Stumptown Mattress Reviews (2026)

Each model has a distinct strength. The Original absorbs movement better than the two coil beds and cushions shoulders and hips without a deep memory-foam hug. The Hybrid is the easiest recommendation for shoppers who want cooler sleep, quick turns, and a stable edge in one mattress. The Peak feels more supportive through the center and responds fastest when you roll over. The tested Luxe Firm pairs the strongest overall support with excellent motion isolation, but its firm surface leaves less room for error if you are light or spend most of the night on your side.

We used each mattress for full nights, daytime lounging, position changes, and partner movement checks. Support scores reflect how well the surface kept the hips and lower back aligned. Cooling covers overnight heat buildup. Pressure relief focuses on the shoulders and hips, while motion isolation measures how much a partner's turns and exits travel across the bed. We also compared response speed, sitting and sleeping near the edge, and whether each mattress kept a consistent feel with repeated use.

Our testing experience

The Original settled under the hips without letting the lower back sag. On the side, its top foam gave the shoulder enough room to sink while keeping the torso supported. It felt cushioned, but never slow or overly soft. The strongest result was motion control: turns and careful exits produced less disturbance here than on either coil model, which matches its 4.6 motion-isolation score.

The compromise is at the perimeter. Sleeping near the side felt secure, but sitting there for more than a few minutes compressed the foam noticeably. That weaker sitting edge explains the 3.7 edge-support score. The surface also stayed closer to neutral than cool, so sleepers who regularly overheat will get better airflow from the Hybrid.

What we liked:

• Partner movement fades quickly instead of rippling across the bed.

• The foam relieves shoulder and hip pressure without a deep, restrictive sink.

Who it is best for:

• Combination sleepers who want a steady medium-firm foam surface.

• Light- to average-weight side sleepers who need more cushioning at the joints.

Where it falls short:

• The edge is too soft for people who sit there while dressing or getting ready.

• Persistent hot sleepers may want the stronger airflow of a coil mattress.

Pros and cons

Details

• Price at publication: Starts at $699

• Firmness: Medium firm

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Profile: 11 inches

• Type: All-foam

• Materials: Serene foam over high-density base foam

• Cooling: Breathable knit cover and open-cell foam

• Pressure relief: Strong, especially for side sleeping

• Responsiveness: Moderate; easy to turn on but not springy

• Motion isolation: Excellent

• Edge support: Fair

• Delivery: Compressed in a box; some sizes may be made to order

• Trial: 100 nights, with a 21-night minimum before a return

• Warranty: 10 years

Review score

Our testing experience

The Hybrid required less effort to turn on than the Original. Its foam cushioned the body, while the coil core returned quickly enough that rolling from back to side felt natural. Air moved through the support unit as we changed positions, and heat did not linger as long as it did on the all-foam Original. The 4.5 responsiveness and 4.4 cooling scores capture that combination well.

Its reinforced coil edge also held up better while sitting and made more of the mattress usable for sleep. Partner movement was still controlled for a hybrid, but larger turns were easy to detect. Couples who wake at small movements should choose the Original or tested Luxe Firm; those who value airflow and mobility more will likely prefer the Hybrid.

What we liked:

• The coil core improves airflow and makes position changes easier.

• The perimeter stays stable for both sitting and sleeping near the side.

Who it is best for:

• Hot sleepers who want a familiar spring feel with some foam cushioning.

• Combination sleepers and couples who prefer mobility over maximum motion isolation.

Where it falls short:

• Large movements travel farther than they do on the Original or Luxe Firm.

• Very light side sleepers may find the top less plush than they want.

Pros and cons

Details

• Price at publication: Starts at $599

• Firmness: Medium

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Profile: 11 inches

• Type: Hybrid

• Materials: Copper-infused gel memory foam over pocket coils; 730 coils in Queen

• Cooling: Gel foam and airflow through the coil core

• Pressure relief: Strong, with less sink than the Original

• Responsiveness: High

• Motion isolation: Good

• Edge support: Very good

• Delivery: Compressed in a box; some sizes may be made to order

• Trial: 100 nights, with a 21-night minimum before a return

• Warranty: 10 years

Review score

Our testing experience

The Peak feels firmer through the center third than at the shoulders and legs. That zoned support kept the hips from dropping during back sleep and made the lower back feel well supported in the morning. The latex-and-coil construction responded immediately when we rolled over, earning the highest responsiveness score in the group at 4.7.

The edge remained composed when we sat down and moved toward the perimeter. Side sleeping was more dependent on body weight and pillow height: the shoulder could settle into the upper layers, but lighter testers felt more resistance than on the Original. The Peak suits sleepers who want to stay on top of the mattress, not those looking for a deep cradle.

What we liked:

• Zoned coils provide clear support through the hips and lower back.

• Latex and coils rebound quickly, so turning takes little effort.

Who it is best for:

• Back sleepers who want stronger support through the center of the bed.

• Combination sleepers who dislike the slow sink of dense foam.

Where it falls short:

• Light side sleepers may not get enough shoulder cushioning.

• Couples who wake easily may prefer the calmer Original or Luxe Firm.

Pros and cons

Details

• Price at publication: Starts at $899

• Firmness: Medium firm

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Profile: 11 inches

• Type: Latex, foam, and zoned-coil hybrid

• Materials: Gel quilt, lumbar foam, copper-infused memory foam, Talalay latex, and five-zone pocket coils; 1,046 coils in Queen

• Cooling: Breathable cover, latex, and airflow through the coils

• Pressure relief: Strong, with more support than sink

• Responsiveness: Very high

• Motion isolation: Good

• Edge support: Very good

• Delivery: Compressed in a box; some sizes may be made to order

• Trial: 100 nights, with a 21-night minimum before a return

• Warranty: 10 years

Review score

Our testing experience

This section and its scores apply to the 12-inch Firm Luxe with a foam support base. It felt substantially firmer than the Original, Hybrid, or Peak, but the gel grid and memory foam prevented the surface from feeling flat. Back sleeping produced the most stable hip and lumbar alignment in the group, which supports its 4.7 support score.

The Luxe Firm also paired strong motion control with the steadiest overnight temperature. Partner turns caused little disturbance, and the surface released warmth more readily than the Original. It was easy enough to roll on, but it lacked the buoyant response of the Peak. Lightweight side sleepers felt the most pressure at the shoulder, making this a poor choice for anyone who wants a soft landing.

What we liked:

• Firm support stays consistent from the shoulders through the hips.

• Motion control and temperature regulation are both excellent.

Who it is best for:

• Back, stomach, and combination sleepers who already know they like a firm bed.

• Couples who prioritize motion isolation without wanting a warmer foam surface.

Where it falls short:

• Many lightweight side sleepers will need more shoulder and hip cushioning.

• People who want coil bounce should consider the Hybrid or Peak instead.

Pros and cons

Details

• Price at publication: Mattresses start at $949; size and version affect price

• Tested version: Firm with foam base

• Current versions: Extra Firm, Firm, Plush, and Hybrid Plush

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Profile: 12 inches for the tested Firm; current versions range from 11 to 12 inches

• Type: Gel-grid foam mattress; a Hybrid Plush version is also available

• Tested materials: Organic cotton cover, wool quilt, gel grid, copper-infused memory foam, comfort foam, and high-density base foam

• Cooling: Breathable cover, wool, and gel grid

• Pressure relief: Strong for a firm mattress when body weight suits the surface

• Responsiveness: Moderate to high

• Motion isolation: Excellent

• Edge support: Very good

• Delivery: Compressed in a box; some sizes and versions are made to order

• Trial: 100 nights, with a 21-night minimum before a return

• Warranty: 15 years

Review score

The scores reveal clear trade-offs. The Original is the best choice for a calm foam surface and strong pressure relief, but its edge is the weakest. The Hybrid gives up some motion isolation to improve cooling, response, and perimeter stability. The Peak leads on responsiveness and adds the strongest zoned support. The Luxe Firm earns the highest overall score by combining firm support, motion control, and steady temperature, but it only works if you genuinely enjoy a firm mattress.

Choose the Original if you want a medium-firm foam feel, share a bed with a light sleeper, or need more shoulder and hip cushioning. Pick the Hybrid for the most versatile balance of airflow, easy movement, and edge support. The Peak is better for back and combination sleepers who want more support through the center and a quick rebound. Choose the Luxe Firm only if you already prefer a firm mattress and want the best mix of support, motion isolation, and temperature control in this group.

Also check the return terms before buying. Stumptown's trial lasts 100 nights, but the company asks buyers to keep the mattress for at least 21 nights before starting a return. The mattress must remain clean, undamaged, and eligible under the company's condition and law-tag requirements.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the closest price comparison. It comes in soft, medium, and firm versions and can be ordered with a pillow top, giving shoppers more control over surface feel than the Stumptown Hybrid. It is much taller, however, and its optional upgrades push the price higher. Choose Brooklyn Bedding for firmness choice; choose Stumptown Hybrid for a simpler 11-inch design at a lower regular starting price.

The Casper Original is an 11-inch, medium-firm foam mattress with three-zone support. It is the most direct alternative to the Stumptown Original, but its current listed price is higher. Casper makes more sense if you specifically want zoned foam support. Stumptown Original offers the stronger value if your priorities are pressure relief and motion isolation without added zoning.

The Saatva Classic sits in a higher price tier and is not a direct budget match. Its dual-coil design, Euro pillow top, three firmness choices, free in-room setup, and longer trial create a more full-service purchase. Choose it for a taller, hotel-style innerspring and white-glove delivery. Choose the Peak when you want responsive zoned support in a boxed mattress that costs less.

• Allow the mattress to expand fully before judging its height or firmness, then give your body the required 21-night adjustment period.

• Match pillow height to the surface. Side sleepers often need more loft on the Peak or Luxe Firm than on the Original.

• Use breathable sheets and lighter bedding before deciding that a mattress sleeps too warm.

• Place the mattress on a solid or closely spaced support system to protect alignment, edge stability, and warranty coverage.

• Rotate the mattress periodically; do not flip these one-sided designs.

• If you share the bed, check turning, getting up, and edge sitting during the first weeks while a return is still possible.

• Add a topper only after the mattress has had time to break in. An early topper can hide whether the underlying firmness is actually right.

• Use a protector from the first night because stains, odors, tears, and other damage can affect return or warranty eligibility.

• Confirm the current price, production time, and delivery estimate at checkout, especially for made-to-order sizes and Luxe versions.

The tested Luxe Firm and the Original tied at 4.6 for motion isolation. Choose the Luxe Firm if both partners like a firm, cooler surface. Choose the Original for a more forgiving medium-firm foam feel. The Hybrid is the better compromise when both people want more bounce and easier movement.

The tested Luxe Firm maintained the steadiest temperature. The Hybrid ranked next because its coil core allows more airflow than the Original's foam base.

The Peak responded fastest and earned a 4.7 for responsiveness. The Hybrid followed at 4.5 and feels slightly softer on top.