HomeGoods Sofa Reviews (2026)

These four broke into two clear camps: oversized stationary sofas built for sprawl, and recliners meant for long sessions where convenience matters as much as cushioning. Treasure Trove felt the easiest to live with day to day, while Leya delivered the best mix of recline comfort and room-fit practicality. Jayne Park was the softest to sink into, but it also ran warmer and showed lint and pressure marks faster. Tarrant had the most useful built-ins, though it needs more space and a little more attention to fabric care.

Each sofa went through the same routine: unboxing and setup, then a week of real life—laptop work, two-hour movies, casual hosting, and quick naps. We scored assembly friction, cooling, comfort, durability cues, layout practicality, cleaning effort, and overall value. Comfort was broken into seat comfort, back support, and seat-depth fit, while layout included both everyday usability and how easy it was to shift positions as the room got used.

Our Testing Experience

Jayne Park’s first impression is all softness—the kind that makes you settle in and stay put. During laptop work, Carlos kept adjusting to avoid a rounded-shoulders posture, while Mia noticed right away that the deep seat nudged her into a tucked-leg position. It was great for late-night lounging, but I ended up adding a small lumbar pillow so I didn’t slowly slide forward.

What we liked

• Big, loungey seat that invites you to sprawl

• Soft surface comfort for long TV sessions

• Reversible back cushions helped wear feel more even

Who it is best for

• Taller users, or anyone who prefers deep-seat lounging

• Living rooms where the sofa is the main hangout spot

Where it falls short

• Shorter legs may feel too far back

• Runs warm during long sessions

• Lint and pressure marks show easily

Pros & Cons

Details

• Overall dimensions: 41" H x 96" W x 43" D

• Model: PC8150638

• Upholstery: plush velvety pile; toss pillows in chenille/slub yarn

• Cushion setup: loose, reversible back cushions

• Perceived cushion firmness: medium-plush

• Cooling / breathability: tends to run warm

• Support for different body sizes: best for average-to-tall loungers; petite testers may find it too deep

• Cleaning: frequent lint rolling; occasional spot-cleaning
  

• Pet-friendliness: moderate (hair clings to the fabric)

• Durability: reversible cushions helped spread out day-to-day wear

• Assembly: basic positioning and final setup

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Treasure Trove felt more structured the moment we sat down—less “sink,” more steady support, and a surface that didn’t hold heat the way plush fabrics can. During a shared movie night, Jenna and Ethan noticed fewer ripple effects when one person shifted. For laptop work, the seat stayed supportive, and the back didn’t slump when I leaned into it. Marcus also pointed out the firmer front edge when he perched to tie his shoes—more stable than the plush models.

What we liked

• Easy wipe-down feel for everyday messes

• Balanced support for upright and relaxed sitting

• Firmer edge support for quick sit-stand moments

Who it is best for

• Homes that want easier upkeep and fewer fabric headaches

• Mixed-use seating: working, hosting, and TV nights

Where it falls short

• Leather can feel slick for some loungers

• Not as instantly “sink-in” as plush fabric sofas

Pros & Cons

Details

• Overall dimensions: 40" H x 93" W x 40" D

• Model: 1930438

• Frame: corner-blocked frame

• Cushion setup: attached back; loose seat cushions

• Cushion materials: high-resiliency foam wrapped in a feather-fiber blend

• Upholstery: top-grain leather on contact areas; matched faux leather elsewhere

• Perceived cushion firmness: medium

• Cooling / breathability: generally neutral to cool

• Support for different body sizes: a more universally supportive fit across testers

• Cleaning: quick wipe-down for day-to-day messes
  

• Pet-friendliness: higher than plush fabrics (hair clings less)

• Durability: stable feel under repeated use and posture changes

• Assembly: standard setup

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Tarrant was our most feature-heavy pick. On a long sports night, Marcus treated the drop-down table like a mini console, and the USB charging kept phones powered without cords snaking across the room. Because you can recline, seat-depth fit was easier to dial in—your hips land where you want them. Jamal liked it for post-work stretching, but he also called out the practical downside: you need clearance behind the sofa, and it isn’t something you’ll move around casually.

What we liked

• Recline comfort for multi-hour sessions

• Drop-down table and built-in charging convenience

• Supportive feel once fully reclined

Who it is best for

• Gaming, sports, and movie setups where features matter

• Anyone who wants a more adjustable lounging posture

Where it falls short

• Recline clearance demands extra space

• Chenille runs warm and needs faster spill cleanup

Pros & Cons

Details

• Overall dimensions: 40" H x 86" W x 40" D

• Model: 9140589

• Reclining: dual-sided recliner; middle seat stays stationary

• Recliner release: pull tab

• Frame: corner-blocked; metal reinforced seat

• Upholstery: polyester chenille

• Convenience features: drop-down table with cup holders and USB charging

• Perceived cushion firmness: medium-plush (feels more supportive in recline)

• Cooling / breathability: tends to run warm

• Cleaning: spot-cleaning helps; the fabric can hold spills
  

• Pet-friendliness: moderate (fabric can trap hair)

• Durability: stable under heavier use and repeated recline cycles

• Assembly: heavier handling; power cord management

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

Leya’s main advantage was fitting into a room that normally can’t spare the space for a recliner. The space-saver design let us recline without giving up the main walkways. During a two-hour laptop session, Carlos felt the back stay supportive without pushing his head forward. I also liked the smoother seat feel and the gradual, controlled recline—no sudden drop. The trade-offs were practical: you need a plan for power access, and how “easy” it is to live with depends on the cover you choose, especially if you tend to snack on the sofa.

What we liked

• More wall-friendly recline behavior

• Cooler seat feel than plush chenille

• Easy to settle into for work-to-TV routines

Who it is best for

• Smaller living rooms that still want power recline

• People who run warm and want a cooler-feeling seat

Where it falls short

• Needs power planning and basic cord discipline

• Cover care varies and can require more attention than leather

Pros & Cons

Details

• Overall dimensions: 43" H x 92" W x 38.5" D

• Model: S670RP4

• Upholstery options: 700+ fabrics; top-grain leather choices available

• Back cushion access: zipper-back design

• Seat feel: Performa-Weave cushioning is described as cooler and more durable

• Reclining: power space-saver configuration

• Perceived cushion firmness: medium

• Cooling / breathability: tends to feel cool

• Support for different body sizes: good range; tall testers wanted a bit more upper-back height

• Cleaning: routine fabric care and quicker spill cleanup
  

• Pet-friendliness: moderate (depends on the fabric)

• Durability: stable feel through repeated posture changes

• Assembly: power connection plus final placement planning

Review Score

Treasure Trove scored best overall because it stayed steady across comfort, cooling, durability, and ease of movement. Leya’s clearest edge was cooling plus room-fit practicality. Jayne Park delivered pure lounge softness, but the deep seat and higher-cleaning effort pulled its score down. Tarrant was the best “session sofa” for reclining and built-in conveniences, though it needs more space and faster spill cleanup.

Start with how you actually sit. Deep, soft seats reward sprawling but can feel awkward for shorter legs; recliners solve part of the depth issue by letting you change the angle. Next, match upholstery to your routine—wipeable surfaces handle kids, pets, and snacking better, while plush fabrics usually take more maintenance. For petite loungers who dislike deep seats, Treasure Trove was the most forgiving. For couples who want recline without overfilling the room, Leya made the best use of space. For sports and gaming setups where features matter, Tarrant is the clear pick.

• Why you’d pick these models

  • You want comfort-first seating built for long, everyday sessions

  • You value recline and convenience features like integrated charging

  • You prefer a living-room-anchor silhouette over compact minimalism

• Other options worth considering

  • Burrow Nomad Sofa: modular flexibility for frequent layout changes

  • La-Z-Boy reclining sofa lines: broad recline options with support-forward builds

  • Article Sven Sofa: cleaner modern styling with a firmer, more upright sit

• Measure walking paths, not just wall width—recliners need clearance.

• If you run warm, prioritize cooler-feeling upholstery and avoid plush pile fabrics for all-day use.

• Add a small lumbar pillow early if you notice any forward slide during long movies.

• Treat deep-seat sofas like lounge furniture: use a footrest or ottoman to reduce leg strain.

• Keep a fabric brush or lint roller nearby if you choose velvet-like or chenille upholstery.

• For recliners, plan outlet access and route cords away from foot traffic.

• Wipe spills right away on mixed-material upholstery to prevent uneven wear.

• Rotate loose cushions regularly to slow down body impressions.

• If you host often, test the front edge—can guests sit upright without sinking?