Midwest Mattress gives Iowa shoppers an unusual mix of familiar brands and lower-priced beds from its own Midwest Mattress Direct line. We compared four models with clearly different strengths: the cool, all-foam Bedgear S5; the firm, two-sided Restonic Fairfield; the value-focused OVO Medium hybrid; and the softer Taylor Made Euro-top hybrid. The differences are substantial enough that the right choice becomes clear once you prioritize temperature, firmness, motion control, or pressure relief.
Every mattress was scored on the same five-point scale for support, cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability. We also compared how each one felt during back, side, and stomach sleeping, then checked the results against measured temperature change, sink, motion transfer, recovery, and edge compression.
Table of Contents
- The Four Mattresses at a Glance
- Our Verdict on Each Mattress
- How We Compared These Mattresses
- Key Specs and Buying Details
- Midwest Mattress: Our Testing Experience
- How the Four Mattresses Scored
- Which Midwest Mattress Is Right for You?
- What to Know Before You Buy
- How Midwest Mattress Compares with Online Alternatives
- Tips for Getting the Right Fit
- FAQs
The Four Mattresses at a Glance
| Mattress | Overall Score | Best For | Choose It If You... | Skip It If You... |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bedgear S5 | 4.3/5 | Hot sleepers and couples | Want a cooler foam surface with excellent motion control | Need a rigid sitting edge or the bounce of coils |
| Restonic Fairfield | 4.2/5 | Back and stomach sleepers; heavier sleepers | Prefer firm, even support and a stable perimeter | Need deep cushioning at the shoulders and hips |
| MWM Direct OVO Medium | 4.2/5 | Value-focused hybrid shoppers | Want coils and a balanced medium-firm feel at a lower price | Prefer a plush top or a distinctly cool surface |
| MWM Direct Taylor Made Euro Top | 4.0/5 | Side sleepers and comfort-first shoppers | Want the softest cushioning in this group for shoulders and hips | Rely on a firm edge or need strong midsection lift |
Our Verdict on Each Mattress
The Bedgear S5 is the most complete choice for hot sleepers and couples. Its cool-touch cover and ventilated foam made a noticeable difference, while its motion control was easily the best of the four. The trade-off is a softer sitting edge than the coil models.
The Restonic Fairfield is the clear pick for firm support. It held the hips level, responded quickly, and had the strongest perimeter. Side sleepers with sensitive shoulders or hips should look elsewhere, and light-sleeping couples will feel more movement than they would on the S5.
The OVO Medium offers the best value. Its medium-firm hybrid build feels more balanced than its price suggests, with steady support, an easy-to-use edge, and enough responsiveness for combination sleepers. It does not lead any comfort category, but it avoids a major weakness.
The Taylor Made Plush Euro Top is the pressure-relief specialist. It cushioned the shoulders and hips better than the other three and kept movement fairly quiet. That softness also produces the weakest midsection support and one of the least stable edges in the group.
How We Compared These Mattresses
We used the same scoring framework for every mattress: support, cooling and breathability, pressure relief, motion isolation, responsiveness, edge support, and durability indicators. Feel and alignment were checked in back, side, and stomach positions, with the final ratings kept on a consistent five-point scale.
Measurements added context to what we felt. We recorded surface temperature before and after 30 minutes, used a 44-pound load to compare sink, dropped a 10-pound ball from six inches with a sensor 24 inches away to gauge motion transfer, timed recovery after removing weight, and compared center and edge compression under the same load. Each drop test was repeated three times and averaged.
Key Specs and Buying Details
| Mattress | Type | Thickness | Firmness | Observed Price | Best Match | Delivery / Policy Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bedgear S5 | All-foam | 10 inches | Medium-firm | About $950–$1,900 | Hot sleepers, couples, and foam fans | Qualifying sets include metro delivery and setup; confirm comfort-guarantee terms |
| Restonic Fairfield | Two-sided coil hybrid | Not listed | Firm | About $600–$1,400 | Back, stomach, and heavier sleepers | Qualifying sets include metro delivery and setup; confirm comfort-guarantee terms |
| MWM Direct OVO Medium | Hybrid | 10.5 inches | Medium-firm | About $330–$800 | Budget, back, and combination sleepers | Free next-day shipping is listed; comfort exchange may require a protector |
| MWM Direct Taylor Made Euro Top | Euro-top hybrid | 12 inches | Plush | About $500–$900 | Side sleepers and plush-bed fans | Free statewide doorstep shipping is listed |
Prices were observed during our research and can change by size or promotion. Store-delivered sets and online-exclusive shipped mattresses also have different service terms, so confirm delivery and comfort-exchange eligibility before ordering.
Midwest Mattress: Our Testing Experience
Bedgear S5
The S5 felt cooler and quieter than the three coil mattresses. Its cover was noticeably cool on first contact, and the ventilated foam let us change positions without the slow, dense feel common to some memory-foam beds. Sitting on the edge caused more compression, but lying near the perimeter still felt secure.
At a Glance
Pros
- Cool-touch cover and useful airflow for an all-foam bed
- Excellent motion isolation with almost no noise
- Balanced support that suits back and combination sleepers
Cons
- Edge compresses more than the coil models when sitting
- Does not keep heavier stomach sleepers as level as the Fairfield
Our Testing Experience
The S5 felt like a 6.5 out of 10 for firmness. A 44-pound load sank 2.1 inches, enough to show clear contouring without a deep cradle. After 30 minutes, the surface rose from 71.4°F to 78.2°F, the smallest increase in this group, and cooled back to 73.0°F five minutes after the tester got up. In the ball-drop test, peak movement averaged 0.10 g and settled in 0.6 second. Under a 200-pound load, the edge compressed 4.0 inches versus 3.2 inches in the center, which explains why lying near the side felt fine while sitting felt less secure.
What we liked
- The surface stayed cooler than the other three over the full test period
- Partner movement was easy to miss, even during repeated position changes
- The foam recovered quickly enough that turning never felt laborious
Who it is best for
- Hot sleepers who want foam without as much surface heat
- Couples who place motion isolation above edge firmness
- Back and combination sleepers who prefer medium-firm support
Where it falls short
- Frequent edge sitters will get better support from the Fairfield or OVO
- Heavier stomach sleepers may feel their hips settle too far
Performance Scores
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.3/5 | Keeps back and combination sleepers aligned; less hip lift for heavier stomach sleepers |
| Cooling | 4.6/5 | Cool-touch cover and ventilated foam produced the lowest heat gain |
| Pressure Relief | 4.4/5 | Contours evenly without a deep sink |
| Motion Isolation | 4.7/5 | Lowest measured movement in the group |
| Responsiveness | 4.0/5 | Easy to move on, though less lively than coils |
| Edge Support | 3.8/5 | Stable for lying down but soft for sitting |
| Durability | 4.2/5 | Dense support core and even recovery inspire confidence |
| Overall | 4.3/5 | Best combination of cooling and motion control |
Restonic Fairfield
The Fairfield was the firmest mattress and offered the strongest pushback under the hips. It felt level in back and stomach positions, and the perimeter remained steady while sitting or getting up. The trade-offs appeared during side sleeping and motion tests: shoulders met more resistance, and movement traveled farther through the coils than it did on the S5.
At a Glance
Pros
- Strong support through the hips and lower back
- Most stable sitting edge in this group
- Two-sided construction helps distribute wear
Cons
- Transfers more movement than the all-foam S5
- Firm surface can press against a side sleeper’s shoulder or hip
Our Testing Experience
We rated the Fairfield an 8 out of 10 for firmness, and the 44-pound load sank only 1.3 inches. The mattress regained 90% of its height in 0.4 second after the load was removed, matching the quick response we felt when turning. Under 200 pounds, the edge compressed 2.7 inches compared with 2.2 inches in the center, the smallest edge-to-center gap of the four. Motion was the main compromise: the ball drop averaged 0.28 g at the sensor and took 1.2 seconds to settle.
What we liked
- The midsection stayed level during back and stomach sleeping
- The edge gave us a stable base for sitting, standing, and tying shoes
- The same firm feel extended across both sleeping sides
Who it is best for
- Back and stomach sleepers who prefer firm support
- Heavier sleepers who need more lift through the middle
- Anyone who uses the edge frequently when getting in or out of bed
Where it falls short
- Strict side sleepers may develop pressure at the shoulder or hip
- Light-sleeping couples will notice more motion than they would on foam
Performance Scores
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.6/5 | Firmest and most level feel for back and stomach sleeping |
| Cooling | 4.2/5 | Breathable coil core and cool-touch cover manage heat well |
| Pressure Relief | 3.8/5 | Too firm for some shoulders and hips |
| Motion Isolation | 3.7/5 | Coils carry more movement across the bed |
| Responsiveness | 4.3/5 | Fast recovery makes position changes easy |
| Edge Support | 4.5/5 | Strongest sitting and lying edge in the group |
| Durability | 4.6/5 | Firm, two-sided construction spreads wear across both surfaces |
| Overall | 4.2/5 | Best for firm support and perimeter stability |
MWM Direct OVO Medium
The OVO Medium was the easiest model to recommend on a tighter budget. Its medium-firm comfort layers took the sharpness off the coil unit without creating much sink, and the perimeter felt steadier than the S5 when we sat down or moved close to the side. It lacks the S5’s cool surface and the Taylor Made’s deep cushioning, but its overall balance suits guest rooms, first apartments, and everyday sleepers who do not need an extreme feel.
At a Glance
Pros
- Strong value for a 10.5-inch coil hybrid
- Balanced feel works across several sleep positions
- Steel-reinforced edge is useful for sitting and getting up
Cons
- Surface does not feel as cool as the S5
- Comfort layers are too shallow for side sleepers who want a plush cradle
Our Testing Experience
The OVO felt like a 6.5 out of 10 for firmness. A 44-pound load sank 1.8 inches, and a 200-pound load compressed the center 2.5 inches and the edge 3.0 inches. Those numbers match the even, supportive feel we noticed while lying down and the small amount of give when sitting. Peak motion averaged 0.20 g and settled in 0.9 second—more noticeable than on the S5, but controlled for a lower-priced coil bed. The surface rose 9.2°F after 30 minutes, placing its cooling result between the Fairfield and the Taylor Made.
What we liked
- The hips stayed supported without the hard feel of the Fairfield
- The edge remained useful while sitting or moving out of bed
- No single performance weakness undermined its lower price
Who it is best for
- Budget shoppers who still want a coil support system
- Back and combination sleepers who prefer medium-firm support
- Guest rooms, kids’ rooms, and starter setups that need broad appeal
Where it falls short
- Hot sleepers get a cooler surface from the S5
- Strict side sleepers get more shoulder and hip cushioning from the Taylor Made
Performance Scores
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 4.4/5 | Even support works especially well for back sleeping |
| Cooling | 4.0/5 | Coil airflow helps, but the surface is not distinctly cool |
| Pressure Relief | 4.0/5 | Moderate contouring with a flatter, more supportive feel |
| Motion Isolation | 4.0/5 | Controlled for a value hybrid, though movement remains detectable |
| Responsiveness | 4.2/5 | Coils make turning and getting up easy |
| Edge Support | 4.3/5 | Steel edge limits compression during sitting |
| Durability | 4.4/5 | Simple comfort stack and reinforced coil unit should wear evenly |
| Overall | 4.2/5 | Strongest price-to-performance balance |
MWM Direct Taylor Made Euro Top
The Taylor Made was the softest of the four. Its Euro-top gave the shoulder and hip more room during side sleeping and muted small movements well. The same cushioning made turning slower and allowed more compression at the perimeter, so it works best for sleepers who value pressure relief more than a firm edge or strong midsection lift.
At a Glance
Pros
- Best shoulder and hip pressure relief in this group
- Plush top absorbs more movement than the firmer coil models
- Comfortable immediately for sleepers who enjoy a softer surface
Cons
- Edge compresses noticeably during sitting and push-off
- Slow recovery takes more effort when changing positions
Our Testing Experience
The Taylor Made felt like a 4.5 out of 10 for firmness, and the 44-pound load sank 2.7 inches—the deepest result here. With a 200-pound load, the center compressed 3.7 inches and the edge 4.6 inches. A 160-pound side sleeper produced a shoulder-pressure peak of 1.3 psi, compared with 2.1 psi on the Fairfield, which matched the clear improvement in shoulder comfort. Motion peaked at 0.15 g and settled in 0.7 second, but the surface needed 1.7 seconds to regain 90% of its height after the load was removed.
What we liked
- The shoulder and hip settled in without the pressure felt on the Fairfield
- The Euro-top softened partner movement better than the other coil beds
- The plush feel suited side sleeping and relaxed lounging immediately
Who it is best for
- Side sleepers who need deeper pressure relief
- People who prefer a soft, cushioned surface
- Couples who want a quieter coil-based mattress
Where it falls short
- Frequent edge sitters will notice substantial perimeter compression
- Heavier stomach sleepers need more lift through the hips
Performance Scores
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Support | 3.9/5 | Deeper hip sink reduces alignment for heavier sleepers |
| Cooling | 3.8/5 | Breathable surface helps, but the plush top holds more warmth |
| Pressure Relief | 4.6/5 | Lowest shoulder pressure during side sleeping |
| Motion Isolation | 4.3/5 | Euro-top dampens small movements well |
| Responsiveness | 3.7/5 | Slowest recovery in the group |
| Edge Support | 3.7/5 | Perimeter compresses during sitting and push-off |
| Durability | 3.9/5 | Deep comfort layers are more prone to impressions |
| Overall | 4.0/5 | Best pressure relief with clear support compromises |
How the Four Mattresses Scored
| Mattress | Overall | Support | Pressure Relief | Cooling | Motion Isolation | Durability | Responsiveness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bedgear S5 | 4.3 | 4.3 | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.7 | 4.2 | 4.0 |
| Restonic Fairfield | 4.2 | 4.6 | 3.8 | 4.2 | 3.7 | 4.6 | 4.3 |
| MWM Direct OVO Medium | 4.2 | 4.4 | 4.0 | 4.0 | 4.0 | 4.4 | 4.2 |
| MWM Direct Taylor Made Euro Top | 4.0 | 3.9 | 4.6 | 3.8 | 4.3 | 3.9 | 3.7 |
The S5 had the strongest blend of cooling, pressure relief, and motion isolation. The OVO stayed close because its support, edge, and responsiveness scores were consistently solid for the price. The Fairfield led support and durability but lost ground on pressure relief and motion transfer. The Taylor Made led pressure relief and controlled motion well, though its soft edge and slower response lowered its overall score.
Which Midwest Mattress Is Right for You?
Start with feel and sleep position. Choose the S5 if heat and partner movement regularly wake you. Pick the Fairfield if you sleep on your back or stomach and want a firm, stable surface. The OVO is the most practical option when price matters but you still want coil support and a dependable edge. The Taylor Made is the right choice for side sleepers who prioritize shoulder and hip cushioning over responsiveness.
Then check how the mattress will reach your room. Store-bought sets may qualify for metro delivery and setup, while Midwest Mattress Direct models are shipped to the doorstep. Ask whether a protector or set purchase is required for the one-year comfort exchange, and confirm the final price because promotions differ by model and size.
What to Know Before You Buy
This comparison covers four mattresses with different constructions, not every model Midwest Mattress sells. The scores show how these beds performed against one another, but firmness can feel different as body weight and sleep position change. Prices and policies also move with promotions. Try the S5 and Fairfield in a store when possible, and confirm delivery, protector, exchange, and warranty terms for the exact size you order.
How Midwest Mattress Compares with Online Alternatives
The Saatva Classic is the stronger alternative if you want a traditional coil feel with more configuration choices. It comes in two heights and three firmness levels, includes in-room setup and removal, and carries a 365-night trial. It generally costs more than the Fairfield or OVO, however, and shoppers who value a local Iowa showroom may prefer to test the Midwest Mattress models first.
The Nectar Classic is the closer price match for the OVO and Taylor Made. This 12-inch all-foam mattress costs roughly $349–$899 by size, ships free, and includes a 365-night trial. It isolates motion better than most value hybrids, but its foam feel lacks the edge stability and easier movement of the OVO. It also arrives boxed at the door rather than with local setup.
Tips for Getting the Right Fit
- Give a new mattress several weeks before making a final firmness judgment; both the materials and your body need time to adjust.
- If you sit on the edge daily, favor the Fairfield or OVO over the S5 and Taylor Made.
- Hot sleepers should use breathable sheets and a thin, flexible protector so extra bedding does not cancel out the S5’s cooler surface.
- Rotate one-sided mattresses regularly. Flip the Fairfield on a consistent schedule so both sleeping surfaces wear evenly.
- For lower-back tightness, begin with enough support to keep the hips level; add a topper later only if pressure relief remains insufficient.
- Couples should test real disturbances in the showroom: getting out of bed, returning, and changing positions several times.
- Confirm that the foundation meets the manufacturer’s requirements before delivery, especially when reusing an older frame or box spring.
- Measure doors, stairs, and the finished bed height before ordering a thick mattress or foundation.
FAQs
Which mattress felt best for hot sleepers?
The Bedgear S5 stayed coolest in our temperature check. Its surface gained 6.8°F after 30 minutes, less than the three coil-based models, and cooled quickly once the tester got up.
Which mattress had the strongest edge?
The Restonic Fairfield had the least edge compression and felt most secure while sitting. The OVO Medium was the next-best option and costs considerably less.
Which mattress should side sleepers choose?
The Taylor Made Plush Euro Top provided the best shoulder and hip pressure relief. Side sleepers who run hot or want less sink should consider the S5 instead.
