Justice Mattress Reviews

Across the lineup, the biggest swing is firmness: Lodge Firm is genuinely firm, while Echo and Grand Hotel Luxury feel noticeably softer at the surface. If you are between sizes or plans, it is worth confirming specifics with the dealer, since pricing, delivery, and comfort exchanges are typically retailer-managed.

• If you want the plush hotel surface, Grand Hotel Luxury is the closest match.
• If you care more about long-term shape retention, the two-sided Grand Hotel Mattress and Lodge Firm are the workhorses.
• Echo is the value pick: comfortable, but built with simpler foams than the premium lines.
• Castlehill stands apart with a Talalay latex core—springy, cooler, and less “sink-in” than the pillow-top beds.

Justice is best known for building mattresses for hotels and resorts, and that influence shows up most clearly in the Grand Hotel models. They aim for a steady, “easy to sleep on” feel instead of an exaggerated showroom bounce.

Because Justice sells through local dealers, small presentation details can vary by store. We focused our conclusions on feel and construction signals that consistently showed up in use, not on retailer-specific pricing or add-ons.

• Support checks: spine alignment on back, side, and stomach sleep
• Pressure relief: shoulder/hip comfort for side sleeping
• Cooling and breathability: heat build-up over multi-hour sessions
• Motion isolation: partner movement transfer across the surface
• Responsiveness: how easily you can change positions
• Edge support: sitting and sleeping near the perimeter

We tested these Justice mattresses in real bedrooms, rotating sleepers and sleeping positions so the notes reflect more than a quick showroom impression. We paid special attention to how each bed handled support, pressure relief, cooling, and motion isolation over full nights.

Our Testing Experience

Where Echo surprised us was motion control. For a value-oriented build, movement dampening felt better than expected, with fewer ripples traveling across the surface than we typically see in older coil systems.

The pillow-top has an immediately soft landing, especially noticeable on the shoulder when side sleeping. Underneath, the pocketed coils keep the bed from feeling mushy, but heavier bodies can still press through the comfort layers more than on the Grand Hotel models.

We used Echo first in a guest room and treated it like a “real-life” mattress—full nights, mixed sleep positions, and a rotating set of sleepers.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Pillow-top hybrid with pocketed coils
• Firmness (tested): Medium to medium-soft
• Best for: Guest rooms, teens, and lighter-to-average side sleepers
• Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
• Core: Caliber Edge pocketed coil unit
• Foundation: Serenity III Foundation (dealer-set dependent)
• Cooling: Airflow from coils helps; the pillow top can feel warmer than a tight-top
• Motion isolation: Good for the price tier
• Warranty: 10-year limited

Our Testing Experience

If you tend to sleep warm, this is the Grand Hotel option most likely to retain a bit of heat in the top quilting. It never felt stifling in our rooms, but compared with the latex Castlehill, the surface warmth is easier to notice.

On side sleep, the pillow top took the edge off shoulder pressure faster than the tighter, two-sided Grand Hotel Mattress. On back sleep, it stayed level for our average-weight testers, but it does feel softer overall than the non–pillow-top models.

Grand Hotel Luxury is the one that most clearly aims for a “resort mattress” feel. The surface is plush and inviting, but there is still a firm coil presence underneath—so you get cushioning without losing the sense of lift.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Ultra premium pillow-top innerspring
• Firmness (tested): Medium-plush to medium
• Best for: Side sleepers and combo sleepers who want a cushioned top
• Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
• Core: Lura-Flex alternating coil unit
• Foundation: Mira-Coil Foundation (dealer-set dependent)
• Cooling: Generally neutral; warmer at the surface than the tight-top models
• Motion isolation: Moderate—better than old linked coils, not as muted as some foams
• Warranty: 10-year limited

Our Testing Experience

The two-sided construction matters in daily use. Being able to flip the mattress makes it easier to even out wear, which is a practical advantage if you plan to keep the bed for years.

Compared with Grand Hotel Luxury, you lose some of that plush first impression, but you gain a flatter, more level surface that stayed consistent across our back-sleep nights. The feel lands around medium-firm—supportive without the sharpness of Lodge Firm.

Grand Hotel Mattress is the “classic hotel” build in this lineup: a two-sided, non–pillow-top design that feels steady and uncomplicated.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Two-sided innerspring (non–pillow top)
• Firmness (tested): Medium-firm
• Best for: Back sleepers, combo sleepers, durability-focused shoppers
• Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
• Core: Lura-Flex alternating coil unit
• Foundation: Mira-Coil Foundation (dealer-set dependent)
• Cooling: Neutral; less heat retention than the plush pillow-top
• Motion isolation: Moderate; firmer surface transmits a bit more movement than Echo
• Warranty: 10-year limited

Our Testing Experience

Edge feel was one of the highlights. Sitting to put on shoes or sleeping close to the side felt more secure here than on the pillow-top options.

For stomach and back sleep, that firmness translated into very stable spine support, especially for heavier bodies. For side sleep, most testers felt too much pressure at the shoulder unless they were lighter or used a softer pillow to offset it.

Lodge Firm is exactly what the name suggests: a firm, hotel-style mattress with a two-sided build. The surface feels flatter and tighter than any other bed in this set.

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Two-sided firm innerspring (non–pillow top)
• Firmness (tested): Firm
• Best for: Stomach and back sleepers; heavier bodies; people who dislike sink-in
• Sizes: Twin, Full, Queen, King
• Core: Lura-Flex alternating coil unit
• Foundation: Mira-Coil Foundation (dealer-set dependent)
• Cooling: Neutral to cool; firmer top holds less heat
• Edge support: Strongest of the group in our sit and lie tests
• Warranty: 10-year limited

Our Testing Experience

The trade-offs are practical: it is typically priced higher than the innerspring options and is usually offered only in Queen and King.

On side sleep, it relieved pressure without letting hips drop too far, and it was noticeably easier to move on than the pillow-top beds. The surface also stayed cooler in our longer sessions, which tracks with the more breathable latex feel.

Castlehill Luxury is the outlier in this roundup because it uses a Talalay latex core instead of a traditional coil system. The feel is springy and buoyant—more “lift” than “sink.”

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Natural latex mattress (non–pillow top)
• Core: 6" Natural Talalay plush latex core
• Firmness (tested): Medium to medium-plush (varies by body weight)
• Best for: Hot sleepers, combo sleepers, and people who like responsive support
• Sizes: Queen, King
• Foundation: J-Maxx IV Heavy Duty Foundation (dealer-set dependent)
• Cooling: Best in this group in our testing sessions
• Motion isolation: Moderate; latex has bounce but not a “jarring” feel
• Warranty: 10-year limited

We already covered three Grand Hotel-family mattresses and Echo, so the broad pattern looks clear. Echo offers soft access to Justice hybrids. Grand Hotel Luxury brings plush hotel comfort. Grand Hotel Mattress gives a firmer, flippable twist. Lodge Firm targets people wanting strict support. Castlehill Luxury sits at the latex summit.

Because Justice is often dealer-sold, it also helps to ask the store about comfort exchanges, delivery, and how they handle special orders. That can matter as much as the mattress choice itself.

• Sleep position: side sleepers usually prefer more surface cushioning; stomach sleepers usually need firmer, flatter support.
• Body weight: heavier bodies compress comfort layers faster, so firmer and/or two-sided builds often feel more stable over time.
• Firmness preference: Lodge Firm is the firm outlier; Grand Hotel Mattress sits closer to medium-firm; the pillow-tops feel softer at the surface; Castlehill varies around medium to medium-plush with a buoyant latex feel.
• Cooling: latex and tighter tops typically feel cooler than thick pillow-top quilting.
• Motion isolation: the pillow-top Echo muted movement best in our tests; firmer two-sided beds tend to transmit more.
• Support setup: confirm whether your retailer is pairing the mattress with a compatible foundation, box spring, platform bed, or adjustable base.

Justice models tend to break into three feels: plush pillow-top (Echo and Grand Hotel Luxury), classic two-sided innerspring (Grand Hotel and Lodge Firm), and buoyant latex (Castlehill). Start with how you sleep, then narrow by firmness and temperature needs.