Toby's Mattress Reviews (2026)

Toby’s Mattress is a local mattress retailer best known for carrying major lines like Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster, Serta, and Beautyrest. I tested four mainstream builds across those lines for support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability, and found two clear standouts for strong support and two better fits for contouring comfort and partner-friendly sleep.

Product Overview

Testing Team Takeaways

I focused on lumbar support and hip alignment through full nights, plus how each mattress felt while reading in bed and shifting positions. Marcus immediately rewarded the mattresses that stayed cool and didn’t “hammock” under his hips. Jenna and Ethan pushed motion isolation hard; the quietest surface by far was the Tempur. For all-around balance, we kept circling back to the Beautyrest Black Series 1: steady support, strong edges, and a feel that didn’t punish side-sleeping starts.

Toby’s Mattress Comparison Chart

How We Tested It

We rotated these four mattresses through real nights and real routines, then stress-tested them with repeatable checks. Support was judged by hip and lumbar alignment in back and side positions; cooling by heat buildup after long, still stretches; pressure relief by shoulder/hip comfort during sustained side sleeping. Motion isolation was tested with partner movement and get-in/get-out cycles, while responsiveness measured how quickly the surface “lets you turn.” Edge support was evaluated seated and lying near the perimeter, and durability was judged by week-to-week feel stability across repeated use.

Toby’s Mattress: Our Testing Experience

Serta iComfort Standard 12" Medium

Our Testing Experience

The first night felt calm and “quiet,” like the mattress was smoothing out my usual micro-adjustments. After a long desk day, I noticed my lower back stayed supported without feeling pinned, and the medium feel didn’t collapse under my hips when I rolled to my back. Marcus liked the steadier midsection support, but he still felt a bit of heat after a long, still stretch. Jenna and Ethan both called it “partner-friendly” because movement didn’t ripple across the surface.

What we liked

• Stable medium feel that doesn’t wobble

• Very low motion transfer for couples

• Easy, predictable support for back-to-side switching

Who it is best for

• Combination sleepers wanting a calmer foam feel

• Couples who hate being woken up by movement

• People who want medium support without a springy bounce

Where it falls short

• Edges feel less braced than coil-heavy beds

• Hot sleepers may want more airflow-focused options

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): $1,199

• Feel: Medium

• Thickness options in this line: Standard 11.5"–13", Enhanced 14"

• Support design: 5 ZoneResponse design

• Notable foams/materials: Perfect Conform memory foam; EverCool Fuze Gel Memory Foam; graphite-infused memory foam; CoolFeel fabric

• Trial: 100-night trial for purchases made on Serta.com

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

Review Score

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt 12" Soft

Our Testing Experience

This one felt like stepping down into a cushioned pocket, especially on my side. I kept noticing how my shoulder sank without a sharp pressure point, and I could stay in one position longer before needing to shift. The trade-off showed up when Marcus tried it: he called it “too willing to give” under the hips, and he had to work to find a flatter alignment. Jenna and Ethan both gave it the best motion score because their partner tests barely registered.

What we liked

• Deep, consistent pressure relief

• Excellent motion isolation for couples

• Plush comfort that’s easy to settle into

Who it is best for

• Lighter-to-average side sleepers

• People who prioritize contouring over bounce

• Couples sensitive to partner movement

Where it falls short

• Heavier bodies may sink too much at the hips

• Slower surface response can feel “sticky” to some sleepers

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): $3,399

• Comfort level: Plush / Soft

• Thickness: 12"

• Mattress type: Memory foam

• Notable materials/features: TEMPUR-Material; Advanced Relief material; SmartClimate cover (cool-to-touch, removable, machine-washable)

• Warranty: 10-year full replacement limited warranty

Review Score

Beautyrest Black Series 1 Pocketed Coil 14.25" Medium Tight Top

Our Testing Experience

This was the mattress that kept feeling “organized” no matter how messy the night got. I could start on my side, roll to my back, prop up on an elbow to read, and the surface didn’t lose its shape or turn mushy. Marcus liked that it resisted that hammocking sag under the hips, and he called the temperature feel “the most neutral” of the group. Jenna and Ethan felt more movement than on the foam beds, but they both agreed it was the most stable perimeter for edge-of-bed sleeping.

What we liked

• Strong, even support that stays consistent

• Excellent edge stability for couples

• Responsive surface that makes turning feel easy

Who it is best for

• Back sleepers and combo sleepers

• Couples who use the edges and want stability

• People who like a supportive, structured feel

Where it falls short

• Not as motion-deadening as all-foam

• Plush seekers may want a softer top feel

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): $2,299

• Comfort level: Medium

• Thickness: 14.25"

• Construction: Pocketed coil

• Notable layers/materials: Beautyrest gel memory foam; AirFeel foam; AirCool high density foam; Triple-Stranded Pocketed Coil technology

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

Review Score

Stearns & Foster Estate Firm 14.5"

Our Testing Experience

This mattress felt like a classic, firm platform with a polished top layer. When I lay flat on my back, my spine felt level and supported, and I didn’t wake up with that lower-back tightness that shows up when my hips drift too low. Marcus liked it immediately: he could feel the support holding him up instead of letting him sink in. The couple tests were the weakest point; Jenna and Ethan could feel more of each other’s movement than on the foam beds, even though turning felt effortless.

What we liked

• Firm, supportive alignment that holds the hips up

• Excellent edge stability and easy sit-support

• Very easy to reposition and change sleep posture

Who it is best for

• Stomach sleepers and firmer-feel fans

• Back sleepers who want steady lumbar support

• People who dislike a deep foam “hug”

Where it falls short

• Side sleepers with sensitive shoulders may want more cushion

• More partner movement than on foam-heavy mattresses

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price (queen): $2,399

• Comfort level: Firm

• Size (queen): 60"W x 80"L x 14.5"H

• Mattress type: Innerspring

• Notable materials/features: IntelliCoil innersprings with PrecisionEdge support; TEMPUR-Indulge memory foam; TENCEL cover

Review Score

Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses

If you want the most even “no-drama” performance across the board, the Beautyrest Black Series 1 is the steadiest composite score. The Tempur owns pressure relief and motion control, but gives back points in responsiveness and edge confidence. The Stearns & Foster leads the pack in firm support and easy movement, while the Serta iComfort is the most broadly usable foam option with a strong couple-friendly profile.

How to Choose the Toby’s Mattress for Your Sleep Style

If you’re a stomach sleeper or crave a firmer, lifted feel, pick the Stearns & Foster Estate Firm. If you’re a side sleeper who prioritizes pressure relief, the TEMPUR-ProAdapt Soft is the safest bet. For couples who want strong edges plus stable support and easy movement, the Beautyrest Black Series 1 is the best all-arounder. If you want a medium foam feel with excellent motion isolation at a lower price point, the Serta iComfort Standard 12" Medium is the practical choice.

Limitations

Across this set, the biggest trade-offs are feel preference and partner sensitivity. The plush Tempur can run too soft for heavier hips, while the firm Stearns & Foster can feel too unforgiving for side sleepers with sensitive shoulders. The innersprings bring more noticeable partner movement than the foam options, and the foam beds don’t match the best coil designs for edge stability.

Toby’s Mattress Vs. Alternatives

• Why choose these models

  • You want in-store-tested, mainstream builds with familiar feel profiles and a wide range of firmness options.

  • You’re choosing between distinct “lanes”: deep contour (Tempur), balanced foam (Serta), luxury coil stability (Beautyrest), and firm classic support (Stearns & Foster).

  • You care about reliable edge support and straightforward movement, where the coil models clearly excel.

• Alternatives to consider

  • Saatva Classic: strong edge support and a coil-on-coil innerspring design for a more buoyant, supportive feel.

  • Helix Midnight: a medium-feel hybrid tuned for side sleepers needing pressure relief with balanced support.

  • Nectar Premier Memory Foam: a thicker foam option positioned around cooling fibers and pressure relief.

Pro Tips for Toby’s Mattress

• Give any new mattress a consistent break-in window before making comfort calls, especially with foam-heavy builds.

• If you sleep hot, prioritize breathable bedding and a room-temperature reset; mattress materials can only do so much.

• Use a supportive base (platform, slats within spec, or an adjustable base) to keep alignment consistent night to night.

• If you’re a side sleeper, use a pillow height that keeps your neck level; it changes shoulder pressure more than people expect.

• For firmer mattresses, add softness through a topper only after you’ve confirmed your core support is right.

• Couples should test edge time: sitting, tying shoes, and lying on the outer third often reveals the real stability.

• If you feel “stuck” in foam, choose a more responsive surface or adjust bedding friction (slicker protector/sheets can help).

• Rotate your mattress as recommended by the manufacturer/retailer schedule to keep wear more even over time.

• Match firmness to body weight: heavier bodies usually need more support; lighter bodies typically need more pressure relief.

FAQs

Which one is best if I wake up with lower-back tightness?

If your hips tend to sink, the Stearns & Foster Estate Firm or Beautyrest Black Series 1 are the safer picks because they hold the midsection up more consistently.

Which mattress is best for couples who wake each other up?

The TEMPUR-ProAdapt Soft and the Serta iComfort Standard 12" Medium are the quietest surfaces for partner movement in our tests.

Which is easiest to move around on?

The Stearns & Foster Estate Firm and Beautyrest Black Series 1 feel the most responsive when you turn or change positions.