Mattoon Mattress is best approached as a curated lineup: a few mainstream models that cover very different comfort goals, from extra-firm coil support to high-end cooling foam. I focused on support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability to separate “good on the showroom floor” from “still comfortable after weeks,” and to flag who each option fits well and who should skip it.
Product lineup at a glance
| Mattress | Overall Score | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sealy Posturepedic Plus Paterson II Tight Top Ultra Firm | 4.3 | Very strong support; sturdy edges | Too firm for many side sleepers | Heavier back/stomach sleepers; people who hate sink | $949 |
| Sealy Posturepedic Plus Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top | 4.2 | More cushion; easier pressure relief | Not as “locked-in” for strict stomach sleep | Side/back combo sleepers; comfort-first feel | $999 |
| Sealy Posturepedic Pro Dupont II Tight Top Firm | 4.3 | Balanced firmness; dependable perimeter | Less plush on bony shoulders | All-around firmness; couples wanting stability | $1,199 |
| TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 | 4.4 | Excellent cooling + motion control | Slower response; less bounce | Hot sleepers; light-sleeping partners | - |
Testing team takeaways
Across weeks of rotation, we saw a clear pattern: LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 ran coolest and kept partner disturbance lowest, while Paterson II Ultra Firm delivered the most “flat, supported” feel. Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top was the easiest on shoulders and hips, especially for lighter side sleepers, and Dupont II Firm sat in the middle as the most even, no-drama choice. Marcus favored the firmer coil builds for support; Mia gravitated to the Euro top; Carlos kept pointing to which beds held alignment without feeling rigid.
Mattoon Mattress comparison chart
| Comparison item | Paterson II Ultra Firm Tight Top | Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top | Dupont II Firm Tight Top | TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feel category | Extra firm | Medium | Firm | Firm |
| Construction type | Wrapped coil | Wrapped coil | Wrapped coil | Foam comfort system |
| Top style | Tight top | Euro pillow top feel (pillow top) | Tight top | - |
| Height | 13 in | 15 in | 14 in | 13 in |
| Cooling approach | Moisture-wicking cover mentioned | Moisture-wicking cover mentioned | Cool-to-the-touch cover mentioned | SmartClimate cover + cooling layers |
| Motion feel in our tests | Noticeable rebound; movement damped but present | Slightly softer landing; still some coil energy | Most “controlled” of the coil models | Most isolated, least partner ripple |
| Responsiveness | Fast, springy | Medium-fast | Fast with firmer pushback | Slower, foam-forward |
| Edge support | Strongest “sit edge” | Strong, slightly cushioned | Strong and steady | Good, but less spring bracing |
| Pressure relief | Lowest of the set | Best among the coil models | Middle | Best overall (especially for hips/shoulders) |
| Best match | Heavy, firm-preferring sleepers | Side/back combo comfort seekers | Balanced firmness shoppers | Hot sleepers + light sleepers |
How we tested
We bought and rotated these mattresses across the same bed frame and bedding so changes in feel were easier to attribute to the mattress. I tracked Support and Edge Support with repeated sit tests and alignment checks, Cooling through overnight heat buildup and fabric feel, and Pressure Relief by how shoulders/hips behaved after long side-sleep stretches. We scored Motion Isolation by how much movement carried across the surface during exits and position changes, Responsiveness by how easily we could roll and settle, and Durability by how quickly surfaces recovered and whether feel shifted over weeks.
Mattoon Mattress: our testing experience
Sealy Posturepedic Plus Paterson II Tight Top Ultra Firm
Our testing experience
The first night, I noticed the surface barely gave under my hips, and that was the point: my lower back felt “held up” instead of nudged into extension. By night three, I could read in bed without sliding into a soft pocket. Marcus (6'1", about 230 lbs) liked how the mattress refused that hammocking sag when he rolled from side-start to stomach. Mia (5'4", about 125 lbs) tapped out early—her shoulder didn’t sink enough, and she kept repositioning. Carlos (5'11", about 175 lbs) called it “level” through the mid-back, especially when lying flat.
What we liked
-
Very stable lumbar and hip support when sleeping on my back
-
Reliable edge feel when sitting to put on shoes
-
Quick, no-effort turns without foam drag
Who it is best for
-
Heavier back sleepers and stomach sleepers
-
People who prefer minimal contouring and a flatter surface
-
Anyone prioritizing a sturdy perimeter
Where it falls short
-
Light side sleepers who need more shoulder give
-
People who want a plush “sink-in” feel
Pros & cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Strong, steady support for hips and lower back | Can feel rigid for lighter bodies |
| Easy mobility and quick settling | Shoulder pressure for side sleepers |
| Edge feels secure for sitting and sleeping near perimeter | Not the most “cushioned” pressure relief |
| Good choice for firm-preference shoppers | Some bounce can carry movement |
Details
-
Price (queen): $949
-
Firmness: Extra firm
-
Tested size: Queen
-
Dimensions (queen): 60 in x 79 in
-
Height: 13 in
-
Type: Wrapped coil
-
Top: Tight top
-
Cooling notes: Moisture-wicking cover referenced in product overview
-
Adjustable base compatible: Yes
-
Warranty: 10-year limited
-
Shipping: -
-
Trial period: -
Review score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.8 | Hips stayed elevated; strongest “anti-sag” feel in the group |
| Pressure Relief | 3.8 | Fine for back sleep; side-sleep shoulder comfort lagged |
| Cooling | 4.1 | Stayed reasonably neutral for a coil bed; no heavy heat trap |
| Motion Isolation | 4.0 | Better than old-school innerspring, but movement was still noticeable |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 | Easy turns; quick recovery without wobble |
| Edge Support | 4.6 | Sit edge felt braced and stable |
| Durability | 4.5 | Feel stayed consistent over weeks; minimal softening |
| Overall | 4.3 | Best for firm support seekers; less forgiving for side sleepers |
Sealy Posturepedic Plus Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top
Our testing experience
This one felt like the “friendlier” Paterson the moment I lay down—more cushion up top, more forgiveness at the shoulder. I could side-sleep longer without that sharp pressure buildup, and the Euro-style surface kept my elbow from digging in when I propped myself up with a laptop. Mia immediately relaxed into it, especially when she curled slightly; her shoulder finally had a place to go. Marcus still liked the coil support underneath, but he wanted a touch more firmness when he fully rolled onto his stomach. Carlos paid attention to the transition: he could feel the top compress, then the support layer catch him before it turned mushy.
What we liked
-
Noticeably better pressure relief than the Ultra Firm version
-
Comfortable “buffer” feel for side-sleep starts
-
Still easy to move around without feeling stuck
Who it is best for
-
Side/back combo sleepers who want cushion without losing support
-
People who get shoulder or outer-hip pressure on firm beds
-
Couples who want a slightly softer landing but stable support
Where it falls short
-
Strict stomach sleepers who need a flatter, firmer surface
-
Shoppers who dislike any plush top feel
Pros & cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| More forgiving top layer for shoulders and hips | Can feel too plush for some stomach sleepers |
| Better balance of contouring and support than Ultra Firm | Not as “locked-in” as a true firm tight top |
| Smoother comfort for reading and lounging | Slightly less crisp edge feel than the firmest options |
| Good all-around comfort for mixed positions | Cushion can feel warm for very hot sleepers |
Details
-
Price (queen): $999
-
Firmness: Medium
-
Tested size: Queen
-
Height: 15 in
-
Type: Wrapped coil
-
Top: Pillow top / Euro pillow top feel
-
Sizes referenced by retailer listing: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split California King
-
Adjustable base compatible: Yes
-
Warranty: 10-year limited
-
Shipping: -
-
Trial period: -
Review score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.2 | Supportive for back/side; less ideal for long stomach stretches |
| Pressure Relief | 4.4 | Best shoulder/hip comfort among the coil options |
| Cooling | 4.0 | Mostly neutral; cushion held a bit more warmth than tight tops |
| Motion Isolation | 4.1 | Partner movement was muted, though not “foam quiet” |
| Responsiveness | 4.2 | Turns were easy; slight plush delay before fully settled |
| Edge Support | 4.3 | Strong perimeter, just a touch more compressive at the edge |
| Durability | 4.3 | Held feel well over weeks with minor break-in |
| Overall | 4.2 | Comfort-forward coil pick for combo sleepers and side sleepers |
Sealy Posturepedic Pro Dupont II Tight Top Firm
Our testing experience
This was the mattress I kept coming back to when I wanted the simplest answer: firm, stable, and predictable. It didn’t have that “extra-firm board” posture of Paterson Ultra Firm, but it also didn’t invite the deeper top-layer sink of the Euro pillow top. I could fall asleep on my side, roll to my back, and wake up without feeling like my hips had drifted. Marcus called it “firm without being punishing,” and he liked how the edge held when he sat to tie shoes. Mia could side-sleep on it, but only with a thicker pillow and a bit more attention to shoulder position. Carlos liked the transition the most here—he said the support “shows up on time” when you settle in.
What we liked
-
Balanced firmness that works across positions
-
Strong edge stability without a hard rim feel
-
Controlled bounce that doesn’t feel jittery
Who it is best for
-
People who want firm support but still want some surface comfort
-
Back sleepers and combo sleepers
-
Couples who value stability and consistent support
Where it falls short
-
Very pressure-sensitive side sleepers
-
Shoppers seeking a plush, deep-conforming surface
Pros & cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Firm support with a more approachable surface than Ultra Firm | Can still pressure shoulders for lighter side sleepers |
| Solid perimeter for sitting and edge sleeping | Not a plush “hotel top” feel |
| Even feel that stays consistent across the bed | Motion is controlled but not fully eliminated |
| Good middle-ground pick for mixed households | Cushion lovers may want more softness |
Details
-
Price (queen): $1,199
-
Firmness: Firm
-
Tested size: Queen
-
Height: 14 in
-
Type: Wrapped coil
-
Top: Tight top
-
Adjustable base compatible: Yes
-
Warranty: 10-year limited
-
Shipping: -
-
Trial period: -
Review score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.6 | Consistent alignment for back and combo sleep; very stable hips |
| Pressure Relief | 4.0 | Better than Ultra Firm for most people, still firm at shoulders |
| Cooling | 4.1 | Stayed neutral; cover feel was cool-to-touch at bedtime |
| Motion Isolation | 4.1 | Controlled bounce; partner movement noticeable but not disruptive |
| Responsiveness | 4.3 | Quick turns; no “stuck” sensation |
| Edge Support | 4.5 | Strong sitting edge with minimal collapse |
| Durability | 4.4 | Held firmness over weeks; little change night-to-night |
| Overall | 4.3 | The most balanced firm coil choice in this set |
TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0
Our testing experience
The first thing I noticed was temperature—when I slid under the covers, the surface didn’t warm up as quickly as the others. The second thing was silence: when I shifted positions, the movement stayed local, without the little ripple you get on coil beds. I’m a hybrid sleeper, and on this mattress I could rotate from side to back without fighting the surface, but it did ask for a beat of patience—the foam “catches up” after you move. Marcus appreciated the cooler feel but wanted more bounce when he went stomach-down. Mia loved the pressure relief, especially at the shoulder and outer hip, and Carlos said the mid-back stayed level because the foam conformed without letting the hips drift.
What we liked
-
Best motion isolation in the group
-
Strong cooling feel at the surface
-
Excellent pressure relief without a loose, saggy feel
Who it is best for
-
Hot sleepers who still want a firm feel
-
Light sleepers sharing a bed
-
Side sleepers who need contouring without going plush
Where it falls short
-
People who need springy bounce and instant response
-
Anyone who dislikes foam’s slower recovery
Pros & cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Top-tier cooling feel compared to typical foam beds | Less bounce than coil options |
| Excellent motion isolation | Slower response when changing positions |
| Strong pressure relief for shoulders and hips | Edge is good but not as “braced” as firm coils |
| Firm feel without harshness | Premium price category in most markets |
Details
-
Price: -
-
Firmness: Firm
-
Mattress height: 13 in
-
Sizes referenced by retailer listing: Twin XL, Queen, King, California King
-
Key materials referenced: SmartClimate cover, heat-diffusing layer, Pure Cool Plus material, Ventilated Advanced Relief material
-
Cover: Removable, machine-washable cover referenced
-
Adjustable base friendly: Yes
-
Warranty: 10-year
-
Shipping: -
-
Trial period: -
Review score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.5 | Firm foam kept hips from drifting while still conforming |
| Pressure Relief | 4.6 | Best overall comfort at shoulder/hip contact points |
| Cooling | 4.7 | Clear advantage in surface cool feel and heat management |
| Motion Isolation | 4.8 | Least partner ripple; most “quiet” surface |
| Responsiveness | 3.9 | Noticeably slower to rebound than coils |
| Edge Support | 4.1 | Supportive enough, but not as rigid as firm coil edges |
| Durability | 4.4 | Stable feel across weeks; no obvious softening in our rotation |
| Overall | 4.4 | Best for cooling and motion control; slower response is the trade |
Compare performance scores across these mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness | Edge Support |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paterson II Tight Top Ultra Firm | 4.3 | 4.8 | 3.8 | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.5 | 4.4 | 4.6 |
| Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top | 4.2 | 4.2 | 4.4 | 4.0 | 4.1 | 4.3 | 4.2 | 4.3 |
| Dupont II Tight Top Firm | 4.3 | 4.6 | 4.0 | 4.1 | 4.1 | 4.4 | 4.3 | 4.5 |
| TEMPUR-LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 | 4.4 | 4.5 | 4.6 | 4.7 | 4.8 | 4.4 | 3.9 | 4.1 |
On pure balance, Dupont II Firm and Paterson II Ultra Firm both land at 4.3 overall, but they earn it differently: Paterson wins on sheer firmness and edge strength, while Dupont spreads the points more evenly. Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top is the pressure-relief leader among the coil models, and LuxeBreeze clearly separates itself for Cooling and Motion Isolation, with Responsiveness being the trade.
How to choose among Mattoon Mattress options
Start with sleep position and how much contouring you tolerate. If you’re heavier or spend real time on your stomach, Paterson II Ultra Firm is the safest “hips stay up” choice. If you’re a side sleeper (especially lightweight) or you wake up with shoulder pressure, Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top is the easier night-one fit. If you want one firm bed that doesn’t feel extreme, Dupont II Firm is the most broadly compatible. If heat and partner movement are your top two problems, LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 is the clear specialist.
Limitations and trade-offs
These options don’t try to be everything at once, and that’s the point. Paterson II Ultra Firm can be unforgiving for lighter side sleepers, while Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top can feel too cushioned for strict stomach sleepers. Dupont II Firm is balanced, but it won’t satisfy shoppers who want a plush top or deep foam hug. LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 reduces motion and heat better than the coils, but the slower foam response and reduced bounce won’t fit everyone, especially people who like a springy surface.
Mattoon Mattress vs alternatives
People choose these models for three reasons: clear firmness targeting, recognizable mainstream builds, and a straightforward “pick by problem” spread (support, pressure relief, or cooling). If you want a coil-based luxury feel with more distinct plush/firm tuning, Saatva Classic is a strong alternative for back and combo sleepers. If you want a cooling-forward hybrid with more bounce than foam, Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe is a practical swap for hot sleepers who still want easy mobility.
Pro tips for Mattoon Mattress shoppers
-
Pick your mattress by your primary failure mode: hips sinking, shoulder pressure, overheating, or partner disturbance
-
If you are between two feels, choose the firmer coil model and adjust with a thin topper rather than buying too soft
-
Test edge support by sitting fully on the corner for 60 seconds; weak edges show fast
-
For side sleepers, spend at least five minutes on one side before judging pressure relief
-
Bring your normal pillow to the showroom if possible; pillow height can change perceived firmness
-
Use the same sheets for the first two weeks; thick flannel can mask heat buildup
-
If you sleep hot, prioritize breathable bedding and keep the protector thin and stretchy
-
Give your body a consistent routine: same bedtime and same position start for the first few nights
-
Rotate the mattress head-to-foot (if compatible) during early break-in to keep feel even
FAQs
Q: Which option is best if I wake up from my partner moving?
A: LuxeBreeze Firm 2.0 showed the least motion carry across the surface.
Q: Which one felt firmest at the hips?
A: Paterson II Ultra Firm kept my hips highest and felt the most “flat.”
Q: Which one helped the most with shoulder pressure?
A: Paterson II Medium Euro Pillow Top was the most forgiving among the coil models.
Q: Which is easiest to move on?
A: The coil models are quicker to turn on; LuxeBreeze has a slower foam rebound.
