Serena & Lily Sofa Reviews (2026)

Across the four sofas, we kept coming back to two clear comfort styles: the deep-seat loungers (Haven, Barton Luxury Depth, Miramar) and the more upright daily sit (Spruce Street). Haven was the easiest to melt into for movie nights, while Spruce Street kept posture steadier for laptop work and conversation.

Barton Luxury Depth delivered the most “designer-structured” look while still giving you real sprawl space. Miramar felt the most traditional and buoyant under weight, but its decorative fringe is a detail you have to live with—especially if you have pets, kids, or a robot vacuum.

We rotated these sofas through real routines—nightly TV watching, laptop work, casual hosting, and short naps—then tracked how comfort changed over repeated use, following our How We Test Sofas process. We scored assembly and setup, cooling and breathability, comfort and ergonomics, durability, size and layout practicality, fabric and cleaning, and value. We also did “shared lounging” checks to see how easy it was to shift positions without disrupting the person next to you.

Our Testing Experience

The Haven is the sofa that turns sitting into lounging. Within a few minutes, everyone naturally slid into a more relaxed posture. Marcus kept checking whether the 27.5" depth would make his hips sink too far back; it didn’t, but it did encourage a laid-back sprawl. Jenna and Ethan treated it like a shared “movie nest,” and the wide inside seat made it easy to lean together without feeling crowded.

What we liked:

• Deep seat depth that supports long, laid-back lounging
• Sturdy feel when people shift positions or sit on the edge
• Cushions stay inviting through long sessions

Who it is best for:

• Homes that prioritize movie nights, naps, and casual hosting
• Taller users who want real legroom
• Anyone who likes a softer, “settle in” feel

Where it falls short:

• Shorter users may want an ottoman to make the deepest sit more comfortable
• How forgiving it is with stains and pets depends on the upholstery you choose

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $3,988–$6,298
• Overall dimensions: 83"–107"W x 41"D x 32"H
• Seat depth: 27.5"D
• Seat height: 16.5"H
• Inside seat: 69"–93"W x 27.5"D x 13"H
• Arm width: 6"W
• Frame: maple; mortise-and-tenon construction
• Suspension: sinuous spring suspension
• Back cushion fill: down/feather blend (per listing)

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Spruce Street felt noticeably more upright than the deep-seat options. It’s the sofa we reached for when we wanted to sit “normally”—feet on the floor, back supported, laptop balanced—without immediately sliding into nap mode. Marcus liked that it held posture, and the slimmer, tailored build made it easier to stand up and re-sit without wrestling the cushions.

What we liked:

• Balanced 22" seat depth that works for a wide range of body types
• Slipcovered design is a practical advantage for routine upkeep
• Tailored shape feels steady and predictable for daily use

Who it is best for:

• Households that mix sitting, chatting, and laptop time
• People who prefer a more upright, supported posture
• Anyone prioritizing easier cleaning through a slipcover

Where it falls short:

• If you want a “sink-in” nap sofa, this one reads firmer and more structured
• Price can climb depending on size, fabric, and options

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $4,298–$7,768
• Overall dimensions: 81"–106"W x 35"D x 34"H
• Seat depth: 22"D
• Seat height: 17"H
• Arm height: 24"H
• Leg height: 4"H
• Upholstery concept: slipcovered; sleeper options available

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Barton Luxury Depth was the sofa we kept calling the “library sofa.” It has clean track arms, a grounded silhouette, and enough depth to lounge without turning the room into a casual den. The 26" seat depth made it easy to slide into a semi-recline, but it also meant we wanted a deliberate cushion setup when working on a laptop. Marcus tested the edge and frame feel by perching and standing repeatedly; it stayed composed and didn’t feel wobbly.

What we liked:

• Deep seat that still looks tailored and intentional
• Exposed oak base detail that reads premium
• Easy to share without feeling cramped

Who it is best for:

• Taller users and lounge-first households
• Rooms that want a structured, design-forward profile
• People who prefer a deeper, more relaxed posture

Where it falls short:

• Deep seat can be too much for shorter legs without a footrest
• Price climbs quickly with sizing and fabric options

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $5,668–$12,488
• Overall dimensions: 84"–108"W x 39"D x 35"H
• Seat depth: 26"D
• Seat height: 19"H
• Arm height: 30"H
• Diagonal depth: 30"D
• Design notes: deeper seat; slim arms; exposed solid oak base

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Miramar felt the most traditional of the group: roll arms, a slight recline, and a sit that encourages you to lean back and stay awhile. The 27" seat depth made it easy to tuck legs up, and Marcus liked the buoyant support—it felt springy without turning bouncy, and the edges didn’t collapse when he perched. The tradeoff is the fringe: it changes how casually you live with the sofa, especially around pets, shoes, and vacuuming.

What we liked:

• Buoyant, supportive feel that stays composed under weight
• Classic proportions with real lounge depth
• Distinctive detail that elevates a room

Who it is best for:

• Traditional or coastal rooms that want a statement sofa
• People who like to recline into the back rather than perch upright
• Homes where trim details won’t get constant abuse

Where it falls short:

• Fringe demands more careful cleaning habits
• Deep seat can feel too relaxed for long, desk-like laptop sessions

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $6,798–$7,138
• Overall dimensions: 87"W x 42"D x 34"H
• Seat depth: 27"D
• Seat height: 18"H
• Arm height: 21"H
• Diagonal depth: 33"D
• Suspension: 8-way hand-tied steel coil springs
• Fringe detail: 7.5" hand-crocheted fringe

Review Score

Spruce Street comes out as the most balanced option for mixed, everyday use—its seat-depth fit and “easy repositioning” scores match how it felt in real life. Haven clearly leads when pure lounge comfort is the goal. Barton Luxury Depth reads the most tailored while still giving you depth, and it scored best on durability. Miramar is the most style-distinctive and buoyant, but it asks more of you on maintenance; for a wider mix of picks, our Best Sofas guide is a helpful next step.

Start with how you actually sit:

• If you lounge first: Prioritize a deeper seat depth—Haven (27.5") and Barton Luxury Depth (26") are the easiest to sprawl on.
• If you sit upright often: Spruce Street’s 22" depth feels the most natural for feet-on-floor posture.
• If you want classic roll arms: Miramar delivers the traditional look and a buoyant sit, as long as you’re okay caring for the fringe.

As a quick rule of thumb: taller loungers should start with Barton Luxury Depth or Haven; mixed-use households tend to do best with Spruce Street; and style-first traditional rooms should shortlist Miramar.

Spruce Street is the easiest for upright sitting. The seat depth stays balanced, and posture holds steadier over long stretches than the deeper lounge models.

Haven is the most “settle in and stay” option. The deep seat supports relaxed positions without immediately feeling like you’re sliding off the front edge.