Key West Mattress Reviews (2026)

Across the four, Ocean Rest Eurotop and Edge B-40 felt the most shoulder-friendly while still keeping our hips supported through the night. Ocean Rest Firm and Edge 3000 XFIRM delivered the most “stay-flat” support and the most confidence when sitting or sleeping near the edge. Marcus (6'1", 230 lbs) preferred the firmer pair for their steadier feel and cooler surface, while Jenna and Ethan noticed the least partner disturbance on the plusher tops. None of these are cloud-soft mattresses.

In our how we test mattresses process, I tested each mattress in the same bedroom setup, then brought in Marcus for heat and support checks and Jenna and Ethan for shared-bed movement nights. We scored support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability using repeatable routines—edge sitting, slow-roll turns, back/side sleep blocks, and a partner “get-in/get-out” drill. We also logged how each surface felt during laptop work and pre-bed reading. Dr. Adrian Walker reviewed our posture notes for alignment red flags and comfort trade-offs.

Our testing experience

Ocean Rest Eurotop has a “cushion first, support second” feel. I’d settle into the top layer, then the coils would push back gently instead of popping me onto the surface. On back-to-side transitions, my shoulder had enough give to relax, but my hips stayed level.

Marcus called it “surprisingly stable for a softer top,” even when he tried to provoke that hammock feeling. Jenna and Ethan agreed it muted most of the ripple when someone climbed in, though you still notice a touch more coil liveliness than you get from the tight-top models.

What we liked

• A more forgiving top that still kept my lower back from feeling “bowed” by morning

• Smooth transitions when changing positions

Who it is best for

• Combo sleepers who want cushioning without losing support

• Couples who want comfort without a dead, foam-only feel

Where it falls short

• Not the strongest choice if you want a very firm, flat surface

• Edge sits softer than the firm models

Pros & cons

Details

• Price (queen mattress only): $529.99

• Type: innerspring

• Top style: pillow top

• Height: 12.5"

• Coil type: wrapped coil

• Covering and comfort materials: CoolTex ticking; Strataflex foam; polyfoam; convoluted foam topper

• Support materials: foam-encased coil; base foam

• Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King

• Shipping: -

• Trial period: -

• Warranty: -

Review score

Our testing experience

Ocean Rest Firm feels disciplined at the surface. It doesn’t let you settle deeply, so my lower back stayed “stacked” without needing to hunt for the right spot. On longer side-sleep blocks, it was tolerable, but it kept nudging me back toward back sleeping.

Marcus liked how easily he could roll from back to stomach without his hips dipping. Jenna and Ethan both said it was the easiest bed to get in and out of with minimal disturbance, largely because the top stays taut and rebounds quickly.

What we liked

• Strong alignment on back sleep, especially after long desk days

• Very steady edge feel when sitting to put on shoes

Who it is best for

• Back sleepers and stomach sleepers who want firm support

• Heavier sleepers who hate sagging

Where it falls short

• Side sleepers with sensitive shoulders may feel pressure buildup

• If you want a plush “hug,” this will feel too strict

Pros & cons

Details

• Price (queen mattress only): $529.99

• Type: innerspring

• Top style: tight top

• Cooling cover: CoolTex thermocool ticking

• Comfort layers: extra-firm quilting/support layers; 1.5 lb polyfoam layer

• Support system: ChiroCoil Premium (8" tall); 6-way foam encased

• Coil type and queen coil count: wrapped coil; 638 coils

• Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King

• Shipping: -

• Trial period: -

• Warranty: -

Review score

Our testing experience

Edge 3000 XFIRM is a firm specialist: flat surface, lifted hips, and very little “give” up top. When I sat to tie my shoes, it held me higher than the Ocean Rest models, and that firmness carried into sleep—great for back sleeping, but less comfortable for extended side time.

Marcus couldn’t get it to feel unstable, even when he dropped his weight onto the center and then the edge. Jenna and Ethan noted that turning felt effortless, but you do sense a bit more bounce than on the plusher options.

What we liked

• The most reliable edge and midsection support in the group

• Quick, crisp repositioning

Who it is best for

• Back/stomach sleepers, especially heavier builds

• Anyone who wants a firm feel for posture consistency

Where it falls short

• Pressure relief is limited for dedicated side sleepers

• Couples who want a very muted surface may prefer plusher tops

Pros & cons

Pros	Cons
Excellent edge stability	Least pressure-relieving feel
Firm, posture-forward support	More noticeable bounce than plush options
Easy to move on	-

Details

• Price (queen mattress only): $629.99

• Type: innerspring

• Top style: tight top

• Covering: DeepFreeze ticking

• Comfort layers: high-density foam (1.5 lbs); extra-firm support; polyfoam support layer

• Support layers: Advanced Edge Coil (wrapped coils); base foam

• Coil type: wrapped coil

• Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King

• Shipping: -

• Trial period: -

• Warranty: -

Review score

Our testing experience

Edge B-40 felt like the “comfort with structure” pick. The top has enough padding that my shoulders could settle, but the center still held my hips up, which left my lower back feeling relaxed when I got up.

Marcus still preferred the extra-firm models, but he admitted B-40 was easier on his shoulder when he started on his side. Jenna and Ethan called it the easiest bed to share: late-night movement registered as a muted shift rather than a rolling wave.

What we liked

• Plush comfort with a steadier lumbar feel than typical plush beds

• Strong couple performance in motion drills

Who it is best for

• Couples who want a softer top without losing stability

• Combo sleepers who start on their side and finish on their back

Where it falls short

• Edge sitting compresses more than the extra-firm model

• Hot sleepers may still prefer the coolest-feeling tight-top builds

Pros & cons

Details

• Price (queen mattress only): $629.99

• Type: innerspring

• Top style: tight top

• Comfort and feel reference: plush

• Height: 15"

• Covering: CoolTex ticking; polyfoam; Poly Gel

• Comfort layer: convoluted foam topper

• Support layers: Gel Visco lumbar support; Advanced Edge Coil; base foam

• Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King

• Shipping: -

• Trial period: -

• Warranty: -

Review score

Ocean Rest Eurotop and Edge B-40 were the most balanced overall, mostly because they kept pressure relief high without letting support collapse. Edge 3000 XFIRM had the clearest single advantage—support and edge stability—but it traded away some pressure relief. Ocean Rest Firm landed in the middle: firm, supportive, and especially comfortable for back sleepers.

Start with your sleep position and body weight, then decide how much surface cushioning (and overall mattress firmness) you actually want. If you sleep mostly on your back or stomach, Ocean Rest Firm or Edge 3000 XFIRM tends to keep posture more consistent. If you rotate positions or get shoulder pressure on your side, Ocean Rest Eurotop or Edge B-40 is usually the safer pick. For couples, weigh motion isolation against edge support: choose Edge B-40 for comfort-first sharing, or Ocean Rest Firm for a steadier, firmer shared surface.

• Give each mattress a simple break-in week by rotating positions instead of judging it after one night.

• Match your pillow height to your main position; firmer beds often need a slightly taller pillow for side time.

• If you sleep hot, start with breathable sheets and lighter bedding before adding thick toppers.

• On extra-firm models, a thin, breathable pad can take the edge off shoulder pressure without changing support much.

• Avoid sitting in the exact same spot every night—especially on plusher tops—to reduce early edge softening.

• If you use an adjustable base, test both flat and slightly elevated positions to find your best lumbar comfort.

• Protect the surface early; spills and moisture shorten comfort-layer life, and knowing how to clean a mattress helps.

Edge 3000 XFIRM, followed by Ocean Rest Firm.

Edge B-40 and Ocean Rest Eurotop were the most forgiving at the shoulder.

Edge B-40 muted partner movement the most in our shared-bed drills.

Edge 3000 XFIRM held the highest during sitting and edge sleeping.