Croft Mattress Reviews (2026)

Croft sells other comfort levels and models, but these are the four covered here. On August 26, 2026, advertised starting prices were $399.99 for Oliver, $599.99 for Mercer Firm, $899.99 for Waverly Plush, and $1,299.99 for Barclay Hybrid. Larger and specialty sizes cost more.

Oliver

Oliver is the sensible choice for a guest room, a child or teen, or a solo back sleeper working with a tight budget. Its shallow cushioning and average motion control make it a poor fit for regular side sleeping, motion-sensitive couples, or heavier pairs.

Best for

• Guest rooms

• Kids and teens

• Budget-minded back sleepers

Not ideal for

• Dedicated side sleepers

• Motion-sensitive couples

• Heavier couples using it nightly

Mercer Firm

Mercer Firm offers the flattest, most resistant surface in this group. It suits back and stomach sleepers who dislike sinking in, but its firm quilted top does not give the shoulder and hip much room to settle.

Best for

• Back sleepers

• Stomach sleepers

• People who prefer a firm surface

Not ideal for

• Lightweight side sleepers

• People who want a plush top

• Sleepers with sensitive shoulders or hips

Waverly Plush

Waverly Plush is the easiest recommendation for side sleepers who want more give without losing the lift of coils. It also works well in a shared bed when both sleepers like a softer surface, though heavier stomach sleepers may sink too far at the hips.

Best for

• Side sleepers

• Couples who prefer a softer feel

• Guest rooms that serve different sleepers

Not ideal for

• People who only enjoy firm beds

• Heavier stomach sleepers

• Anyone who often sits at the edge

Barclay Hybrid

Barclay Hybrid earns its higher price with the most complete performance in the lineup. It cushions the shoulder and hip, keeps movement under better control, and remains easy to turn on. Choose another model if price matters most or if you want an extra-firm surface.

Best for

• Combination sleepers

• Couples

• Primary-bedroom upgrades

Not ideal for

• Shoppers with the lowest budget

• People who need an extra-firm feel

• Anyone who wants the deep hug of an all-foam mattress

All four use pocketed coils, a quilted cover, Croft's Silver Living fiber layer, and CertiPUR-US foams. The available sizes include standard options, Split King, Flex Head Queen and King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King. Croft says these mattresses are made without formaldehyde or fiberglass. Every mattress is final sale, but the separate Perfect Fit program can add a firmer or softer foam layer between nights 31 and 60. That basic adjustment is free; transportation is not, and larger changes may cost extra.

Each mattress went through regular overnight use and the same repeatable checks. Marcus Reed, Carlos Alvarez, and Mia Chen helped compare how support and pressure changed across body types and sleep positions. We rated support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability on a five-point scale. The hands-on checks included spinal-alignment observations, a 30-minute surface-temperature reading, three 10-pound ball drops from 36 inches, a 44-pound compression test, timed recovery after removing weight, and 30 seconds of edge sitting. Dr. Adrian Walker reviewed the notes with one useful distinction in mind: a bed can feel firm without supporting every sleeper equally well.

Our Testing Experience

Oliver felt simple and springy from the first night. At about 6 out of 10 for firmness, it kept Carlos level on his back and made position changes effortless, but Mia's shoulder and outer hip began to feel pressure during longer side-sleeping stretches. A 44-pound load compressed the center by 2.0 inches, and the same load near the edge reached 3.1 inches, matching the less secure perimeter we noticed while sitting. The surface warmed 5.8°F after 30 minutes, while vibrations from the ball-drop test remained noticeable for an average of 0.9 seconds. Those results make Oliver a practical occasional-use bed, not the best everyday choice for a side sleeper or a couple.

What we liked

• The low price works well for rooms that are not used every night.

• The responsive surface makes rolling over and getting up easy.

• Back sleepers get even support without a deep foam cradle.

Who it is best for

• Guest rooms and other lighter-use spaces

• Kids and teens who do not need deep pressure relief

• Budget-minded back sleepers

Where it falls short

• The quilted top does not cushion the shoulder enough for regular side sleeping.

• Partner movement travels farther than it does on Waverly Plush or Barclay Hybrid.

• The edge compresses noticeably when you sit or sleep close to it.

Details

• Starting price: $399.99

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress

• Surface feel: Medium quilted top

• Sizes: Standard, Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King

Our Testing Experience

Mercer Firm had the flattest surface and strongest pushback of the four. We rated the feel about 8 out of 10. My hips stayed level on my back, and both Carlos and Marcus preferred its steady midsection support to Oliver's lighter build. Mia changed positions more often on her side because the quilted top resisted her shoulder instead of letting it settle. The 44-pound load compressed the center by only 1.4 inches and the edge by 2.0 inches. After 30 minutes, the surface was 4.6°F warmer, and ball-drop vibration lasted 0.7 seconds on average. It is the clearest choice here for firm-bed shoppers, but side sleepers should skip it.

What we liked

• The firm top keeps the hips from dipping during back and stomach sleeping.

• Fast recovery makes turning and getting out of bed easy.

• The perimeter feels more stable than Oliver's.

Who it is best for

• Back sleepers who want a level surface

• Stomach sleepers who need firmer hip support

• People who prefer an extra-firm feel to the sinking feel of memory foam

Where it falls short

• Most side sleepers will feel too much pressure at the shoulder.

• The firm quilt offers little of the plush comfort found in Waverly Plush.

• Motion isolation is average, so light sleepers may notice a partner moving.

Details

• Starting price: $599.99

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress

• Surface feel: Firm quilted top

• Sizes: Standard, Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King

Our Testing Experience

Waverly Plush changed the experience most clearly for side sleepers. Its roughly 4-out-of-10 feel let Mia's shoulder settle without forcing her to keep shifting, and I noticed the same improvement over Oliver and Mercer Firm. Carlos still felt stable on his back, although Marcus sank farther at the hips during stomach sleeping. The center compressed 2.7 inches under the 44-pound load, while the edge compressed 2.8 inches. The surface gained 5.1°F during the 30-minute heat check, and ball-drop vibration faded after an average of 0.5 seconds. Waverly is the best pressure-relief pick in the group, provided you are comfortable with a softer edge and a little more effort when turning.

What we liked

• The softer quilt eases pressure at the shoulder and outer hip.

• Independent coils keep the mattress from feeling loose or unstable.

• Motion settles faster than it does on Oliver or Mercer Firm.

Who it is best for

• Side sleepers who need more room for the shoulder and hip

• Couples who agree on a softer surface

• Guest rooms that need to suit several sleep styles

Where it falls short

• Heavier stomach sleepers may sink too far through the midsection.

• The edge does not feel as secure as Mercer Firm's.

• Combination sleepers must work a little harder to turn than on the firmer models.

Details

• Starting price: $899.99

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress

• Surface feel: Soft quilted top

• Sizes: Standard, Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King

Our Testing Experience

Barclay Hybrid was the only model that worked well for every tester and position. Its 5.5-out-of-10 feel cushioned Mia's shoulder, kept Marcus more level than Waverly Plush, and still let Carlos turn without fighting the foam. The 44-pound load compressed the center by 2.3 inches and the edge by 2.3 inches, showing a more consistent surface from center to perimeter. After 30 minutes, the surface was 4.4°F warmer, and ball-drop vibrations ended in an average of 0.4 seconds—the fastest result in this set. Barclay costs considerably more, but it is the Croft model that asks for the fewest compromises.

What we liked

• The foam-and-coil build balances pressure relief with steady alignment.

• The surface cushions side sleepers without trapping combination sleepers.

• It controls partner movement better than the other three models.

Who it is best for

• Combination sleepers who move between their back and side

• Couples with different sleep positions

• Shoppers replacing a basic mattress in the primary bedroom

Where it falls short

• It costs at least twice as much as Mercer Firm at the advertised starting price.

• Dedicated stomach sleepers may prefer Mercer's firmer surface.

• Very light sleepers can still feel some coil vibration from a partner.

Details

• Starting price: $1,299.99

• Type: Hybrid mattress

• Surface feel: Serene memory foam over pocketed coils

• Sizes: Standard, Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King

Barclay Hybrid is the best overall performer because none of its scores falls below 4.0. Waverly Plush is the better value for side sleepers and leads the group in pressure relief. Mercer Firm is a specialist: it trades cushioning and motion isolation for stronger support and faster movement. Oliver remains the budget pick, but its lower pressure-relief, motion, and edge scores limit it to lighter or occasional use.

Let sleep position settle the first cut. Mercer Firm is the strongest match for back and stomach sleepers who want to stay on top of the mattress. Waverly Plush gives side sleepers the most room at the shoulder and hip. Barclay Hybrid suits combination sleepers and couples because it balances cushioning, movement, and motion control. Oliver belongs in a guest room, a child's room, or a budget setup where basic support matters more than deep pressure relief. If you cannot try the bed in a showroom, be conservative: Croft does not accept mattress returns or exchanges.

Why choose Croft

Croft is unusually strong for shoppers who want a locally made, factory-direct mattress in a Split King, Flex Head, Ozark King, or Grand Ozark King. The lineup also gives you clear price steps from a basic pocketed-coil bed to a more cushioned hybrid. Croft says all four use CertiPUR-US foams and are made without fiberglass or formaldehyde.

Alternatives to consider

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: This boxed hybrid offers soft, medium, and firm choices, plus optional pillow-top and cooling upgrades. It is easier to buy sight-unseen because it includes a 120-night trial, while Croft mattresses are final sale. Choose Brooklyn Bedding for firmness choice and return flexibility; choose Croft for specialty sizes and local factory service.

Saatva Classic: Saatva includes in-room setup, optional old-mattress removal, a 365-night trial, and a lifetime warranty. Its three firmness choices and two height options also give shoppers more ways to customize the feel. It costs more than Croft's entry beds, but the service and return policy are much stronger.

Helix Midnight Luxe: Helix is the most targeted alternative for side sleepers. Its medium feel, zoned lumbar coils, reinforced edge, and optional cooling upgrades deliver a more specialized design than Waverly Plush. Barclay Hybrid remains the simpler choice for mixed positions, while Helix offers a 120-night trial that reduces the risk of ordering online.

• For a guest room, Oliver offers enough support without paying for premium comfort. Choose Mercer Firm only if you know your visitors tend to like a hard surface.

• For recurring shoulder or outer-hip pressure, start with Waverly Plush or Barclay Hybrid. Oliver and Mercer Firm do not provide enough side-sleeping give.

• Hot sleepers should favor the firmer, shallower-sinking models. Mercer Firm showed the smallest temperature increase in our 30-minute check.

• Allow the mattress 30 nights to break in. Croft's Perfect Fit adjustment is available only from nights 31 through 60.

• Budget for transportation if you use Perfect Fit; Croft does not include it.

• Rotate the mattress every one to two months and use a supportive base. Croft excludes damage tied to inadequate support or missed rotation from warranty coverage.

• Put on a mattress protector immediately. Croft says any stain can void the warranty.

For most adults, yes. A solo back sleeper on a strict budget may be comfortable, but Oliver is better suited to guest rooms, children, and lighter-use spaces. Side sleepers and couples should move up to Waverly Plush or Barclay Hybrid.

Waverly Plush provided the best shoulder and hip relief and earned the highest pressure-relief score. Barclay Hybrid is the better choice for a side sleeper who also wants steadier support, easier movement, or stronger motion isolation.

Mercer Firm held the hips most level and felt best for people who like a firm, flat surface. Barclay Hybrid scored slightly higher for support overall because it maintained alignment across a wider range of bodies and positions.

Barclay Hybrid is the clear couple pick. It had the best motion isolation in this group, a stable edge, and a medium feel that worked across more sleep positions. Waverly Plush is the alternative when both partners prefer a softer top.