Mattress shopping usually comes down to one simple question: does your body feel supported for a full night? To answer that, our team rotated five Croft mattresses through real bedrooms and logged what happened after the novelty wore off.
We focused on alignment, pressure relief, temperature, motion transfer, and edge stability. The notes below reflect how different bodies and sleep styles reacted to the same lineup, not a quick showroom impression.
Product Overview
| Mattress | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price (approx.) | Overall Score |
| Croft Oliver | Low entry price, responsive surface, easy to change positions | Light cushioning for shoulders, more partner movement than premium models | Kids, guest rooms, budget back sleepers | From about $399 (size dependent) | 3.8 / 5 |
| Croft Mercer Firm | Very even support, firm “hotel” feel, stable edges for most sleepers | Can feel rigid for side sleepers, not a cool-to-the-touch surface | Back and stomach sleepers, rentals, firmer-feel fans | From about $600+ (size dependent) | 4.1 / 5 |
| Croft Waverly Plush | Noticeably softer top, stronger pressure relief, good blend of contour and bounce | May feel soft for heavier stomach sleepers, higher price tier | Side sleepers, combo sleepers, couples wanting comfort without “stuck” feel | From about $899 (size dependent) | 4.3 / 5 |
| Croft Barclay Firm | Most supportive feel in this group, excellent edge stability, strong durability outlook | Too firm for many lighter side sleepers, premium price | Heavier bodies, back/stomach sleepers, people who prefer a firm platform | From about $1,299 (size dependent) | 4.4 / 5 |
| Croft Barclay Plush | Deepest cushioning in the lineup, best motion control for couples | Premium price, still more “supported plush” than ultra-soft | Side sleepers and couples who want a quieter surface | From about $1,299 (size dependent) | 4.4 / 5 |
Testing Team Takeaways
Across the lineup, the biggest separator was how much the comfort layers let shoulders and hips sink before the coil support pushed back. The Barclay Firm held me the most level when I moved from back to side, but it also made it clear that lighter side sleepers may want more surface give.
Mia (lighter, strict side sleeper) consistently gravitated toward Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush. Both took pressure off her shoulders without letting her hips drift downward. Mercer Firm worked well for back and stomach sleepers, but most side sleepers in our rotation described it as “too straight” after longer stretches.
For couples, the pattern was straightforward: Oliver transferred the most motion, Mercer Firm improved it, and Waverly Plush plus Barclay Plush stayed the calmest when a partner got up or turned over. Marcus (heavier and heat-sensitive) also rated the Waverly and Barclay covers as the most comfortable overnight, with fewer warm spots than the simpler builds.
Croft Mattress Comparison Chart
| Mattress | Type | Firmness (our take) | Available Sizes | Materials / Construction | Cooling Features | Support System | Pressure Relief Feel | Responsiveness | Motion Isolation | Durability Outlook |
| Croft Oliver | Pocketed-coil mattress with a quilted top | Medium to medium-firm | Common sizes | Quilted foams over pocketed coils | Coil airflow + silver-fiber lining | Pocketed coils | Light contour, mostly “on top” | Very quick, lively | Fair; partners feel bigger shifts | Best for lighter use and guest rooms |
| Croft Mercer Firm | Firm pocketed-coil | Firm | Wide size list | Firm quilt and foams over pocketed coils | Coil airflow + silver-fiber lining | Pocketed coils | Moderate cushion, flatter feel | Quick and easy to move | Good; some bounce remains | Strong everyday value |
| Croft Waverly Plush | Plush pocketed-coil | Medium-plush | Standard sizes | Softer quilt and foams over pocketed coils | Coil airflow + silver-fiber lining | Pocketed coils | Deeper shoulder/hip relief | Balanced; plush but not slow | Very good for couples | Solid long-term outlook |
| Croft Barclay Firm | Premium firm hybrid | Firm-plus | Standard sizes | Firmer comfort package over pocketed coils | Breathable build + silver-fiber lining | Pocketed coils | Lift-forward, limited shoulder sink | Fast, strong push-back | Good; responsive but controlled | Best for heavier nightly use |
| Croft Barclay Plush | Premium plush hybrid | Medium-plush | Standard sizes | Thicker comfort layers over pocketed coils | Breathable build + silver-fiber lining | Pocketed coils | Deepest cradle in the group | Responsive for a plush bed | Excellent; quietest surface here | Premium materials, strong core |
What We Tested And How We Tested It
Each Croft mattress spent multiple nights as a real bed, not a short trial. We rotated them through two primary bedrooms and a guest room, kept the rooms at normal home temperatures, and tracked wake-ups, position changes, and how we felt in the morning.
For support, we watched spinal alignment on the back and side and paid attention to hip drop, lower-back gap, and whether the midsection felt “hammocked.” For pressure relief, our side sleepers stayed put longer and noted shoulder and outer-hip pressure as it built over time.
Motion and edge performance came from shared-bed nights plus simple impact tests. Cooling was judged by overnight heat build-up and whether the surface felt clammy or neutral under the same bedding.
We scored the lineup using the same set of categories shown in the tables: support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, responsiveness, durability, and value.
Croft Mattress: Our Testing Experience
Croft Oliver Mattress Review
Our Testing Experience
Oliver is the clear budget entry in this lineup. On my back, it felt steady and responsive, with my hips held up without much sink. On my side, the surface stayed firmer, so my shoulder didn’t settle as easily as it did on the plusher models.
Marcus pushed it harder. Under his heavier frame, he noticed more dip through the middle and preferred it for shorter stretches rather than full nights. Motion was also easier to feel here, especially when another person sat down or got up on the opposite side.
Cooling stayed reasonable for a basic build. The mattress didn’t trap heat aggressively, but it also didn’t have the “cooler than expected” feel we saw on the higher-tier options.
Who it fits best: guest rooms, kids, lighter sleepers, and anyone who wants a straightforward, responsive mattress with simple trade-offs in pressure relief and motion control.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Accessible price point | Shoulders and hips may want more cushion |
| Responsive feel for easy repositioning | More noticeable partner movement |
| Neutral temperature for most sleepers | Edges feel less secure for heavier bodies |
| Simple fit for guest rooms and kids | Less refined feel than the premium models |
Details
- Price: Starts around $399 for smaller sizes; varies by current listings
- Firmness: Medium to medium-firm in our testing (firmer for side sleepers)
- Type: Pocketed-coil mattress with a quilted top
- Available sizes: Common sizes in Croft’s lineup
- Support core: Pocketed coils
- Comfort layers: Quilted foams; modest contour depth
- Cooling: Airflow from coils; surface stayed generally neutral
- Pressure relief: Better for back than strict side sleeping
- Trial / adjustment: Perfect Fit adjustments may be available after the initial break-in window
- Warranty: Covered under Croft’s warranty terms (details vary by product)
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 3.6 | Fine for average builds; dips for heavier sleepers. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.2 | Firm on shoulders; better on the back. |
| Cooling | 3.9 | Mostly neutral in our nights. |
| Motion Isolation | 3.1 | Partners notice bigger movements. |
| Edge Support | 3.4 | Okay seated; less confidence for heavy bodies. |
| Responsiveness | 4.6 | Easy to move; quick rebound. |
| Durability | 3.4 | Best suited to lighter use. |
| Value | 4.8 | Strong price-to-performance at entry level. |
| Overall | 3.8 | Budget-friendly with clear trade-offs. |
Croft Mercer Firm Mattress Review
Our Testing Experience
Mercer Firm is where the lineup starts to feel more “daily-driver” than occasional-use. Lying on my back, the surface stayed flat and supportive, with no obvious sag through the middle. Carlos, who tends to feel mid-back fatigue when support is lacking, reported consistently steady alignment over a full week.
For side sleeping, it’s a firmer bet. Marcus could tolerate it on his side for a while, but he did not choose it for long, shoulder-heavy stretches. Motion was improved versus Oliver, though you still feel some bounce when a partner moves decisively.
Temperature stayed “neutral,” not actively cool. The mattress didn’t create obvious hot spots, but our heat-sensitive tester still preferred the Waverly and Barclay surfaces.
Who it fits best: back and stomach sleepers who like a firm, structured feel, plus guest suites or rentals that need support first and softness second.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Firm, even support for backs and stomachs | Often too firm for strict side sleepers |
| Less motion than a basic innerspring feel | Some bounce still reaches partners |
| More stable edges than the entry model | Not a “plush” comfort experience |
| Strong value within the lineup | Cooling is neutral rather than actively cool |
Details
- Price: Listed from around $600+ depending on size
- Firmness: Firm, with minimal sink
- Type: Pocketed-coil mattress with firmer comfort layers
- Available sizes: Wide size range in Croft’s catalog
- Support core: Pocketed coils
- Comfort layers: Firm foams tuned for a flatter feel
- Cooling: Mostly neutral overnight
- Pressure relief: Better for backs/hips than shoulders
- Trial / adjustment: Perfect Fit adjustments may be available after the initial break-in window
- Warranty: Covered under Croft’s warranty terms (details vary by product)
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.4 | Excellent for back and stomach alignment. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.6 | Firm shoulder feel for side sleepers. |
| Cooling | 3.8 | Neutral; minor warmth for hot sleepers. |
| Motion Isolation | 3.4 | Better than entry level; still bouncy. |
| Edge Support | 4.5 | Confident edge sitting and sleeping. |
| Responsiveness | 4.5 | Easy repositioning. |
| Durability | 4.2 | Feels rental-ready and sturdy. |
| Value | 4.4 | Strong performance for the price tier. |
| Overall | 4.1 | Firm, supportive, value-focused option. |
Croft Waverly Plush Mattress Review
Our Testing Experience
Waverly Plush is where the lineup starts to feel “comfort-first” without drifting into slow, sinky foam. The top has more give, so my shoulder eased in more naturally on my side. Underneath, the coil support kept my hips from sliding downward, which is the point where many softer mattresses fail.
Mia’s side-sleeping sessions were the clearest signal. She stayed comfortable longer here than on the firm models and didn’t report the “pinned shoulder” sensation she gets on flatter surfaces. Carlos also liked that he could switch positions without feeling trapped.
For couples, it struck a useful middle ground: calmer than Oliver, more forgiving than Mercer, but still responsive enough to roll over easily. Marcus expected a plush bed to run hot and rated it closer to neutral than he anticipated.
Who it fits best: side sleepers, combination sleepers, and couples who want contour without giving up mobility.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Very good shoulder and hip comfort | Can be soft under the pelvis for some stomach sleepers |
| Support stays steady under changing positions | Costs more than the firmer entry models |
| Good couple performance without dead feel | Heavier mattress to maneuver once placed |
| Comfort-forward feel without “stuck” sensation | Not for people who want a very firm surface |
Details
- Price: Starts around $899 depending on size
- Firmness: Medium-plush
- Type: Plush pocketed-coil mattress
- Available sizes: Standard mattress sizes
- Support core: Pocketed coils
- Comfort layers: Softer quilt and foam layers for deeper contour
- Cooling: Neutral-to-cooler feel than thicker foam designs
- Pressure relief: Strong for shoulders and hips
- Trial / adjustment: Perfect Fit adjustments may be available after the initial break-in window
- Warranty: Covered under Croft’s warranty terms (details vary by product)
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.3 | Hips stayed level for most testers. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.7 | Best shoulder comfort short of Barclay Plush. |
| Cooling | 4.2 | Generally neutral for hot sleepers. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.3 | Partners feel muted movement. |
| Edge Support | 4.2 | Secure enough for edge sleeping. |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 | Plush, but still easy to turn. |
| Durability | 4.3 | Solid build for long use. |
| Value | 4.2 | Pricing matches performance tier. |
| Overall | 4.3 | Balanced plush option with standout pressure relief. |
Croft Barclay Firm Mattress Review
Our Testing Experience
Barclay Firm was the most support-forward mattress we tested in this Croft set. On my back, it kept my lower back lifted without feeling like a bare board. The bed has a decisive push-back that makes alignment easy to feel when you roll between positions.
Marcus finally stopped hunting for hip support here. He could stay on his stomach longer without feeling his pelvis dip, which is usually his deal-breaker on softer beds. Jamal also rated the edges as extremely stable for sitting, stretching, and sleeping near the perimeter.
Motion control landed in a useful middle ground. It isn’t dead quiet like some memory foam mattresses, but partner movement stayed contained enough that it didn’t feel disruptive in our shared-bed checks. Cooling also ranked near the top in this lineup for Marcus.
Who it fits best: heavier back and stomach sleepers, taller athletic builds, and anyone who wants firmness for alignment and durability.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Standout support for heavier sleepers | Often too firm for petite side sleepers |
| Very stable edges for full-width use | Less cushy first contact than the plush version |
| Strong durability outlook | Premium price may be out of reach |
| Responsive feel with good motion control | Not the right fit for “soft bed” fans |
Details
- Price: Starts around $1,299 depending on size
- Firmness: Firm-plus
- Type: Premium hybrid with pocketed coils
- Available sizes: Standard mattress sizes
- Support core: Pocketed coils
- Comfort layers: Firmer comfort foams for lift and alignment
- Cooling: Ranked near the top for our hot sleeper
- Pressure relief: Better for backs/stomachs than shoulders
- Trial / adjustment: Perfect Fit adjustments may be available after the initial break-in window
- Warranty: Covered under Croft’s warranty terms (details vary by product)
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.8 | Best lift and alignment in the group. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.8 | Firm shoulder contour for side sleeping. |
| Cooling | 4.3 | Stayed closer to neutral overnight. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.2 | Controlled movement with some rebound. |
| Edge Support | 4.7 | Rock-solid perimeter. |
| Responsiveness | 4.6 | Fast, supportive turning. |
| Durability | 4.7 | Feels built for heavy nightly use. |
| Value | 4.0 | Premium performance at premium pricing. |
| Overall | 4.4 | Support-first pick for heavier sleepers. |
Croft Barclay Plush Mattress Review
Our Testing Experience
Barclay Plush keeps the same “serious support” feeling under the surface, but it adds more cushioning on top. On my side, my shoulder settled in more comfortably than it did on Barclay Firm, while the midsection still felt supported rather than saggy.
Jenna and Ethan essentially treated it like their bed for the test window. The consistent feedback was that movement stayed in its lane: turning and getting up felt muted compared with Oliver and even compared with Mercer Firm. Mia also ranked it as the most comfortable side-sleeper surface in the group.
Cooling was slightly warmer than Barclay Firm but still acceptable for our heat-sensitive tester, especially compared with dense foam designs. Edge stability remained strong, which mattered for couples using the full width.
Who it fits best: side sleepers and couples who want a quieter, more pressure-relieving feel without losing support.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Best pressure relief in the lineup | Premium price compared with Oliver/Mercer |
| Excellent motion isolation for couples | Runs slightly warmer than Barclay Firm |
| Strong edges for full-width use | Too soft for some extra-firm fans |
| Plush feel that still stays aligned | Heavy to move once installed |
Details
- Price: Starts around $1,299 depending on size
- Firmness: Medium-plush
- Type: Premium plush hybrid with pocketed coils
- Available sizes: Standard mattress sizes
- Support core: Pocketed coils
- Comfort layers: Thicker cushioning for deeper pressure relief
- Cooling: Slightly warmer than the firm version, still manageable
- Pressure relief: Highest in this lineup, especially for shoulders
- Trial / adjustment: Perfect Fit adjustments may be available after the initial break-in window
- Warranty: Covered under Croft’s warranty terms (details vary by product)
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.5 | Supportive core under a softer top. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.8 | Deep, controlled cradle. |
| Cooling | 4.1 | Slight warmth; still comfortable. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.6 | Quietest feel for couples here. |
| Edge Support | 4.4 | Stable perimeter for shared use. |
| Responsiveness | 4.3 | Turns easily for a plush bed. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Premium build with strong core. |
| Value | 4.1 | Best fit for those who want premium plush. |
| Overall | 4.4 | Best all-around for couples and side sleepers. |
Compare Performance Scores Of These Mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness |
| Croft Oliver | 3.8 | 3.6 | 3.2 | 3.9 | 3.1 | 3.4 | 4.6 |
| Croft Mercer Firm | 4.1 | 4.4 | 3.6 | 3.8 | 3.4 | 4.2 | 4.5 |
| Croft Waverly Plush | 4.3 | 4.3 | 4.7 | 4.2 | 4.3 | 4.3 | 4.4 |
| Croft Barclay Firm | 4.4 | 4.8 | 3.8 | 4.3 | 4.2 | 4.7 | 4.6 |
| Croft Barclay Plush | 4.4 | 4.5 | 4.8 | 4.1 | 4.6 | 4.6 | 4.3 |
In practical terms, the lineup splits cleanly. Oliver is the budget utility pick, Mercer Firm is the structured “firm hotel feel” value, Waverly Plush is the comfort-balanced option, and the two Barclay models are the premium step—Firm for maximum support and Plush for the most pressure relief and couple-friendly calm.
Best Picks
Best overall: Croft Barclay Plush. It delivered the strongest mix of pressure relief, motion control, and stable support across our side sleepers and couple testing.
Best for heavy sleepers: Croft Barclay Firm. If your priority is pelvic lift, edge stability, and a firm platform that stays aligned night after night, this was the clearest match.
Best value: Croft Mercer Firm. It gives a firm, structured feel with strong overall support, without the premium jump into the Barclay tier.
How To Choose The Croft Mattress?
Start with two levers: sleep position and body weight. Those two factors determine whether you need more surface cushioning or more push-back under the hips and lower back.
- Side sleepers: Prioritize pressure relief. Waverly Plush or Barclay Plush made the biggest difference for shoulders.
- Back sleepers: Look for even support. Mercer Firm, Waverly Plush, and Barclay Firm can all work depending on how firm you like it.
- Stomach sleepers: Favor firmness and lift. Mercer Firm works for many; Barclay Firm is the safer bet for heavier bodies.
- Couples: Put motion isolation and edge stability higher on the list. Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush were the calmest in our shared-bed checks.
- Budget setups: Oliver fits guest rooms and kids well, as long as you’re realistic about its lighter pressure relief and higher motion transfer.
Limitations
If you want an extremely soft, “marshmallow” surface, this lineup stays on the supportive side—even the Plush models aim for controlled sink rather than deep collapse.
On the other end, people who want an ultra-unyielding feel may still find Mercer Firm and Barclay Firm too forgiving compared with truly extra-firm options.
Policies At A Glance
| Mattress | Shipping (cost and region) | Trial Period | Return Policy / Fees | Warranty Length | Notable Conditions |
| Croft Oliver | Regional delivery options; costs vary by location and setup | Comfort break-in required before adjustments | Mattresses/foundations are final sale; comfort changes handled through adjustments | Varies by product line | Foundation requirements and care rules apply |
| Croft Mercer Firm | Regional delivery options; costs vary by location and setup | Comfort break-in required before adjustments | Mattresses/foundations are final sale; comfort changes handled through adjustments | Varies by product line | Foundation requirements and care rules apply |
| Croft Waverly Plush | Regional delivery options; costs vary by location and setup | Comfort break-in required before adjustments | Mattresses/foundations are final sale; comfort changes handled through adjustments | Varies by product line | Foundation requirements and care rules apply |
| Croft Barclay Firm | Regional delivery options; costs vary by location and setup | Comfort break-in required before adjustments | Mattresses/foundations are final sale; comfort changes handled through adjustments | Varies by product line | Foundation requirements and care rules apply |
| Croft Barclay Plush | Regional delivery options; costs vary by location and setup | Comfort break-in required before adjustments | Mattresses/foundations are final sale; comfort changes handled through adjustments | Varies by product line | Foundation requirements and care rules apply |
The biggest thing to understand is that Croft leans into fitting and factory adjustments rather than long, no-questions-asked trial returns. If you like the idea of dialing in feel through a defined adjustment window, this approach can make sense. If you require a generous return period, it may feel restrictive.
FAQs
Are Croft mattresses only sold locally, or can these reviews help online buyers too?
Croft is set up as a local and regional retailer. These reviews are most relevant if you live inside their delivery footprint or can shop in person.
Which Croft mattress is best for a strict side sleeper with shoulder pain?
Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush were the clearest wins for our side sleepers. Barclay Plush had the deepest shoulder-friendly cushioning, while Waverly Plush balanced comfort and budget.
How do Croft mattresses handle motion transfer for couples?
Oliver carried the most motion. Mercer Firm improved it. Waverly Plush and Barclay Plush were the most couple-friendly in our shared-bed nights.
Do Croft mattresses sleep hot for heavier people?
It depended on the model. Marcus rated Waverly Plush and the Barclay models as the most comfortable overnight, while the simpler builds felt more “neutral” than cool.
How long do Croft mattresses typically last?
Durability will track with build and body weight. In our tests, the Barclay models felt the most robust for heavier nightly use, while Oliver was the clear “guest room and lighter-use” pick.
Can Croft adjust a mattress if the firmness feels wrong?
Yes. The Perfect Fit program is designed for comfort tweaks after the break-in period and within a defined window. Details and any fees depend on the type of change.
Which Croft mattress works best for a heavier stomach sleeper?
Barclay Firm was the most consistent choice for keeping hips lifted. Mercer Firm can work for some stomach sleepers, but Barclay Firm handled heavier bodies more confidently.
Is the entry-level Croft Oliver worth considering over a big-box mattress?
If you want a straightforward, responsive bed for a guest room or a kid’s room, Oliver is worth considering. Just expect less pressure relief and more noticeable motion than the premium models.
Should I pick Waverly Plush or Barclay Plush for a one-mattress household?
Waverly Plush is the more balanced pick for many homes. Barclay Plush is the upgrade if you want stronger pressure relief and better couple performance and can justify the higher price tier.
How do Croft warranties and returns compare to big online brands?
Croft leans more traditional: final sale on mattresses with defined warranty coverage and a separate adjustment program, rather than long free-return trials.
