Croft Mattress Reviews

Mattress shopping keeps circling back to one question. Where does my body actually feel right for eight hours straight. That question pulled me toward the Croft Mattress lineup, because this kind of regional brand often hides some very dialed-in designs.

I run our test group with Marcus, Carlos, Mia, Jenna, Jamal, and Ethan rotating through beds in real homes. Each person brings a different body, different sleep habits, different complaints. Under those circumstances, Croft’s pitch about handcrafted support, pocketed coils, and adjustment services felt worth pushing hard, not just reading on a tag. 

During several weeks with these Croft mattresses in our rotation, I kept circling back to alignment and durability. Marcus kept hunting for hip support and cooling. Mia chased pressure relief for her shoulders. Jenna and Ethan chased motion isolation for their shared bed. The story that formed around these Croft Mattress reviews came from that messy, nightly mix.

Product Overview

Mattress	Pros	Cons	Ideal For	Price (Queen, approx)	Overall Score
Croft Oliver	Very affordable, springy feel, easy to move on	Limited pressure relief, more motion transfer, basic finishes	Guest rooms, kids, lighter sleepers who like a firm spring feel	Around $399 for starting sizes, queen higher	3.8 / 5
Croft Mercer Firm	Strong edge support, firmer feel, pocketed coils	Too firm for strict side sleepers, some minor motion felt	Back and stomach sleepers, heavier bodies, rentals	From about $599	4.1 / 5
Croft Waverly Plush	Pocketed coils, plush surface, better pressure relief	Too soft for some stomach sleepers, moderate price jump	Side sleepers, combo sleepers wanting contour plus support	From about $899	4.3 / 5
Croft Barclay Firm	Very robust build, zoned support feel, good cooling package	Firm for lighter side sleepers, premium price	Larger bodies, back sleepers, hot sleepers who like firmness	From about $1,299	4.4 / 5
Croft Barclay Plush	Deep cushioning over strong coils, great for couples	Still not “ultra soft,” premium pricing	Side sleepers, couples wanting motion control and contour	From about $1,299	4.4 / 5

Testing Team Takeaways

I felt Croft’s lineup through the lens of late-thirties back tightness and combination sleeping. On the Barclay Firm, I rolled from back to side and felt my lumbar stay lifted, even as my ribs eased into the quilting. My notes read “spine feels stacked, but shoulders need a hint more give.” Waverly Plush flipped that equation, because my shoulders fell into a soft pocket while my hips rested on a more structured coil core.

Marcus came at these beds as a 6'1", 230-pound heater of a human. He kept chasing a “reset” feeling under his hips. On Oliver, he lay on his back, exhaled once, then muttered “hips dipping a bit, feels like a starter mattress.” On Barclay Firm, he rolled from back to stomach and said “this keeps my pelvis from sinking, finally feels like I can breathe.” Heat-wise, he flagged slightly warm foam quilts on Oliver and Mercer, while he praised the silver-infused fibers and more breathable builds in Waverly and Barclay. 

Mia moved through each mattress like a pressure-mapping device in human form. At 5'4" and 125 pounds, her shoulders usually complain first. Oliver pushed back against her side-sleeping frame, and she whispered “this kind of surface makes my shoulder feel pinned.” Waverly Plush flipped her mood. She curled into a loose fetal position, waited through a full podcast episode, then summarized it with “pressure off my shoulders, still not swampy under my hip.” Barclay Plush earned the most smiles, because she described the surface as “a soft pocket that never collapses.” 

Jenna looked at these Croft beds through a shared-bed lens, always with Ethan roaming beside her. On Oliver, she felt every bathroom trip and called it “that trampoline kind of motion.” Mercer Firm calmed things, although she still noticed a little bounce when Ethan dropped back into bed. Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush changed her tone. She described Waverly as “easy to roll over on, but his movements stay in his lane.” Barclay Plush became her favorite couple surface, because she could sprawl near the edge while Ethan tossed near the middle without getting jostled awake. 

Croft Mattress Comparison Chart

Mattress	Type	Firmness (our take)	Available Sizes	Materials / Construction	Cooling Features	Support System	Pressure Relief Feel	Responsiveness	Motion Isolation	Durability Outlook
Croft Oliver	Traditional innerspring with foam quilt	Medium-firm to firm	Twin, Full, Queen, King	Quilted foam comfort over coil unit; basic edge support; budget build	Airy coil core, simple breathable cover	Linked coil system, non-zoned	Shallow contour, more on top of bed	Very quick response, strong bounce	Noticeable movement across surface	Entry-level longevity, suited for lighter users and guest rooms
Croft Mercer Firm	Hybrid style innerspring	Firm	Common US sizes, queen focus	Firm comfort foams, pocketed coils, foam encased edge	Hydropur fiber for moisture management	Individually wrapped coils under firm foam	Moderate cushioning, firm surface feel	Quick response, easier repositioning	Better isolation than Oliver, some bounce left	Stronger components than Oliver, good for daily adult use
Croft Waverly Plush	Hybrid with plush top	Medium-plush	Standard sizes	Plush quilt foams, pocketed coils, foam encasement, Alphasan silver fiber	Alphasan Hydropur fiber aimed at fresher, cooler surface	800 series pocketed coil core	Deep contour for shoulders and hips	Balanced response, slight buoyant lift	Very good, partner movement mostly muted	Upgraded coil set and foams, solid long-term outlook
Croft Barclay Firm	Premium hybrid	Firm-plus	Standard sizes	High density foams, 800 series pocketed coils, silver lining fabric	Silver infused quilt, breathable design	Robust pocketed coil unit with foam rails	Firmer cradle, more lift than hug	Fast response, strong push-back	Good isolation, some firm-bed rebound	Premium build, best longevity for heavier sleepers
Croft Barclay Plush	Premium plush hybrid	Medium-plush	Standard sizes	Extra comfort foams over same coil core, silver lining fabric	Same silver and breathable quilt as firm	Same 800 series pocketed coil system	Deeper hug, strong pressure relief	Still responsive, easier to turn than many plush beds	Very strong isolation for couples	Premium materials with softer top, still long-wearing core

What We Tested And How We Tested It

I treated each Croft mattress as a full-time bed for several nights, not just a quick showroom flop. We rotated mattresses through two main bedrooms and one guest room, kept room temperatures near normal home levels, and tracked basic sleep metrics like wake-ups, position changes, and morning stiffness.

Support got judged first from the perspective of spinal alignment. I lay on my back and side on each mattress, then I watched where my lower back either lifted or dipped. Carlos repeated the same routine, because his mid-back fatigue often shows up when a support core weakens.

Pressure relief testing leaned heavily on side-sleeping sessions. Mia stayed on her side for longer stretches, paying close attention to shoulders, outer hips, and knees. I joined her for shorter side-sleep windows, so I could compare my heavier frame to her lighter one.

Motion isolation and couple performance came from Jenna and Ethan’s shared-bed nights. Ethan shifted often, rolled toward the edge, and sometimes climbed out for late-night water runs. Jenna reported how much of that movement traveled across the mattress, and I added drop tests with a weighted object to push the point.

We checked cooling by tracking perceived heat, sweat, and cover feel during long sleep and shorter reading sessions. Marcus, who sleeps hot, spent extra time on the plusher, more foam-heavy builds. He rated surfaces as neutral, warm, or uncomfortably hot, based on his overnight experience.

Edge support testing covered sitting, tying shoes, and sleeping very close to the perimeter. Jamal also knelt on edges while stretching after workouts, which highlighted foam encasement strength. Durability and value judgments relied on material quality, construction details from Croft’s spec lists, and how each bed felt after repeated nights. 

These criteria turned into the scoring metrics you will see in the review tables: Support, Pressure Relief, Cooling, Motion Isolation, Edge Support, Responsiveness, Durability, and Value.

Croft Mattress: Our Testing Experience

Croft Oliver Mattress Review – “The Entry-Level Workhorse Of Croft Mattress Reviews”

Our Testing Experience

Oliver came in as the budget Croft option, and it felt that way in a very honest manner. I set it up in our smaller guest room first, then moved it into my own room for several nights. On my back, the surface felt firm and springy, with my hips held up but not deeply cradled. Once I rolled to my side, my outer shoulder felt perched on top of the quilt, not nested inside it.

Marcus gave Oliver a much harder stress test. He dropped onto his back, knees up, and then stretched flat. The coil unit gave a quick bounce, and he grunted “this kind of feel reminds me of older motel beds, but tighter.” Under his 230-pound frame, the midsection dipped a little deeper than mine. During a stomach-sleeping spell, he felt his hips slide just a bit downward, enough to make him prefer shorter naps rather than full nights.

Mia’s experience with Oliver summed up its pressure behavior. She curled on her left side, pulled her knees slightly up, and stayed still. After about twenty minutes, she shifted and said “my shoulder wants more cushion, this kind of firmness is okay for a nap, not a marathon.” Her lighter build rode higher on the springs, which reduced any cradling she might feel on a plusher bed.

Motion transfer came through loud and clear. I lay near one edge while Marcus sat down hard on the other side. My body bounced a noticeable amount, and my notes for Oliver read “great if you like lively springs, rough if your partner moves a lot.”

For cooling, Oliver behaved fine. The basic coil system let heat vent, and the quilt never trapped oppressive warmth during our tests. Under my body, the surface stayed closer to room temperature through the night, even without any fancy cooling fabric claims on the product page. 

From the perspective of sleeper types, Oliver fit guest rooms, kids, lighter back sleepers, and rentals. It behaved like a straightforward innerspring with a firm lean and a budget build, not like a plush, pressure-relieving hybrid.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Very accessible price for a Croft bed	Limited deep pressure relief for shoulders and hips
Springy, responsive feel that helps combination sleepers move	Noticeable motion transfer across the surface
Decent basic cooling from airy coil core	Edge support feels only moderate for heavier users
Simple design that works for guest rooms or kids	Finish and feel lag behind higher Croft models

Details

• Price: Starts around $399 for smaller sizes, queen higher based on current listings
• Firmness: Medium-firm to firm in our testing
• Type: Traditional innerspring with foam quilt
• Available sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King, according to Croft’s catalog 
• Support core: Linked coil unit, non-zoned
• Comfort layers: Quilted foams, basic upholstery fibers
• Edge support: Standard perimeter, no heavy-duty rail feel
• Cooling: Coil system promotes airflow, cover feels neutral in temperature
• Pressure relief: Shallow contour, better for back and stomach than for pure side sleeping
• Responsiveness: Quick rebound, easy repositioning
• Durability: Adequate for lighter adults and guest use; not a tank for heavy daily use
• Shipping: Delivered through Croft’s regional delivery service, fees vary by location 
• Trial / adjustment: Eligible for Croft’s Perfect Fit Guarantee adjustments after 30 nights, during days 31–60, with certain limits 
• Warranty: Covered under Croft’s mattress warranty program, with coverage against body impressions beyond set thresholds 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	3.6	Keeps average bodies from bottoming out, but hips sag for heavier sleepers.
Pressure Relief	3.2	Side sleepers feel pressure on shoulders, back sleepers fare better.
Cooling	3.9	Coil core and basic quilt kept heat from building in our tests.
Motion Isolation	3.1	Linked coils carry movement, partners will feel bigger shifts.
Edge Support	3.4	Acceptable for sitting, feels less secure for heavier testers.
Responsiveness	4.6	Moves fast under the body, very easy to change positions.
Durability	3.4	Entry components suit lighter users and guest use more than heavy nightly use.
Value	4.8	Price feels aggressive for a branded innerspring from this regional maker.
Overall	3.8	Strong budget utility, clear trade-offs in pressure relief and motion control.

Croft Mercer Firm Mattress Review – “The Rental-Ready Backbone In Croft Mattress Reviews”

Our Testing Experience

Mercer Firm felt like the first step into Croft’s serious everyday lineup. When I lay down on my back, the surface greeted me with a firm, even plane. My lumbar rested on a thin layer of foam before hitting the pocketed coil support below, and I wrote “straight spine, zero hammock feel.”

Carlos spent a full workweek on Mercer Firm. He came in from long desk days, stretched out flat, and focused on mid-back fatigue. After several nights, he reported “no mid-back sag, this feels like a structured hotel bed, in a good way.” Transitional foam between the quilt and the pocketed coils created a smooth path from surface to core under his frame. 

Marcus tested the limits on stomach and back. On his stomach, his hips stayed high enough for him to keep using the bed the entire night. He described the feel as “finally a Croft that resets my back when I wake up.” On his side, however, his shoulders felt jammed after longer stretches, reinforcing that Mercer Firm caters more to back and stomach sleepers.

Motion isolation landed in a middle zone. I lay still while another tester rolled and got up, and I felt movement but not sharp jolts. The pocketed coils broke up some of that motion, while the firm foam kept things snappier than a slow-moving memory foam bed would.

Heat behavior stayed manageable. Marcus, who runs hot, called it “neutral to slightly warm if I stay in one spot too long,” which placed Mercer Firm ahead of softer, thicker foam beds we have tested elsewhere, but behind the more advanced cooling packages in Waverly and Barclay. 

In my view, Mercer Firm sat right in the sweet spot for entry-to-mid-price rentals, guest suites that host many body types, and home sleepers who like a firmer, hotel-style surface.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Firm, structured feel that supports backs and stomachs well	Too firm for many strict side sleepers
Pocketed coils reduce motion compared with basic innersprings	Some partner movement still noticeable
Stronger edge encasement for sitting and sleeping near the side	Lacks the deep hug of plush Croft models
Price fits mid-market budgets with better build than Oliver	Cooling only neutral, not actively cool-to-the-touch

Details

• Price: Listed from about $599 for Croft’s size range
• Firmness: Firm in our tests, with minimal sink
• Type: Hybrid-style pocketed coil mattress with firm foams
• Available sizes: Common sizes including queen and king, per Croft’s vendor catalog 
• Support core: Individually wrapped coil system, designed for more targeted support
• Comfort layers: Firmer polyurethane foams in the quilt and transition, tuned for a flatter feel 
• Edge support: Foam encased perimeter that holds up well under sitting and lying
• Cooling: Hydropur or similar fibers in the quilt, moderate temperature performance 
• Pressure relief: Limited depth for shoulders, adequate for lumbar and hips
• Responsiveness: Quick bounce from coils and firm foams, easy to move
• Durability: Upgraded over Oliver; suitable for nightly use by average and somewhat heavier sleepers
• Shipping: Localized delivery service, fees dependent on region and setup options 
• Trial / adjustment: Eligible for Croft Perfect Fit adjustments after the first 30 nights of use 
• Warranty: Covered by Croft’s multi-year mattress warranty, with body impression limits and usage rules 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.4	Holds spines level for back and stomach sleepers, including heavier testers.
Pressure Relief	3.6	Back sleepers comfortable; side sleepers notice firm shoulder feel.
Cooling	3.8	Neutral temperature, minor warmth for very hot sleepers.
Motion Isolation	3.4	Pocketed coils help, yet some bounce still reaches partners.
Edge Support	4.5	Foam encasement supports sitting and edge sleeping confidently.
Responsiveness	4.5	Fast adjustment, zero stuck-in-the-mud sensation.
Durability	4.2	Materials and build feel rental-ready and robust.
Value	4.4	Strong performance per dollar within the Croft lineup.
Overall	4.1	Reliable, firm hybrid that favors back and stomach sleepers.

Croft Waverly Plush Mattress Review – “The Shoulder Saver In Croft Mattress Reviews”

Our Testing Experience

Waverly Plush looked ordinary on the stand, yet it changed the tone of our tests once people actually lay down. The top quilt felt richer under my hands, with more loft and a softer first contact. I rolled onto my side and felt my shoulder sink more gradually, meeting resistance deeper in the pocketed coils rather than right at the surface.

Mia treated Waverly Plush like a potential long-term home. She lay on her right side, lined her spine with a pillow, and checked in after a full show episode. Her comment landed simply: “pressure off my shoulders without my neck twisting.” That kind of feedback rarely shows up on firmer beds for her. The 800 series pocketed coil core and the foam encasement held her hips level while the top foam layers cushioned her joints. 

Carlos rotated through back and side positions. On his back, he felt more immediate plushness than on Mercer, yet he never described a mid-back dip. On his side, his notes read “medium-plush, no mid-back fatigue next morning, still easy to shift.” That balance came from the way Waverly’s coils compressed under weight without losing that underlying structure.

Motion performance impressed Jenna and Ethan. Ethan rolled across the bed, changed sides, and climbed out late one night. Jenna reported feeling a gentle wave but not the sharp jolt seen on Oliver. She called it “couple-friendly, with enough bounce that I can still roll over.”

Marcus handled heat testing again. He started with skepticism, said “plush usually means hot for me,” then came back after his nights on Waverly Plush with a more neutral verdict. He felt slightly warm in heavy blankets, yet he did not experience the hot-spot feeling that dense memory foam designs usually produce, likely due to the coil airflow and Hydropur/Alphasan quilt fibers. 

From the perspective of sleeper types, Waverly Plush targeted side sleepers, combination sleepers, and couples who wanted contour without losing mobility. Stomach-only sleepers with heavier builds might find it a bit soft under the pelvis.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Excellent pressure relief for shoulders and hips	Too soft under the pelvis for some stomach sleepers
800 series pocketed coils give strong underlying support	Price step up from Mercer and Oliver
Good motion isolation with some bounce left	Heavy, harder to move once set up
Silver-infused and Hydropur fibers help maintain a fresh surface feel	May feel “too plush” for very firm-bed fans

Details

• Price: Starts around $899 according to Croft’s catalog 
• Firmness: Medium-plush in our team testing
• Type: Plush hybrid with 800 series pocketed coils
• Available sizes: Standard mattress sizes including queen; built as part of the main Croft line
• Support core: 800 series pocketed coil unit with foam encased perimeter for edge stability 
• Comfort layers: Multiple foam layers for cushioning; quilt with Alphasan Hydropur fibers for freshness and temperature balance 
• Edge support: Stronger than softer budget beds; good for sleeping near the edge
• Cooling: Quilted top feels neutral, coils move air; no icy cool-to-the-touch gimmick
• Pressure relief: Very good for side sleepers, strong contour around shoulders
• Responsiveness: Balanced; softer surface with enough bounce from coils underneath
• Durability: Uses upgraded coil system and foams, giving a solid medium-term and long-term outlook
• Shipping: Delivered by Croft’s regional delivery teams, with options for in-home setup 
• Trial / adjustment: Eligible for Perfect Fit adjustments after 30 nights, during days 31–60 
• Warranty: Protected by Croft’s warranty policy with specified body impression limits and exclusions 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.3	Holds hips level while letting shoulders sink for most testers.
Pressure Relief	4.7	Mia’s shoulders and my side sleeping felt well cushioned.
Cooling	4.2	Sleeps neutral for our hot sleepers, with minor warmth only.
Motion Isolation	4.3	Couples feel muted motion without dead, memory-foam heaviness.
Edge Support	4.2	Foam rails support sitting and edge sleeping securely.
Responsiveness	4.4	Plush surface still lets combination sleepers move easily.
Durability	4.3	Upgraded coils and foams inspire confidence for long use.
Value	4.2	Higher price yet matching performance for mid-to-upper budgets.
Overall	4.3	Strong all-around plush hybrid with standout pressure relief.

Croft Barclay Firm Mattress Review – “The Heavy-Hitter Support Star Of Croft Mattress Reviews”

Our Testing Experience

Barclay Firm entered the test rotation as the serious, no-nonsense Croft flagship for support. From the first night, my back noticed the difference. Lying flat, I felt the quilt cushioning a bit, then a decisive push-back from the coil core. My lumbar stayed lifted, yet I never felt perched on a board.

Marcus, as expected, became the real stress test. He rolled from side to stomach, then stayed there longer than on any other Croft. His morning comment hit exactly what this mattress wants to do: “hips up, chest free, this kind of feel lets me wake without that saggy hangover.” The 800 series pocketed coils and firmer comfort package created a platform that finally matched his frame. 

Jamal liked Barclay Firm for post-workout recovery. He sat on the edge tying shoes, and the foam encasement refused to cave. When he knelt on one knee to stretch, the surface pushed back evenly instead of dipping weirdly under the joint. Overnight, he slept mostly on his back and reported excellent drive out of the surface during turning.

Cooling performance placed Barclay Firm near the top of the Croft range. The silver lining fabric and breathable quilting felt less stuffy under a comforter, and Marcus rated it as “one of the cooler firm hybrids Croft builds.” 

Motion isolation landed in a good compromise zone. I ran our drop tests with a weighted object near one side while lying on the other. The impact felt damped by the coil wrapping and foam layers, yet the mattress kept a responsive character for position changes. Edge sleeping also felt secure, even when I pushed my shoulder and hip close to the perimeter.

From my perspective, Barclay Firm fit heavier back and stomach sleepers, taller athletic bodies, and anyone who values a firm, supportive platform over deep plush comfort.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Very strong support for heavier and athletic sleepers	Too firm for many petite side sleepers
Excellent edge support for sitting and sleeping	Less cozy initial feel than Barclay Plush
Cooler feel than softer foam-heavy designs	Premium price puts it out of budget range for some
Balanced motion control with a responsive coil core	May feel “overly firm” for people used to memory foam

Details

• Price: Around $1,299 for key sizes in the Barclay line 
• Firmness: Firm-plus, with strong push-back under hips and lumbar
• Type: Premium hybrid with thicker comfort package and 800 series coils
• Available sizes: Core US sizes including queen and king
• Support core: 800 series pocketed coil unit with heavy foam encasement for edge stability 
• Comfort layers: High density foams tuned firmer, quilted into a silver-lined cover
• Edge support: Very strong; supports sitting, kneeling, and edge sleeping for heavier bodies
• Cooling: Silver lining fabric and breathable quilt work with coil airflow for cooler nights 
• Pressure relief: Adequate for back and stomach sleeping, limited shoulder cradle for lighter side sleepers
• Responsiveness: Fast, supportive rebound; easy for active bodies to move
• Durability: Feels built for long-term use under heavier loads
• Shipping: White-glove style local delivery options available through Croft’s delivery partners 
• Trial / adjustment: Eligible for Perfect Fit adjustments in the 31–60 day window, after initial 30-night period 
• Warranty: Covered by Croft’s mattress warranty program with defined sagging thresholds and maintenance expectations 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.8	Delivers standout lift for heavier back and stomach sleepers.
Pressure Relief	3.8	Firmer comfort set reduces shoulder contour on side.
Cooling	4.3	Silver lining quilt and coils kept testers closer to neutral.
Motion Isolation	4.2	Pocketed coils and foams absorb most partner motion.
Edge Support	4.7	Edge feels rock solid for sitting and sleeping.
Responsiveness	4.6	Active sleepers move without resistance or stuck feeling.
Durability	4.7	Premium materials suggest long service life.
Value	4.0	High performance with a matching premium price.
Overall	4.4	Heavy-hitter option for support-focused sleepers.

Croft Barclay Plush Mattress Review – “The Couple-Friendly Flagship Of Croft Mattress Reviews”

Our Testing Experience

Barclay Plush took Barclay Firm’s skeleton and wrapped it in a thicker comfort story. I noticed the difference as soon as I dropped onto my side. The quilt compressed under my shoulder, then the deeper foams allowed more sink before the familiar Barclay coil strength kicked in. I felt held, not jammed, and still aligned.

Jenna and Ethan basically claimed Barclay Plush as their bed for the test window. The first night, Ethan cycled through his usual pattern: side at first, then back, later a quick stomach stint, and at least one bathroom trip. Jenna woke up and said “I knew he got up once, but I never felt the bed slam.” Later nights brought similar feedback. She called it “the most couple-friendly Croft in this group.”

From Ethan’s view, the surface let him turn without thinking. He mentioned “this kind of mattress lets my shoulders sink when I start on my side, then it firms up when I roll to my back.” The pocketed coils and plush foam layers combined into a feel that changed character politely as his posture shifted.

Mia evaluated Barclay Plush strictly as a side sleeper. She nested on her left side, shoulder deep into the quilt, and stayed there for about half an hour. When she sat up, she said “shoulder feels fresh, hip pressure low, this is my favorite Croft so far.” At her lighter weight, the plush design finally gave her the depth of cradle she wanted while still leveraging the strong coil core underneath.

Cooling and edge performance mirrored Barclay Firm. The silver lining fabric and pocketed coil support kept heat to a minimum for Marcus, even though there was more foam above the coils. He called it “slightly warmer than the Firm, still acceptable.” Edge sitting felt sturdy when Jenna and Ethan both crowded the sides during movie nights. 

From the perspective of sleeper types, Barclay Plush hit side sleepers, couples, and combination sleepers wanting premium comfort and motion control. Extra-firm devotees might find it too soft, yet it never collapsed into an ultra-squishy feel.

Pros & Cons

Pros	Cons
Excellent pressure relief plus strong underlying support	Premium price compared with Oliver or Mercer
Very good motion isolation for couples	Slightly warmer than the firm Barclay for hot sleepers
Strong edge support and stable perimeter	Too plush for rare extra-firm fans
Deep yet controlled cradle beneficial for side sleepers	Heavy and harder to move during rearranging

Details

• Price: Also around $1,299 for queen in the Barclay line 
• Firmness: Medium-plush, with deeper sink than Waverly but strong core
• Type: Premium plush hybrid mattress
• Available sizes: Common sizes including queen and king
• Support core: Same 800 series pocketed coil unit and foam encasement used in Barclay Firm 
• Comfort layers: Thicker, plusher foam stack under silver lining quilt
• Edge support: Strong enough for couples using the full width
• Cooling: Good airflow from coils and breathable cover, slightly warmer feel from deeper foams
• Pressure relief: High; shoulders and hips get a generous cradle
• Responsiveness: Still agile, with enough bounce to help turning
• Durability: Premium materials and strong coil unit suggest long life with proper support base
• Shipping: Delivered via Croft’s local delivery network with available setup services 
• Trial / adjustment: Covered by Perfect Fit adjustments during the specified window after 30 nights 
• Warranty: Included under Croft’s mattress warranty rules, covering sagging beyond allowed depth 

Review Score

Metric	Score	Remarks
Support	4.5	Underlying coil strength still keeps hips from sagging.
Pressure Relief	4.8	Deep, controlled cradle for shoulders and hips.
Cooling	4.1	Slight warmth from thicker foam, yet no major overheating.
Motion Isolation	4.6	Jenna and Ethan reported limited partner disturbance.
Edge Support	4.4	Edges support sitting and shared-bed use well.
Responsiveness	4.3	Plush surface still lets sleepers turn easily.
Durability	4.6	Strong core and quality foams feel long-lasting.
Value	4.1	High comfort per dollar for people who can reach the price.
Overall	4.4	Premium plush hybrid tailored for couples and side sleepers.

Compare Performance Scores Of These Mattresses

Mattress	Overall Score	Support	Pressure Relief	Cooling	Motion Isolation	Durability	Responsiveness
Croft Oliver	3.8	3.6	3.2	3.9	3.1	3.4	4.6
Croft Mercer Firm	4.1	4.4	3.6	3.8	3.4	4.2	4.5
Croft Waverly Plush	4.3	4.3	4.7	4.2	4.3	4.3	4.4
Croft Barclay Firm	4.4	4.8	3.8	4.3	4.2	4.7	4.6
Croft Barclay Plush	4.4	4.5	4.8	4.1	4.6	4.6	4.3

In my view, Waverly Plush and the two Barclay models form the performance core of these Croft Mattress reviews. Waverly takes the balanced, plush-yet-supportive slot, Barclay Firm focuses on maximum lift and durability, and Barclay Plush becomes the pressure-relief and couple specialist. Oliver and Mercer Firm sit lower in overall score, yet they carve out clear roles for budget setups and firmer rental-style beds.

Best Picks

Best Overall Croft Mattress Reviews Pick – Croft Barclay Plush
For side sleepers and couples, Barclay Plush emerged as the most complete package. The combination of deep pressure relief, strong support, and high motion isolation matched what Mia, Jenna, and Ethan experienced night after night, with scores that stayed strong in every metric.

Best Croft Mattress For Heavy Sleepers – Croft Barclay Firm
From the perspective of larger bodies and athletic frames, Barclay Firm delivered the cleanest alignment and the most robust edge support. Marcus and Jamal both described a “reset” feeling in their backs, which lined up with Barclay Firm’s standout support and durability scores.

Best Value In Croft Mattress Reviews – Croft Mercer Firm
Mercer Firm struck the best performance-to-price ratio. The mattress gives firmer hybrid support, stronger edges, and better motion control than Oliver, without stepping into Barclay pricing, which fits rentals, guest suites, and home sleepers who like a firm, hotel-style bed.

How To Choose The Croft Mattress?

Choosing among these Croft models starts with sleep position and body weight. From the perspective of spinal alignment, heavier back and stomach sleepers need stronger coil support and firmer foams. Lighter side sleepers need more depth in the comfort layers, otherwise pressure builds fast around shoulders and hips.

Temperature sensitivity comes next. People who sleep hot usually do better on firmer surfaces with less sink, plus coil systems that move air. Budget plays a role as well, since Croft stretches from the entry-level Oliver into premium Barclay territory.

For a light-weight side sleeper, Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush make the most sense. Mia’s experience on those mattresses showed how their plusher surfaces and pocketed coils combine into shoulder-friendly cradles, without twisting the neck.

For an average-weight back sleeper, Mercer Firm and Waverly Plush both fit, depending on firmness preference. Carlos found Mercer Firm kept his mid-back aligned when he wanted a flatter, firmer feel, while Waverly Plush added more surface comfort without losing structure.

For a hot sleeper like Marcus, Barclay Firm and Waverly Plush performed better than softer, foam-heavy beds would. The coil cores, breathable quilts, and silver lining covers helped control heat build-up, especially under firmer conditions where the body sits higher.

For a heavier couple, Barclay Firm and Barclay Plush offered the best mix of support, motion isolation, and edge strength. Jenna and Ethan’s nights on Barclay Plush highlighted how the mattress allowed full-width use of the surface without edge collapse, while Barclay Firm would serve couples preferring a firmer overall feel.

For a budget-focused guest room, Oliver still earns a place. The mattress keeps lighter bodies adequately supported, responds quickly when people climb in and out, and keeps airflow moving through the coil core. Mercer Firm becomes the step-up choice when the same room will also host heavier guests or long-term renters.

Limitations

Across these Croft Mattress reviews, certain sleeper types remained underserved. People seeking an extremely soft, marshmallow-like surface will not find that kind of feel here, even on Barclay Plush. Extra-firm fans who want a near-unyielding board might still want something harder than Barclay Firm or Mercer Firm.

Very heavy sleepers well above typical weight ranges may still want even thicker or more heavily reinforced mattresses than Croft currently lists, especially for long-term durability. Shoppers who insist on ultra-low budget pricing also may find the Croft line expensive once they move beyond Oliver.

Fans of very bouncy, classic Bonnell innersprings with loud motion and minimal foam will notice that Croft’s better performers lean toward pocketed coils and more modern hybrid behavior.

Policies At A Glance

Mattress	Shipping (cost and region)	Trial Period	Return Policy / Fees	Warranty Length	Notable Conditions
Croft Oliver	Local delivery through Croft’s service area; fees vary by distance and options	Perfect Fit adjustment window opens after 30 nights	Mattress sales treated as final; adjustments rather than returns in many cases	Multi-year mattress warranty, length depends on product line	Must allow 30 nights before requesting changes; usage requirements apply
Croft Mercer Firm	Same regional delivery structure, optional in-home setup	Eligible for Perfect Fit adjustments between days 31–60	Exchanges focus on adjustments or model changes within policy rules	Coverage against qualifying body impressions for advertised term	Must keep mattress on an appropriate foundation; stains and misuse can void coverage
Croft Waverly Plush	Delivered by Croft trucks within their Missouri-area network and surroundings	Same 30-night break-in before adjustment	Returns of mattresses generally restricted; adjustments favored	Warranty term aligned with Croft’s premium hybrid policies	Perfect Fit changes may involve altering the mattress rather than replacing it
Croft Barclay Firm	Regional white-glove style delivery for heavier premium models	30-night minimum use, then adjustment options	No simple “sleep trial” with free returns; store works through adjustments	Long-term mattress warranty with body impression limits	Customer may be responsible for transport or service fees during warranty service
Croft Barclay Plush	Same delivery pattern as Barclay Firm	Same Perfect Fit and adjustment timing	Focus on tailoring comfort rather than issuing refunds	Warranty coverage consistent with Barclay Firm	Keeping original documentation and following care instructions helps preserve coverage

From the perspective of policy friendliness, Croft leans harder into adjustment and comfort tailoring than into open-ended free returns. People who like the idea of a regional maker modifying a mattress to fit them better will see value here, while shoppers seeking long, no-questions-asked free trials may feel constrained.

FAQs

1. Are Croft mattresses only sold locally, or can these Croft Mattress reviews help online buyers too?
Croft operates with a strong local and regional focus, using its own delivery network and showrooms in Missouri markets. These Croft Mattress reviews still help online shoppers within that region, because the same models and policies appear on the website and in stores. People outside that service area may have limited access to direct delivery from Croft. 

2. Which Croft mattress is best for a strict side sleeper with shoulder pain?
From the perspective of pressure relief, Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush clearly outperformed the firmer models. Mia’s shoulders relaxed more deeply into those surfaces, and my side-sleeping tests confirmed that kind of contour. Between them, Barclay Plush offered the deepest hug, while Waverly Plush balanced plushness and budget.

3. How do Croft mattresses handle motion transfer for couples?
Oliver behaves like a classic innerspring, where movement travels easily through the coils. Mercer Firm improves things with pocketed coils, yet Jenna still noticed some bounce from Ethan’s movements. Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush handled motion best, letting Ethan roll and get up while Jenna stayed mostly undisturbed, especially on Barclay Plush.

4. Do Croft mattresses sleep hot for heavier people?
Heat varies across the line. Oliver and Mercer Firm stayed relatively neutral due to their coil cores and simpler quilts. Waverly Plush and the Barclay models add more foam, yet the silver lining fabrics and breathable designs kept Marcus inside his comfort zone. He still found Barclay Firm and Waverly Plush cooler than many dense memory foam beds he has tried. 

5. How long do Croft mattresses typically last?
Durability depends on model and body weight. Oliver feels tuned for lighter sleepers, kids, or guest rooms, with more modest long-term expectations. Mercer Firm, Waverly Plush, and the Barclay models use stronger coil units and higher-grade foams, aligning with Croft’s warranty structure that covers qualifying body impressions over multi-year spans. Heavier sleepers will squeeze more life from Barclay Firm or Barclay Plush. 

6. Can Croft adjust a mattress if the firmness feels wrong?
Yes. The Perfect Fit Guarantee allows adjustments after the first 30 nights and within a defined window afterward. Under those circumstances, Croft can modify comfort layers or otherwise tailor the mattress, often instead of swapping it outright. Customers may owe certain fees, yet the intent focuses on dialing in feel rather than leaving buyers stuck. 

7. Which Croft mattress works best for a heavier stomach sleeper?
During our tests, Barclay Firm clearly matched that profile. Marcus, who sleeps hot and rotates through stomach periods, found his hips stayed elevated and his chest felt open. Mercer Firm also functioned for lighter stomach sleepers, yet Barclay Firm delivered a more decisive lift for larger frames.

8. Is the entry-level Croft Oliver worth considering over a big-box mattress?
Oliver does not try to imitate a luxury hybrid. Instead, it behaves like a solid, budget innerspring with some Croft build quality and local service behind it. For guest rooms, kids, and budget setups, its springy support and strong value score kept it in our recommended list, with clear expectations around pressure relief limitations and motion transfer.

9. Should I pick Waverly Plush or Barclay Plush if I want one do-everything mattress?
From the perspective of balance, Waverly Plush hits that all-rounder role for many households, blending plush comfort with strong support at a mid-upper price. Barclay Plush pushes deeper into premium territory, with more pressure relief and better couple performance, matching sleepers who can justify the higher budget and want that step up in refinement.

10. How do Croft warranties and returns compare to big online brands?
Croft’s system feels more old-school. The company focuses on in-person support, adjustments, and a defined warranty with body impression thresholds, instead of long, free-return sleep trials. People who prefer local service and adjustment options may like that approach, while those who expect year-long, no-cost returns need to recalibrate expectations for this regional maker.

Related Post

Croft Mattress Review

Slumber Castle Mattress Review

Serweet Mattress Review

Tuft and Needle Mattress Review

Stephanie Mattress Reviews

CIUANCE Mattress Review

Seventable Mattress Reviews

Ethical Mattress Reviews

Lynnbery Mattress Reviews

Simmons Mattress Reviews

Sleepyhead Mattress Review

LIYIH Mattress Review

Ikasa Mattress Reviews