We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for more information.

OLIVER & SMITH Mattress Review: Affordable Comfort with Some Drawbacks

Do you often wake up feeling restless, even after a full night’s sleep? It’s possible your mattress could be to blame. The OLIVER & SMITH mattress promises a blend of plush comfort, cooling technology, and support without breaking the bank. But does it really deliver, or are there hidden drawbacks that could disrupt your sleep? Let’s take a deep dive into its strengths and weaknesses to find out 😊

What is the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress?

The OLIVER & SMITH mattress is a hybrid model designed to combine the softness of memory foam with the support of individually wrapped pocket springs. Their flagship product is a 12-inch queen mattress featuring a plush Euro pillow top and a breathable cover. It’s marketed as providing cooling, motion isolation, and a balanced firmness that caters to back, stomach, and side sleepers. The mattress is also eco-friendly, with CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certifications, ensuring safety and non-toxic materials. But, like any product, it has its pros and cons. Let’s take a closer look.

OLIVER & SMITH Mattress Review

Key Features of the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress

  • Hybrid Construction: Combines memory foam for comfort and individually wrapped pocket springs for support.
  • 12-Inch Firmness: Offers medium-firm support with a plush Euro pillow top for added softness.
  • Breathable Cover: Helps with airflow to reduce heat retention and promote a cooler sleep environment.
  • Cooling Technology: Gel-infused foam and breathable fabric work together to help regulate temperature.
  • CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX Certified: Ensures the mattress uses safe, eco-friendly materials.
  • Motion Isolation: Individually wrapped springs minimize motion transfer, making it ideal for couples.
  • Affordable Pricing: A solid option for those seeking a hybrid mattress at a reasonable price.
  • Easy Setup: Mattress-in-a-box delivery for convenient home setup.

Why Choose the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress?

The OLIVER & SMITH mattress offers a good mix of plush comfort, cooling, and support for back, stomach, and combination sleepers. Its medium-firm support, coupled with the cooling gel foam and breathable fabric, makes it an appealing option for hot sleepers. Additionally, the 12-inch thickness and hybrid construction offer a solid base for durability and support. However, while it provides great value for money, its thin profile, limited cooling capabilities, and the possibility of sagging over time may make it less suitable for long-term use for some sleepers.

Pros and Cons of the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress

Pros of the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress

  • Plush Euro Pillow Top: Adds softness for a luxurious feel without compromising support.
  • Medium-Firm Support: Works well for back, stomach, and combination sleepers, offering good spinal alignment.
  • Cooling Features: Gel foam and breathable cover help regulate temperature, keeping the mattress cooler than many traditional foam models.
  • Motion Isolation: The individually wrapped pocket springs reduce motion transfer, which is ideal for couples.
  • CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX Certified: Ensures that the materials used are safe, non-toxic, and eco-friendly.
  • Affordable Price: Offers a hybrid mattress with cooling and comfort at a budget-friendly price.
  • Easy Setup: Mattress arrives compressed in a box, making setup simple and convenient.
  • 100-Day Return Policy: Gives peace of mind, allowing you to test the mattress risk-free.

Cons of the OLIVER & SMITH Mattress

  • Thin Profile (12 inches): While thicker than many foam mattresses, it may not provide enough support for heavier individuals or long-term durability.
  • Durability Concerns: The hybrid construction may face issues like sagging or wear over time, especially with heavier use.
  • Weak Edge Support: Sitting or sleeping near the edges may feel unstable or cause the mattress to lose support.
  • Heat Retention: The cooling gel helps, but deep foam layers can still trap heat, especially for hot sleepers.
  • Limited Firmness Options: The mattress only comes in a medium-firm option, which may not suit all sleep preferences.
  • Off-Gassing: As with most foam mattresses, there may be an off-gassing odor during the first few days after unpacking.
  • New Brand Reputation: As a relatively new brand, OLIVER & SMITH lacks the long-term track record and customer feedback that some other established mattress brands have.
  • Heavy Weight: At 12 inches thick, the mattress can be heavy, making it harder to move or rotate.
OLIVER & SMITH Mattress Review

Pros vs. Cons Table

Pros Cons
Plush Euro pillow top for added softness Thin profile may not support heavier sleepers
Medium firmness suits most sleeping positions Durability concerns, especially with heavier use
Gel-infused foam for cooling comfort Weak edge support, may feel unstable near edges
Breathable fabric enhances airflow and cooling May still retain heat in deeper foam layers
Motion isolation due to pocket springs Limited firmness options
CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certified materials Off-gassing odor on unpacking
Affordable hybrid mattress New brand with limited reputation
Mattress-in-a-box delivery for easy setup Heavy and difficult to move or rotate
100-day return policy for peace of mind

Transition to Dweva Platform

If you like the OLIVER & SMITH mattress for its cooling and affordability but are concerned about durability, edge support, and long-term performance, Dweva is an excellent alternative. Dweva is a curated home goods platform that specializes in high-quality, value-driven products. With a focus on quality and durability, Dweva ensures that you can trust the mattresses they offer.

Dweva provides 14-day free returns and 100-day returns on mattresses, including free delivery. This makes shopping stress-free, knowing that you can try a mattress at home with minimal risk.

View all

If you're looking for a hybrid mattress with better edge support, cooling, and durability, consider the Luna Luxury Hybrid Mattress from Dweva. The Luna mattress offers advanced cooling technology, superior support, and long-lasting durability compared to the OLIVER & SMITH mattress.

Why Choose the Luna Mattress?

  • Advanced Cooling: Gel-infused memory foam and breathable layers ensure a cooler sleep throughout the night.
  • Enhanced Edge Support: Reinforced edges provide better stability, preventing sagging and offering a more stable sleeping surface.
  • Durability: High-density materials ensure the Luna mattress maintains support and comfort over time.
  • Back Support: Luna-Lumbar Zone technology promotes optimal spinal alignment and relieves pressure points.

Comparison Chart: OLIVER & SMITH vs. Luna

Feature OLIVER & SMITH Mattress Luna Luxury Hybrid Mattress
Support Medium firmness, good for most sleepers Luna-Lumbar Zone for better spinal alignment
Edge Support Weak edge support Reinforced edge support for added stability
Cooling Gel-infused foam and breathable cover Advanced cooling with gel-infused memory foam
Durability Risk of sagging over time High durability with long-lasting materials
Warranty 100-day return policy 100-night return policy with free delivery and returns

Q&A

Q: What firmness is the OLIVER & SMITH mattress?
A: The OLIVER & SMITH mattress is medium firm, which works well for back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers may find it a bit firm.

Q: Does the OLIVER & SMITH mattress help with back pain?
A: Yes, the medium firmness and hybrid construction provide support and spinal alignment, which can help alleviate mild back pain.

Q: Can the OLIVER & SMITH mattress handle heavier sleepers?
A: The OLIVER & SMITH mattress may not be the best choice for heavier sleepers due to its thinner profile and risk of sagging over time.

Q: How does the Luna mattress compare to the OLIVER & SMITH mattress?
A: The Luna mattress offers better edge support, cooling, and long-term durability, making it a better choice for those seeking a reliable mattress.

Q: Does the OLIVER & SMITH mattress retain heat?
A: The OLIVER & SMITH mattress has cooling features, but some users may still experience heat retention, particularly with deeper foam layers.

Q: How is motion isolation in the OLIVER & SMITH mattress?
A: The OLIVER & SMITH mattress performs well in motion isolation thanks to its pocketed springs, making it a good choice for couples.

Q: Does Dweva offer free returns?
A: Yes, Dweva offers 14-day free returns on most products and 100-day returns for mattresses with free delivery.

Q: Is the OLIVER & SMITH mattress eco-friendly?
A: Yes, it is made with eco-friendly materials and is CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX certified.

OLIVER & SMITH Mattress Review

Conclusion

The OLIVER & SMITH mattress offers a good mix of cooling, support, and comfort at an affordable price. However, concerns about its durability, edge support, and heat retention may make it less ideal for long-term use. For buyers seeking a mattress that offers superior durability, cooling, and edge support, Dweva provides the Luna Luxury Hybrid Mattress as an excellent alternative. With its superior features and long-term value, the Luna mattress is an ideal choice for restful, reliable sleep.

Previous post
Next post
Back to Mattress Reviews

Our Testing Team

Chris Miller

Lead Tester

Chris oversees the full testing pipeline for mattresses, sofas, and other home products. He coordinates the team, designs scoring frameworks, and lives with every product long enough to feel real strengths and weaknesses. His combination-sleeping and mixed lounging habits keep him focused on long-term comfort and support.

Marcus Reed

Heavyweight Sofa & Mattress Tester

Marcus brings a heavier build and heat-sensitive profile into every test. He pushes deep cushions, edges, and frames harder than most users. His feedback highlights whether a design holds up under load, runs hot, or collapses into a hammock-like slump during long gaming or streaming sessions.

Carlos Alvarez

Posture & Work-From-Home Specialist

Carlos spends long hours working from sofas and beds with a laptop. He tracks how mid-back, neck, and lumbar regions respond to different setups. His notes reveal whether a product keeps posture neutral during extended sitting or lying, and whether small adjustments still feel stable and controlled.

Mia Chen

Petite Side-Sleeper & Lounger

Mia tests how mattresses and sofas treat a smaller frame during side sleeping and curled-up lounging. She feels pressure and seat-depth problems very quickly. Her feedback exposes designs that swallow shorter users, leave feet dangling, or create sharp pressure points at shoulders, hips, and knees.

Jenna Brooks

Couple Comfort & Motion Tester

Jenna evaluates how well sofas and mattresses handle real shared use with a partner. She tracks motion transfer, usable width, and edge comfort when two adults spread out. Her comments highlight whether a product supports relaxed couple lounging, easy repositioning, and quiet nights without constant disturbance.

Jamal Davis

Tall, Active-Body Tester

Jamal brings a tall, athletic frame and post-workout soreness into the lab. He checks seat depth, leg support, and surface responsiveness on every product. His notes show whether cushions bounce back, frames feel solid under long legs, and sleep surfaces support joints during recovery stretches and naps.

Ethan Cole

Restless Lounger & Partner Tester

Ethan acts as the moving partner in many couple-focused tests. He shifts positions frequently and pays attention to how easily a surface lets him turn, slide, or return after short breaks. His feedback exposes cushions that feel too squishy, too sticky, or poorly shaped for real-world lounging patterns.