a 7" firm foam base
• Height: around 14" including comfort and support layers
• Available sizes: twin through king on the Metro Mattress site
• Cooling: cooling fabric plus gel foams, designed for hot sleepers under typical bedroom conditions 
• Pressure relief: deep contour at shoulders and hips, especially for light and average frames
• Responsiveness: moderate; foam slows movement slightly yet does not behave like ultra-dense memory foam
• Motion isolation: strong, due to continuous foam base and absence of coils
• Edge support: fair, with some compression during heavy edge sitting
• Durability: higher-density foams and a 10-year warranty give reasonable lifespan expectations 
• Shipping: boxed-mattress shipping through Metro Mattress, compatible with UPS-style delivery networks 
• Trial: eligible for 90-Night Comfort Guarantee when paired with required protector and pillow purchased at checkout 
• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty from the Chill program 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.2	Held my 185-pound frame in neutral alignment; Marcus wanted firmer hip support.
Pressure Relief	4.5	Deep foam cradle worked well for my side sleep and especially for Mia’s shoulders.
Cooling	4.4	Cooling cover and gel foams kept surface temperatures in a comfortable band most nights.
Motion Isolation	4.7	Marcus’s night movements showed up as small ripples, not big jolts for Jenna.
Edge Support	3.8	Noticeable compression while sitting near the perimeter, typical for many foam beds.
Responsiveness	4.0	Slower than hybrids, yet still manageable for position changes during restless nights.
Durability Outlook	4.4	Firmer base foam and 10-year warranty suggest a solid life for typical use.
Materials / Air Quality	4.3	Modern foams and cooling textiles, with no strong odors during expansion.
Value	4.1	Sits in a reasonable price pocket relative to build, cooling, and support level.
Overall Score	4.3	Cool-feeling foam option that favors average and lighter sleepers, plus motion-sensitive couples.

Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam – “Metro Hybrid Chill Specialist”

Our Testing Experience

Chill Polar Dream brought wrapped coils into the Chill family, and I felt that difference as soon as I lay down. The premium cooling cover matched CoolHaven’s vibe, yet the base responded with a springier push. Under the upper gel visco and transition foam, the 8" coil unit introduced a distinctive rhythm to every movement. 

I started on my back again. My hips eased through the gel layer and met firm yet responsive coils. That combination made my lower back feel supported without any hard plate sensation. When I turned onto my side, the foam layers took the edge off the coils. The cradle felt shallower than on CoolHaven but still clear. In my notes I wrote, “Hybrid feel lands between classic springs and deep foam; good for my mixed nights.”

During one longer test night, I ran a temperature sensor under my torso. Readings stayed several degrees lower than our older non-cooling hybrid reference mattress in the house. Subjectively, my skin felt less clammy under the sheet.

Marcus loved Polar Dream almost immediately. On the first evening he sprawled on his back and said, “This is the reset hit I needed under my hips.” When he rolled to his stomach, the coils and medium transition foam kept him higher than on CoolHaven. He still limited pure stomach sleep to shorter windows, yet his morning logs on this mattress showed less lingering tightness.

Heat behavior mattered a lot for him. After a week he told me, “I am sweating less here than on a lot of standard hybrids; the cover and gel do their job.” Our basic thermal readings lined up with that feeling.

Mia used Polar Dream as her “movement upgrade” from CoolHaven. On her side she still got enough relief at the shoulder. When she flipped to her other side, the surface bounced back more quickly. She described that difference as “a nudge rather than a drag when I roll over.” Her only hesitation involved deeper sleep stretches. For very long nights she still preferred the more enveloping feel from CoolHaven or Nobility.

Jenna again tested partner motion. With Marcus shifting weight, the motion app showed higher peaks than on CoolHaven. She felt that as a bit more bounce at her side of the bed. Her verdict sounded like this: “Still fine for me; just not dead-silent like a purely foam bed.”

Polar Dream ended up serving best as the Chill option for heavier or hotter sleepers who want hybrid support with strong cooling and a moderate contour.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Hybrid design combines cooling gel foams with responsive pocket coils	More motion transfer than all-foam CoolHaven for very light sleepers
Strong hip support for heavier testers	Slightly less plush contour for pure side-sleep purists
Cooler surface feel than many standard hybrids	Coil feel may bother people who dislike any bounce
Bed-in-a-box convenience with multiple size options	Edge support still trails some heavy-duty innersprings

Details

• Price: from around $849 for twin sizes online; larger sizes scale upward across the range 
• Firmness: medium leaning toward medium-firm under heavier bodies
• Construction: hybrid mattress combining foam layers with a wrapped-coil support core
• Comfort system: premium cooling cover, 1.5" gel bead visco, 1.5" medium transition layer above coils 
• Support core: 8" unit with roughly 790 wrapped coils in queen
• Height: around 12–13", depending on exact configuration
• Available sizes: twin through king, sold under the Chill program at Metro Mattress
• Cooling: designed for hot sleepers, using cooling fabric and gel-infused foams with air flow through the coil unit 
• Pressure relief: balanced feel that softens impact yet keeps sleepers closer to the surface than deep foam beds
• Responsiveness: noticeable bounce from the coil system beneath the foam layers
• Motion isolation: moderate; coils introduce more transfer than solid foam bases
• Edge support: better than CoolHaven, though not as rigid as heavily reinforced innersprings
• Durability: pocket-coil construction and 10-year warranty indicate reliable performance window 
• Shipping: boxed or scheduled delivery through Metro Mattress with flexible regional options 
• Trial: eligible for the 90-Night Comfort Guarantee when purchased with required Metro Mattress protector and pillow 
• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty on the mattress core 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.5	Coil unit held my back steady and gave Marcus the hip lift he wanted.
Pressure Relief	4.3	Foam layers delivered adequate cushion for side sleep, though not as deep as thick pillow-tops.
Cooling	4.6	Cooling fabric and gel foam combined with airflow from coils kept hot sleepers comfortable.
Motion Isolation	4.1	Some movement reached Jenna when Marcus moved, yet impact felt shorter and softer than old-style springs.
Edge Support	4.2	Edges felt stronger than all-foam models, with modest compression during sitting.
Responsiveness	4.5	Coils added bounce that helped repositioning without feeling jittery.
Durability Outlook	4.5	Wrapped coils and quality foams, plus 10-year warranty, support a solid lifespan.
Materials / Air Quality	4.3	Clean expansion, modern foams, and solid coil construction without heavy odors.
Value	4.3	Aggressive pricing for a cooling hybrid inside the Metro Mattress catalog.
Overall Score	4.4	Hybrid Chill option that targets hot sleepers and heavier bodies effectively.

Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top – “Metro Value Euro-Top Innerspring”

Our Testing Experience

Sea Island Euro Top came from the Comfort Concepts collection, which Metro Mattress calls an exclusive value line. The spec sheet for Sea Island lists comfort fiber and quilting foam in the Euro top, comfort foam in the upholstery, and a 660-pocket-coil support unit with foam-encased edge. 

I set Sea Island up on a standard foundation in our second bedroom. The mattress felt lighter than the Chill hybrids during setup. When I lay on my back, the Euro-top surface gave a bit of surface plushness before the pocket coils pushed back. My hips never plunged far. The feel reminded me of mid-range hotel beds that pick a neutral middle ground. In my journal I wrote, “Comfort sits between firm budget coils and deep cushion; nothing flashy, fairly steady.”

On side sleep, my shoulder met enough padding to avoid immediate pressure. After longer periods, I did start to feel more awareness at the shoulder tip than on the Chill models. The contouring felt shallower. For my 185-pound body, the trade-off was clear. I got easier movement than on the foams but less deep relief.

Marcus treated Sea Island as a test for value-focused back and stomach sleepers. Lying on his back, he liked the pocket-coil push under his lumbar area. On his stomach, he felt his hips ride fairly level, especially during shorter naps. His comment after several nights sounded like this: “Feels like a straightforward firmish innerspring with a soft lid; good for the price lane.” Heat did not spike for him here, thanks to the coil ventilation and quilted top.

Mia’s experience exposed the main limitation. On her side she initially liked the Euro-top cushion. After a couple of hours, she wrote that “pressure around my outer shoulder builds earlier than on Chill.” For her frame, the thinner comfort stack on Sea Island gave less room for the shoulder to sink, especially during long side-sleep runs. She still saw it as fine for guest rooms or shorter nights.

Jenna’s motion tests put Sea Island near the middle of our set. Pocket coils plus lighter foam layers transmitted partner movements more than CoolHaven or Polar Dream. She woke up once when Marcus got in quickly. When he moved slower, the disturbance felt milder. Her written line read, “This behaves like a standard spring bed with a slightly more cushioned top; I notice him, but it isn’t wild.”

For our group, Sea Island worked best as a value Euro-top choice for back and combo sleepers who like some bounce and who do not need deep side-sleep contouring.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Euro-top cushion with supportive pocket coils underneath	Shallower contouring for lighter side sleepers during long nights
Foam-encased edge gives better sitting stability	Motion transfer higher than on Chill foam models
Comfort Concepts pricing keeps this model accessible	Less feature-heavy than premium American Splendor builds
Good airflow and traditional bounce for people who dislike slow foam	Shorter comfort stack may not suit severe joint sensitivity

Details

• Price: typically lower mid-range inside Metro Mattress, below many American Splendor and Tempur-Pedic offerings 
• Firmness: lands near medium to medium-firm
• Construction: Euro-top innerspring mattress in the exclusive Comfort Concepts collection
• Comfort system: comfort fiber layer, FR barrier, multiple quilting foam layers, Euro-top construction, plus comfort foam in upholstery 
• Support core: 660 pocket-coil unit with foam-encased edge support
• Height: approximately 11.5" profile 
• Available sizes: twin through queen and king variations, with stock varying over time
• Cooling: decent ventilation from pocket coils and breathable quilting
• Pressure relief: moderate; best for average-weight sleepers rather than ultra-light side sleepers with fragile joints
• Responsiveness: spring feel, easier to move on than thick foam builds
• Motion isolation: fair; pocket coils tame some movement yet still transfer noticeable shifts
• Edge support: stronger than foam beds due to foam-encased coil perimeter
• Durability: 10-year warranty, coil design, and moderate price suggest a solid but not ultra-luxury lifespan 
• Shipping: standard delivery through Metro Mattress with same-day or next-day options in some regions 
• Trial: eligible for the 90-Night Comfort Guarantee with required protector and pillow purchases 
• Warranty: 10-year warranty associated with the model listing 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.3	Pocket coils held my back and Marcus’s frame reasonably level in back and stomach positions.
Pressure Relief	3.9	Euro-top softened contact yet could not match Chill or Nobility for long side-sleep stretches.
Cooling	4.2	Coil airflow and breathable quilting kept temperature in a comfortable range.
Motion Isolation	3.8	Partner shifts reached Jenna more clearly here, especially with quick movements.
Edge Support	4.4	Foam-encased perimeter gave solid sitting support and secure lying near the edge.
Responsiveness	4.6	Springy feel helped easy movement for restless sleepers and active stretch routines.
Durability Outlook	4.1	Pocket-coil build and 10-year warranty indicate respectable longevity for the price tier.
Materials / Air Quality	3.9	Standard foams and fibers, nothing exotic, yet no concerning odors or obvious weaknesses.
Value	4.4	Strong proposition for shoppers wanting a neutral-feel Euro-top at an accessible price.
Overall Score	4.1	Straightforward Euro-top innerspring that works well for value-driven back and combo sleepers.

American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top – “Metro Traditional Pillow-Top Favorite”

Our Testing Experience

American Splendor runs as another key house line for Metro Mattress. The brand description emphasizes made-in-USA builds and mid-range pricing. Nobility Box Pillow Top sits near the upper part of that range, with a multi-layer pillow-top stack over perimeter pocket coils. 

I placed Nobility on a solid state foundation, which matches the product description. That detail matters because the coil unit expects uniform support. The top felt plush under my hand, with clear loft from comfort fiber, soft foam layers, and a three-inch gel section stacked above additional comfort foam.

Lying on my back, I felt a gentle sink in the top layers before the 824 perimeter pocket coils stopped me. My hips floated lower than on Sea Island, yet stayed under control. After a full night, my lower back felt relaxed. Side sleeping changed the tone even more. The thick top allowed my shoulder to nestle deeply without sharp pressure. In my notes I wrote, “This behaves like the classic hotel pillow-top look, yet spine still feels organized.”

Marcus tested Nobility with measured skepticism. He often dislikes softer tops that let his hips sink too far. On his back he felt more enveloped than on Sea Island or Polar Dream. After a few nights he told me, “For a softer option, this holds up better than I expected; hips stay okay.” During longer stomach sessions, though, he noticed more sway in his lower back, which pushed him back toward back sleeping.

Mia enjoyed Nobility most among the four models for pure side sleeping. Her shoulder slid into the soft foam and gel combination, and she felt the pocket coils catch her hips without harshness. Her favorite line during debrief sounded like this: “This is the kind of plush feel I expect when someone says pillow-top, without that swampy sink.” She did mention a bit more warmth under heavy blankets on warmer nights. That warmth linked directly to the thicker foam stack near her body.

Jenna’s motion testing put Nobility between Sea Island and Polar Dream. The coil core carried some motion, yet the thick top slowed and diffused the movement. When Marcus climbed into bed quickly, she felt a dull wave instead of a sharp jolt. Her log summarized it as “classic couple bed energy; not silent, yet comfortable and predictable.”

As a group, we pegged Nobility as the traditional-feel Metro Mattress choice for people who want pillow-top plushness and decent edge support at a mid-range price.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Deep pillow-top comfort that suits side sleepers well	Thicker foam stack can feel warm without breathable sheets and blankets
Perimeter pocket coils give strong edge support	Stomach sleepers with heavier hips may want a firmer surface
Made-in-USA positioning adds appeal for some buyers	Motion isolation still behind all-foam models
Ten-year non-prorated warranty within a mid-range price band	Heaviest sleepers may want more robust internal zoning

Details

• Price: American Splendor mattresses generally run about $1,099–$1,699 depending on size and configuration 
• Firmness: medium-plush overall feel
• Construction: pillow-top hybrid with multiple foam layers over an 824-count perimeter pocket-coil system
• Comfort system: comfort fiber, FR barrier, super-soft foams, 3" gel foam, additional comfort foam layers 
• Support core: 9" 824 perimeter pocket coils paired with a solid state foundation
• Height: profile sits in the lower-to-mid teen inches depending on size
• Available sizes: twin through king, including box and set configurations
• Cooling: gel foam moderates heat somewhat; thicker pillow-top still runs warmer than Chill hybrids for very hot users 
• Pressure relief: strong, especially for side sleepers and people with sensitive shoulders and hips
• Responsiveness: moderate bounce from coils under a slower-responding foam stack
• Motion isolation: mid-pack; top layers soften movements that coils transmit
• Edge support: robust, with reinforced perimeter coils supporting sitting and sleeping along the edge
• Durability: 10-year non-prorated warranty and perimeter coil design imply a stable life for typical home use 
• Shipping: delivery through Metro Mattress with regional same-day or next-day options in many markets 
• Trial: eligible for 90-Night Comfort Guarantee when policy conditions are met, including protector and pillow purchase 
• Warranty: 10-year non-prorated warranty as stated on product information 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.3	Pocket coils held my and Marcus’s backs reasonably straight, though pure stomach sessions felt softer.
Pressure Relief	4.7	Deep pillow-top structure eased Mia’s shoulders and my hips during side sleep.
Cooling	4.0	Gel foam helped, yet thick comfort stack still ran warmer than Chill hybrids for hot sleepers.
Motion Isolation	4.0	Coils carried some movement but the plush top dulled impact for Jenna.
Edge Support	4.7	Perimeter coils delivered very solid sitting and lying support at the edge.
Responsiveness	4.2	Coil bounce under foam provided a pleasant, controlled movement pattern.
Durability Outlook	4.4	Non-prorated 10-year warranty and robust coil design suggest reliable service life.
Materials / Air Quality	4.2	Standard yet solid foams and coils, made-in-USA construction, no strong odors.
Value	4.1	Balanced feature set at a mid-range price inside the Metro Mattress catalog.
Overall Score	4.2	Traditional pillow-top choice for shoppers wanting plush comfort and secure edges.

Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses

Mattress	Overall Score	Support	Pressure Relief	Cooling	Motion Isolation	Durability	Responsiveness
Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam	4.3	4.2	4.5	4.4	4.7	4.4	4.0
Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam	4.4	4.5	4.3	4.6	4.1	4.5	4.5
Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top	4.1	4.3	3.9	4.2	3.8	4.1	4.6
American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top	4.2	4.3	4.7	4.0	4.0	4.4	4.2

From these scores, Chill Polar Dream emerges as the most balanced performer for support, cooling, and responsiveness together. Chill CoolHaven functions as a motion-isolation specialist with strong pressure relief. Sea Island Euro Top slots into a value role with lively responsiveness but lower motion isolation and contouring. Nobility Box Pillow Top leans toward pressure relief and edge security, making it the plush specialist.

Best Picks

• Best Metro Mattress Cooling Hybrid – “Chill Polar Dream Metro Mattress Hybrid Review Winner”
  Polar Dream takes this award because our hot sleepers felt more comfortable here than on the other three models. The coil and gel-foam pairing stabilized Marcus’s hips and let airflow move through the mattress, while my own back stayed supported in every tested position.
• Best Metro Mattress Foam Bed – “Chill CoolHaven Metro Mattress Foam Review Pick”
  CoolHaven wins this category by combining a cool-to-the-touch cover with strong contouring and excellent motion isolation. This kind of feel suited Mia’s lighter side-sleep frame and Jenna’s couple-focused testing, which matters for shoppers wanting quiet foam with real cooling features.
• Best Metro Mattress Pillow-Top – “American Splendor Nobility Metro Mattress Pillow Top Review Choice”
  Nobility Box Pillow Top claims this award due to its plush yet organized surface and robust edge perimeter. Our side sleepers described its pressure relief as standout within the group, and the non-prorated 10-year warranty adds confidence for people chasing a classic pillow-top experience.

How to Choose the Metro Mattress?

Picking among these Metro Mattress options requires clear thinking about body type, sleep style, and budget. From the perspective of firmness, people who prefer a neutral to medium-firm feel usually match best with Chill Polar Dream or Sea Island Euro Top. Shoppers seeking deeper cushion lean more naturally toward CoolHaven or Nobility Box Pillow Top.

Under heavier body weight, coil support grows important. Marcus’s experience showed that Chill Polar Dream and Sea Island Euro Top kept his hips more controlled than CoolHaven, especially for stomach and combo sleep. Lighter bodies like Mia’s floated higher in every mattress and felt firmness more sharply, which led her toward CoolHaven and Nobility.

Temperature sensitivity matters strongly here. Chill-branded models use cooling covers and gel foams engineered specifically for hot sleepers. Sea Island and Nobility breathe through coil cores yet still rely on quilted tops and pillow-tops that trap a bit more warmth. Very heat-prone shoppers in our group leaned heavily toward Polar Dream.

Budget sits as the final filter. Comfort Concepts Sea Island typically represents the value Euro-top option. Chill and American Splendor occupy mid-range bands with extra features. Tempur-Pedic and other brands at Metro Mattress rise further above this group, so those fall outside this specific article. 

Based on our testing, here are quick matches:

• Light-weight side sleeper
  CoolHaven and Nobility Box Pillow Top served Mia best. CoolHaven gave her cool contouring with solid spine alignment, while Nobility added extra plushness for nights when comfort took priority over temperature.
• Average-weight back sleeper
  Polar Dream delivered clear hip support and a balanced feel for my combination pattern. Sea Island Euro Top provided a simpler, slightly firmer coil experience that still kept my lower back happy.
• Hot sleeper who tosses and turns
  Polar Dream stood out in this profile. The cooling cover, gel foams, and pocket-coil core handled heat and movement for Marcus better than the other options.
• Heavier couple sharing a queen
  Polar Dream again carried strong support and acceptable motion control. Nobility added plush comfort for side sleeping but moved a bit more under quick weight shifts, which matters for very light partners.

Limitations

These Metro Mattress models share some clear limits. None of them qualify as ultra-cheap options; even Comfort Concepts sits above the most basic discount mattresses from big-box chains. Ultra-low-budget shoppers with tight constraints may not find a fit in this specific group. 

People who want extremely firm, almost board-like sleeping surfaces will likely find CoolHaven and Nobility too plush and may still view Polar Dream and Sea Island as too forgiving. Very heavy sleepers far above Marcus’s weight who insist on near-zero sink might require more specialized, zoned support than these models provide.

Fans of ultra-bouncy, traditional Bonnell-coil innersprings will probably view the Chill models as too damped, while Sea Island and Nobility sit closer yet still feature pocket-coil technology that behaves differently from old open-coil designs.

Finally, Metro Mattress as a retailer has been undergoing financial stress, with recent reporting about bankruptcy proceedings and store closures in parts of its network. This reality may affect local availability and sale pricing for these models over the next months, so shoppers should verify in-store inventory and timelines. 

Policies at a Glance

Metro Mattress applies its 90-Night Comfort Guarantee and warranty framework across many premium mattresses, including the Chill, Comfort Concepts, and American Splendor lines. To unlock the comfort guarantee, buyers must purchase a qualified protector and premium pillow at the same time as the mattress. Returns typically function as comfort exchanges rather than refunds. 

Mattress	Shipping (Cost and Region)	Trial Period	Return Policy / Fees	Warranty Length	Notable Conditions
Chill CoolHaven Memory Foam	Bed-in-a-box shipping and local delivery available; many New York and nearby regions see same-day or next-day mattress delivery with qualifying orders	Up to 90 nights under Metro Mattress Comfort Guarantee	Exchanges allowed within the window when required protector and pillow were purchased; no standard cash refunds; delivery or exchange fees may apply	10-year limited warranty	Mattress must stay in good condition with protector; used on proper support; Comfort Guarantee tied to accessory purchase
Chill Polar Dream Hybrid Memory Foam	Ships through Metro Mattress with local in-home delivery; some sizes ship boxed; regional free or discounted delivery tied to promotions	90-night comfort trial when policy requirements are met	One comfort exchange usually allowed in the window; restocking or delivery fees may apply; no traditional refunds	10-year limited warranty	Must maintain protector and pillow on the invoice for comfort program; correct foundation required for warranty validity
Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top	Delivered through Metro Mattress trucks in service regions such as Albany, Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse; some delivery tiers free during sales	Covered by 90-night comfort program for qualifying purchases	Comfort exchange credit toward another mattress; customer pays any price difference and service fee	10-year limited warranty	Comfort Concepts catalog often tied closely to store policies; stains or misuse can void comfort coverage and warranty
American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top	Standard Metro Mattress delivery in primary markets; may include setup and removal for an additional charge or as a promotion	Included in 90-night comfort guarantee when accessories meet requirements	Exchanges permitted within window; policy does not focus on refunds; any extra delivery or pickup fees disclosed at sale	10-year non-prorated warranty	Solid state foundation or equivalent support required; original tags and proof of purchase needed for warranty processing

From the perspective of buyer friendliness, Chill and American Splendor models look similar under this policy grid. All four choices share the same comfort-exchange structure and 10-year coverage, although Nobility specifically lists non-prorated terms. Shoppers need to pay close attention to the accessory requirement and any service fees, since skipping the protector and pillow purchase usually removes the comfort-exchange option completely.

FAQs

1. What is Metro Mattress, and does it make its own beds?
Metro Mattress operates primarily as a regional mattress retailer that carries brands such as Sealy, Tempur-Pedic, Comfort Concepts, Chill, and American Splendor. Several of the mattresses reviewed here come from exclusive house collections like Chill and Comfort Concepts, which are produced for Metro Mattress and sold through its channels. 

2. Which Metro Mattress model is best for a hot sleeper?
During our tests, Chill Polar Dream stood out for hot sleepers. Its cooling fabric and gel foam sat above a ventilated pocket-coil core, giving Marcus and me lower temperature readings than Sea Island or Nobility. CoolHaven also performed well, yet the hybrid construction in Polar Dream kept heavier, warm bodies more comfortable across full nights. 

3. Are Metro Mattress foam beds good for back pain?
CoolHaven provided decent lumbar support for my combination-sleeping back, with firm underlying foam holding my hips in check. For heavier individuals with back pain risk, Polar Dream’s coil support gave a stronger sense of hip lift and “reset” feeling, which Marcus appreciated. People with serious back conditions should align mattress choices with medical advice, yet these two models felt more spine-friendly than softer, low-density alternatives.

4. Does Metro Mattress offer free returns on these mattresses?
Metro Mattress generally operates with a comfort-exchange system rather than free refunds. Customers can complete an exchange within the 90-night window when they purchased a protector and premium pillow at the same time, yet they usually pay service or delivery fees during that swap. Cash refunds are not the norm, according to both policy pages and customer reports. 

5. How long will a Metro Mattress Chill or American Splendor mattress last?
Chill and American Splendor products we examined include 10-year warranties, with reasonable materials and construction for that span. Our durability outlook scores reflect expectations of a solid decade for typical home use under proper support and rotation, although individual outcomes vary with weight, care, and environment. 

6. Is Metro Mattress going out of business, and does that affect these products?
Recent reporting indicates Metro Mattress has faced bankruptcy proceedings and is in the process of closing or consolidating stores, with going-out-of-business sales in some areas. Warranty coverage for the products themselves flows through manufacturers as well as retailer assistance, so shoppers should confirm how service will work if local stores close. Availability and sale pricing may change rapidly during this period. 

7. Which Metro Mattress option works best for a lightweight side sleeper?
Mia’s experience pointed to Chill CoolHaven and American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top. Both gave her shoulder-friendly cradles that avoided sharp pressure. She favored Nobility for plush nights and CoolHaven for cooler, slightly firmer sessions, so those two models cover that profile effectively.

8. Are these Metro Mattress models good for adjustable bases?
Chill foam and hybrid models work well on adjustable bases because their flexible foam and pocket-coil constructions handle bending without major issues. Sea Island and Nobility can also function on adjustable systems when foundations match manufacturer recommendations, although very thick pillow-tops sometimes crease more noticeably at high angles. 

9. How does Comfort Concepts compare with American Splendor at Metro Mattress?
Comfort Concepts Sea Island Euro Top represents a more budget-oriented Euro-top innerspring, while American Splendor Nobility Box Pillow Top targets a plush, mid-range pillow-top segment. In our tests, Sea Island delivered straightforward support and bounce, whereas Nobility leaned toward deeper pressure relief and stronger edge performance. Pricing and materials reflect that step-up positioning. 

10. Can I find these Metro Mattress collections in other stores?
Chill and Comfort Concepts collections appear on Metro Mattress marketing as exclusive offerings, and American Splendor at this specific spec configuration also ties closely to the chain. Other retailers may carry similar constructions under different names, yet these exact versions are positioned as Metro Mattress staples, especially in its New York state service regions.

Related Post

Luxizawmlinium Mattress Review

Sleptight Mattress Review

CHEVNI Mattress Reviews

Mambrc Mattress Reviews

Hom Mattress Reviews

Puzdaz Mattress Reviews

SynthoSpace Mattress Reviews

SaniSnooze Mattress Reviews

VECELO Mattress Reviews

Jerome's Mattress

UniPon Mattress Review

Kensington Mattress Reviews

Metro Mattress Reviews

Sweet Dreams Mattress Reviews

Vesgantti Mattress Review