Evaya Mattress Reviews

The Evaya Original felt structured the moment I sat down—springy on top, then firmer once I settled. Sleeping on my back, my hips stayed level and my lower back felt supported through the night. The tradeoff showed up when I rolled onto my side: my shoulder met the firmer surface sooner than I prefer.

Marcus had the opposite reaction. Under his 230-pound frame, the bed felt more like a true medium-firm and kept his hips from dipping. He also flagged it as one of the cooler-feeling options we tested, especially compared with dense foams that tend to hold heat.

Mia didn’t click with the Original on her side. After about twenty minutes, she said her shoulder never found a soft pocket. On the Original with PillowTopper, her shoulder finally sank enough while her spine stayed straight. And on the Bliss, she got the most consistent relief at her shoulder and hip over long stretches.

For couples, Jenna focused on how much Ethan’s movement traveled. On the Original, she felt a quick ripple when he got in and out, but it faded fast. The PillowTopper added more surface loft, so bigger movements carried a bit farther. Bliss struck the best balance in our room: more cushioning, controlled bounce, and less disturbance during his late-night position changes.

For this review, we ran our usual mattress test workflow with extra attention to odor and temperature. After unboxing, we let each bed air out and logged scent changes; in our room, it was mostly wool.

Next came pressure mapping and alignment checks. Testers lay on their back, side, and briefly on their stomach while we logged pressure points at shoulders, lower back, and hips. We also measured sinkage at the center and closer to the edge across different body types.

Cooling and motion tests followed. Marcus ran the hot-sleeper setup (warm room plus heavy blanket) while I tracked surface temperature rebound after position changes. For motion isolation, Jenna stayed near the edge as Ethan climbed in and out, then we repeated the routine across multiple nights.

To score the lineup, we used nine metrics: spinal support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, responsiveness, materials and safety, durability, and value. Scores run from 3.0 to 5.0, and we finalize them only after pairing numbers with sleep notes.

Our Testing Experience

Unboxing the Original, the bed felt substantial and immediately responsive. When I pressed in with my hand, it gave quickly, then pushed back in a firmer, more supportive way. On my back, my hips settled just enough for a neutral spine, and I didn’t get that “hammock” feeling after long reading sessions.

Side sleeping was where I noticed the firmness most. I could settle in, but my shoulder didn’t sink as freely as it does on plusher surfaces. If you’re a strict side sleeper—or you’re lightweight and sensitive at the shoulder—this model can feel a touch too direct.

Marcus liked it more than I did. He described the support as “resetting” because his hips stayed level on both his back and stomach. With his weight engaging more of the mattress, the feel came across as medium-firm rather than hard.

Mia was the clearest “not for me” case here. Her hips were fine, but her shoulder pressure built up and she kept shifting to get comfortable. It’s a good example of how a supportive feel can still miss the mark for lighter side sleepers.

In the couple tests, the Original handled motion transfer reasonably well for a bouncy, responsive bed. Jenna could tell when Ethan got up, but she didn’t feel dragged across the surface. Edge support was solid for sleeping near the side, with more compression when sitting right on the perimeter.

Temperature performance was a highlight. Between the breathable cover, wool, and responsive support layers, the surface stayed fairly neutral under a light comforter. In the warmer setup, it warmed up, but it also cooled back down quickly once Marcus shifted positions.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): varies by promotions
• Firmness feel: medium-firm to firm, roughly 6.5–7.5 on a 10-point feel scale
• Height: 11 inches
• Construction: organic cotton cover; EverEden® wool; latex comfort; pocketed coils
• Available sizes: twin through king and California king
• Cooling features: breathable cover and wool; airflow through the coil core
• Pressure relief: moderate; firmer at the shoulder for lighter side sleepers
• Responsiveness: quick rebound; easy repositioning
• Motion isolation: good for a responsive build; some movement still noticeable
• Edge support: solid for sleeping; more compression when sitting at the perimeter
• Durability: strong outlook supported by materials and warranty length
• Materials and safety: materials and certifications listed by the brand
• Shipping: free shipping (contiguous U.S.); optional in-home setup where offered
• Trial period: 100-night trial
• Warranty: 25-year limited warranty

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Adding the PillowTopper changes the first contact immediately. The surface feels softer and more cushioning, while the underlying mattress still provides the same steady support. For me, it smoothed out the firmness transition without turning the bed into a slow, sink-in feel.

During side-sleeping, I could stay still longer before my shoulder started to complain. The topper let my shoulder and hip settle in a little deeper, then the support underneath stopped me from sinking out of alignment. Repositioning stayed easy because the bed still responds quickly.

This was Mia’s best match outside of Bliss. She called it “soft on top with a strong floor underneath,” and that describes the feel well. Her shoulder finally relaxed, but she still felt stable through her midsection.

Marcus appreciated the added comfort, but he also noticed more surface movement. He liked the upgrade for lounging and back sleeping, yet he preferred the more direct, firmer feel of the standard Original on stomach nights.

For Jenna and Ethan, the topper was mostly positive: better cushioning, easier rolling, and less of the abrupt firmness they noticed on the Original. The downside was that bigger movements traveled a bit more, especially when Ethan flopped back into bed.

At the edge, the added height is noticeable when sitting. The topper compresses first, which can create a slight “roll” sensation near the very outside. Once you’re lying down, it feels much more stable.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): around $1,898 list for the mattress + PillowTopper (promos vary)
• Firmness feel: medium-firm overall with a softer, plusher surface
• Height: ~14 inches combined (11" mattress + 3" topper)
• Construction: Original mattress build plus a wool-and-latex PillowTopper
• Available sizes: same width options as the Original; availability can vary
• Cooling features: wool-rich top helps with moisture management; breathable overall
• Pressure relief: improved at shoulders and hips versus the Original
• Responsiveness: stays quick and easy to move on
• Motion isolation: moderate; more surface travel than the Original
• Edge support: adequate for sleeping; less stable for sitting right at the edge
• Durability: core should hold up well; topper may compress sooner
• Materials and safety: materials and certifications listed by the brand
• Shipping: free shipping (contiguous U.S.); optional upgraded delivery where offered
• Trial period: 100-night trial
• Warranty: 25-year limited warranty (review product terms for add-on components)

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Bliss felt like the most refined build in the set. The top layers had more cushioning than the Original, but the overall feel stayed supportive. On my back, I sank in a little more at first contact, then leveled out into a stable position.

On my side, Bliss gave me the easiest shoulder entry of the three. I could settle into a pocket without feeling stuck, and I woke up with less shoulder tightness than I usually get on firmer beds.

Mia gravitated to Bliss right away. Over multiple nights, she consistently reported less shoulder and hip irritation, and she didn’t feel the mattress sagging under her midsection. For her, it was the clearest “pressure relief without losing support” option.

Marcus experienced Bliss as firmer than it sounds on paper. It supported him well on his back and didn’t let his hips dip, but he still leaned toward the Original for stomach-heavy weeks. He summed it up as a model he could live with nightly, just not his first pick for stomach sleeping.

For couples, Bliss performed best in our room. Jenna could still sense Ethan’s bigger moves, but the motion felt slower and more muted than on the other two. Sleeping near the edge also felt more secure than the PillowTopper setup.

Cooling was another strong point. The breathable cover and wool helped manage moisture, and the support core promoted airflow better than dense foam beds we’ve tested. Marcus reported fewer “heat spikes” in the middle of the night.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): around $1,699 list price (promos vary)
• Firmness feel: medium-firm to firm with more cushion up top
• Height: 12 inches
• Construction: organic cotton cover; EverEden® wool; latex comfort; zoned pocketed coils
• Available sizes: twin through king and California king, subject to stock
• Cooling features: breathable cover and wool; airflow through the coil support core
• Pressure relief: highest in our testing across shoulders and hips
• Responsiveness: buoyant and controlled; easy repositioning
• Motion isolation: very good for most couples
• Edge support: strongest of the three in our tests
• Durability: strong outlook supported by materials and warranty length
• Materials and safety: materials and certifications listed by the brand
• Shipping: free shipping across the contiguous U.S.; optional upgraded delivery where offered
• Trial period: 100-night trial
• Warranty: 25-year limited warranty

Review Score

Choosing among these three mostly comes down to sleep position and how much surface cushion you need. Heavier sleepers usually want steadier hip support, while lighter sleepers tend to feel shoulder pressure sooner.

If you’re a lighter or pressure-sensitive side sleeper, start with Bliss or the Original with PillowTopper. Both let the shoulder and hip settle in more naturally than the standard Original.

For back sleepers, the Original and Bliss are the easiest fits. Pick the Original if you want a firmer, more direct feel; pick Bliss if you want more cushioning at first contact while still staying supported.

Hot sleepers should do well across the board thanks to the breathable cover and wool, but Bliss stayed coolest for Marcus in our warm-room setup. If you like a firmer, more “on top” feel, the Original can still be a strong choice.

Couples who share the bed or sleep close to the edge will likely prefer Bliss. It had the most stable edge feel and the least disruptive motion in our tests. The PillowTopper version is still couple-friendly, but it allows a bit more surface movement.

Budget is the final lever. The Original is usually the lowest entry point into the line, while Bliss sits higher as the most premium build. If you’re on the fence, consider starting firmer and adding a topper later rather than buying extra plushness upfront.

In our testing, all three models stayed fairly temperature-neutral. Bliss performed best for Marcus in our warm-room setup.

Bliss gave our side sleepers the most consistent shoulder relief, with the Original + PillowTopper close behind.

It depends on your build and position. Mia found it too firm on her side, while Marcus experienced it as a comfortable medium-firm.

The Original’s ripples faded fast. The PillowTopper let bigger movements travel more. Bliss muted Ethan’s repositioning the most.

Marcus (about 230 pounds) slept comfortably on all three, with the Original as his favorite for stomach sleeping.

We noticed a light wool scent for the first couple of days. It faded with normal ventilation and didn’t read as strongly chemical.

Give yourself time. Our bodies often need a couple of weeks to settle into a new support profile before you decide.

If you want more shoulder and hip cushioning, yes—the topper meaningfully softens first contact while keeping support underneath.

They feel more responsive. Instead of a slow, sinking “hug,” the surface rebounds quickly when you move.

We didn’t see early signs of edge collapse during our test period. Bliss felt the most stable at the edge, while the taller PillowTopper setup compressed more for sitting.