Croft Mattress Reviews (2026)

Croft sells more than these four models, but they’re the ones we tested. At the time of our check, their starting prices were listed at $399.99 (Oliver), $599.99 (Mercer Firm), $899.99 (Waverly Plush), and $1,299.99 (Barclay Hybrid).

Oliver

Best for

• Guest rooms

• Kids and teens

• Budget back sleepers

Not ideal for

• Strict side sleepers

• Motion-sensitive couples

• Heavier full-time pairs

Mercer Firm

Best for

• Back sleepers

• Stomach sleepers

• Firm-feel fans

Not ideal for

• Petite side sleepers

• Plush-bed shoppers

• Deep-cushion seekers

Waverly Plush

Best for

• Side sleepers

• Softer-feel couples

• Flexible guest rooms

Not ideal for

• Firm-only sleepers

• Heavy stomach sleepers

• Edge-perchers

Barclay Hybrid

Best for

• Combo sleepers

• Couples

• Upgrade shoppers

Not ideal for

• Lowest-budget buyers

• Extra-firm loyalists

• All-foam die-hards

Across the four models we tested, Croft keeps the core recipe consistent: pocketed coils, a quilted cover with its Silver Living silver-fiber layer, and CertiPUR-US foams. Sizes go beyond the usual lineup, including Split King and Flex Head options, plus Ozark King and Grand Ozark King. Croft also markets these mattresses as formaldehyde- and fiberglass-free. Mattresses are final sale, but the Perfect Fit Guarantee allows comfort adjustments between nights 31 and 60.

We slept on each mattress for regular overnight use, then repeated the same checks with Marcus Reed, Carlos Alvarez, and Mia Chen to see how the feel changed across body types and sleep styles. We scored support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability using alignment checks, 30–60 minute heat checks, slow-turn tests, edge sitting, and repeated-use notes. Dr. Adrian Walker reviewed our notes and pushed us to separate “firm feel” from true alignment support.

Our Testing Experience

In our testing, Oliver felt like the simplest bed in the group. It stayed fairly flat when we rolled around and didn’t “grab” at the shoulders, so changing positions was easy. Carlos liked the even back support, but he noticed it felt more basic through the middle than Mercer Firm. Mia ran out of cushioning first on her side—after a longer stretch, her shoulder and outer hip wanted more give. The edge worked for a quick sit, but it compressed more than the higher-priced models. Overall, it read as a practical guest-room or kids’ mattress, not a plush comfort upgrade.

What we liked

• Low entry price

• Easy to change positions

• Neutral enough for short-stay use

Who it is best for

• Guest bedrooms

• Kids and teens

• Budget back sleepers

Where it falls short

• Limited shoulder cushioning

• More motion transfer

• Softer edge feel

Details

• Starting price: From $399.99.

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress.

• Surface feel: Medium quilted top.

• Available sizes: standard sizes plus Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King.

Our Testing Experience

Mercer Firm immediately felt flatter and more “hotel-firm” than Oliver. On my back, the firmer quilted top kept my hips from dipping, which is usually what my lower back wants after long desk days. Carlos liked how evenly his shoulders and hips stayed lined up, and Marcus preferred how the surface held him up without a mild hammock feel. Mia was the clear outlier—on her side, the top pushed back early and she rotated more often. This is the pick for sleepers who want the surface to keep them on top, not sink around them.

What we liked

• Flatter lumbar support

• Fast, stable movement

• Better edge confidence

Who it is best for

• Back sleepers

• Stomach sleepers

• Firm-feel shoppers

Where it falls short

• Too rigid for many side sleepers

• Less plush comfort

• Motion control is only average

Details

• Starting price: From $599.99.

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress.

• Surface feel: Firm quilted top.

• Available sizes: standard sizes plus Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King.

Our Testing Experience

Waverly Plush was the first model that let Mia stay on one side longer without constant readjusting. Her shoulder settled in more easily, and the top had enough give to take the edge off pressure buildup. I felt the same improvement on my side compared with Oliver and Mercer Firm. Carlos still found steady support underneath, though he said the plusher top blurred the surface feel a bit. Marcus found it comfortable but less ideal for long stomach-sleep stretches or frequent edge sitting. If you want a softer landing without a “mushy” feel, this was the easiest crowd-pleaser.

What we liked

• Better shoulder and hip relief

• Softer, more welcoming top

• More couple-friendly feel

Who it is best for

• Side sleepers

• Softer-feel couples

• Flexible guest rooms

Where it falls short

• More sink under hips

• Edge feels softer than firmer beds

• Turns are not as crisp

Details

• Starting price: From $899.99.

• Type: Pocketed-coil mattress.

• Surface feel: Soft quilted top.

• Available sizes: standard sizes plus Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King.

Our Testing Experience

Barclay Hybrid felt like the point where the lineup became more polished. In our tests, the cushioning ran deeper, but the surface still turned easily instead of feeling sticky. Carlos liked the cleaner handoff from the comfort layer into the support core, and Marcus stayed more level through the hips here than on Waverly Plush. Mia still got enough shoulder give, which was the key check for side sleeping. It was the most consistently balanced option across different sleepers.

What we liked

• Best support/comfort balance

• Deeper pressure relief

• Strongest motion control in the set

Who it is best for

• Combo sleepers

• Couples

• Upgrade shoppers

Where it falls short

• Costs more than the others

• Not extra-firm

• Still not all-foam quiet

Details

• Starting price: From $1,299.99.

• Type: Hybrid mattress.

• Surface feel: Serene memory foam over pocketed coils.

• Available sizes: standard sizes plus Split King, Flex Head Queen/King, Ozark King, and Grand Ozark King.

The scores matched our nights on the beds. Barclay Hybrid was the most even performer, without a clear weak spot. Waverly Plush led the group on pressure relief, especially for side sleeping. Mercer Firm was the specialist pick for firm support and quick movement, while Oliver was the straightforward budget option.

Start with sleep position and how much pushback you like. Mercer Firm is the firmest, most “on top” feel of the four, so it fits most back and stomach sleepers. Waverly Plush is the easiest match for side sleepers who need more shoulder and hip give. Barclay Hybrid is the safest all-around pick for mixed positions and couples, with deeper cushioning and calmer motion. Oliver makes the most sense for guest-room duty, kids’ rooms, or budgets where simple support matters more than plush comfort.

Why choose one of these models

• Locally made, factory-built mattresses with uncommon size choices.

• A clear step-up path from basic coil beds to a more cushioned hybrid.

• Silver-fiber cover and CertiPUR-US foams, with the brand listing these as formaldehyde- and fiberglass-free.

Alternatives to consider

• Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: a widely available online value hybrid with an optional cooling upgrade.

• Saatva Classic: stronger service perks with white-glove delivery, a long trial period, and a lifetime warranty.

• Helix Midnight Luxe: more dialed-in for side sleepers, with zoned lumbar support and cooling-cover options.

• For a guest room you’re buying sight-unseen, Oliver or Mercer Firm usually makes more sense than paying for the premium hybrid.

• If shoulder or outer-hip pressure is your recurring issue, skip Oliver and Mercer Firm and start with Waverly Plush or Barclay Hybrid.

• If you sleep hot, don’t default to the softest option—firmer, less sink-heavy surfaces tended to do better in our testing.

• Give the mattress a real break-in period. Croft says soreness can happen in the first 30 nights, and the Perfect Fit window starts after that.

• If you may use the Perfect Fit program, plan for transportation costs—Croft notes it isn’t included.

• Rotate the mattress every 1–2 months and use a supportive base to help avoid wear issues.

• Use a mattress protector right away; Croft notes stains can void the warranty.

It can work for a solo budget sleeper, but we liked it most for guest rooms, kids, and lighter-use spaces where simple support is enough and pressure relief doesn’t have to be plush.

In our tests, Waverly Plush gave the easiest shoulder and hip relief. Barclay Hybrid was the better second choice if you still want steadier support underneath.

Mercer Firm delivered the flattest, most “hotel-firm” support in our lineup. Barclay Hybrid was close, but with more cushioning on top.

Barclay Hybrid was the strongest couple pick here thanks to calmer motion and balanced feel. Waverly Plush came next if both sleepers prefer a softer landing.