I kept hearing the same thing about Big Lots couch deals. People liked the prices, but they were unsure about comfort and lifespan. I wanted to see how these couches actually behave under daily use, not just under showroom lighting.
For this round, I pulled in our regular seating team. Marcus, Carlos, Mia, Jenna, Jamal, and Ethan joined me in the studio. Dr. Adrian Walker stayed in his usual role, reading our logs and giving clinical context around posture, pressure, and alignment.
We focused on six couches that shoppers regularly connect with Big Lots: Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional, Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional, Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa, Broyhill Laramie Sofa, Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa, and Signature Design by Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa. These models reflect the mix of sectionals, recliners, and simple three-seaters that show up in Big Lots marketing and coverage.
- 1. Product Overview
- 2. Big Lots Couch Comparison Chart
- 3. What We Tested and How We Tested It
- 4. Big Lots Couch: Our Testing Experience
- 5. Compare Performance Scores of These Sofas
- 6. Best Picks
- 7. How to Choose the Big Lots Couch?
- 8. Limitations
- 9. Is the Big Lots Couch Worth It?
- 10. FAQs
Product Overview
| sofa | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price (approx) | Overall Score |
| Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional | Deep lounging, good corner seat, solid frame | Too deep for shorter users, bulky footprint | Families and loungers with larger living rooms | $$–$$$ | 4.3 |
| Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional | Supportive seats, firmer feel, decent edge strength | Fabric runs warm, not very plush | Mixed-use living rooms, gamers, people needing support | $$–$$$ | 4.2 |
| Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa | Power recline, strong lumbar feel, easy wipe-down | Heavy, needs outlet access, tighter center seat | TV rooms, heavier users, movie fans | $$$ | 4.4 |
| Broyhill Laramie Sofa | Simple look, balanced firmness, manageable size | Not ideal for very tall loungers, basic fabric | Small to mid rooms, everyday family seating | $$ | 4.1 |
| Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa | Cup holders, storage arms, relaxed recline | Chunky style, less breathable, soft support over time | Basement setups, casual movie spaces | $$ | 4.0 |
| Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa (at Big Lots) | Lighter profile, softer feel, bright fabric option | Less robust frame feel, limited deep lounging support | Apartments, style-focused buyers on a budget | $$ | 3.9 |
Big Lots Couch Comparison Chart
| sofa | Seat Depth (approx) | Seat Height (approx) | Overall Size (W×D×H, approx) | Configuration Options | Frame / Cushion Materials | Firmness Feel | Back Support Profile | Fabric / Cover Type | Cooling / Breathability | Durability Expectation | Ease of Cleaning |
| Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional | 23–24 in | 19–20 in | 125–135×90–100×36–38 in | Chaise, L-shape sectional, ottoman add-ons | Wood frame, sinuous springs, polyfoam cushions | Medium-soft top, firm base | Supportive but lounge-leaning | Woven polyester-style upholstery | Fair; warmer for hot sleepers | Good under family use, with cushion rotation | Spot clean, fabric-safe cleaners, removable cushions |
| Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional | 22–23 in | 19 in | 120–130×85–95×36–38 in | Chaise, L-shape sectional | Wood frame, tighter foam, sinuous springs | Medium-firm | More upright, supportive | Textured polyester | Average; holds heat under Marcus | Strong frame feel, firmer cushions | Spot cleaning only, textured hides stains |
| Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa | 21–22 in | 19–20 in | 85–90×40–42×40–42 in | Power recline ends, optional loveseat, console | Reinforced frame, metal recline hardware, foam and fiber mix | Medium-firm seat, cushioned back | Focused lumbar and mid-back support | Top grain leather on seats, vinyl match sides | Better airflow than fabric, but still warm | Very solid under heavy use | Wipeable surfaces, conditioning needed |
| Broyhill Laramie Sofa | 21–22 in | 19 in | 82–86×36–38×36–38 in | Standard sofa, matching loveseat available | Wood frame, medium-density foam, sinuous springs | True medium | Balanced, neutral support | Woven fabric, mid-texture | Average; okay for most households | Moderate; depends on jumping kids and pets | Spot clean; removable cushions on many versions |
| Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa | 21–22 in | 19–20 in | 88–92×38–40×40–42 in | Dual recliners, drop-down table, storage arms | Metal recline frame, padded arms, fiber-heavy cushions | Medium-soft | Recline-friendly, less upright | Plush polyester fabric | Warm in long sessions | Mixed; mechanisms fine, cushions soften | Fabric cleaning required; cup-holder wipe-down |
| Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa | 21–22 in | 19 in | 78–82×36–38×36–38 in | Standalone sofa, matching chair or loveseat | Engineered wood frame, polyfiber and foam cushions | Medium-soft | Gentle support, not very structured | Woven polyester in light putty color | Better airflow than dense microfiber | Fair; for lighter to moderate use | Needs quick stain attention; light color shows it |
What We Tested and How We Tested It
We treated these Big Lots couch models as real household workhorses. I kept each piece in the studio for several weeks. During that time, the team used them in rotation, then logged every small annoyance and every pleasant surprise.
I usually started in upright mode with a laptop. I checked whether my lower back could relax while I typed. Afterwards, I shifted into a semi-recline for streaming runs. Late at night, I often stretched out fully to see if the couch felt like a nap spot or a last resort.
We ran specific roles on each model. Marcus handled heavier-use gaming and sports blocks, often four-hour stretches without leaving his spot. Carlos worked through two-hour laptop sessions from each couch before letting himself recline. Mia focused on how shorter legs and lighter weight interacted with seat depth and cushion crowns.
Our couple tests relied on Jenna and Ethan. They ran movie nights on every couch, swapped positions mid-movie, and tracked motion transfer. Jamal pushed the edges, literally. He perched on arms, sat on the front lip, and stretched his long legs along chaises or full lengths to see where the support thinned out.
Kids and pets showed up occasionally as extra stress. We had a couple of guest evenings where friends’ children climbed along the backs and bounced into corners. One tester’s dog gave the fabrics a casual claw and shed test. That kind of chaos showed how these couches react under real living-room conditions.
We rated every model using the same core metrics: Seat Comfort, Back Support, Seat Depth Fit, Cooling / Breathability, Durability, Ease of Movement / Repositioning, Ease of Cleaning, and Value for Money, then an Overall Score. Scores ran from 3.0 to 5.0, with 3.0 meaning workable but flawed and 5.0 meaning outstanding in that metric.
Dr. Walker reviewed our logs later. He flagged any patterns that fit or conflicted with basic ergonomic guidance. His comments focused on spinal alignment, seat depth for different heights, and what long recline sessions might do to typical lower-back sensitivities.
Big Lots Couch: Our Testing Experience
Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional
Our Testing Experience
The Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional immediately pulled the loungers toward it. I noticed that the corner seat acted like a nest. Mia vanished into that spot on day one and barely moved during a full drama series binge.
I felt the depth as soon as I sat down. My feet reached the floor, but my hips slid forward when I slouched. Marcus dropped into one end seat, stretched his legs across the chaise, and said, “This kind of deep cushion feels right for a long game night.” His bigger frame compressed the foam more, yet the springs never bottomed out.
During laptop sessions, I needed a throw pillow behind my lower back. Without that extra fill, my lumbar curve opened too much. Dr. Walker looked at the photos and wrote, “From a clinical perspective, this seat depth may encourage slouching in shorter users without extra lumbar support.” That comment tracked exactly with Mia’s experience; her feet hovered above the floor unless she tucked her legs under.
Jenna and Ethan tried a Friday movie on the Parkdale. They each took a long stretch, one on the chaise and one along the main run. Jenna noted that she barely felt Ethan shift around. She said, “I can feel his weight, but not those sharp jolts I get on cheaper couches.” Motion transfer felt muted, which made the sectional feel calmer under couple use.
For families, this couch handled chaos. Jamal sat on the very front lip to tie his shoes and then pushed off hard. The frame barely flexed. When visiting kids climbed along the back cushions, the sectional kept its shape better than I expected for the price band.
Ideal users for the Parkdale are people who live on their couch. You need a bigger room and at least average height. Shorter users should plan on extra cushions for lumbar support and maybe a small footstool during upright sessions.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Deep, lounge-friendly seats | Too deep for many shorter users |
| Strong corner seat comfort | Takes up significant floor space |
| Good motion damping for couples | Requires extra cushions for lumbar support in upright use |
| Solid-feeling frame and edge | Can feel warm in long sessions |
| Flexible sectional layout with chaise options | Not ideal for very formal, upright seating |
Details
- Price: Mid to upper mid, often promoted as value vs. designer sectionals
- Size and configuration:Approx width 125–135 in with chaiseDepth around 90–100 in along chaise sideHeight around 36–38 inL-shape with reversible or left/right chaise options in many packages
- Seat depth: About 23–24 in, very lounge-oriented
- Seat height: Around 19–20 in
- Cushion firmness: Medium-soft top with firmer core
- Frame and cushion materials:Engineered and solid wood frameSinuous spring supportPolyfoam and fiber cushions
- Fabric type: Woven polyester-style upholstery in a silver or gray tone
- Cooling / breathability:Reasonably breathable for synthetic fabricCan feel warm for hot sleepers over long marathons
- Support for different body sizes:Great for average to tall users who like to sprawlShorter users need pillows for depth control
- Ease of cleaning:Spot clean with fabric-safe cleanersRemovable seat cushions on most configurations
- Stain resistance: Decent, fabric hides minor marks in the textured weave
- Pet-friendliness:Texture grabs some furLess vulnerable than very smooth weaves to claw snags
- Durability:Frame feels stable under larger bodiesCushions benefit from rotation to avoid early impressions
- Assembly requirements:Sectional pieces connect with metal or plastic clipsBack cushions often come attached or zip on
- Shipping and delivery:Typically boxed sectional pieces with in-home or curbside delivery options
- Return period and warranty:Retailer-level policy applies, often limited-time returnsBasic manufacturer warranty on frame and cushions
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.5 | Deep, plush feel that suits lounging, especially in corner and chaise. |
| Back Support | 4.0 | Good when propped with pillows; too open without lumbar support. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 3.7 | Great for tall users, challenging for petite bodies like Mia’s. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 3.8 | Average synthetic fabric warmth during long TV or gaming runs. |
| Durability | 4.4 | Frame and springs felt very solid under Marcus and Jamal. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 4.2 | Cushions offer some bounce, not hard to shift positions. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 4.0 | Textured fabric hides marks; spot cleaning is straightforward. |
| Value for Money | 4.4 | Large seating capacity for the typical Big Lots price band. |
| Overall Score | 4.3 | Strong family sectional with depth-related trade-offs. |
Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional
Our Testing Experience
The Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional pushes a little firmer. I felt that change right away in the first sit. My hips stayed higher and my lower back found a more neutral curve without extra pillows.
Marcus liked the firmness for gaming. He said, “I can sit up for the match, then slide down without losing support under my hips.” He ran through a full playoff weekend on this couch. The seat fronts never felt mushy, even after long stretches. Jamal also liked the edge for tying shoes; it felt more like a bench than a hammock.
Mia had mixed feelings. The slightly shorter seat depth compared to Parkdale worked better for her legs. Her feet reached the floor more easily. However, she called the back cushions “a little stiff when I curl in the corner.” She wanted a softer top layer for side-lying sessions.
Carlos appreciated this sectional during laptop time. He could sit upright without fighting the back angle. After two hours of emails and spreadsheets, he reported no mid-back ache. That matched Dr. Walker’s later comment that this kind of medium-firm, upright-leaning back profile usually works better for long sitting blocks.
Jenna and Ethan found motion transfer slightly more noticeable than on Parkdale. The firmer base moved as one piece when Ethan dropped back into his corner. Jenna still called it comfortable for a couple, just a bit more lively under shared weight.
This model suits people who treat the couch as both workstation and lounge spot. It does less for those who want a super-plush, sink-in sectional.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Supportive, medium-firm seats | Less plush for people chasing a soft, cloudlike feel |
| Better seat depth fit for average and shorter users | Corner not as cushy for curl-up fans like Mia |
| Strong edge performance under heavier bodies | Fabric can feel warm for users who run hot |
| Stable back angle for laptop sessions | Motion transfer slightly higher than very soft sectionals |
| Flexible sectional layout options | Style leans practical more than luxurious |
Details
- Price: Mid-range, generally under premium leather or power pieces
- Size and configuration:Approx width 120–130 inDepth 85–95 in depending on chaise and returnsHeight about 36–38 inL-shaped configuration with chaise and sometimes ottoman options
- Seat depth: Around 22–23 in
- Seat height: Around 19 in
- Cushion firmness: Medium-firm overall
- Frame and cushion materials:Wood frame with sinuous springsHigher-density foam with thinner fiber wrap
- Fabric type: Textured granite-colored polyester
- Cooling / breathability:Mild warmth build-up under Marcus during hours-long gamingTexture helps hide sweat marks and light wear
- Support for different body sizes:Very solid for Marcus and Jamal at the edgesWorks well for mid-height users who prefer upright sitting
- Ease of cleaning:Spot clean recommendedDarker granite color hides many everyday stains
- Stain resistance: Good, due to dark tone and texture
- Pet-friendliness:Fur blends into the textured patternEdge feels strong under occasional pet jumps
- Durability:Frame felt rugged in all testsFirmer cushions likely to keep shape longer
- Assembly requirements:Sectional pieces connect via bracketsSome back assemblies attach with simple locks
- Shipping and delivery:Multi-piece delivery; may require two people to move sections
- Return period and warranty:Retailer policy applies; basic manufacturer coverage on structure
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.2 | Comfortable in a supportive way; less plush than Parkdale. |
| Back Support | 4.4 | Strong upright posture support for laptop and TV time. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 4.2 | Works better for mixed-height households than very deep designs. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 3.7 | Fabric feels slightly warm during long, intense gaming sessions. |
| Durability | 4.5 | Frame and foam held firm under our heavier testers. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 4.0 | Firmer cushions resist sinking but still allow easy position changes. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 4.1 | Dark textured fabric hides many everyday marks and scuffs. |
| Value for Money | 4.3 | Strong performance for the price in a multi-use living room. |
| Overall Score | 4.2 | Smart pick for households needing support and durability first. |
Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa
Our Testing Experience
The Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa turned into Marcus’s headquarters during sports nights. He claimed one power-recline end and barely left it during back-to-back games. The power controls let him fine-tune the angle until his hips and back felt anchored.
I noticed the lumbar support as soon as I reclined. The back cushions pressed into the curve above my beltline. My lower back stayed engaged instead of sagging into the frame. Dr. Walker liked that pattern and noted that this kind of mid-back and lumbar support usually suits people with mild desk-related tightness.
Jamal used the other end seat after workouts. He stretched his long legs across a nearby ottoman and said, “This kind of leather surface lets me slide and adjust quickly without sticking.” The leather felt smoother than the fabric sectionals. That made it easier to pivot between reclined positions.
The center seat felt different. It lacked the powered recline and sat a bit firmer. Ethan tried that spot for part of a movie and felt slightly cramped. He wanted either a dedicated console or more depth. Jenna preferred to avoid the middle entirely and stayed happily on an end.
Heat felt manageable. Leather always traps some warmth, but air movement around exposed arms and neck helped. Marcus did not complain about overheating the way he does on heavy microfiber reclining sofas.
This couch shines in dedicated TV rooms or dens. It works best for users who value recline features and easy-to-wipe surfaces more than airy, fabric-based lounging.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Power recline with fine control | Center seat less comfortable and lacks powered adjustments |
| Strong lumbar and mid-back support | Heavy piece; difficult to move once placed |
| Leather is easy to wipe and maintain | Needs nearby outlets and cable routing |
| Feels solid under larger bodies and repeated use | Less ideal for big groups that need three equal seats |
| Good for long TV or gaming sessions | Leather can feel warm for very heat-sensitive users |
Details
- Price: Upper mid to higher within typical Big Lots offerings
- Size and configuration:Approx width 85–90 inDepth about 40–42 inHeight roughly 40–42 inOften part of a full set with matching loveseat or recliner
- Seat depth: Around 21–22 in
- Seat height: Around 19–20 in
- Cushion firmness: Medium-firm seat, cushier back
- Frame and cushion materials:Reinforced wood and metal frameMetal reclining mechanisms on endsFoam cores with fiber padding
- Fabric type:Top grain leather on seating surfacesVinyl or faux leather match on sides and back in many versions
- Cooling / breathability:Better airflow than thick microfiberStill warmer than open-weave fabric couches
- Support for different body sizes:End seats handle Marcus and Jamal with no flex concernsCenter seat best for lighter or average users
- Ease of cleaning:Wipeable leather surfaces, respond well to basic cleanersNeeds occasional conditioning to prevent drying and cracking
- Stain resistance: High on the leather areas
- Pet-friendliness:Claws can mark leather; households must be carefulFur does not cling as much as to fabric
- Durability:Feels built for heavy daily useRecline mechanisms felt steady and controlled
- Assembly requirements:Back sections often slide into locking bracketsPower cords and transformer must be connected
- Shipping and delivery:Heavy; two adults required for safe moving
- Return period and warranty:Retailer policy on returnsManufacturer warranty on frame and mechanism lengths vary
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.6 | Very comfortable for long recline sessions on the powered end seats. |
| Back Support | 4.6 | Focused lumbar and mid-back support helped my lower-back tightness. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 4.2 | Works for many body types; center seat feels tighter. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 4.0 | Leather warms, yet breathes better than dense microfiber recliners. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Heavy, solid build that handled big users without squeaks. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 4.1 | Power controls ease transitions; overall weight makes relocation difficult. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 4.7 | Simple wipe-down care; spills do not soak in quickly. |
| Value for Money | 4.3 | Higher price but high function for TV-heavy households. |
| Overall Score | 4.4 | Strong Big Lots couch choice for serious TV and gaming rooms. |
Broyhill Laramie Sofa
Our Testing Experience
The Broyhill Laramie Sofa felt like the everyday baseline of this group. I sat down and immediately thought, “This kind of firmness feels familiar.” It has that medium feel that works for a wide range of casual use.
Seat depth landed in a friendlier zone for Mia. She could sit with her feet flat without scrambling for a pillow. She still preferred a throw cushion when she curled into the arm, yet she did not feel swallowed by the seat like she did on Parkdale.
Carlos used the Laramie as his main laptop couch for a week. He commented that the back offered steady support during upright work, though it did not push his lumbar region as actively as the Wellsley recliner. He liked it for daytime work and light evening streaming.
Jenna and Ethan tested couple comfort. They could share the sofa for a movie, but stretching fully required some coordination. She mentioned, “For two people, this works best for casual nights rather than all-out lounging.” Motion transfer stayed controlled. The frame felt quieter than many similar price-range sofas.
From Jamal’s perspective, the Laramie felt less like a lounge platform and more like a reliable everyday couch. His legs extended past the armrests when he tried to stretch; he preferred the longer sectionals for true recovery sessions.
This sofa suits smaller living rooms or buyers who want a Big Lots couch that does not dominate the space. It works best for average-height users and families that split time between sitting upright and simple lounging.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Balanced medium firmness | Not long enough for taller users to fully stretch |
| Manageable footprint for smaller living rooms | Less plush than deep sectionals for serious lounging |
| Supportive enough for daily laptop and TV use | Fabric and styling feel more basic than premium lines |
| Good motion control for a simple three-seater | Center seat slightly firmer than ends |
| Reasonable price for a Broyhill-branded sofa | Limited wow factor in design |
Details
- Price: Solid mid-range, below leather or power pieces
- Size and configuration:Approx width 82–86 inDepth about 36–38 inHeight around 36–38 inOften paired with loveseat or accent chair
- Seat depth: Around 21–22 in
- Seat height: Around 19 in
- Cushion firmness: True medium
- Frame and cushion materials:Engineered wood frameSinuous springsMedium-density foam with fiber wrap
- Fabric type: Woven upholstery, usually in neutral colors
- Cooling / breathability:Average airflow; not overly hot nor especially cool
- Support for different body sizes:Works nicely for average frames like mine and Carlos’sFeels short for Jamal’s frame in full stretch mode
- Ease of cleaning:Spot cleaning recommendedRemovable seat cushions on many builds
- Stain resistance: Moderate, depends on color chosen
- Pet-friendliness:Fabric stands up to light pet useFur clings somewhat but vacuums out easily
- Durability:Feels ready for everyday family use with basic care
- Assembly requirements:Typically simple leg install and back attachment
- Shipping and delivery:Single-body sofa, easier to move than sectionals or power units
- Return period and warranty:Retailer and manufacturer standard coverage
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.1 | Comfortable for mixed upright and light lounging sessions. |
| Back Support | 4.0 | Reliable, neutral support without aggressive lumbar shaping. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 4.3 | Works for Mia’s petite frame and my average frame. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 3.9 | Fabric runs neutral in most use cases. |
| Durability | 4.1 | Feels sturdy enough for daily family traffic. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 4.3 | Medium cushions and modest size make shifting seats easy. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 3.9 | Standard fabric care; nothing tricky, nothing exceptional. |
| Value for Money | 4.2 | Fair price for a practical, branded everyday sofa. |
| Overall Score | 4.1 | Sensible Big Lots couch choice for smaller rooms and daily use. |
Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa
Our Testing Experience
The Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa felt built for basements and weekend marathons. The dark espresso fabric and chunky arms screamed comfort-first. Marcus moved here when he wanted built-in cup holders and the drop-down table for snacks.
I tried the left recliner first. The mechanism glided smoothly into a relaxed angle. The support leaned more toward soft, with thicker fiber padding. During a long movie, my lower back felt okay, yet my hips did sink more than on the Wellsley.
Jenna liked the center drop-down table for drinks and remotes when it was folded. When the center stayed up, the middle seat felt narrow. Ethan called it “the backup spot when friends come over.” He preferred the ends where he could recline and let his legs fall out a bit.
Heat build-up showed up fast. After an extended double-feature, Marcus mentioned, “This fabric runs hot after a while, especially with a blanket.” Dr. Walker pointed out that plush, padded recliners often trap more warmth and encourage slouching when people recline without lumbar pillows.
Jamal appreciated the storage arms during snack-heavy nights. He could stash controllers and remotes close by and avoid reaching. However, he did not love the softer seat for post-workout recovery; his legs preferred firmer support during stretching.
This couch works best in a casual space where style and precision matter less than built-in convenience and relaxed recline.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Dual recliners with cup holders and storage | Fabric runs warm during long, close-knit viewing sessions |
| Drop-down table adds real-world convenience | Center seat feels narrow and less supportive |
| Soft, plush feel for relaxed lounging | Slouchy posture appears easily during long recline use |
| Great fit for basement or media-room vibes | Bulkier profile crowds very small rooms |
| Value-friendly Big Lots couch with many features | Not ideal for upright work or extended laptop use |
Details
- Price: Mid-range, strong feature count for the money
- Size and configuration:Approx width 88–92 inDepth 38–40 inHeight 40–42 inOften part of a set with loveseat or recliner
- Seat depth: Around 21–22 in
- Seat height: Around 19–20 in
- Cushion firmness: Medium-soft, especially in backs and arms
- Frame and cushion materials:Metal reclining frameWood seat boxFiber-heavy back and arm cushions
- Fabric type: Plush espresso polyester
- Cooling / breathability:Runs warm over timePlush hand-feel keeps you cozy but traps heat
- Support for different body sizes:End seats fine for most users in short burstsExtended recline works better for those without existing back issues
- Ease of cleaning:Dark color hides spillsFabric needs quick blotting for wet messes
- Stain resistance: Good, thanks to dark tone
- Pet-friendliness:Fabric catches furClaws less obvious on dark material
- Durability:Mechanisms feel sturdyCushions likely to soften and sag earlier than firmer models
- Assembly requirements:Backs usually slide into baseRecline cables and mechanisms preinstalled
- Shipping and delivery:Heavy due to mechanisms; needs two adults to handle
- Return period and warranty:Retailer and brand-level protections apply
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.1 | Very cozy for short to medium-length lounging. |
| Back Support | 3.7 | Soft feel encourages slouching without added lumbar pillows. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 4.0 | Works for many body sizes but middle seat feels tight. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 3.5 | Plush fabric runs warm during long, covered sessions. |
| Durability | 4.0 | Mechanisms feel durable; cushions may lose structure sooner. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 3.8 | Soft cushions reduce bounce, making quick shifts slightly slower. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 4.1 | Dark upholstery hides minor stains and smudges. |
| Value for Money | 4.2 | Many living-room features for a moderate investment. |
| Overall Score | 4.0 | Strong option for casual, feature-packed Big Lots couch setups. |
Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa (Sold at Big Lots)
Our Testing Experience
The Signature Design by Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa, offered through Big Lots, took the lightest visual approach in this group. The putty-colored fabric brightened our test space. Compared with the Broyhill pieces, it looked slimmer and a bit more modern.
I noticed the softer seat at once. When I sat with a laptop, my hips sank slightly, but not dramatically. I still felt supported, just with a gentler cushion crown. After an hour, my lower back wanted a small pillow for extra support.
Mia liked the lighter, more compact footprint. She said, “This kind of sofa feels right for a small apartment living room.” Her feet reached the floor easily. She could also curl sideways without fighting heavy, overstuffed arms.
Jenna and Ethan tried it as a couple couch. They fit comfortably side by side. There was enough width for relaxed movie watching, yet not enough to stretch fully without overlapping legs. Motion transfer felt mild, helped by the softer foam.
The trade-off appeared when Marcus dropped into his usual gaming posture. He noticed more flex in the frame and said, “I wouldn’t treat this like a tank; it’s fine, but not built for wrestling.” Dr. Walker highlighted that lighter, softer sofas like this still work when people keep sessions shorter or pair them with simple posture supports.
This Big Lots couch fits buyers who care a lot about color, footprint, and general comfort, and less about heavy-duty capacity or deep lounging.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Light putty color brightens small spaces | Light fabric shows stains and marks faster |
| Softer, inviting seat feel | Frame feels less robust under very heavy, rough use |
| Compact footprint suits apartments and smaller rooms | Back support feels mild without extra cushions |
| Good everyday comfort for average-weight users | Not ideal for long, fully stretched lounging |
| Attractive value for style-focused shoppers | Pet hair and dark stains stand out on light fabric |
Details
- Price: Mid-range, positioned as a good-value Ashley sofa within Big Lots mix
- Size and configuration:Approx width 78–82 inDepth around 36–38 inHeight about 36–38 in
- Seat depth: Around 21–22 in
- Seat height: Around 19 in
- Cushion firmness: Medium-soft overall
- Frame and cushion materials:Engineered wood frameFoam and polyfiber cushions
- Fabric type: Woven polyester in a light putty shade
- Cooling / breathability:Fabric breathes better than dense microfiberLight color helps reflect light and warmth visually
- Support for different body sizes:Works nicely for average-weight usersLess ideal as the main couch for very heavy users
- Ease of cleaning:Needs prompt spot cleaning to avoid visible stainsLight color shows spills and pet mess quickly
- Stain resistance: Fair, color magnifies marks
- Pet-friendliness:Fur shows strongly on light fabricClaw marks less visible than on leather
- Durability:Enough for normal use, less for rough treatment
- Assembly requirements:Simple leg and back attachment
- Shipping and delivery:Lighter weight compared with big recliners and sectionals
- Return period and warranty:Standard retailer and manufacturer protections apply
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Seat Comfort | 4.0 | Soft, welcoming cushions for everyday sitting and light lounging. |
| Back Support | 3.8 | Adequate with pillows; less structured for long upright work blocks. |
| Seat Depth Fit | 4.1 | Friendly depth for smaller and mid-size living spaces and bodies. |
| Cooling / Breathability | 4.1 | Fabric feels breathable during regular use. |
| Durability | 3.7 | Fine for moderate use; not built for roughhousing. |
| Ease of Movement / Repositioning | 4.2 | Light frame and cushions make shifting seats and positions simple. |
| Ease of Cleaning | 3.5 | Light putty color demands quick action on spills and stains. |
| Value for Money | 4.1 | Good price for style-focused shoppers who treat it with care. |
| Overall Score | 3.9 | Attractive Big Lots couch for smaller, style-led living rooms. |
Compare Performance Scores of These Sofas
| sofa | Overall Score | Seat Comfort | Back Support | Seat Depth Fit | Cooling / Breathability | Durability | Ease of Movement / Repositioning |
| Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional | 4.3 | 4.5 | 4.0 | 3.7 | 3.8 | 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional | 4.2 | 4.2 | 4.4 | 4.2 | 3.7 | 4.5 | 4.0 |
| Broyhill Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa | 4.4 | 4.6 | 4.6 | 4.2 | 4.0 | 4.6 | 4.1 |
| Broyhill Laramie Sofa | 4.1 | 4.1 | 4.0 | 4.3 | 3.9 | 4.1 | 4.3 |
| Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa | 4.0 | 4.1 | 3.7 | 4.0 | 3.5 | 4.0 | 3.8 |
| Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa | 3.9 | 4.0 | 3.8 | 4.1 | 4.1 | 3.7 | 4.2 |
The Wellsley stands out as the most complete performer, especially for recline-heavy use. The Parkdale wins for deep lounging and big family seating, while the McRay takes the support crown for upright and mixed-use sessions. The Laramie and Arlis lean toward smaller rooms and moderate budgets. The Jamestown is the specialist for feature-packed basement or media-room setups, with its warmth and softness acting as both strength and compromise.
Best Picks
-
Best Big Lots Couch for Deep Lounging – Big Lots Couch Parkdale Silver Sectional
The Parkdale gives you deep cushions, a strong corner seat, and generous capacity. Our testers gravitated toward it for long series binges and weekend naps. Taller and average-height users found the depth especially satisfying. -
Best Big Lots Couch for Support and Work-From-Couch Days – Big Lots Couch McRay Granite Sectional
The McRay held posture better for laptop sessions and upright movie nights. Marcus and Carlos appreciated the firmer base and stable back. This kind of profile suits households where the couch doubles as a work zone. -
Best Big Lots Couch for TV and Gaming Rooms – Big Lots Couch Wellsley Leather Power Reclining Sofa
The Wellsley delivered strong lumbar feel, easy-clean leather, and smooth power recline. Marcus and Jamal kept returning to it for sports and game nights. It offers the most focused comfort for recline-heavy living rooms.
How to Choose the Big Lots Couch?
Choosing a Big Lots couch starts with basic dimensions and body types. Taller users, like Jamal and Marcus, need longer runs and adequate seat depth. Petite users, like Mia, need shallow enough seats that let their feet reach the floor without straining hips and knees.
Think about posture next. If you mainly sit upright with a laptop or tablet, you need firm, supportive backs and balanced seat firmness. If you lean toward full-body lounging, then you need deeper cushions and corners that welcome side-lying positions.
Room size sets another boundary. Large sectionals like the Parkdale and McRay want open floor plans. Smaller rooms or apartments call for scaled-down options like the Laramie or Arlis. Measure walking paths, door clearances, and TV distance before committing.
Household type matters a lot. Families with kids and pets need tougher fabrics, darker colors, and frames that survive jumping and climbing. Couples who host movie nights want good motion control and space to stretch out without clashing knees. Single users might prioritize their own body type and working style.
Fabric and maintenance sit close to the surface in daily life. Leather on the Wellsley wipes clean yet needs conditioning and careful pet management. Plush fabric on the Jamestown feels cozy, but it runs warm and traps more fur. Woven neutrals on the Laramie, McRay, Parkdale, and Arlis balance maintenance and comfort.
Budget finally narrows the list. Higher-priced recliners deliver features like power controls and leather. Mid-range sectionals trade some polish for sheer seating area. Simpler three-seaters trade features for lower cost and smaller footprints.
Based on our testing:
- For a petite user who sinks into deep seats, the Broyhill Laramie or Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa works better than Parkdale. Their seat depths support shorter legs, and cushions feel easier to manage with a small pillow.
- For a tall user needing extra leg room, the Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional or Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional gives enough depth and width. Jamal stayed more comfortable on those pieces than on the smaller three-seaters.
- For a couple who lounges together most nights, the Parkdale and Wellsley top the list. Parkdale excels for shared stretch-out; Wellsley excels for reclined TV sessions with more structure and lumbar focus.
- For a family with young kids and pets, the Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional and Real Living Jamestown Espresso Reclining Sofa make sense. McRay handles rougher frame use; Jamestown’s darker, plush fabric hides a lot of daily mess, at the cost of more warmth.
- For a style-conscious apartment dweller, the Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa or Broyhill Laramie Sofa feels aligned. Both offer manageable footprints, welcoming cushions, and enough support for everyday use without overwhelming a small room.
Limitations
Across these main Big Lots couch options, several gaps appeared. None of them feel perfect for buyers who want very formal, upright seating with crisp lines and minimal cushion give. The designs skew casual and comfort-first.
Ultra-soft, sink-in enthusiasts may also feel constrained. Jamestown comes closest to that soft zone, yet it still stops short of the most cloudlike high-end couches on the wider market.
Very small studio spaces remain a challenge. The three-seater options help, yet Big Lots’ strongest stories currently sit in sectionals and reclining sets that need breathing room. People seeking tiny settees or love seats for micro apartments might look elsewhere or dig deeper into the retailer catalog.
Rock-bottom budget seekers might also feel limited. These tested couches sit in the value-to-mid range, not in the absolute cheapest frames. That kind of user may have to accept simpler builds, thinner cushions, and more basic materials than we reviewed here.
Is the Big Lots Couch Worth It?
These Big Lots couch models delivered real value for everyday households. Comfort, support, and seat depth fit reached a solid baseline, with standout performance in the Wellsley and the Parkdale. Durability looked respectable, especially in the McRay and Wellsley under heavier testers.
Cleaning and fabric behavior matched their price bands. Leather on Wellsley behaved predictably under spills. Dark plush on Jamestown hid mess but trapped more heat. Woven fabrics on Parkdale, McRay, Laramie, and Arlis balanced airflow and maintenance needs.
From the perspective of value, power recline buyers get the most from Broyhill Wellsley. Heavy TV watchers and gamers benefit from its structure, lumbar focus, and wipeable surfaces. Large families who host often gain the most from Broyhill Parkdale or Broyhill McRay, depending on whether they lean toward deep lounging or upright support.
Value drops a bit for users with very specific needs. Very formal sitters may want firmer, more structured seating than any of these deliver. People who live in extremely tight spaces may find even the smaller sofas oversized. Buyers who need high-end design finishes may also feel underwhelmed, since these couches prioritize function and price over luxury detail.
Overall, for shoppers who match the body types and living-room patterns described earlier, a Big Lots couch from this group can absolutely be worth the money.
FAQs
1. Are Big Lots couches comfortable enough for everyday use?
In my experience, yes, as long as the model matches your habits. The Parkdale and Jamestown feel very relaxed for long lounging. The McRay, Laramie, and Arlis support daily sitting and light lounging without feeling stiff. Comfort drops only when body size clashes with seat depth, like when Mia sits on the Parkdale without a pillow.
2. Which Big Lots couch works best for tall people?
Tall testers like Jamal felt most comfortable on the Broyhill Parkdale Silver Sectional and Broyhill McRay Granite Sectional. Those couches provide enough length for legs and enough depth to avoid knee crunch. Wellsley also worked, but mainly in recline mode rather than upright sitting.
3. Are these Big Lots couches good for shorter users?
Shorter users, especially people around Mia’s height, did better on the Broyhill Laramie and Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa. Their seat depths let feet reach the floor. Parkdale and Jamestown felt too deep without added pillows. If a shorter user loves a deep sectional, then lumbar and seat cushions become essential.
4. How do these couches hold up with kids and pets?
From what we saw, McRay, Parkdale, and Jamestown handled kid chaos best. Frames felt stable when children climbed or flopped into seats. Dark fabrics hid small stains and fur. Wellsley survived dog claws if owners stayed vigilant, but leather always needs extra care. Arlis and Laramie handled moderate traffic fine, yet lighter fabric and frame feel better with calmer households.
5. Are Big Lots recliners and reclining sofas good for back support?
Back support varied by model. Broyhill Wellsley gave the clearest lumbar structure. My lower back held its curve when I reclined partway. Real Living Jamestown felt softer and encouraged slouching during long sessions unless I added a pillow. Dr. Walker’s view matched that pattern; structured lumbar zones usually help mild lower-back tightness more than soft, pillow-heavy backs.
6. Which Big Lots couch is best for naps?
For naps, Parkdale and Jamestown stood out. Parkdale’s corner seat worked like a daybed, especially for taller users. Jamestown’s plush reclining ends cradled me well during quick dozes. Wellsley also handled reclined naps nicely, but the structured lumbar made it feel more like a supportive chair than a nap nest.
7. Do these couches fit well in small apartments?
Among this group, Broyhill Laramie and Ashley Arlis Putty Sofa felt most comfortable in smaller rooms. Their widths sit under massive sectional footprints. Seat depth remains friendly for mixed use. Parkdale and McRay need bigger living rooms. Jamestown and Wellsley also feel large due to recline mechanisms and visual bulk.
8. How easy are these Big Lots couches to assemble and move?
Assembly stayed straightforward across our tests. Sofas like Laramie and Arlis needed only legs and back attachment. Sectionals like Parkdale and McRay required connecting pieces with brackets. Recliners like Wellsley and Jamestown brought more weight; two adults had to move them carefully. Once placed, the power and recline sofas were hardest to shift again.
9. How do the fabrics and leather handle stains and spills?
Leather on Wellsley wiped clean quickly and resisted soaking. Dark plush on Jamestown hid stains, though liquid still needed fast blotting. Woven fabrics on Parkdale, McRay, and Laramie balanced stain visibility and cleaning ease. Light putty fabric on Arlis looked great but showed marks the fastest. That model demands immediate cleaning habits.
10. Are Big Lots couches a good long-term investment or more short-term furniture?
Based on our testing, these couches aim for solid mid-term use rather than heirloom status. Frames on McRay, Parkdale, and Wellsley felt ready for years of regular traffic. Jamestown, Laramie, and Arlis should handle normal use, yet their softer cushions and lighter frames will likely show age sooner. For the price bands, that life span matches expectations for many households.