Sam's Club Mattress Reviews (2026)

Across nightly use, the two hybrids stayed the most stable—especially for heavier bodies and anyone who changes positions a lot. The all-foam beds were quieter and delivered deeper pressure relief, but they tended to hold more heat and their edges gave up sooner.

Marcus watched for any hint of ‘hammocking,’ Mia focused on shoulder comfort, and Ethan cared most about how easily he could roll over and feel settled again.

We slept on each mattress for two weeks on the same sturdy foundation, following our standard mattress testing protocol, rotating our order so every model saw the same conditions. Each night we logged spinal alignment and comfort in back and side positions, then checked again the next morning.

Cooling, motion isolation, and responsiveness came from repeatable drills—heat build-up checks, partner-movement routines, and turn-and-roll tests. We scored edge support by sitting and perimeter sleeping, and we judged durability by week-to-week consistency and any early impressions.

Our Testing Experience

On my back, this hybrid kept my hips a bit more lifted than the foam beds—supportive, but not board-like. During Marcus’s edge routine (sit, stand, then roll near the perimeter), the side compressed but didn’t collapse into that slippery, rolling-off feeling. Ethan also called out how easy it was to change positions and settle back into a neutral posture.

What we liked

• Support stayed consistent, even after long desk days

• Cooling felt steady through a full night

• Rolling over felt easy, without the “stuck” foam feel

Who it is best for

• Combination sleepers who rotate between back and side

• Heavier sleepers who want less risk of sinking too deep

• Anyone who prefers a buoyant hybrid feel over a deep foam hug

Where it falls short

• Very light sleepers may still notice a partner’s movement

• If your shoulders need a deep hug, foam may feel gentler

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $349.00–$699.00

• Mattress type: Hybrid

• Thickness: 14"

• Firmness options: Medium / Plush / Firm

• Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Materials: Graphite-infused foam over a coil support system

• Cooling: Cool-to-touch feel with airflow from coils

• Warranty: 10-year limited warranty

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

This mattress felt quieter and more cradling right away. On my side, my shoulder sank in quickly—without the ‘floating’ sensation we sometimes get on hybrids. Mia liked how it eased shoulder pressure without making her constantly adjust pillow height. The trade-offs showed up with time: Marcus felt more heat buildup, and the edge softened when we kept sitting in the same spot.

What we liked

• Excellent pressure relief at shoulders and hips

• Very little motion transfer

• Calm, cushy surface feel

Who it is best for

• Side sleepers who want deeper contouring

• Light to average-weight sleepers

• Guest rooms where a quiet surface matters

Where it falls short

• Hot sleepers may need extra temperature management

• Edge sitting feels softer than on hybrids

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: From $199.98

• Mattress type: Memory foam

• Thickness: 12"

• Firmness options: Medium / Firm / Ultra Plush

• Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Materials: Memory foam comfort layers

• Warranty: 10-year warranty

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

This one felt cooler when we first laid down, and it stayed less warm-and-sticky than the standard memory foam bed when we stayed in one position (reading or watching TV). Mia appreciated the softer top for side sleeping, but she still noticed the slower recovery when she switched sides. Marcus agreed it handled heat better than he expects from foam—although he still preferred the airflow of a hybrid.

What we liked

• Cool-to-touch feel at bedtime

• Excellent motion isolation

• Pressure relief stayed consistent night to night

Who it is best for

• Foam fans who sleep warm

• Light sleepers who hate being bumped awake

• Side sleepers who like a softer top layer

Where it falls short

• People who hate slow-response foam

• Anyone who sits on the edge a lot

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $699.98–$999.98

• Mattress type: Gel memory foam

• Thickness: 13"

• Firmness options: Not specified

• Available sizes: Twin XL, Queen, King

• Materials: Gel memory foam comfort layers

• Cooling: Designed for a cooler surface feel (the “Chill” feature)

• Warranty: 10-year warranty

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

The latex hybrid felt noticeably different right away—more buoyant, less sink, and a quicker push-back when I rolled. Ethan said it was the easiest to move on, with almost no lag. Marcus liked the steady hip support when he spent time on his stomach, and he didn’t flag heat the way he did on the all-foam beds. Mia still preferred the deeper cradle of memory foam on shoulder-sensitive nights, but she felt well-supported here.

What we liked

• Fast, springy response that makes turning easy

• Steady support for back and stomach sleeping

• Temperature stayed even through the night

Who it is best for

• Back sleepers who like a medium-firm feel

• Restless sleepers who change positions often

• Hot sleepers who still want cushioning

Where it falls short

• Very pressure-sensitive side sleepers may want more plushness

• Motion control is lower than the foam models

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $599.00–$999.00

• Mattress type: Hybrid with organic latex

• Thickness: 12"

• Firmness options: Medium-firm

• Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

• Materials: Organic latex in the comfort layers

• Cooling: Latex and coils promote airflow

• Warranty: 10-year warranty

Review Score

On paper and in nightly use, the two hybrids were the most balanced overall. The organic latex hybrid was the quickest to respond, while the 14" hybrid did a bit better at keeping partner movement in check. The foam beds won on motion isolation and pressure relief, but they were slower to move on and their edges felt softer. If you want one straightforward all-rounder, the 14" hybrid is the safest choice in this group; if easy movement is your priority, the latex hybrid is the standout.

Start with construction. Memory foam tends to give you a deeper cradle and a quieter surface. Hybrids usually feel steadier through the hips and make it easier to change positions.

Then match the model to your sleep style: hot sleepers generally do best with the Organic Latex Hybrid (or the Chill 13" if you want an all-foam feel). Lighter side sleepers often prefer the extra cushioning of the 12" Memory Foam. If you’re heavier or you rotate positions, the 14" Hybrid is the most balanced option here. And if edge seating matters, the hybrids are the safer bet.

• Use a sturdy foundation. On flexible slats, hybrids can feel less stable.

• For 13"–14" mattresses, deep-pocket sheets help keep corners from popping off.

• Let foam mattresses fully expand before you judge firmness.

• If foam sleeps warm, try breathable sheets and a lighter comforter before you write off the mattress.

• Rotate regularly to keep wear more even.

• Test the edge by sitting down (like you would to tie shoes); it’s a good preview of long-term edge support.

• If you move a lot at night, prioritize faster response over pure softness.

• Match your pillow loft to the mattress: softer tops usually need a slightly higher pillow.

• If you’re a light sleeper, repeat the same get-in/get-out routine to check for motion transfer.