Sleep testing turns strange once a retail brand launches its own mattress line. I wanted to know whether Havertys house-brand beds actually compete with national names or just fill floor space. That question tugged at me every time I walked past the 1885 display.
I pulled our full crew together again. I handle coordination and notes, Marcus brings the bigger frame and heat sensitivity, Mia guards pressure points, while Jamal chases bounce and support for an athletic body. We rotated across five Havertys mattresses from the 1885 2.0 and 1885 Youth Essentials series, logging every night.
We used the same routine for each bed. I tracked lower-back tension and alignment through full weeks, Marcus chased edge feel and temperature, Mia focused on shoulder comfort, Jamal checked responsiveness during stretches and late returns from workouts. By the end, certain Havertys mattresses felt dialed in for specific sleepers, while others landed squarely in “very average” territory.
Table of Contents
Main Havertys-brand mattresses we tested
| Mattress | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price* | Overall Score |
| 1885 Collection 2.0 Firm Tight Top – “Havertys Mattress Reviews Spine-Stabilizer” | Strong support, firm feel, good edge stability, low motion transfer | Too firm for many side sleepers, modest pressure relief | Back sleepers, heavier sleepers, stomach sleepers needing hip support | Approx. mid-range, often around upper-middle price for firm hybrids | 4.4 / 5 |
| 1885 Collection 2.0 Medium Pillow Top – “Havertys Mattress Reviews Everyday Hybrid” | Balanced feel, contour plus support, solid cooling, couple friendly | Lighter side sleepers may still want more plushness | Average-weight combo sleepers, couples sharing a bed | Mid-range; queen usually under typical premium hybrid pricing | 4.6 / 5 |
| 1885 Collection 2.0 Soft Tight Top – “Havertys Mattress Reviews Pressure-Relief Favorite” | Deep cushioning, strong pressure relief, wrapped coil support underneath | Too soft for strict stomach sleepers, some heavier backs | Side sleepers, lighter bodies, people wanting “cushiony” top | Similar band to other 1885 mattresses, often sale driven | 4.5 / 5 |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Firm – “Havertys Mattress Reviews Kid-Friendly Support Base” | Firmer surface, good support for growing bodies, lower profile feel | Not plush enough for teens wanting cloudlike softness | Kids needing structure, parents prioritizing durability | Youth-focused pricing, usually below adult 1885 models | 4.2 / 5 |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top – “Havertys Mattress Reviews Youth Comfort Upgrade” | 12.5" profile, five foam layers, gel quilt foam, softer top feel | Shorter 5-year warranty, not ideal for very heavy teens | Kids and tweens wanting softer comfort, lighter side sleepers | Around mid-range youth pricing, often in the high hundreds | 4.3 / 5 |
Testing Team Takeaways
We tested five Havertys mattresses from the 1885 Collection 2.0 and Youth Essentials lines. Across the set, the feel changes a lot more than the branding suggests. The Firm Tight Top stays flat and steady, the Medium Pillow Top splits the difference, and the Soft Tight Top leans into cushioning.
On the heavier end, Marcus kept circling back to support and temperature. He preferred the firmer build when he wanted his hips to stay level and the surface to feel cooler. Mia, who is lighter and side-sleeps, felt the most relief on the softer options, where her shoulder could sink in without feeling the coil unit underneath.
Jamal paid attention to how easy it was to change positions and how secure the edges felt. The Medium Pillow Top gave him the cleanest mix of grip and rebound, while the Youth models felt best as kid-focused beds rather than full-time adult options. If you want one safe pick, the Medium Pillow Top is the easiest recommendation.
What We Tested and How We Tested It
We ran our usual multi-week routine on each Havertys model, rotating sleepers and logging notes every night. Scores reflect a mix of hands-on checks and real sleep, not a single showroom try.
I spent full workweeks on the adult 1885 mattresses, switching between back and side sleeping and tracking pressure, alignment, and how quickly the foams settled. Marcus handled the heat and edge checks. We also ran quick motion and bounce comparisons to see how each build reacts to movement.
For support, we compared posture photos and in-the-moment feedback, then matched that against how each bed behaved under different body types. That is why the same model can score well for one sleeper and still feel off for another.
Havertys Mattress: Our Testing Experience
1885 Collection 2.0 Firm Tight Top
Our Testing Experience
This is the firmest adult option we tested, and it feels that way the moment you lie down. On my back, my hips stayed level and my lower back felt supported instead of pushed upward. Sitting and shifting near the edge also felt steady, with less sink than the other 1885 models.
Marcus liked it most for the same reason: it kept his midsection from dipping while still feeling breathable for his heat checks. The tradeoff is comfort for dedicated side sleepers. If you spend most of the night on your side, the surface can feel too flat through the shoulder.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Very strong support under hips and lower back | Too firm for many dedicated side sleepers |
| Firm edge feel for sitting and getting up | Surface feels somewhat rigid for petite bodies |
| Good temperature performance for a firm hybrid design | Limited plushness for people wanting a cushy top |
| Low motion transfer for a coil-based mattress | Not ideal for kids or very light teens as a primary bed |
Details
- Brand / Line: 1885 Collection 2.0 by Havertys, exclusive in-house line
- Construction type: Hybrid-style design with individually wrapped coil core and firm foam comfort system
- Height: Around 12" published height for queen size
- Firmness feel (our scale): Around 8 out of 10, clearly firm
- Cooling features: Breathable quilt, open coil unit for airflow, relatively thin comfort stack, no heavy slow-responding gel slabs
- Best sleeper profiles: Heavier back sleepers, combination back-and-stomach sleepers, people needing strong lumbar support
- Shipping and setup: Delivered via Havertys Top Drawer Delivery with setup and packaging removal available in most regions
1885 Collection 2.0 Medium Pillow Top
Our Testing Experience
The Medium Pillow Top came across as the most “middle of the road” mattress in this lineup. The pillow top takes the edge off pressure points, but the coil system still keeps the bed from feeling loose or overly plush. I could switch between side and back without fighting the surface.
Across our group, it handled the widest mix of sleeper types. Marcus found it supportive enough for most nights, Mia liked that it cushioned her shoulder without swallowing her, and Jamal noted that it stayed responsive when he rolled and changed positions. If you are unsure where you land on firmness, this is the safest starting point.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Balanced mix of support and cushioning | Not soft enough for ultra-plush seekers |
| Good cooling for a foam-topped hybrid | Heavier strict stomach sleepers may want more firmness |
| Couple-friendly motion control with some bounce | Petite side sleepers might prefer extra plushness |
| Versatile feel for guest rooms and main bedrooms | Pillow top may compress slightly faster than tight tops over many years |
Details
- Brand / Line: 1885 Collection 2.0 by Havertys, part of the in-house anniversary line
- Construction type: Hybrid pillow top, wrapped coil core, multi-layer foam pillow surface
- Firmness feel: Around 6.5 on our scale, medium-firm leaning comfortable
- Height: Feels in the 12–13" range, pillow top adds visual loft
- Cooling design: Breathable top fabrics, heat-dissipating foam layers, open coil core for airflow
- Warranty: Standard store mattress warranty, specifics depend on purchase paperwork
1885 Collection 2.0 Soft Tight Top
Our Testing Experience
The Soft Tight Top is the comfort-first choice among the adult 1885 beds. It lets the shoulder and outer hip sink in more, which made side sleeping feel noticeably gentler for me and for Mia. The surface has more “hug,” and it creates a deeper cradle than the Medium Pillow Top.
That extra give comes with limits. Marcus could feel his hips settling deeper than he preferred, and position changes took a bit more effort than on the firmer options. If you are heavier or mostly sleep on your stomach, the Medium or Firm builds are usually the better fit.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Excellent pressure relief for shoulders and hips | Too soft for most strict stomach sleepers |
| Comfort-focused feel that still hides a strong coil core | Heavier sleepers may experience extra sink over time |
| Good motion absorption for restless partners | Movement requires slightly more effort than on firmer models |
| Appealing option for side sleepers who dislike ultra-firm beds | Runs a touch warmer than the firm tight top for heavy bodies |
Details
- Brand / Line: 1885 Collection 2.0 by Havertys, soft comfort variant
- Construction type: Soft tight top hybrid with individually wrapped coils
- Firmness feel: Around 5.5, on the plusher side of medium
- Height: Sits in the same general profile range as other 1885 2.0 beds
- Cooling design: Breathable fabrics plus coil airflow; softer foams hold slightly more heat than firmer builds
- Warranty: Standard store mattress warranty, with timeline at purchase
1885 Youth Essentials Firm
Our Testing Experience
The Youth Essentials Firm is built with kids in mind, not long-term adult use. It feels simple and flat, with a firmer top that keeps a lighter body from sinking too deeply. On my back it stayed supportive without feeling sharp, which is the kind of feel many kids tolerate well.
For adults, especially heavier ones, it can feel too basic and too firm. As a child-focused bed, it makes sense for a straightforward, supportive setup. If the child wants more surface comfort, the Youth Pillow Top is the more forgiving option.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Supportive surface tuned toward lighter bodies | Not plush enough for side-sleeping adults |
| Durable feel for kids who jump and play | Limited contouring for sensitive shoulders or hips |
| Reasonable price for a branded youth mattress | Shorter feature list than adult 1885 models |
| Good option for bunk beds and tight spaces | Less suitable for long-term use by heavy teens |
Details
- Brand / Line: 1885 Youth Essentials by Havertys, part of the 1885 family
- Construction type: Innerspring-style youth mattress with multiple foam layers over the coil core
- Firmness feel: Around 7.5 on our scale, clearly firm yet not rock hard
- Height: Slimmer than 1885 2.0 beds, friendlier for bunks and low rails
- Cooling design: Basic breathable cover plus open coil interior
- Price position: Typically cheaper than adult 1885 models, within mid-range youth pricing
- Warranty: Youth line coverage paired with quality materials, term checked at sale
1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top
Our Testing Experience
The Youth Essentials Pillow Top adds a softer, friendlier surface to the youth build. Side sleeping felt gentler than on the Youth Firm, and the top layer gave a bit more cushion while still feeling supportive for smaller frames.
Marcus could tell right away that it is not designed for his weight long term, but that is not the goal of this model. For kids and many teens who want a plush feel without paying for an adult mattress tier, this is the more comfortable Youth option.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Plush pillow top feel for kids and light teens | Adult bodies overload the foam stack quickly |
| Five foam layers plus gel quilt foam for comfort and temperature control | Shorter 5-year warranty than some adult mattresses |
| 12.5" height gives substantial look and feel | Less ideal for very firm preference households |
| Good side-sleep pressure relief for petite bodies | Not suited for very heavy teens or adults long term |
Details
- Brand / Line: 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top by Havertys
- Height: 12.5" specified in product copy
- Construction: Pillow top youth mattress with multi-layer foam stack above coil core
- Firmness feel: Around 6, medium comfort leaning gentle
- Cooling features: Gel quilt foam and breathable surface materials aim at temperature regulation
- Price level: Typically positioned in mid-to-upper youth bracket, often around mid-hundreds in twin sizes
Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness |
| 1885 2.0 Firm Tight Top | 4.4 | 4.8 | 3.7 | 4.4 | 4.5 | 4.7 | 4.2 |
| 1885 2.0 Medium Pillow Top | 4.6 | 4.6 | 4.7 | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.5 | 4.5 |
| 1885 2.0 Soft Tight Top | 4.5 | 4.2 | 4.8 | 4.1 | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.0 |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Firm | 4.2 | 4.5 | 3.6 | 4.2 | 3.9 | 4.4 | 4.5 |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top | 4.3 | 4.1 | 4.6 | 4.2 | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.3 |
The scores match what we felt in real sleep. The 1885 2.0 Medium Pillow Top is the most balanced adult option. The Firm Tight Top leads on support and stability, while the Soft Tight Top is the comfort pick for side sleepers who want more cushioning. The Youth models score lower overall, but they make sense when the buyer is actually a kid.
Best Picks
- Best Overall Pick – 1885 Collection 2.0 Medium Pillow Top: Balanced feel with enough cushion for shoulders and enough pushback to keep hips from dipping.
- Best Choice for Side Sleepers – 1885 Collection 2.0 Soft Tight Top: Deeper pressure relief and a gentler surface, especially for lighter bodies.
- Best Option for Kids – 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top: More forgiving than the youth firm, with a softer top that still feels supportive for smaller frames.
How to Choose the Havertys Mattress?
Start with your sleep position, then factor in body weight and how warm you sleep. These Havertys beds land in clear firmness lanes, and the right pick usually comes down to feel.
- Back sleepers, stomach sleepers, hot sleepers, and higher-weight sleepers usually do best on the 1885 Collection 2.0 Firm Tight Top.
- Most combination sleepers and many couples fit the 1885 Collection 2.0 Medium Pillow Top.
- Side sleepers and lighter bodies tend to prefer the 1885 Collection 2.0 Soft Tight Top for its extra cushioning.
- For a flatter, firmer kids’ bed, the 1885 Youth Essentials Firm is the straightforward pick.
- For kids or teens who want a softer surface, the 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top is the more comfortable option.
- If you are buying during a promotion, focus on the comfort match first. A lower price only helps if you keep the mattress.
Limitations
These mattresses cover common firmness needs, but they do not hit every niche. If you want an extremely hard, almost board-like surface, even the Firm Tight Top may not be enough.
Very heavy sleepers beyond the ranges we tested may need a mattress built specifically for higher loads, with thicker coils and reinforced edges.
If you want a very springy, minimal-foam innerspring feel, the builds here can feel more muted. The adult 1885 line can also land above strict budget tiers, even when promotions help.
Policies at a Glance
| Mattress | Shipping (cost and region) | Trial Period / Comfort Window | Return Policy / Fees | Warranty Length | Notable Conditions |
| 1885 2.0 Firm Tight Top | Delivered through Havertys Top Drawer Delivery in service regions; fee varies by market; includes setup and packaging removal; complimentary mattress removal for qualifying purchases | Comfort exchange usually available between about 30 and 90 nights, depending on current program | One comfort re-selection per customer; delivery fees generally non-refundable; certain restocking fees for FedEx-type shipments do not apply here | Standard mattress warranty, term specified at purchase | 3-day general reselect policy exists but does not cover mattresses the same way as furniture; confirm store specifics at sale |
| 1885 2.0 Medium Pillow Top | Same Top Drawer Delivery framework, with optional pickup in some areas | Same comfort-guarantee range as other Havertys mattresses in this line | One-time comfort exchange; may require matching brand box spring if changing brands during re-selection | Standard mattress warranty through Havertys | Comfort exchange usually requires at least 30 nights of use before swap; height differences alone rarely qualify |
| 1885 2.0 Soft Tight Top | Same delivery options, including free mattress removal for new purchases | Comfort window similar to firm and medium models, often 30–90 nights | Reselect options limited to one exchange; delivery charge for new selection applies | Standard mattress warranty | Mattress may need to be free of major stains or damage to qualify for exchange |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Firm | Top Drawer Delivery available; youth items often bundled with bedroom furniture deliveries | Comfort and reselect rules similar to other mattresses, though families rarely use multi-exchange options | 3-day general reselect framework plus extended mattress comfort exchange where applicable | Youth-oriented mattress warranty; term detailed on tag or receipt | Some policies exclude floor samples or clearance items; comfort exchange generally applies to regular stock only |
| 1885 Youth Essentials Pillow Top | Same delivery network with haul-away for old mattress | Comfort window falls under Havertys mattress comfort guarantee policies | One allowed comfort exchange; FedEx-style restocking fees mainly impact shipped accessories instead | 5-year non-prorated warranty specifically stated for this model | Must meet warranty care guidelines; keep documentation and tags for any service claims |
Havertys’ policy setup is mostly straightforward. Delivery and setup rules can vary by area, and the comfort guarantee is structured around exchanges rather than unlimited returns. Before you buy, check the fees, timelines, and the one-exchange limit so there are no surprises.
FAQs
Are Havertys mattresses good quality compared with national brands?
The 1885 2.0 models held up well in our hands-on checks and night-to-night use. Their build and feel land in the same range as many mid-tier national hybrids.
Which Havertys mattress is best for back pain ?
In our testing, the 1885 2.0 Firm Tight Top kept the most consistent alignment for back sleeping. If you want a little more cushioning without losing support, the Medium Pillow Top is the next step.
Do Havertys mattresses sleep hot?
None of these felt like a true “cold” mattress, but the firmer builds tended to breathe better in our heat checks. The softer, plusher surfaces held a bit more warmth.
How long will a Havertys 1885 mattress last?
Lifespan depends on body weight, use, and foundation support. The 1885 2.0 line has a sturdier feel than the Youth models and should be the longer-lasting choice for adults.
Do Havertys mattresses require a specific box spring?
They work best with a supportive base that keeps the mattress flat and stable. Follow Havertys’ guidance for compatible foundations so you do not risk support issues.
Is there a sleep trial for Havertys mattresses?
Havertys typically uses a comfort-guarantee style window focused on exchanges. The exact rules can depend on your purchase and location, so confirm the timeline and any fees before checkout.
How do Havertys Youth Essentials mattresses compare with cheaper kids’ beds?
The Youth Essentials models felt more structured than many bargain kids mattresses. The Pillow Top version is the softer, more comfortable pick for most kids.
Which Havertys mattress works best for combination sleepers?
The 1885 2.0 Medium Pillow Top was the easiest to move on while still offering pressure relief. It matched the widest range of sleep styles in our group.
Are Havertys mattresses a good value during sales?
When promotions bring pricing down, the 1885 2.0 line can look more competitive within its tier. Value still depends on choosing the right firmness for your body and sleep position.
Should heavier sleepers choose the Havertys firm or medium option?
Firmer support usually works better as body weight rises, and that was true in our testing. If you are heavier but still want a softer top feel, the Medium Pillow Top can work, but the Firm Tight Top is the safer starting point.
