Costco Leather Sofa Reviews (2026)

Costco leather sofas tend to aim for high comfort-per-dollar with familiar silhouettes, deep seats, and materials like top-grain leather on the touch points. In our rotation, the best fits were households that want easy wipe-down upkeep and relaxed nightly lounging, while the main drawbacks were heat retention on long sits and seat depths that can overwhelm shorter legs.

Product Overview

Testing Team Takeaways

Across the set, we kept coming back to two patterns: deep seats rewarded long legs and “feet-up” loungers, while shorter testers did better on the slightly less deep sofa. Marcus (6'1", ~230 lbs) consistently flagged heat buildup on longer sessions, and Mia (5'4", ~125 lbs) cared most about whether her feet stayed planted and her knees didn’t float. If you want one “easy” daily driver, Rawlins felt the most even; if you want maximum adjustment, Fallon’s power headrests changed the game.

Costco Leather Sofa Comparison Chart

How We Tested It

We rotated each sofa into the same living-room setup and ran repeated daily-life scenarios: laptop work, long TV sessions, gaming marathons, and short naps. We scored Assembly, Cooling, Comfort, Durability, Layout Practicality, Cleaning, and Value, with Comfort reflected through seat feel, back support, and seat-depth fit. We also noted how easily we could reposition ourselves over a long sit and whether the layout stayed practical in a real room.

Costco Leather Sofa: Our Testing Experience

Buckley Leather Sofa

Our Testing Experience

I started on Buckley after desk hours, laptop balanced on my thighs, and I immediately noticed the pillow-top “give” before the foam pushed back into shape. On longer episodes, my lower back wanted a touch more structure, so I kept shifting from upright to semi-reclined. Marcus liked the initial plushness but said the warmth builds when you stay planted. Mia could lounge, but the deeper seat nudged her into a tuck-your-legs posture to feel anchored.

What we liked:

• Cushions feel plush up top but don’t collapse

• Track arms give clean elbow support

Who it is best for:

• Average-to-taller users who like a deeper lounge

• People who want a soft-first sit with underlying support

Where it falls short:

• Petite users may perch rather than plant their feet

• Long sits can feel warm in a still posture

Pros & Cons

Details

• Color: Beige

• Upholstery: Top Grain Leather with Matching Split Leather on Sides and Back

• Overall dimensions: 92" L x 39" W x 35" H

• Seat depth: 22.8"

• Seat height: 20"

• Arm height: 24"

• Leg height: 2"

• Weight: 148.1 lbs

• Weight capacity: 330 lbs per seat

• Seat cushions: 2.2 high density foam seat cores with blend-down initial softness

• Back cushions: polyester fibers in a baffled bag to help prevent sagging

• Frame: furniture-grade engineered wood, corner blocked and glued in key joints

• Legs: solid wood with espresso finish

• Warranty: springs 5 years; leather 1 year; cushioning 1 year; finishes/other parts 1 year

• Delivery: delivery, setup and packaging removal included

Review Score

Rawlins Leather Sofa

Our Testing Experience

Rawlins felt like the “steady hand” of the group. I could sit upright to type, then slide into a relaxed angle without feeling like I was falling backward. The attached cushions kept the surface tidy after a week of repeat sits, and the spring/foam combo stayed consistent when Marcus dropped into the seat after gaming. Mia had an easier time finding a planted position here than on the deeper options, and my lower back did best when I stayed centered rather than slouching into the corner.

What we liked:

• Even support across long sessions

• Cushions stay visually neat because they’re attached

Who it is best for:

• People who want predictable support night after night

• Mixed households with different sitting styles

Where it falls short:

• Not a “sink-in” lounge if you want ultra-plush

• No recline/headrest adjustment for nap-focused use

Pros & Cons

Details

• Upholstery: Top Grain Leather With Matching Split Leather on Sides and Back

• Color: Brown or Cream

• Seat cushions: 2.0 lb density foam

• Suspension: Sinuous spring suspension

• Seat/back cushions: Attached seat and back cushions

• Overall dimensions: 90.9" L x 40.9" W x 37.7" H

• Inside seating width: 71.2"

• Seat depth: 21.6"

• Seat height: 19.6"

• Armrests: 9.8" wide; 24" high

• Legs: Solid wood legs in walnut finish

• Delivery: delivery, setup and packaging removal included

Review Score

Fallon Leather Power Reclining Sofa with Power Headrests

Our Testing Experience

Fallon was our movie-night favorite because the power recline and headrest let me stop chasing the “just-right” angle. I’d start upright, tap into a slight recline, then raise the headrest until my neck stopped craning. Marcus appreciated the support but called out heat buildup when he stayed reclined for a full game. Mia liked the controlled head position, though the deep seat meant she tended to curl or perch. When I tried a quick nap, the recline angle made it easier to settle without stacking extra pillows.

What we liked:

• Headrest tuning helps reduce neck strain

• Pocketed-coil seat feels buoyant, not flat

Who it is best for:

• People who live in recline for TV, gaming, or recovery

• Users who want a higher-back feel with adjustability

Where it falls short:

• Warmest feel on extended sessions

• Heavy, power-based setup limits quick room changes

Pros & Cons

Details

• Upholstery: Top grain leather with vinyl match on sides and back

• Seat support: Pocketed coils seat cushions

• Suspension: Sinuous spring suspension

• Recline: Two power recliners with power headrests

• Charging: Two USB charging ports (one on each arm)

• Overall dimensions: 85" L x 39" W x 42.5" H

• Weight: 267.74 lb

• Seat width: 67.5"

• Seat depth: 22"

• Seat height: 19"

• Arm height: 24"

• Length when fully reclined: 60"

• Delivery: delivery, setup and packaging removal included

Review Score

Natuzzigroup Leather Sectional

Our Testing Experience

This sectional changed how we used the room: people naturally spread out, and I stopped “fighting” for a single sweet-spot seat. The deep seat made it easy for me to pull one leg up while working, then stretch out fully during a late-night binge. Marcus liked the sprawl space, but he still called out leather warmth when he stayed planted. Mia enjoyed curling into the corner, though she had to tuck her legs to feel supported. For my lower back, it was best when I added a small lumbar cushion and avoided sliding into a slouch.

What we liked:

• Big lounging span for hosting and daily sprawl

• Clean, low-profile look that doesn’t feel bulky

Who it is best for:

• Families and hosts who want multiple “usable” seats

• People who lounge sideways or stretch out often

Where it falls short:

• Low height can feel less supportive for upper backs

• Deep seat can be tough for shorter legs

Pros & Cons

Details

• Configuration: 2-piece sectional

• Upholstery: Top Grain Leather on all seating areas, armrests and front rails; matching split leather on sides and back

• Seat support: High density foam cushion

• Suspension: Elastic webbed seating

• Frame: Wood frame construction

• Legs: Solid wood legs

• Assembly: Assembly required

• Overall dimensions: 109.7" L x 89.7" D x 31.8" H

• Seat height: 19"

• Seat depth: 23"

• Armrest width: 7"

• Armrest height: 26"

• Leg height: 1.6"

• Weight: 244.71 lbs (piece weights listed)

• Delivery: delivery, setup and packaging removal included

Review Score

Compare Performance Scores of These Sofas

The numbers show two clear “shape” differences. Rawlins is the most even across the board, with fewer sharp weaknesses. Fallon concentrates its advantage in comfort and back support thanks to power adjustment, but pays for it in cooling and moveability. Buckley’s comfort is strong if you like a deeper seat, while Natuzzigroup wins for sprawl comfort and room-wide usability, with back support as the main trade-off.

How to Choose the Costco Leather Sofa?

Start with seat depth and your default posture: if you sit upright to work, a slightly less deep seat like Rawlins is easier to “live in” daily; if you lounge with feet up, Buckley or Natuzzigroup makes more sense. If you want head/neck control during long TV nights, Fallon’s power headrests stand out. For typical scenarios: petite loungers who curl up tend to prefer Rawlins; taller stretch-out users fit Buckley or Natuzzigroup; recline-first households should focus on Fallon.

Limitations

Across these Costco leather sofas, the biggest trade-offs were warmth over long sessions and seat-depth bias toward lounging. Buckley and Natuzzigroup can feel oversized for shorter legs, while Fallon’s power build reduces flexibility in room layout and can trap heat during marathon sits. Rawlins is the most balanced, but it won’t satisfy shoppers who want a true recliner feel or a high, supportive headrest.

Costco Leather Sofa Vs. Alternatives

• Why choose these models

  • Strong mix of leather touch points and everyday wipe-down practicality

  • Comfort-forward seat designs that suit nightly TV and hosting

  • Delivery/setup convenience and straightforward room-ready usability

• Alternatives to consider

  • West Elm Axel Leather Sofa for a structured, modern sit

  • Pottery Barn Turner Square Arm Leather Sofa for a classic silhouette with broad sizing options

  • Article Sven Tufted Leather Sofa for a vintage-leaning look with a deep bench seat

Pro Tips for Costco Leather Sofa

• Measure doorways, turns, and elevator depth before ordering, not just the final room footprint.

• If you’re under about 5'6", prioritize slightly less seat depth or plan on a lumbar pillow to reduce the “perch” effect.

• For leather warmth, use a breathable throw on long TV nights and rotate sitting spots to avoid heat buildup.

• Keep leather away from direct sun and heat vents so color shifts happen more evenly over time.

• Wipe down weekly with a soft cloth to keep body oils from building up on arms and headrest areas.

• If you choose a recliner, plan outlet access and keep a little clearance for recline travel.

• For sectionals, map the walking paths first; big corner pieces can quietly shrink your usable room.

• Treat “soft on day one” as a feel preference, not a guarantee of posture support; test your default posture for 30–60 minutes.

• If you share seating nightly, pick an option that stays comfortable when you change positions frequently rather than one perfect “pose.”

FAQs

Do leather sofas feel hot during long movie nights?

They can. In our rotation, the recliner model ran the warmest when we stayed in one position for hours, while the stationary sofas were easier to “cool down” simply by shifting posture.

Which option felt best for lower-back sensitivity?

Rawlins felt the most naturally supportive for upright sitting, while Buckley and the sectional were better when I added a small lumbar cushion and avoided sliding into a slouch.

Is a power reclining sofa worth it if you only recline occasionally?

Only if you value the head/neck adjustability. If recline is a rare feature for you, a well-balanced stationary sofa can feel simpler day to day.

What’s the most practical choice for hosting?

The sectional handled group seating most naturally, because people could spread out without fighting for one preferred seat.