Mulligan Mattress Reviews (2026)

The all-latex sample earned the higher overall score because its support changed very little from the first hour to the end of the night. Mia also found it more forgiving through the shoulder and hip during long side-sleep stretches. Its main compromise was the perimeter, which compressed noticeably more when we sat near the edge.

The Black Swan was the easier mattress to move on. Marcus preferred its faster rebound and cooler feel, while Jamal chose it for frequent position changes. It gave up some motion isolation and felt firmer at bony pressure points, but its stronger edge made better use of the full sleep surface.

Each mattress received 21 nights of use from three sleepers: Mia, a 5'4", 132-pound side sleeper; Marcus, a 6'1", 205-pound back/side sleeper; and Jamal, a 5'10", 176-pound combination sleeper. We compared support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability on a five-point scale.

In addition to overnight notes, we measured sink with 44- and 150-pound loads, tracked surface temperature for 30 minutes, timed the surface’s return to 90% of its original height, compared center and edge compression, and repeated a 10-pound ball drop three times for motion transfer. A 1,000-pass rolling test provided a consistent check for height loss and changes in feel.

Our Testing Experience

The tested all-latex sample felt medium-firm at 3.3/5, though Mulligan’s broader latex range runs from soft to extra firm. It allowed enough give for the shoulder and hip to settle, then held the pelvis in place. Under a 44-pound load, the surface compressed 1.3 inches; a 150-pound load reached 2.1 inches. That controlled depth matched Mia’s experience on her side: the mattress cushioned pressure without letting her waist drop out of alignment.

Temperature rose 6.8°F after 30 minutes and returned to within 1.5°F of baseline 10 minutes after the sleeper got up. That is a solid result for a foam-free all-latex build, though the Black Swan released heat faster. The surface also recovered to 90% of its original height in 1.1 seconds, so turning never felt difficult even though the rebound was less lively than the hybrid’s.

Motion control was the clearest advantage. The vibration from our ball drop settled in 1.6 seconds, compared with 2.2 seconds on the Black Swan. After 1,000 rolling passes, the all-latex sample showed less than 0.1 inch of permanent height change and retained the same measured firmness. Edge sitting remained its weakest area: the same 150-pound load compressed 2.8 inches near the perimeter versus 2.1 inches in the center.

What we liked:

• Steady midsection support that did not loosen as the night went on

• Better shoulder and hip relief for sustained side sleeping

• Quieter motion control for partners with different schedules

Who it is best for:

• Side/back combination sleepers who want stable contouring

• People who dislike the deep, slow sink of memory foam

• Shoppers who want several firmness choices within an all-latex design

Where it falls short:

• Quick position changes take a little more effort than on the Black Swan

• The edge compresses more when sitting, especially for heavier sleepers

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: All-latex mattress family.

• Current configurations: Blue Heron, Morning Dove, Blue Heron+, and Morning Dove+.

• Published sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King.

• Published prices: $1,150–$1,250 Twin; $1,250–$1,350 Twin XL; $2,025–$2,225 Full; $2,225–$2,425 Queen; $2,450–$2,850 King.

• Materials: Mulligan describes its latex as certified organic, hypoallergenic, and resistant to mold and mildew.

• Published firmness range: Soft to extra firm.

Review Score

Our Testing Experience

The Black Swan felt firmer and more lifted at 3.5/5. Its spring unit stopped a 44-pound load at 1.1 inches and a 150-pound load at 1.8 inches, so the body stayed closer to the surface than on the all-latex sample. Jamal could move from his back to his side without pushing off with an elbow, and Marcus found it easier to stand from the edge in the morning.

The surface returned to 90% of its original height in 0.6 seconds, roughly twice as fast as the all-latex bed. That speed was helpful for combination sleeping, but the trade-off was more movement across the mattress. Ball-drop vibration lasted 2.2 seconds. A light sleeper may notice a partner turning, even though the coils kept the transfer from feeling sharp.

Cooling and edge support were its best measured results. After 30 minutes, the surface temperature rose 5.5°F and returned to within 1°F of baseline after 10 minutes. Near the perimeter, the 150-pound load produced 2.1 inches of compression, only 0.3 inch more than in the center. The bed also kept its springy feel through 1,000 rolling passes, with about 0.1 inch of lasting height change and no new spring noise.

What we liked:

• Fast rebound that made turning and getting out of bed easier

• A steadier perimeter for sleepers who use the full width

• Better heat release than the all-latex sample

Who it is best for:

• Combination sleepers who change positions often

• Couples who need stronger edge support and more usable space

• Back sleepers who prefer gentle contouring without deep sink

Where it falls short:

• Partner movement is easier to feel than on the all-latex sample

• Lighter side sleepers may want more cushioning at the shoulder

Pros & Cons

Details

• Type: Spring-and-latex hybrid.

• Published sizes: Queen and King.

• Published prices: $2,750 Queen and $2,950 King.

Review Score

The all-latex sample is the more balanced choice for side sleeping, pressure relief, and motion control. The Black Swan is more specialized: it gives active sleepers faster movement, better cooling, and a firmer edge, but it transmits more partner movement and provides less cushioning at the shoulder.

Choose from the all-latex line if you want steady support, quieter motion, and more give at the shoulder and hip. Because Mulligan publishes firmnesses from soft to extra firm, match the configuration to your body weight and primary position instead of assuming every latex model feels like our medium-firm sample. Lighter side sleepers should start softer; back sleepers and people who prefer to stay on top of the bed will usually be more comfortable in the middle or firmer end of the range.

Choose the Black Swan if turning, edge stability, and heat release matter more than maximum motion isolation. Its quicker response suits active combination sleepers, and its stronger perimeter works well for couples who regularly use the outer third of the bed. The trade-off is a firmer feel at the shoulder and a much narrower published size selection.

Mulligan publishes prices and basic material information, but its website does not fully explain how the four all-latex configurations differ. It also does not provide enough public detail to confirm a home trial, return policy, warranty, or standard delivery terms. Call the Portland shop to confirm the current build, firmness, total height, lead time, and purchase policies before ordering.

Neither design feels like slow-moving memory foam. The all-latex line pushes back more evenly, while the Black Swan adds spring lift. Shoppers seeking deep contouring may prefer a different material, and anyone outside Queen or King should rule out the Black Swan unless Mulligan confirms a custom option.

Avocado Green Mattress is the stronger choice for shoppers who want a widely available latex hybrid with formal certifications and a clearly published purchase package. It offers multiple feels, six standard sizes, zoned coils, a one-year trial, and a 25-year limited warranty. Mulligan’s Black Swan has a simpler local-store approach and a less complicated feel choice, but Avocado provides more ways to tune firmness and more information before checkout.

Sleep On Latex Pure Green is the most direct alternative to Mulligan’s all-latex line. It uses an eight-inch organic latex core with organic cotton and wool, comes in medium or firm, and is sold in six sizes with 100-day free returns and a 10-year warranty. It is the easier online purchase and typically occupies a lower price tier, while Mulligan offers a broader published firmness range and local guidance for Portland-area buyers.

Saatva Latex Hybrid competes most closely with the Black Swan. Its 12-inch build combines a five-zone latex comfort layer with individually wrapped coils and a medium-firm feel. Saatva also includes nationwide in-room setup, a 365-night trial, and a lifetime warranty. Black Swan is the more personal, locally made option; Saatva is easier to buy if service coverage and clearly documented policies matter most.

• Keep your pillow and foundation unchanged during the first two weeks so you can judge the mattress itself.

• Side sleepers should watch for shoulder pressure and waist support separately; a softer surface is not better if the pelvis drops too far.

• Use breathable bedding before deciding that the mattress sleeps too warm.

• Test the edge while sitting and lying down. Those positions reveal different kinds of perimeter support.

• Rotate the mattress regularly, especially when one partner is much heavier or sleeps in the same spot every night.

• Place the mattress on a rigid, well-supported foundation; flexible or widely spaced slats can make latex feel softer and less stable.

• If the Black Swan feels firm at the shoulder, adjust pillow height before changing the entire sleep setup.

The Black Swan. Its spring unit restored the surface faster and helped complete position changes with less effort, making it the better choice for active combination sleepers.

The all-latex sample provided better relief during extended side sleeping. It let the shoulder and hip settle more deeply while keeping the midsection supported.

Choose Black Swan for stronger edges and easier movement across the bed. Choose the all-latex line if limiting motion transfer is the priority. Couples sensitive to movement will notice the difference most.

No. Both designs respond more quickly and hold the body closer to the surface. The all-latex line has smooth, steady pushback, while Black Swan feels springier and more lifted.