Graco Mattress Reviews (2026)

The Ultra Premium 2-in-1 is the best overall choice. Its infant and toddler sides feel meaningfully different, and the quick-unzip cover is easier to remove than the other zip-off covers. At 12.67 pounds, though, it takes more effort to lift inside a crib.

The Dual Comfort 6-Inch is the better pick when wipe-clean protection matters more than fast cover removal. It keeps the two-stage construction and adds a waterproof sleep surface, but it is still bulky at about 12 pounds.

The Deluxe Foam suits warmer rooms. Its perforated core gives it a small airflow advantage, while its 7-pound weight makes sheet changes easy. It remains a single-sided mattress, and its design is very close to the Premium.

The Premium Foam is the straightforward budget choice. It is light, firm, and easy to handle, but its water-resistant cover needs prompt cleanup and does not replace a waterproof protector.

Each mattress went into the same standard full-size crib frame and toddler-bed setup so we could check fit, corner gaps, sheet tension, and handling. We repeated cover removal, wipe-down, compression, edge, and temperature checks under the same room conditions. Support scores reflect flatness and resistance to uneven sink; pressure-relief scores are only a relative measure of how much more forgiving the toddler surface felt, not a recommendation for a softer infant bed. Cooling, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability were scored on the same five-point scale across all four models.

Our Testing Experience

At 7 pounds, the Premium Foam was the easiest model to lift while pulling a fitted sheet over the corners. Its 52-by-27.6-inch footprint sat snugly in our full-size crib frame, and the foam reached close to its listed 5-inch height after settling.

The surface stayed flat through repeated center and edge presses, which supports its 4.5/5 support score. During a short spill check, the water-resistant cover held moisture on the surface long enough for a quick wipe, but it is not a waterproof barrier. Prompt cleanup still matters. The foam recovered evenly and never developed the cupped feel we noticed on softer toddler surfaces.

What we liked:

• Water-resistant cover gave us time to wipe up small spills

• Seven-pound build was the easiest to lift for sheet changes

• Firm surface stayed even across the center and corners

Who it is best for:

• Parents who want a simple, lightweight crib mattress

• Nurseries where the mattress is lifted often for sheet changes

• Families prioritizing a firm, flat infant sleep surface

Where it falls short:

• Single-sided construction has no separate toddler feel

• Water-resistant cover is not fully waterproof

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $99.99

• Type: Crib & toddler mattress

• Size: Fits a standard full-size crib and toddler bed

• Dimensions: 52" L x 27.6" W x up to 5" H

• Weight: 7 lbs

• Feel: Firm

• Core: 100% polyurethane foam

• Cover: 100% polyester; removable; water-resistant

• Certifications: GREENGUARD Gold; CertiPUR-US

• Care: Removable cover; wash per care instructions

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

The Deluxe is almost as easy to handle as the Premium: both weigh 7 pounds and fit a 52-by-27.6-inch footprint. The Deluxe topped out near its listed 4.5-inch height, so it remained easy to lift clear of the crib rails during sheet changes.

Its main distinction is the perforated foam core. Under the same fitted sheet, the surface warmed a little more slowly than the other single-sided model, matching its 4.2/5 cooling score. The difference was modest, not dramatic. Repeated presses across the middle and corners produced an even rebound, and the firm surface stayed flat instead of folding around the load.

What we liked:

• Perforated foam built up heat more slowly than basic solid foam

• Firm surface stayed level from corner to corner

• Seven-pound build and removable cover simplified routine care

Who it is best for:

• Warmer nurseries where a small airflow advantage helps

• Parents who want firm support without a two-stage design

• Cribs where the mattress is lifted often for sheet changes

Where it falls short:

• Single-sided construction has no separate toddler feel

• Very similar in weight and feel to the Premium Foam

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $99.99

• Type: Crib & toddler mattress

• Size: Fits a standard full-size crib and toddler bed

• Dimensions: 52" L x 28" W x up to 4.5" H

• Weight: 7 lbs

• Feel: Firm

• Core: 100% polyurethane foam (perforated)

• Cover: 100% polyester; removable; water-resistant; washable

• Certifications: GREENGUARD Gold; CertiPUR-US; JPMA

• Care: Removable cover; wash per care instructions

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

The Ultra Premium 2-in-1 felt like the most complete design. Its 52-by-28-inch footprint reached close to the listed 6-inch height, and the denser build stayed level through repeated compression. The infant side held the firm, flat character expected from a crib mattress; the toddler side added a noticeable amount of surface give without becoming plush.

The quick-unzip feature made the water-resistant cover easier to remove for washing, although it still comes off as a cover rather than a small removable patch. At 12.67 pounds, this model took more effort to lift and flip than either 7-pound option. It earned 4.6/5 for support and 4.4/5 for relative pressure relief, the strongest balance in this group, and the foam returned to shape promptly after each compression check.

What we liked:

• Clearly different infant and toddler surfaces

• Quick-unzip design made the cover easier to remove

• Six-inch build stayed level and recovered quickly

Who it is best for:

• Families who expect to remove and wash the cover often

• Parents buying one mattress for crib and toddler-bed stages

• Shoppers who want the best overall balance in this lineup

Where it falls short:

• At 12.67 pounds, it is harder to lift and flip

• Water-resistant cover is not a waterproof sleep surface

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $149.99

• Type: Dual-sided crib & toddler mattress

• Size: Fits a standard full-size crib and toddler bed

• Dimensions: 52" L x 28" W x up to 6" H

• Weight: 12.67 lbs

• Feel: Firm side / softer side

• Core: 100% polyurethane foam

• Cover: 100% polyester; removable; water-resistant; quick unzip

• Certifications: GREENGUARD Gold; CertiPUR-US; JPMA

• Care: Removable cover; wash per care instructions

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

The Dual Comfort arrives fully expanded, so its 52-by-28-inch, 6-inch shape is ready for a fit check as soon as the packaging is off. At about 12 pounds, it felt more substantial than the Premium and Deluxe, but it was also harder to lift while tightening a fitted sheet.

The smooth infant side stayed firm and level across the centerline. The convoluted toddler side allowed a little more surface give while remaining supportive. Edge checks matched its 4.0/5 score: steadier than the thinner models, though not rigid. Its waterproof sleep surface made a quick wipe easier than on the water-resistant covers, but removing the whole cover took more time than it did with the Ultra’s quick-unzip design.

What we liked:

• Smooth infant side and more forgiving toddler side

• Waterproof sleep surface handled quick wipe-downs well

• Six-inch profile felt steady around the perimeter

Who it is best for:

• Parents who want two stages and a waterproof sleep surface

• Children moving from a crib to a toddler bed

• Families who prefer a fully expanded mattress over a rolled one

Where it falls short:

• About 12 pounds and awkward to lift in a tight crib

• Whole-cover removal takes longer than the Ultra’s quick unzip

Pros & Cons

Details

• Price: $139.99

• Type: Dual-sided crib & toddler mattress

• Size: Fits a standard full-size crib and toddler bed

• Dimensions: 52" L x 28" W x 6" H

• Weight: About 12 lbs

• Feel: Firm side / softer side

• Core: 100% polyurethane foam

• Cover: 100% polyester; removable; waterproof sleep surface

• Certifications: GREENGUARD Gold; CertiPUR-US; JPMA

• Care: Removable cover; wash per care instructions

Review Score

The Ultra Premium 2-in-1 leads because it combines top-tier support with the most forgiving toddler side and a cover that is quicker to remove. The Dual Comfort finishes close behind and is the better choice for a waterproof sleep surface. Premium and Deluxe tie overall: Premium has slightly stronger support and edges, while Deluxe gives up a little structural heft for better airflow. Motion isolation is nearly identical across the group because each model uses a foam core.

Start with fit and infant firmness. The mattress should sit snugly in the crib, stay flat under a fitted sheet, and show no damage or lasting indentation. Then decide whether you want one consistent firm surface or a separate toddler side. Premium and Deluxe are easier to lift at 7 pounds; Ultra and Dual Comfort provide a true two-stage design but weigh roughly 12 pounds. For cleanup, Dual Comfort offers a waterproof sleep surface, Ultra has the easiest cover to remove, and Premium and Deluxe use water-resistant covers that need prompt attention. Deluxe is the best of these four for a warm room, though its airflow advantage is modest.

Why choose Graco: These models cover the practical middle of the crib-mattress market. They use firm foam, have removable covers, and cost $99.99 to $149.99 at the verified listings. Graco is especially competitive when low weight or a simple two-stage foam design matters.

Sealy Baby: Sealy is the closest same-price alternative. Current two-stage models such as the Butterfly and Soybean Foam-Core sit around $119.99 to $129.99, and the wider lineup includes foam, fiber, hybrid, and innerspring cores. Choose Sealy if you want more construction choices or a wipe-clean waterproof exterior at a similar price.

Newton Baby: Newton costs considerably more, starting around $199.99 and reaching $349.99 for the waterproof model. Its advantage is a highly breathable polymer core that can be washed along with the cover. It makes sense for families who value full-core washability enough to accept the price jump.

Naturepedic: Naturepedic is also a premium alternative, with current crib mattresses starting around $279. Its focus is certified-organic materials, waterproof protection, and two-stage options. It is the stronger fit for an organic-material priority, while Graco remains the better value choice.

• Let compressed Premium, Deluxe, and Ultra models expand for the full time stated in their instructions; Dual Comfort arrives fully expanded.

• Use only a snug fitted crib sheet on the sleep surface, and recheck the corner fit after every change.

• Rotate single-sided models head to foot; flip two-stage models only when your child is ready for the labeled toddler side.

• Keep a spare fitted sheet ready so a wet one can be removed without delaying the crib reset.

• Before switching a two-stage mattress, confirm the infant and toddler labels instead of judging by feel alone.

• Follow the sewn-in care label for the exact cover version, use a gentle cold wash when allowed, and hang it to dry.

• Do not reinstall a cover until both the cover and mattress surface are completely dry.

• Check all four sides for new gaps, bunching, tears, or lasting indentations whenever you change the sheet.

• If a new mattress has an odor, ventilate the room and wait until the smell has cleared before setting up the crib.

For a fast surface wipe, the Dual Comfort was easiest because its sleep surface is waterproof. For removing and washing the cover, the Ultra Premium 2-in-1 was quicker because of its quick-unzip design. Premium and Deluxe use water-resistant covers, so spills need prompt attention.

Yes. The Ultra Premium 2-in-1 and Dual Comfort both have a clearly firmer infant side and a somewhat more forgiving toddler side. The toddler surfaces still feel supportive; neither is plush.

The Deluxe Foam managed heat best in our comparison. Its perforated foam core warmed more slowly under a fitted sheet than the basic solid-foam models, although the difference was modest.

No. Thickness can make a mattress feel more substantial and can improve handling stability, but safe crib fit and a firm, flat surface matter more. The 7-pound Premium and Deluxe are easier to lift, while the 6-inch models provide two-stage construction at the cost of extra weight.