Shiloh 14" Medium Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress Reviews (2026)

We used the mattress in a multi-week rotation and followed our standard mattress testing process while scoring support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability on a 5-point scale. During testing, we tracked back-to-side transitions, ran partner-movement drills, repeated sit-and-stand checks along the perimeter, and paid attention to heat buildup at bedtime and again in the middle of the night. For durability, we focused on early softening cues and surface stability rather than making a long-term ownership claim.

Our Testing Experience

Unboxing followed the usual bed-in-a-box routine: cut the plastic, let the foam expand, and give it time to settle into its true shape. The first night felt plush right away, but the more useful read came after the mattress stopped changing and the support felt consistent from one night to the next.

Marcus (6'1", about 230 lbs) paid the most attention to heat and hip support. He thought the bed held his midsection fairly evenly, but he still noticed more warmth than he does on hybrids. Mia (5'4", about 125 lbs) had the best result. The foam eased pressure at her shoulder and outer hip, and she could stay on her side longer without that sharp pinch-point feeling. Jenna’s motion tests with Ethan were the clearest win: when he rolled over or got out of bed, very little movement traveled across the surface, though he still noticed the slower rebound when turning quickly.

What we liked

• Deep cushioning at the shoulders and hips

• Very little partner disturbance

• A comfortable medium feel that does not come off hard or rigid

Who it is best for

• Side sleepers and back sleepers who want more contouring

• Couples, especially if one person wakes easily

• Guest rooms where easy comfort matters more than bounce

Where it falls short

• Edge sitting feels softer than the center of the bed

• Quick position changes take more effort than they do on a hybrid

• Cooling is decent, but not especially strong

• Price (by size): Full $469.99; Queen $519.99; King $619.99; California King $619.99.

• Height: 14 inches.

• Feel: Medium.

• Construction: 3 inches of green tea memory foam, 3 inches of air channel foam, and 8 inches of base foam.

• Cover: Soft knit cover with two easy-moving handles on each side.

• Fire barrier and certification: Fiberglass-free fire barrier; CertiPUR-US certified foam.

• Sizes offered: Full, Queen, King, and California King.

• Dimensions and weight: Full 75" × 54" × 14" (67.1 lbs); Queen 80" × 60" × 14" (79.6 lbs); King 80" × 76" × 14" (100.8 lbs); California King 84" × 72" × 14" (100.2 lbs).

• Setup: Compressed and shipped in a box; allow up to 48 hours to fully expand.

• Foundation guidance: Use a box spring or a ventilated slatted base with slats at least 3 inches wide and spaced less than 4 inches apart.

• Warranty and trial: 10-year warranty; trial terms depend on the retailer’s return policy.

Based on our testing, the Shiloh makes the most sense if you start with your sleep style. Side sleepers and back sleepers who want a cushioned top layer usually line up well with it, while stomach sleepers and heavier bodies should be more careful about hip sink. If you run hot, treat it as moderate rather than truly cooling, and if you share a bed, the low motion transfer is one of the better reasons to consider it.

If you want a more obvious cooling mattress, or you care most about low motion transfer plus easy movement, look closely at what kind of feel you actually want. A quicker response points you toward a hybrid mattress, while the Shiloh makes more sense if you want a deeper, slower cradle. In brand terms, that means the Tuft & Needle Original Mattress is the better direction for easier turning, the Saatva Classic Mattress makes more sense for stronger edges and more airflow, and the Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress stays in the same broader all-foam conversation.

The Shiloh has a clear memory-foam profile: slower response, deeper contouring, and less airflow than a coil bed. It is supportive enough near the edge for sleeping, but it is less satisfying if you sit there often while getting dressed. If you prefer a quicker, more lifted surface, this is probably not the right feel.

Why choose the Shiloh

• Its thick comfort layers cushion shoulders and hips without feeling completely unsupportive

• Motion stays quiet for partners and light sleepers

• The medium feel works well if you want more contouring than bounce

Alternatives to consider

• Tuft & Needle Original Mattress: better for quicker response and easier turning

• Saatva Classic Mattress: better for stronger edges and more airflow

• Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress: another all-foam option focused on pressure relief

• Give it up to 48 hours to reach its settled feel before judging firmness.

• Use a breathable protector if you are sensitive to heat.

• Rotate the mattress occasionally to help even out wear.

• Try not to spend long periods sitting on the edge every day.

• Keep it on a ventilated base rather than directly on the floor.

• During the trial window, test both partner movement and quick position changes.

It lands near medium overall, but the first thing most people notice is the plush top. The deeper support shows up after the initial cushion.

Yes. In our motion tests, partner movement stayed surprisingly contained.

It is cooler than dense, older-style foam, but it still runs warmer than many hybrids. Breathable bedding and a ventilated base help.

Give it up to 48 hours to fully expand and settle before deciding how it feels.