I wanted to dig into Everton Mattress because this kind of factory-direct regional brand rarely gets deep coverage, even though they run a full production facility in Filer, Idaho and operate stores in Twin Falls and Elko. From the perspective of an American mattress tester, that mix of local manufacturing, white glove delivery, and old-school coil builds raises real questions about support, durability, and value. The phrase “Everton mattress reviews” kept showing up in search logs, yet serious technical breakdowns stayed scarce.
My testing crew stays fixed. I lead the work, then I bring in Marcus Reed for heavier, warm-sleeping feedback, Mia Chen for light side-sleeper pressure checks, and Jenna Brooks for couple testing with her partner Ethan. We rotated across five Everton-built models from MattressRX and the Spring Air by Everton line: Legacy Pillowtop, Lexington HD Plush, Travona HD Firm, Invigorate Firm, and the Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm. Each mattress lived in our actual bedrooms for extended stretches, so impressions came from real nights, not showrooms.
- 1. Product Overview
- 2. Testing Team Takeaways
- 3. Everton Mattress Comparison Chart
- 4. What We Tested and How We Tested It
-
5. Everton Mattress: Our Testing Experience
- 5.1 Everton Legacy Pillowtop – “Everton Budget Pillowtop Starter”
- 5.2 Everton Lexington HD Plush – “Everton Heavy-Duty Plush Workhorse”
- 5.3 Everton Travona HD Firm – “Everton Heavy-Duty Firm Support Champion”
- 5.4 Everton Invigorate Firm – “Everton Copper Hybrid Cooling Powerhouse”
- 5.5 Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm – “Everton Four Seasons Flagship”
- 6. Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
- 7. Best Picks
- 8. How to Choose the Everton Mattress?
- 9. Limitations
- 10. Policies at a Glance
- 11. FAQs
- 12. Related Post
Product Overview
| Mattress | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price* | Overall Score |
| Everton Legacy Pillowtop | Very low price; simple feel that many guests tolerate | Limited support for heavier bodies; basic Bonnell coils | Guest rooms; lighter sleepers who like a softer top | $249–$549 (size dependent) | 3.7 / 5.0 |
| Everton Lexington HD Plush | Strong deep support; plush surface with latex lumbar boost | Taller profile; may feel dense for very small sleepers | Average to heavier sleepers wanting plush but supported feel | $1,399–$2,099 | 4.3 / 5.0 |
| Everton Travona HD Firm | Very firm, heavy-duty build; great alignment for big frames | Too rigid for many side sleepers; break-in takes time | Back / stomach sleepers, larger bodies, people who dislike sink | $1,199–$1,899 | 4.3 / 5.0 |
| Everton Invigorate Firm | Hybrid design; copper and gel foams help with heat | Price sits high for value shoppers | Hot sleepers who still want a firm, responsive feel | $1,499–$2,299 | 4.3 / 5.0 |
| Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm | Flippable, two-season design; strong edge support | Weighty, harder to move; premium cost | Couples, long-term owners, people who want flippable build | $1,499–$2,399 | 4.4 / 5.0 |
Testing Team Takeaways
I moved across these five beds as a late-30s, 5'10", 185-pound combination sleeper with mild lower-back tightness. On the Legacy Pillowtop, my back felt fine for quick naps, yet longer nights revealed a little sag under hips. On the Travona HD Firm, my spine stayed straight during back sleeping, although my shoulders complained when I settled on my side for longer stretches. The Invigorate Firm gave my back the cleanest “held but not locked” alignment; after a week on that hybrid, the usual morning lumbar stiffness eased.
Marcus Reed sits around 6'1" and 230 pounds, and he treats mattresses like load tests. On Legacy, his comment came fast: “My hips drop too far; I’d crush this thing in a year.” He slid to the edge, bounced once, and frowned at the give. The Lexington HD Plush changed his posture completely; he lay flat on his back, then said “This feels like a reset platform; coils push back in the right spots.” The Travona HD Firm turned almost into a tool for him; under his stomach-sleep position, he reported strong hip support and cool surface feel, though he felt forced off his side after thirty minutes.
Mia Chen, at 5'4" and 125 pounds, lives in side-sleep land. She curled into the Legacy Pillowtop and sighed, “This kind of soft pocket hits my shoulders right,” yet she also noticed the thin profile when she rolled near the edge. On the Lexington HD Plush, she described a deeper cradle over the latex-reinforced lumbar area. Pressure slid away from her outer hip, yet she still felt her spine held level. She bounced off the Travona HD Firm quickly; that surface felt flat and unyielding under her small frame. The Jackson Hole Luxury Firm flippable build gave her something more interesting: the “plusher” seasonal face felt cozy for winter-style bedding, while the cooler yarn side felt better after warm showers.
Jenna Brooks, a 5'7", 160-pound combination sleeper, shared every test night with Ethan Cole, who weighs just under 190 pounds and moves constantly. She focuses on motion. On Legacy, Ethan’s twists rippled straight through the Bonnell coils; she complained, “I feel every toe twitch.” On Invigorate Firm, individually wrapped coils and foam layers muted his flops; she reported that quick bathroom trips barely nudged her. The Jackson Hole Luxury Firm sat between those extremes; encased coils and Talalay latex reduced bounce without killing responsiveness, so their shared nights felt stable, yet not dead. She also liked perching at the encased edge to put on socks, where Legacy felt sketchier.
Everton Mattress Comparison Chart
| Mattress | Type | Height | Firmness (1–10)* | Coil System | Main Comfort Materials | Cooling Features | Motion Isolation | Edge Support | Pressure Relief | Responsiveness | Durability Notes | Warranty |
| Everton Legacy Pillowtop | Innerspring with pillow-top | 8″ depth | Approx. 4–5 / 10, soft-medium | Traditional Bonnell coil unit | Basic comfort foams in pillow-top | Thin profile vents heat easily | Low-moderate; coils spread movement | Modest; compression near corners | Gentle at first; flattens under heavy load | High bounce, easy to move | Entry level build; 5-year full replacement | 5-year full replacement |
| Everton Lexington HD Plush | Heavy-duty innerspring | 14″ depth | Around 6 / 10, medium-firm plush | Extra-firm 12¾-gauge coils | Plush quilting with latex lumbar strip | Taller profile breathes; latex resists heat | Moderate; linked coils but thick surface | Strong; tall, firm edge feel | Solid cradle for average and heavier weights | Reactive surface; easier turning | Tufted build for no shifting, 10-year full replacement | 10-year full replacement |
| Everton Travona HD Firm | Heavy-duty firm innerspring | 12″ depth | About 8 / 10, firm | Extra-firm 12¾-gauge coils | Thin padding, latex in lumbar | Firmer surface, efficient airflow | Moderate; firmness damps some motion | Very strong edge, little roll-off | Limited give for lighter side sleepers | Quick response; no stuck feel | Built for longevity with tufting, 10-year warranty | 10-year full replacement |
| Everton Invigorate Firm | Hybrid | 12″ depth | Around 7 / 10, firm | Individually wrapped coils | HD gel memory foam, copper infused foam, gel quilt | Gel foams plus copper for temperature regulation | Good; pocket coils plus foam quilt | Solid; coil perimeter feels supportive | Balanced contour, especially for backs | Mixed foam-and-coil bounce; easy repositioning | Hybrid build with quality foams, 10-year warranty | 10-year full replacement |
| Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm | Flippable hybrid | 15″ depth | Roughly 6.5 / 10, luxury firm | Individually encased coils | Serene foam and Talalay latex layers | Cooling yarns on one face, wool on the other | Good; encased coils and tufting tame bounce | Strong encased edge support | One side slightly plusher; good joint cushioning | Responsive latex feel; controlled spring | Double-sided, tufted, 10-year full replacement | 10-year full replacement |
What We Tested and How We Tested It
Our testing framework stays consistent across brands. I rely on my lower-back tightness and combination-sleep pattern as a kind of built-in sensor. Marcus supplies heavier-body loading, and Mia gives us lighter side-sleeper pressure data. Jenna and Ethan cover couple use.
We grade each mattress using these key metrics: support, pressure relief, cooling, motion isolation, edge support, durability, responsiveness, and value. Support scores depend on spine alignment for different weights in back, side, and stomach positions. Pressure relief scores depend on what shoulders, hips, and knees tell us after longer sessions, especially for Mia.
Cooling scores reflect skin temperature, sweat awareness, and the feel of the quilt during multi-hour stretches. Motion isolation scores come from Jenna’s partner-movement tests; Ethan changes positions repeatedly while Jenna tracks how much of that movement reaches her. We judge edge support by sitting, tying shoes, and sleeping near the lip, then watching for roll-off.
Durability judgments rely on construction clues like coil gauge, tufting, foam density bands when disclosed, and warranty length. Responsiveness scores look at how quickly surfaces rebound after compression and how freely bigger bodies move. Value scores combine build quality, pricing, region-limited competition, and local policies such as MattressRX’s 30-day comfort exchange on qualifying mattresses.
Everton Mattress: Our Testing Experience
Everton Legacy Pillowtop – “Everton Budget Pillowtop Starter”
Our Testing Experience
Legacy arrived first, and I treated it like a baseline. The 8-inch profile looked almost modest beside the taller Everton builds. I dropped onto my back, felt the pillow-top compress under my hips, then the Bonnell coils pushed back in a uniform way. That kind of support felt acceptable for my 185-pound frame during a quick TV session, yet once I stayed flat for an hour, my lower back started whispering about the shallow comfort layer.
Rolling to my side, I noticed soft initial give under my shoulder. The foam quilt let my arm sink enough for reading, although the narrow depth meant my knees hovered closer to the coil unit. The next morning I woke without serious pain, yet there was a faint sense of having slept on something thin and somewhat basic. Legacy felt like an old-school guest bed, not a main long-term ride.
Marcus took a turn and compressed the mattress hard. His words came out fast: “This feels like a starter mattress; my hips drop too far.” Under his 230-pound body, the Bonnell system produced a mild hammock effect in the center. Edge sitting exaggerated that; he parked near the corner, watched the border collapse a little, then stood up with a short shake of his head.
Mia approached Legacy differently. She lay on her side and curled up, saying “I actually like how soft the top feels for a nap.” For her smaller build, the limited depth mattered less, and the pillow-top produced a cozy pocket around her shoulder. Over longer nights, though, she still felt the basic coil structure when she drifted toward the edge. The sound and bounce created a slightly restless energy whenever she tossed between sides.
In short, Legacy behaved like an entry-level Everton Mattress option that fits spare rooms, kids’ rooms, or short-term setups better than primary adult sleep for demanding bodies.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Very affordable way into Everton’s factory-built line | Limited long-term support for heavier or sensitive backs |
| Light, easy to move or rotate in small spaces | Bonnell coils transmit motion and noise across the surface |
| Soft initial feel that many guests tolerate quickly | Edge support feels weaker during sitting or edge sleeping |
Details
- Price range: Typically $249–$549 by size at MattressRX.
- Type: Traditional innerspring pillow-top with comfort foam over Bonnell coils.
- Profile: 8″ thick, including pillow-top panel.
- Firmness feel: Soft-medium; approximate 4–5 / 10 for our testers.
- Available sizes: Twin through Cal King, including RV/Short Queen and Twin XL.
- Support design: Non-zoned Bonnell unit for broad, even pushback.
- Cooling: Thin build allows airflow; no specialty cooling foams.
- Pressure relief focus: Simple foam quilt; adequate for lighter or occasional sleepers.
- Responsiveness: High bounce because of linked coils; easy position changes.
- Motion isolation: Limited; Marcus and Jenna felt partner movement clearly.
- Durability: Entry-level materials; supported by 5-year full replacement warranty.
- Shipping / delivery context: Sold through local stores like MattressRX; delivery offered regionally.
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 3.4 / 5.0 | Works for lighter and average bodies, yet compresses too easily under heavier hips. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.7 / 5.0 | Pillow-top softens impact on shoulders for Mia during short side-sleep sessions. |
| Cooling | 3.8 / 5.0 | Thin profile dumps heat quickly, though fabrics lack advanced cooling tech. |
| Motion Isolation | 3.2 / 5.0 | Bonnell coils spread Ethan’s movements through the frame for Jenna. |
| Edge Support | 3.3 / 5.0 | Sitting at corners feels wobbly for Marcus; lighter bodies fare slightly better. |
| Durability | 3.3 / 5.0 | Entry-level build and shorter warranty support mainly guest-room use. |
| Responsiveness | 4.0 / 5.0 | High bounce makes turning and getting out of bed very easy. |
| Value | 4.5 / 5.0 | Pricing stays low for a made-in-Idaho mattress with factory-direct heritage. |
| Overall Score | 3.7 / 5.0 | Best framed as a budget Everton Mattress for light use or secondary bedrooms. |
Everton Lexington HD Plush – “Everton Heavy-Duty Plush Workhorse”
Our Testing Experience
Lexington HD Plush landed on the frame like a small wall of fabric and steel. At 14 inches tall with extra-firm 12¾-gauge coils and latex in the lumbar, this mattress announces itself as heavy infrastructure. I eased down on my back and felt the plush quilt layer yield, followed by a firmer, organized push under my lower spine.
After one week of full-time use, my lower-back tightness softened. Instead of sinking into a pocket, I rested “on” the bed with a measured amount of surface give. Side sleeping felt a bit more assertive than I usually like, yet my shoulders stayed aligned rather than twisted downward, which surprised me. Sitting up to read, I noticed how the tufting pinned layers together; no shifting, no bunching, just a firm platform under the upper cushion.
Marcus practically claimed Lexington as his default Everton mattress. He lay flat, then rolled to his stomach, and after a long pause he said “This is the reset level I want; everything holds steady.” His heavier frame activated the latex lumbar zone more than mine. The combination of high-gauge coils and that latex strip created a dense, almost industrial feeling foundation under his hips. Edge sitting felt secure; he could tie his shoes at the border without sliding.
Mia approached cautiously, worried that “HD” would equal brick. The surface surprised her. On her side, she felt a gentle cradle before the firmer core appeared underneath. Her quote captured it: “My shoulder gets a pocket, yet my ribs still feel lifted, not sagging.” She did mention that flipping onto her back made the bed feel a little commanding, with less cozy sink than she usually prefers.
Lexington behaves like an Everton Mattress built for daily use in a primary bedroom where durability, support, and a medium-firm plush feel matter more than ultra-soft cushioning.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Strong, heavy-duty support core that suits average and heavier sleepers | Too dense for very light sleepers who want deep hug |
| Latex lumbar strip adds structured mid-back support | Tall profile may require deeper fitted sheets and higher bed height |
| Tufted construction resists sagging and layer shift | Motion isolation stays moderate, not ultra-absorbing |
Details
- Price range: Around $1,399–$2,099 depending on size.
- Type: Heavy-duty innerspring with plush quilt and latex lumbar reinforcement.
- Profile: 14″ total height.
- Firmness feel: Medium-firm plush, around 6 / 10 in our group.
- Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, RV/Short Queen, King, Cal King, and specialty cuts.
- Support design: Extra-firm 12¾-gauge coils plus latex in the lumbar for added uplift.
- Cooling: Taller coil cavity plus latex help temperature drift toward neutral.
- Pressure relief: Plush quilting takes edge off contact points for mid and heavy builds.
- Responsiveness: Coils snap back quickly; no stuck-in-foam sensation.
- Motion isolation: Better than Legacy, still more active than a full foam design.
- Durability: Tufted for stability, backed by 10-year full replacement warranty.
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.6 / 5.0 | Excellent spinal alignment for me and Marcus in back and stomach sleeping. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.4 / 5.0 | Quilted top and latex lumbar relieve load for average and heavy frames. |
| Cooling | 4.1 / 5.0 | Airy coil cavity and latex keep heat under control during longer nights. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.0 / 5.0 | Motion muted enough for calm couples, though still some bounce. |
| Edge Support | 4.4 / 5.0 | Edge sitting feels steady, even under Marcus’s weight. |
| Durability | 4.7 / 5.0 | HD coils, tufting, and 10-year warranty suggest long service life. |
| Responsiveness | 4.3 / 5.0 | Quick rebound supports turning without effort. |
| Value | 4.1 / 5.0 | Pricing tracks the heavy construction; solid choice for long-term use. |
| Overall Score | 4.3 / 5.0 | A sturdy Everton mattress for primary bedrooms where longevity matters. |
Everton Travona HD Firm – “Everton Heavy-Duty Firm Support Champion”
Our Testing Experience
Travona HD Firm feels like Lexington’s stricter sibling. Same heavy-duty coil philosophy, yet with a thinner comfort stack and clearly firmer tension. I lay on my back first; my lower spine lined up perfectly, and my hips felt locked into place. For my combination style, that support felt fantastic during work-week nights when I stayed mostly on my back.
Side sleeping produced a different story. After twenty minutes with my shoulder buried into the surface, I felt pressure creep up toward my neck. No sharp pain, yet a clear pushback that encouraged flipping. On my stomach, Travona excelled; my hips did not dip, even after long naps. That kind of firmness suits people who dislike any hammock sensation.
Marcus loved Travona in a almost clinical way. He dropped on his stomach, then grinned slightly and said “This is as firm as I’d go for real sleep; hips stay level.” He moved from center to edge and had nearly the same experience there. The border barely compressed, which gave him confidence for sitting or tying shoes at the very lip.
Mia lasted one night. She rolled off the bed in the morning and announced “My shoulder feels like it pressed into a gym floor.” Her lighter frame never sank deeply enough to reach a gentle cradle. For her, this mattress works only as a short nap surface or for sitting, not as a dedicated side-sleep platform.
Travona slots into the Everton Mattress range as the firmest mainstream pick here, aimed at back and stomach sleepers, especially heavier ones, who want a stiff, durable surface.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Extremely firm, stable feel that supports bigger bodies and stomach sleepers | Too rigid for many side sleepers, especially lighter people |
| Heavy-duty coils and tufting create a long-lived workhorse | Break-in period feels unforgiving during first weeks |
| Edge remains strong under sitting and sleeping loads | Limited contouring; comfort feels more “flat” than cushioned |
Details
- Price range: About $1,199–$1,899 depending on size.
- Type: Heavy-duty firm innerspring with latex lumbar pad.
- Profile: 12″ thick.
- Firmness feel: Around 8 / 10, clearly firm.
- Sizes: Twin through Cal King plus RV/Short Queen and specialty cuts.
- Support design: Extra-firm 12¾-gauge coils with tufting and latex lumbar reinforcement.
- Cooling: Firm surface and open coil cavity keep heat manageable.
- Pressure relief: Limited; designed for support first.
- Responsiveness: Quick surface recovery, suitable for active movers.
- Motion isolation: Moderate; firmness damps some partner movement, yet coils still relay energy.
- Durability: Built for extended service life, backed by 10-year full replacement warranty.
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.8 / 5.0 | Holds hips and spine level even for Marcus’s frame. |
| Pressure Relief | 3.6 / 5.0 | Too flat for Mia’s side sleeping; fine for back and stomach. |
| Cooling | 4.2 / 5.0 | Firmness and coil cavity prevent heat buildup during long nights. |
| Motion Isolation | 3.9 / 5.0 | Some motion travel remains, though stiffness reduces big waves. |
| Edge Support | 4.7 / 5.0 | Edges feel almost as strong as the center when sitting or lying. |
| Durability | 4.8 / 5.0 | Heavy coils, tufting, and warranty hint at serious longevity. |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 / 5.0 | Fast rebound; good for people who turn often. |
| Value | 4.2 / 5.0 | Excellent for heavy sleepers needing firmness and durability. |
| Overall Score | 4.3 / 5.0 | A specialist Everton mattress for firm-surface fans and bigger bodies. |
Everton Invigorate Firm – “Everton Copper Hybrid Cooling Powerhouse”
Our Testing Experience
Invigorate Firm shifts the Everton lineup into modern hybrid territory. Under the quilt sit HD gel-infused memory foam, copper-infused foam, then individually wrapped coils. I lay down on my back and felt the quilt compress gently, then a slower, slightly denser sink from the gel layer. Under that, the coils pushed back individually rather than as one big unit.
During the first week, I noticed something important for my desk-tight lower back. After long evening laptop sessions in bed, my lumbar region stayed supported without that locked-in concrete feeling. When I rolled onto my side, my shoulder dipped in just enough to avoid sharp pressure, yet my ribs and waist did not collapse downward.
Marcus, who usually runs hot, picked up on the copper and gel combo quickly. His line summed it up: “This one runs cooler across my back; I stay on the surface, not in a swamp.” He still preferred the unyielding stability of Travona for strict stomach nights, yet he treated Invigorate as the better all-round performer for mixed positions.
Jenna and Ethan used Invigorate as a couple platform. Pocket coils and foams did their job; Ethan’s restless turns translated into short, muted waves rather than full-frame ripples. She reported, “You move, but I feel a smaller echo, not a full shove.” Edge sitting felt solid enough, though not as iron-clad as Travona’s border.
For people chasing Everton mattress reviews focused on hybrids, Invigorate Firm stands out as the brand’s cooling and motion-balanced workhorse.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Hybrid design combines contour, support, and temperature control | Price lands on the higher side for a regional brand |
| Pocket coils improve motion control for couples | Firm feel can feel stiff for those who want deep plushness |
| Copper and gel foams help warm sleepers stay more comfortable | Heavy build feels harder to move without help |
Details
- Price range: Roughly $1,499–$2,299 by size.
- Type: Hybrid mattress with foam comfort stack and wrapped coil support.
- Profile: About 12″ thick.
- Firmness feel: Firm, near 7 / 10.
- Sizes: Twin through Cal King plus RV/Short queen and specialty cuts.
- Support design: Individually wrapped coil core, tuned for point-by-point pushback.
- Cooling: HD gel memory foam, copper-infused foam, and gel-stitched quilt target temperature regulation.
- Pressure relief: Balanced contour that suits back and mixed sleepers well.
- Responsiveness: Hybrid bounce; faster than pure memory foam.
- Motion isolation: Better containment of partner movement than Bonnell or open coil beds.
- Durability: Quality hybrid stack with 10-year full replacement warranty.
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.5 / 5.0 | Keeps my and Marcus’s spines neutral in multiple positions. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.2 / 5.0 | Foam stack softens contact points without excess sink. |
| Cooling | 4.7 / 5.0 | Copper and gel layout keeps warm backs happier through the night. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.3 / 5.0 | Ethan’s movement reached Jenna less; pocket coils help. |
| Edge Support | 4.2 / 5.0 | Sitting and half-sleeping near the edge felt stable. |
| Durability | 4.4 / 5.0 | Hybrid build and warranty imply solid lifespan. |
| Responsiveness | 4.4 / 5.0 | Quick rebound makes movement easy for active sleepers. |
| Value | 4.0 / 5.0 | Pricing feels justified for people who need hybrid cooling and support. |
| Overall Score | 4.3 / 5.0 | A key Everton hybrid for hot sleepers and mixed-position users. |
Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm – “Everton Four Seasons Flagship”
Our Testing Experience
Jackson Hole Luxury Firm arrives as part of the Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons series, and it plays in a different league. The mattress stands 15 inches tall, uses individually encased coils, features Serene comfort foam plus Talalay latex, and flips for seasonal use. One side carries cooling yarns aimed at warmer months; the other side includes natural wool fibers for cooler seasons.
I started on the “cool” side. My back felt supported in a medium-firm way, with the latex giving a slight buoyant lift. Heat never pooled under my lower back during long nights, even with heavy covers. When I flipped to the wool side after a linen change, the surface picked up a faintly cozier feel, ideal for cold-weather bedding stacks. My spine still stayed aligned, which matters more than any marketing story about seasons.
Jenna and Ethan turned this mattress into their main couple test bed. Encased coils and the tufted, double-sided build offered stable motion behavior; Ethan’s signature restless spin produced smaller disturbances than on Legacy or even Lexington. She described it as “a deep, steady platform; I feel you move, yet the bed stays composed.” The encased edge let both of them sprawl toward the sides without collapse.
Mia approached Jackson Hole from a side-sleep perspective. On the cooling side, she felt a firm but forgiving cradle. Her shoulders dipped in enough to relieve pressure, yet the latex layer pushed back slightly, which helped her neck alignment. On the wool side, she perceived a hint more plushness around her hip. She said, “This feels like winter bedding layering baked into the mattress itself.”
Jackson Hole sits in this Everton Mattress ecosystem as the premium, flippable hybrid for couples and long-term owners who want a single mattress to handle seasonal shifts.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Flippable, two-season design extends comfort life and tuning options | Very heavy; flipping requires at least two capable adults |
| Strong encased edge and encased coils suit couples who spread out | Premium pricing pushes it out of tight budgets |
| Latex and Serene foam mix create balanced comfort and support | Feels too firm for users seeking ultra-plush pillow-top sink |
Details
- Price range: Approximately $1,499–$2,399.
- Type: Flippable hybrid with individually encased coils, Serene foam, and Talalay latex.
- Profile: 15″ thick.
- Firmness feel: Luxury firm, around 6.5 / 10 for our team.
- Sizes: Twin through Cal King, including RV/Short Queen and specialty cuts.
- Support design: Encased coils plus latex, tuned for strong mid-section support.
- Cooling: Cooling yarns on one face, natural wool on the other for seasonal tuning.
- Pressure relief: Balanced feel; enough contour for side sleepers, yet no deep sink.
- Responsiveness: Latex gives buoyant, quick rebound.
- Motion isolation: Encased coils and thick comfort stack keep couple movement under control.
- Edge support: Foam-encased edge lets sleepers use more of the surface.
- Durability: Double-sided, tufted build with 10-year full replacement warranty.
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.6 / 5.0 | Keeps my spine neutral on both seasonal sides. |
| Pressure Relief | 4.3 / 5.0 | Mia’s shoulders and hips stay comfortable at night. |
| Cooling | 4.6 / 5.0 | Cooling yarn side and wool side handle different seasons effectively. |
| Motion Isolation | 4.2 / 5.0 | Ethan’s movement reaches Jenna less than on springier beds. |
| Edge Support | 4.5 / 5.0 | Encased edge feels trustworthy for sitting and sleeping near the border. |
| Durability | 4.8 / 5.0 | Double-sided design and tufting promise long usable life. |
| Responsiveness | 4.3 / 5.0 | Latex bounce keeps the surface lively without chaos. |
| Value | 4.1 / 5.0 | Pricey, yet the flippable design stretches utility. |
| Overall Score | 4.4 / 5.0 | A flagship Everton-associated mattress for couples and long-term planners. |
Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness |
| Everton Legacy Pillowtop | 3.7 | 3.4 | 3.7 | 3.8 | 3.2 | 3.3 | 4.0 |
| Everton Lexington HD Plush | 4.3 | 4.6 | 4.4 | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.7 | 4.3 |
| Everton Travona HD Firm | 4.3 | 4.8 | 3.6 | 4.2 | 3.9 | 4.8 | 4.4 |
| Everton Invigorate Firm | 4.3 | 4.5 | 4.2 | 4.7 | 4.3 | 4.4 | 4.4 |
| Spring Air by Everton Jackson Hole Luxury Firm | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.3 | 4.6 | 4.2 | 4.8 | 4.3 |
Jackson Hole and Invigorate form the most balanced performers, mixing strong support, cooling, and durability. Travona looks like a specialist tool for firm-surface lovers who value spine alignment over plushness. Legacy trails the pack yet still occupies a role as a budget, highly responsive Everton option for light use.
Best Picks
-
Best Everton Mattress Reviews Pick for Heavy Sleepers: Everton Travona HD Firm
Travona stabilizes big frames during back and stomach sleep and keeps edges rock solid. Marcus felt especially secure here, with hips holding level and no sag even after long sessions. -
Best Everton Mattress Reviews Pick for Hot Sleepers: Everton Invigorate Firm
Invigorate’s copper and gel stack, plus hybrid airflow, handled Marcus’s heat complaints better than the coil-only builds. The firm yet contouring feel gave my lower back a comfortable cradle without turning sticky. -
Best Everton Mattress Reviews Pick for Couples: Spring Air by Everton Four Seasons Jackson Hole Luxury Firm
Jackson Hole combined encased coils, latex bounce, and strong edge support in a way that kept Jenna and Ethan on stable footing. Their motion tests showed calmer nights than on Legacy or Lexington, especially once they tuned the seasonal side to current bedding.
How to Choose the Everton Mattress?
Choosing among these Everton Mattress models comes down to weight, sleep position, temperature, and budget. People must also consider how long they want the mattress to last and whether they share the bed.
-
Light-weight side sleeper
A smaller person like Mia often needs a softer surface for shoulders and hips. Legacy Pillowtop works for lighter bodies on a budget, yet Lexington HD Plush offers better long-term support with enough quilted softness. Jackson Hole on its slightly plusher wool side also fits if budget allows. -
Average-weight back sleeper
For someone near my size who mainly sleeps on the back, Lexington HD Plush and Invigorate Firm stand out. Lexington provides a dense, traditional coil feel with latex lumbar support, while Invigorate balances contour and cooling through its hybrid stack. -
Hot sleeper in any position
Heat-sensitive users should look first at Invigorate Firm, then Jackson Hole’s cooling side. Copper and gel foams in Invigorate tackle warmth directly, and Jackson Hole adds cooling yarns plus airy encased coils. -
Heavier couple spreading across the mattress
A heavier pair, especially if one partner tosses around, benefits from Jackson Hole Luxury Firm or Invigorate Firm. Encased edges and pocket coils keep surface area usable, while motion control prevents constant disturbance. -
Strict stomach sleeper with higher body weight
Travona HD Firm offers the flattest, most rigid support platform in this group. Marcus’s hips stayed level here, which matters for stomach sleep where any sag can torque the lower back. -
Budget shopper furnishing a spare room
For tight budgets or guest spaces, Legacy Pillowtop still has a role. It keeps up Everton’s factory-direct identity, carries a 5-year full replacement warranty, and remains easy to move into tight spaces.
Limitations
As a group, these Everton Mattress models target people who live within driving distance of Idaho or nearby areas, since Everton operates as a regional retailer with local delivery and white glove service. This structure leaves distant shoppers with limited buying paths.
Very heavy sleepers who want extremely plush yet durable surfaces may feel underserved here, since the heaviest-duty builds lean firm rather than cloud-soft. Side sleepers under Mia’s weight who demand deep contour may also find Travona and sometimes Lexington more rigid than they want.
Ultra-low-budget shoppers hoping for sub-$500 queen hybrids will struggle beyond Legacy; Invigorate and Jackson Hole move into premium territory. Short home trials also limit experimentation, because local stores like MattressRX often use a 30-day comfort exchange framework rather than long online trials.
Policies at a Glance
| Mattress | Shipping (Cost & Region) | Trial Period | Return Policy / Fees | Warranty Length | Notable Conditions |
| Everton Legacy Pillowtop | Local delivery through retailers such as MattressRX in Idaho; fees vary by store. | Typically covered under in-store comfort exchange only, if price threshold met. | MattressRX lists a 30-day comfort exchange on qualifying mattresses; non-qualifying purchases may have limited returns. | 5-year full replacement warranty listed on product page. | Warranty claims often run through store; proof of purchase and law tag required, with photos during claims. |
| Everton Lexington HD Plush | Local delivery and white glove setup available in regional markets via retail partners. | Comfort exchange typically up to 30 days for qualifying price tiers; no long home trial. | Exchanges usually limited to one comfort swap; additional fees may apply in some stores. | 10-year full replacement warranty. | Must maintain mattress in good condition; stains or improper foundations can complicate claims. |
| Everton Travona HD Firm | Similar regional delivery options, sometimes with white glove service. | Comfort exchange policies match Lexington in most MattressRX scenarios. | Returns outside warranty usually processed as exchanges within time limit only. | 10-year full replacement warranty. | Warranty replacements require documentation and photos of sag or defects. |
| Everton Invigorate Firm | Delivered locally through MattressRX and similar outlets; doorstep or setup options offered. | Comfort exchange window around 30 days for qualifying purchases; exact terms vary. | May include restocking or redelivery fees depending on retailer policy. | 10-year full replacement warranty on the hybrid design. | Copper and gel foams fall under standard manufacturer defect rules, not wear-and-tear complaints. |
| Spring Air by Everton Jackson Hole Luxury Firm | Sold through MattressRX with local delivery in Idaho; heavy build usually delivered and installed by crew. | Same local comfort exchange structure; no long nationwide trial. | Return path normally routes through retailer and Spring Air’s warranty framework. | 10-year full replacement warranty. | Flippable design requires owner flipping for even wear; warranty expects proper rotation. |
Within this ecosystem, Jackson Hole and the HD Everton models offer the clearest long-term protection through 10-year full replacement warranties. Legacy carries a shorter term aligned with its budget status, while all models share the same regional pattern: local delivery, limited comfort-exchange windows, and more complex return paths than big direct-to-consumer brands.
FAQs
1. Are Everton mattresses good for side sleepers?
Side sleepers with lighter bodies land in a mixed zone here. Mia felt comfortable on Legacy for short stretches and enjoyed Lexington’s plusher quilt, yet Travona ran too firm for her shoulders. Jackson Hole on the wool side handled her side-sleep posture best by balancing latex support and foam cushioning.
2. Which Everton Mattress stays coolest at night?
Invigorate Firm gave Marcus the most reliable heat relief. Copper-infused foam, HD gel memory foam, and a gel-stitched quilt moved warmth away from his back more effectively than the coil-only builds. Jackson Hole’s cooling side also performed well, especially under heavier bedding stacks.
3. How long can I expect an Everton mattress to last?
The HD and hybrid models with 10-year full replacement warranties feel built for long service lives. Lexington and Travona use heavy-duty coils and tufting, while Invigorate adds pocketed coils and higher-grade foams. Legacy’s 5-year warranty and simpler construction make it better for light-duty roles rather than decade-long primary use.
4. Do Everton mattresses isolate motion well for couples?
Motion control tracks the coil type. Legacy’s Bonnell system sends Ethan’s turns straight through the frame, which bothered Jenna. Hybrids and encased-coil designs like Invigorate and Jackson Hole control movement more tightly. Jenna slept more peacefully on those models, even with Ethan shifting repeatedly.
5. Are Everton mattresses suitable for heavier people?
Heavier sleepers like Marcus found Lexington HD Plush and Travona HD Firm particularly stable. Those extra-firm coils and latex lumbar zones held hips level across the entire surface. Jackson Hole also managed heavier weight well, especially near the edges, thanks to encased coils and a solid perimeter. Lighter models, especially Legacy, felt outmatched under heavier frames.
6. How do Everton Mattress policies compare with big online brands?
Everton operates as a regional factory-direct retailer, so buyers interact with local stores rather than broad e-commerce systems. Dweva’s analysis points out shorter, more complex return paths and limited trial structures compared with online players that often advertise 100-night or longer trials. People who want hands-on showroom testing and local white glove delivery may still favor this setup.
7. Is the white glove delivery worth it for these mattresses?
For tall, heavy models like Lexington, Travona, Invigorate, and Jackson Hole, white glove delivery helps quite a bit. Everton’s own site highlights professional delivery and installation in their service area. Our team would not want to flip Jackson Hole without another person present because of its double-sided, 15-inch build.
8. Which Everton mattress offers the best value for money?
Value changes with use case. Legacy wins for guest rooms or starter setups. Travona and Lexington deliver strong value for heavier or back-focused sleepers who intend to keep the mattress for many years. Invigorate’s price feels justified only if cooling and hybrid feel really matter. Jackson Hole justifies its cost for couples who will actually flip and maintain the mattress over time.
9. How firm do these Everton beds feel in real use?
Legacy lands soft-medium. Lexington hovers in the medium-firm plush range. Travona stands clearly firm, almost orthopedic in effect. Invigorate sits between Lexington and Travona, with foam-aided contour yet firm underlying support. Jackson Hole’s luxury firm feel splits the difference between sturdy and accommodating, especially with the two seasonal faces.
10. Are Everton mattresses easy to move or rotate?
Legacy, with its 8-inch build and simpler coil unit, moves easily and rotates without drama. The HD line and the hybrids feel significantly heavier; Marcus and I needed two-person lifts for safe rotation. Jackson Hole’s flippable structure demands teamwork because of its height and double-sided build. People who move frequently or live alone should weigh that factor before choosing the heaviest models.
