My team and I spent the last few weeks living with a rotating cast of mid-century inspired furniture. We ordered the most popular sofas from AllModern to our testing studio. We unpacked them, assembled the legs, and integrated them into our daily routines. We wanted to see if this Wayfair-owned brand delivers on its promise of accessible modern design or if it sacrifices comfort for style.
The testing process involved my entire seven-person team. We rotated through each model for days at a time. We watched movies, worked on laptops, and hosted mock gatherings to test the social flow of the pieces. I focused on the cushion density and fabric quality. I needed to know if these sofas would pill after a month or sag after a year.
Dr. Adrian Walker joined us to evaluate the ergonomics. He observed our spinal alignment on the notoriously firm mid-century frames. We measured seat depths and back angles. We checked how the velvet and performance fabrics held up to spills. We are ready to share our unfiltered thoughts on the all modern sofa lineup.
Product Overview
| Sofa Model | Pros | Cons | Ideal For | Price | Overall Score |
| AllModern Miller Sofa | Iconic mid-century look, firm support | Seat cushions are very firm | Formal living rooms, offices | $$ | 4.5 |
| AllModern Geo Sectional | Deep seating, reversible chaise | Back cushions can look messy | Lounging, movie nights | $$$ | 4.6 |
| AllModern Aaron Sofa | Compact, budget-friendly | Shallow seat depth | Small apartments | $ | 4.3 |
| AllModern Kasey Velvet Sofa | Luxurious texture, single bench cushion | Velvet runs warm, tufting catches crumbs | Style-conscious hosts | $$ | 4.7 |
| AllModern Leni Modular | Low profile, modern aesthetic | Very low back support | Minimalist lofts | $$$ | 4.4 |
| AllModern Hailee Leather Sofa | Genuine leather feel, durable | Leather scratches easily | Pet-free homes | $$$ | 4.5 |
AllModern Sofa Comparison Chart
| Feature | Miller | Geo | Aaron | Kasey | Leni | Hailee |
| Type | Sofa | Sectional | Sofa | Sofa | Sectional | Sofa |
| Width | 84 inches | 104 inches | 78 inches | 88 inches | 110 inches | 86 inches |
| Seat Depth | 22 inches | 24 inches | 21 inches | 23 inches | 25 inches | 22 inches |
| Seat Height | 18 inches | 17 inches | 18 inches | 18.5 inches | 16 inches | 18 inches |
| Upholstery | Polyester | Performance Fabric | Polyester | Performance Velvet | Polyester Blend | Top Grain Leather |
| Cushion Type | Foam / Firm | Down Blend / Soft | Foam / Medium | Foam / Medium | Foam / Soft | Foam / Firm |
| Legs | Walnut Wood | Black Metal | Tapered Wood | Gold / Metal | Hidden | Wood |
| Assembly | Legs Only | Clips / Legs | Legs Only | Legs Only | Modular Clips | Legs Only |
What We Tested and How We Tested It
We established a strict protocol for these tests. We focused heavily on seat firmness. I used a durometer to measure foam density, but also relied on "butt-tests." Marcus sat on each cushion for two hours straight to check for "bottoming out." We evaluated the fabric durability. We rubbed rough denim against the upholstery 500 times to simulate wear.
We tested the assembly experience. We timed how long it took to unbox and set up each sofa. Most AllModern pieces claim easy assembly, so we put that to the test. We assessed the cleanability. Jenna poured coffee on the performance fabrics to see if it beaded up or soaked in.
Dr. Walker monitored our posture. He paid close attention to the low back heights common in mid-century designs. He checked for neck strain during TV watching. We evaluated the stability. Jamal dropped his 210-pound frame onto the sofas to check for creaks or wobbles.
Testing Team Takeaways
I found the AllModern lineup to be visually striking. They nail the aesthetic. The Miller sofa looks like it costs three times the price. However, I noticed a trend of firmness. Most of these sofas sit stiffly. This is great for my back when working, but less ideal for a Sunday nap. The fabrics generally felt high quality, especially the performance velvet.
Marcus Reed put the frames to the stress test. He found the legs on the Miller sturdy. “I don’t feel any wobble when I shift,” he noted. He struggled with the depth of the Aaron. At 6'1", his knees were too high. He preferred the deep, sinking feel of the Geo sectional.
Carlos Alvarez focused on the back support. He found the Leni modular problematic. The back is very low. “I have no shoulder support,” he complained. He praised the Miller for its upright, supportive back angle. He could type comfortably from it.
Mia Chen loved the Kasey Velvet sofa. “It feels so glamorous,” she said. She curled up on the single bench cushion. She liked that there were no cracks to fall into. She found the seat height of the Aaron perfect for her 5'4" frame; her feet touched the floor easily.
Jenna Brooks tested the couple factor. She found the Geo sectional perfect for movie nights. “We can both stretch out without touching,” she noted. She criticized the Aaron for being too narrow for two people to lounge comfortably.
Jamal Davis needed room. He found the Hailee leather sofa a bit tight. The armrests are high and hard. “I can’t lie down without a pillow,” he said. He loved the open end of the Geo chaise. It let his feet hang off comfortably.
Ethan Cole was the napper. He tried to sleep on the Miller. “It’s too bouncy,” he said. The button tufting dug into his side. He loved the Kasey. The bench seat made a perfect twin bed substitute.
AllModern Sofa: Our Testing Experience
AllModern Miller Sofa
Our Testing Experience:
The Miller is the quintessential mid-century piece. I sat down. It was firm. The foam pushed back immediately. I sat upright. My posture was perfect. I admired the walnut legs. They felt solid. The fabric is a heathered grey polyester. It felt durable but a bit scratchy.
Marcus tried to bounce. The sinuous springs are tight. “This is not a sink-in couch,” he confirmed. He liked the arm height. It was perfect for resting an elbow while holding a drink.
Mia curled up in the corner. She used a throw pillow. The armrests are thin and hard. “You definitely need pillows,” she advised. She liked the visual lightness. It didn't clutter the room.
Dr. Walker praised the seat angle. He noted it keeps the pelvis neutral. He recommended this for reception areas or formal living rooms where conversation is the goal, not sleeping.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Stunning mid-century silhouette | Seat is very firm |
| Durable, tight fabric weave | Fabric can be scratchy |
| High clearance for cleaning | Hard armrests need pillows |
| Holds shape perfectly | Not for napping |
Details
-
Price: $$
-
Dimensions: 84" W x 35" D x 32" H
-
Seat Depth: 22"
-
Upholstery: 100% Polyester
-
Legs: Solid Wood (Walnut stain)
-
Assembly: Screw in legs (10 mins)
-
Warranty: 1 Year Limited
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.0 | Firm, upright support. |
| Support | 4.8 | Excellent back structure. |
| Durability | 4.7 | Fabric is tough. |
| Aesthetics | 4.9 | A design classic. |
| Value | 4.5 | Looks expensive. |
| Overall | 4.5 | The stylish office choice. |
AllModern Geo Sectional
Our Testing Experience:
The Geo looks inviting. It has a chaise. I sat down. It was much softer than the Miller. I sank in about two inches. The back cushions are loose. I leaned back. They molded to my back. It felt casual.
Jenna and Ethan claimed the chaise. “This is the movie spot,” Jenna said. They fit easily. The fabric is a soft woven blend. It felt nice on the skin. Ethan noticed the back cushions looked messy after they stood up. “You have to fluff these,” he noted.
Jamal sat on the regular seat. He found the depth generous. His knees were comfortable. He liked the wide, flat armrests. He balanced his phone on one.
Dr. Walker noted the lack of lumbar structure. The loose pillows shift. He suggested adding a small lumbar pillow for long viewing sessions. I found the clips holding the sectional pieces together were sturdy. They didn't drift apart.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Deep, lounging comfort | Back cushions look messy |
| Reversible chaise is versatile | Fabric can pill over time |
| Soft, inviting aesthetic | Requires regular fluffing |
| Good value for size | Legs are simple metal |
Details
-
Price: $$$
-
Dimensions: 104" W x 60" D (Chaise)
-
Seat Depth: 24"
-
Upholstery: Performance Blend
-
Legs: Black Metal
-
Assembly: Connect clips, legs
-
Warranty: 1 Year
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.7 | Great for relaxing. |
| Support | 4.2 | Loose cushions sag. |
| Durability | 4.4 | Fabric pills slightly. |
| Aesthetics | 4.6 | Modern and casual. |
| Value | 4.6 | Good price for a sectional. |
| Overall | 4.6 | The family lounger. |
AllModern Aaron Sofa
Our Testing Experience:
The Aaron is cute. It is small. I sat down. It felt compact. The seat is shallower. My knees extended past the edge. The back is tufted. I felt the buttons. It is medium-firm. It has a bit more give than the Miller.
Mia loved the scale. “It fits perfectly in a studio,” she said. She could move it herself. It is lightweight. She liked the tapered legs.
Marcus felt cramped. “It’s too narrow for me,” he said. His shoulders took up half the width. He felt the frame flex slightly when he sat down hard.
Dr. Walker approved of the upright posture for short durations. He warned it lacks head support. I checked the fabric. It is a basic polyester. It is easy to clean but feels a bit thin.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Perfect for small spaces | Shallow seating depth |
| Very affordable | Lightweight frame flexes |
| Cute retro design | Thin fabric feel |
| Easy to move | Not for tall people |
Details
-
Price: $
-
Dimensions: 78" W x 32" D x 33" H
-
Seat Depth: 21"
-
Upholstery: Polyester
-
Legs: Rubberwood
-
Assembly: Legs only
-
Warranty: 1 Year
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.2 | Good for size. |
| Support | 4.4 | Decent upright sit. |
| Durability | 4.0 | Frame feels light. |
| Aesthetics | 4.5 | Charming look. |
| Value | 4.8 | Great budget pick. |
| Overall | 4.3 | The apartment starter. |
AllModern Kasey Velvet Sofa
Our Testing Experience:
The Kasey is a showstopper. The velvet is rich. I ran my hand over it. It is soft. I sat on the single bench cushion. It is smooth. No gaps. I loved that. It felt medium-firm. Supportive but plush on top.
Ethan lay down. “This is the best nap couch,” he declared. The single cushion acts like a mattress. The velvet is warm. He fell asleep quickly.
Jenna noticed crumbs in the tufting. “The buttons trap dirt,” she observed. She had to vacuum the crevices. She liked the gold legs. They added a touch of luxury.
Dr. Walker liked the consistent support of the bench cushion. It prevents uneven hip alignment. He noted the velvet can get slippery. You might slide forward if you wear silk.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Luxurious velvet texture | Tufting traps crumbs |
| Single bench cushion (no gaps) | Velvet runs warm |
| Great for napping | Gold legs scratch floors |
| High-end aesthetic | Slippery surface |
Details
-
Price: $$
-
Dimensions: 88" W x 35" D x 30" H
-
Seat Depth: 23"
-
Upholstery: Performance Velvet
-
Legs: Gold Metal
-
Assembly: Legs only
-
Warranty: 1 Year
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.8 | Plush and smooth. |
| Support | 4.6 | Consistent foam density. |
| Durability | 4.5 | Velvet is tough. |
| Aesthetics | 4.9 | Glamorous. |
| Value | 4.6 | Looks more expensive. |
| Overall | 4.7 | The glam statement. |
AllModern Leni Modular Sectional
Our Testing Experience:
The Leni is low. Very low. I sat down. It felt like a lounge pad. The backrest is barely there. It hit my lower back. I couldn't lean back fully. I had to slouch. The modules are easy to move. I rearranged them.
Carlos struggled. “I can’t sit here for long,” he said. His neck hurt. He had no support. He liked the firmness of the seat though. It was good for perching.
Jamal liked the open feel. “It doesn’t block the window,” he noted. He liked the wide seats. He could sit cross-legged.
Dr. Walker flagged the ergonomics. “This is form over function,” he stated. He warned against using this as a primary TV couch unless you lay down.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Sleek, low-profile design | Very poor back support |
| Modular flexibility | Low seat height |
| Open, airy feel | Hard to get out of |
| Firm seat cushions | Niche aesthetic |
Details
-
Price: $$$
-
Dimensions: Modular
-
Seat Depth: 25"
-
Upholstery: Polyester
-
Legs: Hidden
-
Assembly: Clips
-
Warranty: 1 Year
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.0 | Good for lying, bad for sitting. |
| Support | 3.5 | Minimal back support. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Solid construction. |
| Aesthetics | 4.8 | Ultra-modern. |
| Value | 4.3 | Paying for style. |
| Overall | 4.4 | The minimalist's choice. |
AllModern Hailee Leather Sofa
Our Testing Experience:
The Hailee smells like real leather. It is top grain. I sat down. It was slippery. I slid forward. The leather is stiff at first. It needs breaking in. The cushions are firm. I felt the quality.
Marcus liked the durability. “This will last,” he said. He scratched it lightly. It marked. “It will develop a patina,” he noted. He liked the timber legs.
Jenna found it cold. “It takes time to warm up,” she said. She needed a throw blanket. She liked the clean lines. It looked tidy.
Dr. Walker praised the firm support. He noted the leather offers no give, which is good for stability. He suggested it for pet-free homes due to scratch risks.
Pros & Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Genuine leather feel | Scratches easily |
| Very durable construction | Slippery surface |
| Develops patina | Stiff break-in period |
| Timeless design | Cold to the touch |
Details
-
Price: $$$
-
Dimensions: 86" W x 36" D x 32" H
-
Seat Depth: 22"
-
Upholstery: Top Grain Leather
-
Legs: Solid Wood
-
Assembly: Legs only
-
Warranty: 1 Year
Review Score
| Metric | Score | Remarks |
| Comfort | 4.3 | Stiff initially. |
| Support | 4.7 | Very stable. |
| Durability | 4.6 | Leather is tough. |
| Aesthetics | 4.8 | Classic modern. |
| Value | 4.4 | Fair for real leather. |
| Overall | 4.5 | The leather classic. |
Compare Performance Scores of These Sofas
| Sofa | Overall Score | Seat Comfort | Back Support | Seat Depth Fit | Cooling | Durability | Ease of Movement |
| Miller | 4.5 | 4.0 | 4.8 | 4.5 | 4.8 | 4.7 | 4.5 |
| Geo | 4.6 | 4.7 | 4.2 | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4.4 | 3.5 |
| Aaron | 4.3 | 4.2 | 4.4 | 4.0 | 4.8 | 4.0 | 4.8 |
| Kasey | 4.7 | 4.8 | 4.6 | 4.5 | 4.0 | 4.5 | 4.0 |
| Leni | 4.4 | 4.0 | 3.5 | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4.6 | 4.0 |
| Hailee | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.7 | 4.2 | 4.2 | 4.6 | 4.0 |
The Kasey wins for pure style and comfort. The Geo is the best all-rounder for relaxation. The Miller is the design icon but sits firm. The Aaron is the budget king. The Hailee is for leather lovers. The Leni is for specific modern tastes.
Best Picks
-
Best Overall AllModern Sofa: Kasey Velvet Sofa. We chose this for its unique combination of luxurious comfort, stunning aesthetics, and the practical bench cushion design.
-
Best for Lounging: Geo Sectional. This award goes to the Geo for its deep, sink-in feel and versatile reversible chaise that makes movie nights perfect.
-
Best Budget Pick: Aaron Sofa. We selected the Aaron for delivering authentic mid-century style and decent comfort at an unbeatable price point for small spaces.
How to Choose the AllModern Sofa?
You must measure your space. The Aaron fits where others won't. The Geo needs room to breathe.
Consider your firmness preference. If you like soft, get the Geo or Kasey. If you like firm, get the Miller or Hailee.
Think about pets. The Miller's tight weave resists claws. The Kasey's velvet sheds hair easily but attracts dust. The Hailee leather will scratch.
Check your usage. For a formal room, the Miller is perfect. For a TV room, the Geo is essential. For a reading nook, the Aaron works well.
Look at the legs. The Miller has exposed wood. The Kasey has gold. Match your existing hardware.
Limitations
The main limitation is seat firmness. AllModern leans firm. Do not expect a cloud couch unless you buy specific "down" models.
Assembly is usually easy, but boxes are heavy.
Back height is generally low. Mid-century design prioritizes low profiles. Tall people might lack neck support.
Return policy. Wayfair/AllModern has return fees. Be sure before you buy.
Is the AllModern Sofa worth it?
The AllModern sofa is absolutely worth it for style. You get a designer look for a fraction of the cost.
It is worth it for speed. They ship fast. You get it in days, not months.
It is not worth it if you want heirloom quality that lasts 20 years. These are 5-7 year sofas.
FAQs
1. Is the Miller sofa comfortable?
It is firm. It is comfortable for sitting upright, but not for sinking in.
2. Is the velvet hard to clean?
No, performance velvet cleans easily with a damp cloth. It is surprisingly durable.
3. Do the legs scratch floors?
Yes, wood legs can. Always use felt pads.
4. Can I wash the cushion covers?
Check the tag. usually, they are spot clean only or dry clean.
5. Is assembly hard?
No, most require just screwing in legs. The sectionals require connecting clips.
6. Does the leather peel?
The Hailee is top grain leather, so it shouldn't peel like bonded leather.
7. How deep is the Geo?
It is about 24 inches deep internally, which is generous for lounging.
8. Is the Aaron good for tall people?
No, it is compact. Tall people will find the seat too shallow.
9. Do they offer fabric swatches?
Yes, you can usually order free swatches online.
10. How fast is shipping?
AllModern is known for fast, free shipping. Usually under a week.