Aaron’s carries a broad rent-to-own mattress lineup, but a handful of models show up again and again for shoppers who want straightforward comfort without overthinking specs. We tested four popular picks—two coil-based options and two foam beds-in-a-box—scoring support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability. Expect the best balance from the Beautyrest hybrid, while the ultra-plush foam option trades structure for sink-in softness.
Product Overview
| Mattress | Overall Score | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price |
| Beautyrest Select Hybrid Medium Tight Top | 4.4 | Strong support with adaptable contouring | Not the most “dead quiet” for motion | Back/combination sleepers who want lift + cushion | $809.98 |
| Lane 12" Pillow Top Medium Plush with Foundation | 4.0 | Comfort-forward feel with solid edge presence | Noticeable bounce when a partner moves | People who like a cushier, traditional surface | $521.96 |
| Serta 12" Sheep Dreams Memory Foam Mattress in a Box | 3.8 | Excellent motion damping and pressure relief | Slower response when changing positions | Light-to-average sleepers, movement-sensitive partners | $954.98 |
| Sierra Sleep by Ashley 12" Chime Ultra Plush Memory Foam | 3.7 | Deep, cozy pressure relief | Edge and long-session support are limited | Side sleepers who want maximum sink-in softness | $425.98 |
Testing Team Takeaways
We rotated these mattresses through a shared test room and normal home nights. Marcus (6'1", 230 lbs) gravitated to the Beautyrest hybrid because it kept his hips level and felt less “trappy” than the foams. Jenna and Ethan slept most consistently on the Serta Sheep Dreams because the foam muted turn-and-return movement. I got the cleanest lumbar “reset” on the Lane pillow top, but the bounce showed up the moment a partner shifted. The Chime was cozy, yet too sinky for long laptop sessions.
Aaron's Mattress Comparison Chart
| Category | Beautyrest Select Hybrid Medium Tight Top | Lane 12" Pillow Top Medium Plush with Foundation | Serta 12" Sheep Dreams Memory Foam Mattress in a Box | Sierra Sleep by Ashley 12" Chime Ultra Plush Memory Foam |
| Type | Hybrid (coils + foams) | Innerspring with pillow top | All-foam | All-foam |
| Firmness | Medium | Medium Plush | Medium | Ultra Plush |
| Profile | 13" (listed) | 12" | 12" | 12" |
| Core support | 825 Series Pocketed Coil system | Duraspring coil system with edge guard | Foam core | Firm support foam base |
| Comfort layers | Gel memory foam and GelTouch foam (listed) | Comfort foam layers | 3" gel memory foam + 2" transitional foam | Thick memory foam layer |
| Cooling features (listed) | Gel foams; airflow from coils | Breathable surface feel from coil structure | “Cooling layer” not tagged; gel memory foam noted | Not positioned as cooling-focused |
| Motion isolation (test) | Good | Fair | Excellent | Excellent |
| Edge support (test) | Good | Good | Fair | Below average |
| Responsiveness (test) | Quick | Quick-moderate | Slow-moderate | Slow |
| Mattress-in-a-box | No | No | Yes | Compressed shipping noted |
| Warranty (listed) | 10-year limited warranty | - | - | - |
How We Tested It
We slept on each mattress long enough to see how it settled in, then repeated the same check-ins: Support, Cooling, Pressure Relief, Motion Isolation, Responsiveness, Edge Support, and Durability. I focused on lumbar support during full nights plus long “awake-in-bed” blocks. Marcus stressed hip support and heat buildup, then re-checked edge stability while sitting. Jenna and Ethan did partner-movement nights, tracking wakeups and how quickly the surface “re-stabilized.”
Aaron's Mattress: Our Testing Experience
Beautyrest Select Hybrid Medium Tight Top
Our Testing Experience
The first thing I noticed was how the surface stayed level when I moved from back to side—my hips didn’t dip, and my lower back didn’t feel like it was “searching” for support. Marcus immediately tested the perimeter by sitting to lace shoes; it held up without that sudden slide-off sensation. Jenna and Ethan did their usual partner routine—one climbs in, one rolls over, one gets up—and we could feel movement, but it was contained enough that sleep wasn’t constantly interrupted.
What we liked
- Balanced lift and contouring that stayed consistent through the night
- A stable edge for sitting and getting in/out of bed
- Easy position changes without feeling stuck
Who it is best for
- Combination sleepers who rotate between back and side
- Heavier sleepers who hate “hammocking”
- Couples who want a responsive feel without constant wobble
Where it falls short
- Not the quietest option for motion compared with all-foam
- Those who want a slow, deep “hug” may find it too buoyant
- Plush-only shoppers may want a softer surface feel
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Support stays level under hips and lower back | More partner-motion feel than memory foam |
| Quick responsiveness for turning and repositioning | Not a deep “sink-in” surface |
| Edge feels stable for sitting and edge-sleeping | Coil bounce can be noticeable to very light sleepers |
| Good blend of pressure relief and structure | - |
Details
- Price: $809.98
- Firmness: Medium
- Size tested: Queen
- Type: Hybrid (pocketed coils + foams)
- Mattress top: Tight Top
- Profile: 13" (listed)
- Support system: 825 Series Pocketed Coil system
- Comfort layers: GelTouch foam; gel memory foam is also referenced in the listing
- Adjustable base compatible: Yes
- Included items: Mattress; mattress protector
- Warranty: 10-year limited warranty
- Delivery/setup (leasing): Free delivery and set up
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.6 | Strong, level support that prevented hip dip for heavier sleepers |
| Pressure Relief | 4.4 | Cushioning was noticeable without losing alignment |
| Cooling | 4.2 | Less heat buildup than the all-foam options in our rooms |
| Motion Isolation | 4.1 | Contained movement well, but coils still register in partner tests |
| Responsiveness | 4.5 | Easy turning and repositioning without “effort” |
| Edge Support | 4.4 | Stable sit-and-stand edge and usable outer third |
| Durability | 4.5 | Coil-based structure kept its feel consistent across weeks |
| Overall Score | 4.4 | Best all-around balance for mixed sleepers and couples |
Lane 12" Pillow Top Medium Plush Queen Mattress with Foundation
Our Testing Experience
This one felt familiar in the best way: you lie down and immediately get that cushioned pillow-top welcome, then the deeper support shows up a second later. After long desk days, I liked how my lower back settled into a calmer, flatter posture—less “floating,” more grounded. Marcus tested for sag by lying on his stomach; it stayed supportive, though he could feel more surface give than he prefers. When Jenna and Ethan did partner nights, the bounce was the headline: comfortable, but you notice motion when someone climbs in or turns over.
What we liked
- A plush-on-top feel that still transitions into sturdy support
- Stronger edge confidence than the foam beds for sitting
- A straightforward “sleep-on-top” sensation that’s easy to adjust to
Who it is best for
- People who want a softer surface without an ultra-plush sink
- Back sleepers who like a cushioned top with coil lift underneath
- Guest rooms where “classic mattress feel” matters
Where it falls short
- Motion transfer is more obvious than on all-foam
- Heavier sleepers may want a firmer comfort layer
- Light sleepers may wake up to partner movement
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Pillow-top comfort feels immediately inviting | More bounce and partner-motion feel |
| Edge guard helps with sitting and edge use | Not as pressure-cradling as thick memory foam |
| Easy to move on; doesn’t feel sticky | May feel too plush for heavier stomach sleepers |
| Foundation included in this set | - |
Details
- Price: $521.96
- Firmness: Medium Plush
- Size tested: Queen
- Type: Innerspring with pillow top
- Mattress top: Pillow Top
- Profile: 12"
- Support system: Duraspring coil system with edge guard
- Comfort layers: Comfort foam (listed)
- Adjustable base compatible: Yes
- Included items: Mattress; mattress protector; box spring; box spring/foundation cover
- Delivery/setup (leasing): Free delivery and set up
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 4.1 | Good lift with a softer top; heavier sleepers may prefer firmer |
| Pressure Relief | 4.0 | Cushioned enough for most backs, less conforming than memory foam |
| Cooling | 4.0 | Felt less heat-trappy than the plush foams in our testing |
| Motion Isolation | 3.6 | Partner movement is noticeable due to coil bounce |
| Responsiveness | 4.0 | Easy turning; doesn’t resist movement |
| Edge Support | 4.2 | Edge guard translated to reliable sitting stability |
| Durability | 3.9 | Held shape well, but plush tops can show wear sooner over time |
| Overall Score | 4.0 | Comfortable, classic feel with a predictable trade-off on motion |
Serta 12" Sheep Dreams Memory Foam Queen Mattress in a Box
Our Testing Experience
This mattress was the quietest at night. When I lay down on my side, my shoulder sank in smoothly, and the surface stopped moving almost immediately after I changed positions. Jenna and Ethan loved that: when one of them got up, the other didn’t get the “wave” effect. The downside showed up in the morning transitions—rolling out of the center took a little more intent, especially after the foam warmed up. Marcus tested the edge by sitting and shifting his weight; it compressed more than the coil options, but still felt usable for normal mornings.
What we liked
- Strong motion isolation that made partner nights calmer
- Pressure relief from the gel memory foam comfort layer
- A steady, medium feel that didn’t collapse under normal movement
Who it is best for
- Couples who are sensitive to each other’s movement
- Side sleepers who want gentle shoulder/hip cushioning
- People who like a slower, calmer surface feel
Where it falls short
- Edge support is softer than coil-based models
- Not as quick or springy for frequent position changes
- Hot sleepers may want more airflow than an all-foam build provides
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Excellent motion damping for partners | Slower response when turning or getting up |
| Gel memory foam adds noticeable pressure relief | Softer edge compression than coil designs |
| Medium feel works for a wide range of sleepers | Less “lift” under heavier hips than hybrid options |
| Convenient mattress-in-a-box format | - |
Details
- Price: $954.98
- Firmness: Medium
- Size tested: Queen
- Type: All-foam
- Mattress top: Tight Top
- Profile: 12"
- Comfort layers: 3" gel memory foam; 2" transitional support foam; 7" foam core
- Cover features: Antimicrobial cover noted
- Mattress-in-a-box: Yes
- Cooling layer tag: No
- Included items: Mattress in a box; mattress protector
- Delivery/setup (leasing): Free delivery and set up
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 3.8 | Supportive for average builds; heavier hips sink more than on hybrids |
| Pressure Relief | 4.2 | Noticeable cushioning at shoulders and hips |
| Cooling | 3.6 | Comfortable, but airflow is limited compared with coil-based beds |
| Motion Isolation | 4.6 | Best performer for partner movement and vibration control |
| Responsiveness | 3.4 | Memory foam feel slows down quick turns |
| Edge Support | 3.5 | Edges compress under sitting weight more than coil options |
| Durability | 3.7 | Held up well in our run, with typical all-foam sensitivity to body impressions |
| Overall Score | 3.8 | Best for motion control and pressure relief, less ideal for quick movers |
Sierra Sleep by Ashley 12" Chime Ultra Plush Memory Foam Queen Mattress
Our Testing Experience
This was the “exhale” mattress. The moment I lay down, the top felt soft and compliant, and it was easy to understand why side sleepers chase an ultra-plush surface. My shoulders dropped in without a fight, and the bed did a great job muting little movements—Ethan described it as “quiet under me.” Then we ran into the practical stuff: sitting on the edge to put on socks felt less secure, and when I used my laptop in bed, I could feel myself slowly settling into a curved posture. Marcus, in particular, felt like his hips sank past the point where support felt clean.
What we liked
- Deep pressure relief for shoulders and outer hips
- Excellent motion isolation in partner-style movement tests
- A soft surface that feels cozy right away
Who it is best for
- Side sleepers who want maximum plushness
- People who prioritize motion damping over bounce
- Guest rooms where “soft and inviting” is the goal
Where it falls short
- Edge support is limited for sitting and edge-sleeping
- Heavier sleepers may sink too deeply at the hips
- Long awake-in-bed sessions can feel less posture-friendly
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Ultra-plush comfort feel is immediately noticeable | Edge compresses more than the other models |
| Excellent motion isolation | Can feel too sinky for heavier bodies |
| Good pressure relief for side sleeping | Less supportive for long sitting/reading sessions |
| Adjustable base compatible (listed) | - |
Details
- Price: $425.98
- Firmness: Ultra Plush
- Size tested: Queen
- Type: All-foam
- Mattress top: Tight Top
- Profile: 12"
- Comfort description: Thick memory foam layer over firm support foam
- Cover: Stretch knit cover
- Adjustable base compatible: Yes
- Included items: Mattress; mattress protector
- Delivery/setup (leasing): Free delivery and set up
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Support | 3.5 | Soft feel can pull hips out of neutral alignment for heavier sleepers |
| Pressure Relief | 4.4 | Best “cushion” feel for shoulders and hips in side sleeping |
| Cooling | 3.3 | Plusher foam held more warmth than the hybrid in our sessions |
| Motion Isolation | 4.7 | Top performer for dampening partner movement |
| Responsiveness | 3.3 | Slower recovery; turning takes more effort than coil models |
| Edge Support | 3.2 | Edge sitting feels less secure than on the coil-based options |
| Durability | 3.5 | Ultra-plush foams tend to show wear sooner under concentrated weight |
| Overall Score | 3.7 | Best for plush comfort and motion control, weaker on structure |
Compare Performance Scores of These Mattresses
| Mattress | Overall Score | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness | Edge Support |
| Beautyrest Select Hybrid Medium Tight Top | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.4 | 4.2 | 4.1 | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4.4 |
| Lane 12" Pillow Top Medium Plush with Foundation | 4.0 | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.0 | 3.6 | 3.9 | 4.0 | 4.2 |
| Serta 12" Sheep Dreams Memory Foam Mattress in a Box | 3.8 | 3.8 | 4.2 | 3.6 | 4.6 | 3.7 | 3.4 | 3.5 |
| Sierra Sleep by Ashley 12" Chime Ultra Plush Memory Foam | 3.7 | 3.5 | 4.4 | 3.3 | 4.7 | 3.5 | 3.3 | 3.2 |
On the numbers, the Beautyrest is the most evenly strong performer, with no weak category. The Lane is close behind, but its motion score explains why partner sleepers noticed bounce. The two all-foam models clearly dominate motion isolation; between them, the Serta is more balanced overall, while the Chime wins on plush pressure relief but gives back points on edge and support.
How to Choose the Aaron's Mattress?
Choose based on sleeping style and how sensitive your household is to movement. If you want the most balanced feel, go Beautyrest Select Hybrid. If you want a classic, cushioned top and solid edge for daily routines, choose Lane Pillow Top. For couples who wake up easily, Serta Sheep Dreams keeps movement quieter. For lightweight side sleepers craving maximum softness, Chime Ultra Plush is the coziest, but it’s not ideal for heavier bodies.
Limitations
These mattresses trade off in predictable ways: coil-based options feel more responsive but transmit more motion, while the foam beds isolate motion better but soften at the edges and can feel warmer. Dr. Adrian Walker generally prefers designs that keep hips level; by that lens, ultra-plush foams are most likely to bother people who already struggle with low-back tightness after long sitting. Anyone who spends hours reading or working in bed should avoid overly sinky surfaces.
Aaron's Mattress Vs. Alternatives
Why choose these models
- Convenient rent-to-own structure for shoppers who want predictable payments
- Mattress protectors are part of the standard setup, which helps with day-to-day upkeep
- A mix of coil and foam feels, from ultra plush to medium, in one place
Alternatives to consider
- Tuft & Needle Original: for a simpler, responsive foam feel without deep sink
- Nectar Memory Foam: for shoppers who want a classic “hug” profile in the all-foam category
- Sealy Posturepedic hybrid: for those who want mainstream coil support with a more traditional brand ecosystem
Pro Tips for Aaron's Mattress
- Use the included protector consistently; it’s part of how these mattresses are typically set up with Aaron’s.
- Give foam beds a short adjustment period so the surface feel stabilizes after setup.
- If you sleep hot, prioritize coil-based builds or keep bedding lighter; dense foams can hold warmth.
- For edge sitting (shoes, morning routines), the Beautyrest and Lane sets are simply easier to live with.
- If you share the bed and wake up easily, start your shortlist with Serta Sheep Dreams or the Chime.
- If your hips tend to sink on softer beds, keep “medium plush” as your ceiling and avoid ultra plush.
- For adjustable bases, check compatibility on the product listing before committing.
- Rotate the mattress periodically if your model is not reversible to help distribute wear more evenly.
- If you frequently work in bed, favor the more stable surfaces (Beautyrest first, Lane second).
FAQs
Q: Which Aaron’s mattress is best for couples?
A: Serta Sheep Dreams for motion isolation; Beautyrest if you want a livelier, more responsive feel.
Q: Which is best for side sleepers?
A: Chime for the softest pressure relief; Serta Sheep Dreams for a steadier medium feel.
Q: Which sleeps coolest in this group?
A: Beautyrest and Lane felt cooler than the all-foam models in our rooms.
Q: Which has the strongest edge?
A: Beautyrest and Lane, especially for sitting and outer-third sleeping.
