Beauty Sleep Mattress Reviews (2026)

Across testing, I tracked lumbar support and hip alignment. Marcus paid attention to heat management and early sag, Mia focused on shoulder/hip pressure, and Jamal looked for bounce and how easy it was to change positions.

The Dream Weaver Hybrid Medium was the most balanced option. The Dream Weaver Firm felt the most stable and supportive. The Ultra Plush Pillow Top did the best job relieving pressure but can drift too soft for stomach sleeping. The Soothing Nights 10” was the value pick, with the most noticeable trade-offs at the edges and in motion transfer.

All four models come with a 100-night in-home trial and a 10-year limited warranty. The main difference is delivery: Soothing Nights ships as a mattress-in-a-box, while Dream Weaver models arrive via scheduled delivery (with a White Glove upgrade available).

We rotated nights across all four beds and kept the same bedding and foundation so the differences came from the mattresses, not the setup. Each model was scored on support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability using repeatable routines—edge sitting, partner-movement checks, slow rollovers, and next-morning alignment notes. We also watched for break-in changes and whether the surface stayed steady for reading or laptop time.

Our testing experience

Right away, this one felt like a traditional mattress: a quilted top, quick bounce from the coils, and no learning curve. I could sit up to read without feeling like I was sliding toward the middle, and my lower back stayed comfortable as long as I didn’t spend much time near the edge. Marcus was pleasantly surprised that it didn’t trap much heat for a value bed, but he also noticed the perimeter dip when he sat down to tie his shoes. Mia could side-sleep on it, though she said her shoulder started to notice the firmer surface during longer stretches.

What we liked

• Straightforward medium feel that’s easy to adjust to

• Quick, springy response when changing positions

• Better temperature neutrality than many budget beds

Who it is best for

• Guest rooms and secondary bedrooms

• Budget shoppers who still want a coil feel

• Back and combo sleepers who like a traditional surface

Where it falls short

• Edges compress more than the Dream Weaver models

• Partner motion is noticeable compared with plusher tops

• Side sleepers who need deep cushioning may want more comfort layers

Pros & cons

Details

• Price: $399.00–$799.00

• Firmness feel: Medium

• Thickness: 10"

• Construction: Quilted coil mattress-in-a-box with pocketed coils

• Support system: 8" Original Beautyrest pocketed coils

• Cooling: AirCool Foam

• Comfort/pressure relief: Comfort Foam

• Delivery: Ships compressed in a box; most orders arrive in about 1 week via FedEx Ground; allow 24–48 hours to fully expand

• Trial: 100-night in-home trial

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Review score

Our testing experience

If you want one Beauty Sleep bed that doesn’t ask you to compromise much, this was it. It has more cushioning than the Soothing Nights, but it didn’t let my hips sink when I slept on my back. On side nights, the top layers took pressure off my shoulder better, and my lower back stayed relaxed with a standard pillow height. Marcus described the support as a steady push back that kept him from feeling hammocked. Jamal liked how easy it was to turn—there’s enough foam to soften the surface, but the coils help you reset instead of getting stuck.

What we liked

• Most balanced mix of contouring and support

• Easy turning and a stable surface for lounging

• Better pressure relief than the quilted models

Who it is best for

• Combination sleepers who rotate between back and side

• Couples who want medium comfort with decent motion control

• Anyone who wants support without a board-like feel

Where it falls short

• Motion isolation improves, but it isn’t premium-level

• Edge support is solid, not a sit-anywhere edge

• Very pressure-sensitive side sleepers may still want more cushion

Pros & cons

Details

• Price: $699.00–$1,099.00

• Firmness feel: Medium

• Thickness: 11.5"

• Construction: Hybrid with pocketed coils and gel foams

• Support system: Firm 815 Original Beautyrest pocketed coils

• Pressure relief: AllCool Gel Memory Foam (added vs quilted models)

• Cooling: AllCool Gel Foam (added vs quilted models)

• Delivery: Standard scheduled delivery; typical arrival 2–3 weeks; White Glove upgrade available

• Trial: 100-night in-home trial

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

• Sizes shown: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Review score

Our testing experience

This mattress felt firm right away, but it wasn’t punishing. The quilted top is thin, so you notice the support system quickly—which is the point of this model. On my back, my hips stayed level and I woke up without the twisted feeling softer beds can create. Marcus was most comfortable here; he could drift onto his stomach without his midsection sagging. The downside showed up for Mia: she could side-sleep, but she kept repositioning to keep shoulder pressure from building. Jamal appreciated the quick, steady pushback when he changed positions.

What we liked

• Strongest support and most stable surface in the lineup

• Fast response when changing positions

• More secure edge feel than Soothing Nights

Who it is best for

• Back and stomach sleepers

• Heavier bodies who want less sink

• Anyone who prefers a firm, supportive surface

Where it falls short

• Side sleepers may want more cushioning at shoulders and hips

• Motion isolation is average for a coil-forward build

• Firm feel can be too rigid for lightweight sleepers

Pros & cons

Details

• Price: $599.00–$999.00

• Firmness feel: Firm

• Thickness: 12.5"

• Construction: Quilted innerspring with pocketed coils

• Support system: Firm 815 Original Beautyrest pocketed coils

• Pressure relief: AllCool Gel Foam

• Cooling: AirCool Foam

• Delivery: Standard scheduled delivery; typical arrival 2–3 weeks; White Glove upgrade available

• Trial: 100-night in-home trial

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

• Sizes shown: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Review score

Our testing experience

This was the softest surface in the group—the pillow top is the first thing you notice. It’s a gentle landing that takes the edge off sore shoulders and hips, and Mia felt that difference immediately on her side. Marcus liked the comfort but could feel his hips settling deeper, so he treated it as a check-your-alignment bed, especially if you carry more weight in your midsection. For me, it worked best when I started on my side and finished on my back; a small pillow tweak helped keep my neck neutral. Jamal’s note: it’s comfortable, but the surface is slower to spring back after a quick rollover.

What we liked

• Best pressure relief and plush comfort

• Forgiving surface for shoulders and hips

• Less “jolt” from partner movement than the quilted models

Who it is best for

• Side sleepers who want a cushioned pillow top

• People who prioritize comfort layers over firmness

• Lighter-weight sleepers who find “medium” too firm

Where it falls short

• Can feel too soft for stomach sleeping or heavier midsections

• Slower to bounce back when you switch positions

• May not feel as locked-in as the Firm on spinal alignment

Pros & cons

Details

• Price: $699.00–$1,099.00

• Firmness feel: Ultra Plush

• Thickness: 14.25"

• Construction: Pillow top innerspring with pocketed coils

• Support system: Plush 815 Original Beautyrest pocketed coils

• Pressure relief: AllCool Gel Memory Foam + AllCool Gel Foam

• Cooling: AirFeel Foam + AirCool Foam

• Delivery: Standard scheduled delivery; typical arrival 2–3 weeks; White Glove upgrade available

• Trial: 100-night in-home trial

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

• Sizes shown: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Review score

For the most even all-around performance, the Dream Weaver Hybrid Medium is the safest pick—it doesn’t dominate every category, but it avoids big weak spots. The Dream Weaver Firm leads on support, with pressure relief as the clear trade-off. The Ultra Plush Pillow Top is the pressure-relief specialist, with the usual risk of feeling too soft for some sleepers. And the Soothing Nights 10” is the value option, with the scores showing where the lineup saves money (edge support and motion isolation).

Start with your sleep position and body weight, then pick the feel that keeps your hips and shoulders in a neutral line. Back and stomach sleepers (and many heavier sleepers) usually do best on the Dream Weaver Firm. If you rotate between back and side, the Dream Weaver Hybrid Medium is the most balanced. If side sleeping is your priority and you like a softer surface, the Ultra Plush Pillow Top offers the most cushion. For guest rooms or straightforward budget comfort, the Soothing Nights 10” is the simplest, lowest-cost entry point.

• Give the Soothing Nights mattress at least 24–48 hours to fully expand and settle before judging the feel.

• If you sit or sleep near the edge often, the Dream Weaver Firm and Hybrid Medium feel more secure than the Soothing Nights.

• If you run warm, the coil and hybrid builds breathe better than all-foam, but sheets and protectors still matter.

• For couples, the Ultra Plush cuts down on the “jolt,” while the Hybrid Medium keeps a more even, medium feel.

• Rotate the mattress periodically during the first few months to promote even wear.

• Use a mattress protector to keep the quilted surface cleaner and help reduce early wear.

• If you side-sleep and choose the Firm, consider a slightly softer pillow and a bit more hip/shoulder cushioning from your bedding.

• With scheduled delivery, double-check whether setup and old-mattress removal are included or require a White Glove upgrade.

• Expect a short break-in period on any new mattress; the feel often settles after the first week or two.

A: It felt usable right away, but it leveled out after about 24–48 hours of expansion.

A: The Dream Weaver 14.25” Ultra Plush Pillow Top offered the most pressure relief and the softest landing on shoulders and hips.

A: The Dream Weaver 12.5” Firm felt the most stable and supportive, especially for keeping hips from sinking.

A: The Dream Weaver Firm and the Dream Weaver Hybrid Medium both felt quick to respond and easy to roll on.